News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by unholiness on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:09PM (#9696786)
I posted this on an earlier thread about the morality of AdBlock, but it seem relevant to the discussion:

There is a huge irony in that fact that AdBlock's function of keeping ads away from our content will eventually do the opposite. The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content.

Let's face it: paywalls don't work. The alternative on the horizon is native advertising. Buzzfeed is now famously refusing to host ads. Instead they sustain themselves by publishing content that subtly supports the agenda of any company with deep enough pockets to pay for it. A viewer's ability to distinguish between native ads and regular articles is small and quickly vanishing. If separate ads stop reaching people, the path to monetization remaining is to change your content to reflect someone else's agenda.

I keep AdBlock off by default because I prefer a world where creators can make a meaningful articles and a useful apps without caring about who they are supporting, and can, as the price tag, separately attach an ad.

I do see it as a moral issue. There are good people making content that's being sustained by ads. I am never going to remember to give them my modicum of support if I don't consider them innocent until proven guilty. It's worth the small annoyance. It's worth the 2 seconds it takes to turn it on for the problematic pages. Hell, you can even map it to a shortcut[1]. It sucks, but the alternative is positively bleak.

.

TL;DR: The bathroom may be dirty, but at least no one's taking a shit in my kitchen.

[1] https://adblockplus.org/en/faq_customization#shortcuts

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by belorn on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:47AM (#9698255)
Non-consented advertisement has had their click and buy rate diminish each year, and customers are only getting more dissatisfied by each attempt to squeeze more and more from them. Blocks are the natural step when you have somewhere around less than 0.1% success rate per customer. Mail Spam as advertisements can be seen as the warning sign, and spam protection is today a critical feature that all mail programs must have to be considered functional.

Consented advertisement, on the other hand, is having a great time. More stores are now using club memberships for advertisements, and when Facebook started to only send out a fraction of news letters, some customers went and asked where their news letters has gone. People are actively seeking where their consented advertisement are when it is being blocked.

I find taking a moral stand in the name of non-consented advertisement to be a bit sad. They had their chance with do-not-track and they collectively decided to ignore consent. Instead of taking a step back, they doubled down on being more intrusive and anti-consumer. Now they've got to live with the consequences, while companies reroute money to consented advertisements.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by hyperbovine on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:45PM (#9697153)
> The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content.

A false dichotomy if ever there was one. "Paywals" worked in literally every single other sector of the economy for all of recorded human history (I know, I know, who can remember that brief ~6000 year interlude between the Sumerians and the Internet!) The continue to work at your local dry cleaner, grocery store, Home Depot, etc. Really everything that doesn't require a browser. There are all sorts of moral, social, economic, and environmental reasons to be opposed to advertising. I keep AdBlock on by default because I dream of a day when I can pay Google a decent sum of money each month in return for their service.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by cwyers on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:02PM (#9697196)
The issue with Home Depot is that if I buy a dishwasher from there, I get one dishwasher. If I give that dishwasher away, I have no dishwasher. With online content, that doesn't hold. If I give away a copy of an article I just read in the New York Times, I still have a copy.

It goes even further than that. Content I can share with my friends is MORE valuable than content I keep all to myself, in some cases. (Paywalls are most successful where that isn't true -- where there's some advantage to having information that other people don't.)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by gameguy43 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:06PM (#9697207)
Don't copy that floppy!
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by Sideloader on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:12AM (#9697474)
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by 72deluxe on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:50AM (#9698655)
Did it though? Is music "better" or "worse" now?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by Sideloader on Thursday June 11, 2015 @08:44AM (#9699304)
What do you mean by "better" or "worse"? Music is certainly alive and well and I am absolutely spoiled for choice. My musician/dj/producer friends are all busy, happy people.

The recording industry's "good old days" were mostly before my time but producer and musician Steve Albini, who was around back then, called the record industry out in 1993 in an essay succinctly titled The Problem With Music http://www.negativland.com/news/?page_id=17

Here he talks "about the advantages of the internet, the death of the major label system, copyright law and that ‘purple dwarf in assless chaps'" http://www.theguardian.com/music/2014/nov/17/steve-albinis-k...

Article and video here... http://www.theguardian.com/music/2014/nov/17/steve-albini-at...

An excerpt: In contrast to what almost anyone else will tell you, Albini believes there has never been a better time to be involved in music – as a fan and as a musician (excluding, perhaps, the megastars): “I see more bands and I hear more music than ever before in my life. There are more gigs, more songs available than ever before, bands are being treated with more respect, and are more in control of their careers and destinies.

“I see them continuing as a constellation of enterprises: some big, some small, most small but all of them with a more immediate response from their audience and a greater chance to succeed. It is genuinely exciting.”

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by 72deluxe on Thursday June 11, 2015 @10:52AM (#9700037)
Yes I would agree it has never been a better time! I was just asking to see if home taping really did affect it like people believe.

For one thing, the quality of recording interfaces and the accessibility of such hardware is really really great at the moment. I play in a few bands and being able to record practices in clear quality and listen back to them would have been unheard of 15 years ago.

As for the quality of that music, that's entirely subjective.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by coldtea on Thursday June 11, 2015 @07:41AM (#9699011)
Justin Bieber and Nicky Manaj vs Sly and The Family Stone and Marvin Gaye.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by braythwayt on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:33AM (#9699577)
I was around for Sly and The Family Stone and Marvin Gaye, and your comparison is biased. You can always take any two periods of time and compare the worst of X to the best of Y.

When looking backwards, you have an especial temptation to compare whatever is popular right-this-instant to whatever from back then has stood the test of time, even if it wasn’t the most popular thing in the world.

I’d compare Justin Bieber to The Monkees, personally.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by coldtea on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:55PM (#9701937)
>You can always take any two periods of time and compare the worst of X to the best of Y.

Yeah, but both were in the top charts.

Not that good stuff in the charts nowadays.

>I’d compare Justin Bieber to The Monkees, personally.

That comparison would also make my point, though. Bieber is for teenage girls, period, and bad at that.

60's music for teenage girls were the Beatles or at worse Petula Clark and the like.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by slowmotiony on Thursday June 11, 2015 @08:46AM (#9699314)
Mainstream music sure does suck now, but music in general is better today than it ever was.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by coldtea on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:58PM (#9701959)
Music in itself, probably.

But the "mainstreamity" (connecting a society and being a central cultural focus) is also a desirable attribute from music (from art in general), that is lacking today.

That is, there's music that's great but not mainstream and music that's mainstream but not great. The sixties and seventies (up to the nineties maybe) had both.

Modern good music has lost that, and everyone listens to good or even excellent music oblivious on his own little world and niche.

(Oh, and I'm not waxing because I'm some Beatles-loving older guy -- I'm much younger and in fact I listen to tons of new music most people wouldn't even touch, from Nobukazu Takemura to Mount Erie, Four Tet, etc.).

For me it's like great modern music is like some excellent Social Media site, with tons of features, great layout, speedy backends, nice UI et al, but where there are very few people using it. Yeah, in itself it might be a great web app, but where's the conversation and the social aspect?

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by hyperbovine on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:11PM (#9697225)
Obviously, copyright owners need to be able to control the distribution of their IP for this model to work. But that is as separate issue which is not mitigated by the ad-supported model. E.g. there are whole sites devoted to blatantly ripping off content from NY Times, WSJ, etc. and slapping their own ads on top.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by cwyers on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:22PM (#9697266)
It's not about being able to control the distribution of their IP, it's that allowing users to redistribute their IP makes that IP more valuable for users. This isn't a universal truth of all content, but it's certainly a truth for stuff like news articles. Look at this very website. It's premised around sharing articles, blog posts, and such and allowing users to add their own commentary and see what others think about the same article. Every time a paywalled article comes up on the front page Hacker News, half the posts in the first 10 minutes are about how to get around the paywall or complaints about the paywall.

The point is, for a user of Hacker News, an article he or she can post on this site and share with other HN users is simply more valuable than an article he or she cannot. And that's not just a local phenomenon, it's part of Twitter, Facebook and a bunch of other smaller (sometimes ad hoc) online communities.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by amelius on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:32AM (#9698421)
But isn't it great that HN lets us know which articles are worth paying for?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by tolmasky on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:12AM (#9697475)
Its a deeply interrelated issue. Personally, "copyright owners need to be able to control the distribution of their IP" is far more frightening to hear to me than anything about ads. Every "advancement" made for IP holders is usually incredibly customer hostile. We've seen international trade deals over this issue, we've seen fundamental rights degraded over this issue. I personally would prefer it not boil down to legal means of ensuring content owners get their content not ripped off (a last resort that rarely works), as opposed to a natural solution where the distribution method matches the natural inclinations of the users (people generally DON'T feel bad about stealing "content", but DO feel bad about stealing washing machines).

For the record, ads existed before the internet too. Remember the radio? Remember PHYSICAL newspapers. Remember TV? Its kind of nice that the lower economic stratus of society has SOME access to all these services without being blocked by a paywall. In a paywall world, you walk into a library to use the internet because you don't have a computer, then are turned away from every site because you also don't have a credit card.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by pmontra on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:07AM (#9698102)
Ok with your first paragraph and free TV with ads predates the Internet, ok. But free newspapers with ads are a 2000's invention, at least in my part of the world. Newspapers used to be protected by a paywall, currently some hundreds of Euro per year. Problem is: people usually read only one physical newspaper so even one Euro per day would be ok, but they read articles on random websites linked by Google News. Either you micro-pay each article (0.01?) or you won't afford news anymore, unless you read them on only one website again.

Maybe that kind of world would be great for aggregators. Think Flipboard. They could buy content from newspapers and resell it with a subscription. That would work for Blogger and Wordpress.com too: pay for access to all the blogs on the site. Maybe this is the first step of an Apple's strategy to become a news/blog aggregator. Damage the competition and take over.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by eli on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:53PM (#9697402)
That's a very different Internet from the one we live on today. I don't think most people want to pay per page view even if the system were relatively cheap and well implemented. I like that I can link to a page and typically trust that if the other person is on the Internet, they can view it.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by nostrademons on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:52AM (#9698048)
What if it were a flat fee? Google makes on the order of $60/user/year. I'd personally be happy to pay $5/month to Google things.

Grandparent poster has me intrigued. It's common knowledge that you can't make money off consumers on the Internet, but I wonder if this is just a function of the newness of the Internet and intensity of competition when the main business models that support it were invented. I wonder, if Google were to offer a $5/month plan where they wouldn't show you any ads and didn't collect any personal data on you, how many people would take it.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by menzoic on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:02AM (#9698086)
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by coldpie on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:08AM (#9699428)
Wow, that's actually really neat. Thank you for posting that.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by iSnow on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:17AM (#9698136)
I would even pay double this if I had the assurance Google stopped recording my every move.

The stuff they make is fantastic, their services are great and I'd be happy to pay for them. But not on top of them selling my data.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by patrickaljord on Saturday June 13, 2015 @06:11PM (#9712891)
> But not on top of them selling my data.

I have good news for you, Google (and Facebook) are not selling your data, they keep it to themselves. They sell ads display, selling your data would be very bad for their business as customers wouldn't need them then. It's like saying coca cola is making money selling their recipe instead of the prepared soda. Can we just stop repeating this misinformation? I'd expect better from HN.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by soylentcola on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:19PM (#9702114)
Counterpoint(s): A lot of the stuff they make is fantastic (and works fantastically) because their analytics help determine what that website ought to display or what you probably meant by that search query.

I get an email from a friend inviting me to a workshop Friday evening. When I open the invite it asks me if I am going. I click "yes" and it adds the event to my calendar. After work on Friday I use Maps to find the quickest way home through rush hour traffic. Since I have typed in my destination and run the mapping app, Google's algorithms can tell when I get home. Later in the evening, my watch buzzes and I see a notification that tells me that I'll need to leave by 7:34pm to make it to the workshop at 8:00pm in the current traffic. I swipe away the notification and get ready to leave. Once I leave, my Nest thermostat switches over to "away" mode since I don't need to run the a/c nearly as cool while I'm away. Thankfully, since it's 94 degrees today, it will use the weather info in my area as well as the indoor thermometer to calculate the most efficient time to start cooling again when I fire up Maps to head back home.

This is a scenario that I run into just about every day. I may not use all of those things every single day but I do on some. Other times it's more basic (calendar reminders or HVAC auto-tweaking for energy efficiency). Either way, none of it works without analysis of the data I choose to feed it during the course of daily life.

And as far as I can tell, they haven't "sold" my data to anyone. What they have done is use it to make educated guesses about where I live and what may be of interest to me. That way when they sell ad space on the Youtube videos I watch later this evening or on the sidebar of a web search, they can sell that ad space to others who will pay more in the knowledge that their ad budget will be more useful than just a guess.

I certainly remember the web before this sort of thing. Ad space was worth even less than it is now since the only way to stand out was to make your banners more annoying and more abundant. It was worse than cable/tv where a quarter (or more) of every hour is filled by advertising. The advertising is almost never relevant to my interests. It's loud and stupid and on top of it, I still have to pay for cable. To complete the analogy, if Google started a cable network, they could charge $15/mo, show only 10 minutes of ads during an hour-long program, and the ads would at least be for things I would conceivably buy much of the time.

There's plenty of down sides to targeted advertising but the selling of access to my eyeballs is not the same thing as selling my data. It may not seem like much but it makes all the difference to me. In one scenario I consent to one company using the info I give them to enable the services I use. In the other, I'm giving consent for a company to sell my actual info to unknown and undisclosed third parties.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by 72deluxe on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:51AM (#9698660)
I would be tempted too!
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by sliverstorm on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:48AM (#9697640)
Most people would not pay if the cost was fifty cents. But what if it was 0.1 cents? My desktop computer burns 0.1 cents in electricity every ten minutes.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by calgoo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:15AM (#9698129)
i would still not ever visit the site, and i would do everything in my power to rip the content and distribute it freely.

I keep adblock on all the time now, only adding a few exceptions which i deem worthy. My problem is that i can not stand to have so much BS ads added to the text of the page. Sometimes i even use adblock to remove part of the webpages so i only get the content, when the author has made the page to messy.

However, its not that hard to make a page acceptable, just don't add 10 ad boxes around and inside you article. Also don't add ads inside the text I'm reading, that is going to get blocked in seconds. Flash and image ads (especially ones that try to imitate page functions) are atrocities that a lot of times makes me leave a page and not visit it until months later when i forget why i was not visiting it.

The only ads i approve are small, text based ads that are clearly marked as such and that don't interrupt the flow of information from the page. The moment i have to halt and reason if something is and ad or not, you get automatically blacklisted, and heavily so.

On my home network i redirect several abusive ad networks DNS entries to an internal server that hijacks the ads and replaces them with jolly rogers :P

Its really fun to see some pages with 8 jolly rogers smiling back at you giving me a evil grin thinking of the cents the page is loosing.

[Edit: fixed spelling]

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by 72deluxe on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:53AM (#9698666)
If you are ripping content and distributing it, aren't you engaging in copyright infringement?

The argument for infringing copyright has never stood up. "Music wants to be free" etc. etc. is all a load of rubbish. "Food wants to be free" is another slogan we could all adopt but nobody would accept it because food has a cost, the same way that creating content has a cost.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by ptman on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:41AM (#9698011)
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by felipeerias on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:08AM (#9698106)
I see people posting that link over and over, as it it made some kind of valuable point. Do you realize that for this to work, you need to be permanently tracked by Google?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mike_hearn on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:47AM (#9698650)
Er, yes. What is your proposed alternative? Ads have the advantage of being anonymous and the "tracking" is optional (you can block cookies and see worse ads, if you like). The alternative is to pay for things. On the internet paying for things requires an account and (modulo bitcoin) a credit card, neither of which are anonymous or private.

So far we cannot have our cake AND eat it. So you have to pick.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by castell on Thursday June 11, 2015 @08:59AM (#9699379)
Ah, isn't Google (among others) one of the "problems"?

* The lack of quality control of their ads displays a "download" button next to real download links and trick casual users to download malware.

* Ads that follow you around and are so creepy that's certainly the number one reason to block ads.

* Pay little money for ad impressions to the website owners. They prefer clicks over impressions, which leads to a lose-lose.

They could improve the situation by doing the opposite of what they do at the moment.

And Apple with its iAds is not much better, they would profit if more websites would cease to provide a mobile version and provide an iAs funded iOS app in their walled garden app store.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by beobab on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:20AM (#9699508)
I may be in the minority, but I actually like the fact that when I look at cameras on amazon, I see adverts for lenses and tripods and cool flashes.

It's nicer (imho) than just seeing "get this weight loss pill and lose pounds!" ads, which I am never going to even be vaguely interested in.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by soylentcola on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:37PM (#9702230)
Exactly. And in addition, the companies that pay to advertise will pay more when their ads have a better chance of reaching potential customers. This leads to fewer ads needed to generate the same revenue, less wasted ad budget by people who sell the products advertised, and less irrelevant stuff cluttering up your browser window.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by _up on Sunday June 14, 2015 @05:24AM (#9714292)
And with all that tracking, they also can look if poeple price check items and than rise the price if they come back. Because now they know the customer already decided to buy. Happened with collaborating Flight booking sites.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by dunkelheit on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:07AM (#9698701)
That's kind of a different thing. You do not pay google for their service (search). Instead you pay for content using google. Google sits in their favorite position of the all-tracking middleman and uses gathered information for serving you more and more creepy ads.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:45AM (#9698249)
It's not tenable for the user to create and maintain a subscription for every site they want to read on the internet. People may pay a central broker to manage these subscriptions, like they do with cable companies, but they won't create tens of individual subscriptions for the sites they like to read.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by menzoic on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:01AM (#9698080)
> I dream of a day when I can pay Google a decent sum of money each month in return for their service

The wait over https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by hyperbovine on Thursday June 11, 2015 @10:02AM (#9699746)
Know what site I do not see participating there? Google.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:58PM (#9697011)
I see your point, but the the alternative is we need a better solution; blocking ads doesn't mean the writing becomes corrupt and we give up and that's it. Adblocking will lead to content creators finding a better revenue source; there are a lot of people that don't want to compromise themselves by being a paid voice for corporate interests.

Buzzfeed is a poor example; it's just garbage content that is being re-circulated by many different places. There are TONS of sites that have paywalls and/or ads on their sites and their writing is still compromised. So I think paying for content and getting advertisements out of good content is the solution to restore independence, but the price point needs to be right.

I hate blocking ads (I whitelist sites I visit frequently with reasonable ads) but ads have become obnoxious, so AdBlock is a natural reaction to site owners treating users like shit. Sadly, a lot of reasonable sites with unobtrusive ads have gotten caught up in blacklists.

I would pay for good news content if I could pay for a bundle of good content at a fair price. Even something like the NY Times is a hard sell; it feels weird given the wealth of sources and information we have access to these days. NY Times is a great source, but I don't want to only read a single source. And it quickly becomes unaffordable if you want to pay for a lot of sources of information.

Spotify and similar providers solved this with music and I still think a better solution will come out eventually for news. There are a lot of people that want to pay a fair price for good content, but the current options are not very good.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mozumder on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:29PM (#9697116)
Spotify isn't profitable. I don't know any subscription-based pure-play internet media company that's profitable. (Maybe Netflix? But we'll have to see how profitable they are now that other subscription services have recently launched.)

The NYTimes is probably the highest-end as far as content quality is concerned, but if you're not going to pay for that, why would you pay for anything else?

Absolutely no one is paying for content online. People pay for art. They don't pay for commodity, and everything online is information commodity. There's just too much low-value competing sources that are "good enough" for consumer interests.

Given that, I think ad-blocking has largely been overstated as a concern for media sites. Among my own friends, I only know one person that uses ad-blockers. Ads aren't a problem that people worry about. In fact, for a good media property, ads are a draw. People buy fashion magazines and Sunday newspapers for the ads, for example.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by trimbo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:02AM (#9697699)
> Absolutely no one is paying for content online

"The Financial Times saw a sharp increase in profits in 2014, driven by growth in subscription and digital revenues and a record high circulation.

The FT’s total circulation grew 10% year-on-year to nearly 720,000 across print and online. FT.com subscriptions grew 21% to almost 504,000, with digital now representing 70% of the FT’s total paying audience."

http://aboutus.ft.com/2015/02/27/financial-times-2014-result...

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mozumder on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:00AM (#9697881)
right. And about 320,000 people pay $24,000/year for a Bloomberg terminal. I still see them (FT, WSJ, BB, etc..) as a niche trade-specific media properties, with no relevance to people outside of the industry.

Or to put it another way, you're saying "Sure, subscriptions on the internet can work.. all you need is everyone to be a banker!"

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by MaysonL on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:04AM (#9697444)
Absolutely no one is paying for content online.

Techpinions, the Information, and Ben Thompson would all disagree.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mozumder on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:51AM (#9697653)
Those are industry sites, for professionals to use for their jobs. They're equivalent to academic journals. Bankers can pay Bloomberg $24,000/year for their terminal.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by MaysonL on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:15AM (#9698370)
OK, how about Lynda.com?

In other words, people who think the information will pay for itself, or is valuable in some other way, are willing to pay for it. That's a far cry from absolutely nobody.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by afarrell on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:33PM (#9697122)
> Adblocking will lead to content creators finding a better revenue source;

Is this true though? If you throw a child into the water and thereby force them to either sink or swim, it does not actually force them to swim.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by malandrew on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:14AM (#9697739)
If you throw a bunch of children into the water and thereby force them to either sink or swim, those that know how to swim will and those that don't will sink.

This will filter out those that can't produce content that people are willing to pay for. Hopefully this will kill low quality content. Those producing high-quality valuable content will be recognized by those that know how to make money from quality content those partnerships will be the ones that learn to swim.

Advertising supported content has increased the noise and drowned out the quality. It will be nice to once again hear more of the people with something worth saying.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by afarrell on Friday June 12, 2015 @08:51AM (#9705509)
> Those producing high-quality valuable content will be recognized by those that know how to make money from quality content those partnerships will be the ones that learn to swim.

And they will be constantly fighting against those who know how to write software to get access to the content without paying.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by Karunamon on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:47AM (#9699650)
Sounds like a great way for extremely specialized, niche content to die.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by malandrew on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:54PM (#9701224)
Most of the extremely specialized niche content I enjoy is written by people who write about things because they like to write about things they care about regardless of revenue. For those that need to get paid, if their content is worth it, they will be able to charge.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by asddubs on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:55AM (#9698060)
goodbye, niche content
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mercer on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:30AM (#9698415)
The crucial difference is that this is not a child but more like a robot specifically designed to operate in a certain way for profit. Sadly this robot cannot swim, and its owners are scrambling to make swimming illegal, keeping their robot afloat with ugly floaters, or <insert other analogy>.

Meanwhile, if we were to let the robot sink to the bottom, the actual creators of the robot, who have a passion for robotics, will find ways to create a robot that swims, and will love doing it.

Might it hurt them in the short run? Yes, and I'm all for working hard at solutions to that problem (basic income perhaps? But that's a whole other issue). But in the long run these creators can and have found ways around these problems. We see some of this in music and gaming, and it's already happening in 'publishing' (individual journalists and writers finding ways to get profit/donations, blendle.com, certain paywalled publications, etc.)

But I for one am tired of working hard at a beautiful site for an 'owner' and then working even harder at turning the end result into a slow, ad-infested, privacy-invading mess. The sooner that solutions are 'forced' into existence, the more likely it will be that I can build profitable things that are not crap.

And I've spoken to many journalists and musicians who feel the same way.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by eli on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:51PM (#9697397)
So far that hasn't been the case for newspapers, which have never really recovered from the decline in ad rates over the past few decades. Many smaller papers have gone out of business. Larger ones have cut back on expensive foreign correspondents and beat reporters.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by bsbechtel on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:41PM (#9697140)
Horrible analogy, but a percentage will, and a percentage will sink.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by eeeeeeeeeeeee on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:34PM (#9697125)
It's not going to change over night, but neither did music.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by afarrell on Friday June 12, 2015 @08:48AM (#9705493)
Is music better for mundane artists to be able to make a living now than it was in the 90s?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by ksec on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:38PM (#9697132)
I am going to guess half of the people who uses Adblock is because it brings much better experience in browsing. And that is mostly because the web loads much faster, and the browser is much more responsive.

We change from 2 - 6 Mbps ADSL to 10s / 100s or even Gigabit Fibre, we moved from Single to Quad Core / Thread, 2GB to now mostly 4/8GB Memory, and order of magnitude faster with SSD. Software improvements, much better OS etc...

And yet the web is still slow, very slow compared to the technological improvement we have.

So how would a normal user do / think, Anything that is moving, distracting, or have a sense of constantly running, i.e Ads, they blame those. And Since there are likely many of those running, what else to blame that is slowing down the web?

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by simon_vetter on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:31AM (#9698779)
> Anything that is moving, distracting

This. It's really hard to stay focused on an article or piece of text longer than a few sentences with flickering images, autoplaying videos (with sound), and recently those pesky javascript overlay popups.

Blocking ads doesn't just make for a faster web experience, it also allows you to have proper attention spans necessary to read and digest two pages of text, and that's true for any kind of audience, tech-savvy or not.

Obviously, privacy invasion, constant and pervasive tracking, malware distribution, profiling and exploitation of personal data in jurisdictions with poor consumer protection laws and over which you have no control or say are all alarming and dangerous.

When people started raising concerns and calling this out a few years back, ad networks (and the tech industry they are living on) came forward with DNT, "voluntary opt outs", privacy policies and "personalized contents and ads".

Most people would probably agree that all these options are equally laughable as they merely try to appease concerns rather than addressing them.

Regardless of my personal opinion, is it really surprising to see people of all kinds start using tools making their experience better? For most people, the web is merely a medium, just like paper books.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by interpol_p on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:28AM (#9697779)
> The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content.

I love ads "inside" my content when they are done right.

The most effective advertising for me is when an author I like to read recommends a product by directly writing about it because they were paid to do so and they like to use the product. Ad blockers don't block these because they aren't ads, they show up inline with the rest of the author's content (and the author acknowledges it was a sponsored posting).

I am completely happy with this model. The whole reason I read an author is because I like her style and opinion. So a recommendation from her, as long as she genuinely likes the product, is actually interesting to me.

The same goes for video: algorithmically determined video ads at the start or within video content are rubbish and I will block them. But the presenters themselves recommending something in-line I am totally open to watching.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:17AM (#9698140)
> The most effective advertising for me is when an author I like to read recommends a product by directly writing about it because they were paid to do so and they like to use the product.

You're very careful to specify that the author must genuinely like the product. How do you know that they like to use the product? There's a reason that the responsible disclosure and the distinction between content and advertising has existed as an ethical guideline for decades longer than the Web has, and that's because "content creators should get paid by the subject of their content but be uninfluenced by the money" is a horrendously childish view of the world.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mst on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:08AM (#9698344)
Trust. When I see Daring Fireball advertise something, I know it's approved by Gruber. And he makes it clear that it's a paid advert anyway.

Works great for me; it'd never occur to me to even want to block those adverts.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by coldtea on Thursday June 11, 2015 @07:43AM (#9699019)
>Trust. When I see Daring Fireball advertise something, I know it's approved by Gruber.

It's very easy to convince yourself you "approve" something if money coming your way depends on that approval.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by interpol_p on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:35AM (#9698792)
Generally if you like the author you get a good feeling of what they like. You read them because you have similar taste to them, you have used and enjoyed their recommendations in the past.

If they start recommending bad products just for the money, I imagine they will very soon lose their integrity and your trust.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by ads_are_crap on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:27AM (#9697971)
Goodbye ads. We won't miss you. If you have content, and it is worth it, people may pay for it. Otherwise, natural selection, survival of the fittest etc. Excellent move by Apple. They managed to kill Flash, and now Ads.. fantastic!
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by cookiecaper on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:34AM (#9697994)
People won't pay for anything but highly specialized content. First-class integration of ad blockers will eventually just drive down the amount of actual content available; people will put fluff content that is actually an ad or they'll have to go do something else with their time. Maybe this is a good thing or maybe it's a bad thing, but one thing is for sure: people are not going to be taking special action to pay for content that isn't highly specialized.

One potential non-ad route for monetization would be an extension for the browser that opens your bitcoin wallet and sends a tip to a page's creator based on how much of your time was spent on that site that day. That'd be better than ads if we could get widespread adoption, as the site's owners wouldn't feel compelled to make deals with entities that may force them to compromise their content. Maybe Firefox can integrate it to counteract Safari.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mercer on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:16AM (#9698372)
But why is that a bad thing? The already bad, native-ad-infested content would get worse, and people will actually start paying for the good content. The state of publishing is already pretty bad as it is, and any void left behind will be and is being filled up by better alternatives.

It's like arguing for big music labels because otherwise music would disappear. It won't, and it didn't!

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mike_hearn on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:48AM (#9698653)
I read lots of great ad supported content every day.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by jfoutz on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:37AM (#9698002)
I hope you realize the frustration and consternation of the gp poster. It's really hard to identify where the monitization happens. Right now, i sort of default to comments like this as well meaning at worst.

Now, i sort of wonder, did you get paid for this?

That's not necessarily bad. I can imagine a scheme were advertisers do sentiment analysis on comments, and reimburse users for positive emotions in response to a brand. I think it would be hard to sustain discourse int that environment, but i'd hope you at least got paid.

Everyone is an astroturfer would be a strange world. Real communication would be to subtle for the SA to detect. Interesting indeed.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by egypturnash on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:56AM (#9698504)
There are other alternatives to "ads alongside my content" that don't involve "more obnoxious ads".

I make a webcomic. Historically, that's very much an ad-supported medium. I also block ads aggressively; it's one of the reasons I hassle with jailbreaking my iThings.

I put my adblocking mouth where my money is: as long as I'm getting enough money per new page of comics on Patreon, I don't have any ads on my current project. It's been great to not have anything trying to distract people from reading my content. Sometime next year, as the Patreon income rises, I'll turn off ads on all my comics, new or old. There's no paywall; anyone who wants to read my comic can do this for free, with no ads thanks to the generosity of my supporters.

Obviously it's easier for one person to make enough money via the donation box than it is for a large company; this does not necessarily scale. But it's an option worth considering. And hell, it can work on a larger scale - if you're old enough to remember a time before cable, or if you listen to the radio in the car, you may be familiar with the yearly donation drives on your local public tv/radio station; you may even be a supporter. Or hell: last year when an algorithm change at Google resulted in a lot less drive-by traffic to Metafilter, they started taking donations from their regular userbase. It has ended up being a significant portion of their income; https://metatalk.metafilter.com/23721/State-of-Metafilter-an...

(Yes, I am also aware that I am arguably stealing from all the people whose ads I block without supporting them. I've made my peace with that moral quandary. I fast-forwarded over the commercials when I used to watch stuff on TV, too.)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by WalterGR on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:09AM (#9698708)

    I make a webcomic...  I also block ads aggressively...  I put
    my adblocking mouth where my money is: as long as I'm getting
    enough money per new page of comics on Patreon, I don't have any
    ads on my current project.  It's been great to not have anything
    trying to distract people from reading my content.  Sometime
    next year, as the Patreon income rises, I'll turn off ads on
    all my comics, new or old.
Sorry to simplify, but I'm not familiar with your work: Is it safe to say that you

1. show exactly enough advertisements to earn what you subjectively feel is a salary commensurate with your investment -- time investment or otherwise

2. block all ads from other sites?

(Disclaimer: I make a portion of my income from ads.)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by egypturnash on Friday June 19, 2015 @02:04AM (#9743236)
I show no ads on my comic. All of the money I make from it comes from Patreon.

When I browse the web, I use adblockers.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by frik on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:28AM (#9697552)
The problem are not ads, but certain kinds of ads.

Bad ads: CPU intensive ads and privacy inversive "personalised" ads that follow you around

Solution: Show us simple text or picture based banner ads with ad content related to the website topic and pay the website owner a reasonable money per 1000 views/impressions called CPM.

AdBlocker should block only the bad ads, and keep the static non inversive ads. Remember as soon as browser vendors blocked the annoying popups the ads industry had to change their ads format. It's time that browser vendors initiate another such forced change. Though blocking all ads is a bad solution, as an internet without ads means probably a bad web walled garden paywall experience - a lose lose situation.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by sliverstorm on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:34AM (#9697582)
"Personalized" ads can actually be kind of nice. I like seeing ads that are for things I care about, instead of for things that "people who visit this site" care about.

There's hazards, it's true, but I feel like I have seen the future where ads are helpful and don't feel like ads as we have come to know them, and I like it.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by frik on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:56AM (#9697680)
Personalised ads show what I just bought or viewed and never will buy as I bought something else. Non-personalized ads shouldn't show things what other people bought but it should show me things about the current page content or or the site topic. Show me pictures with links to amazon books about the programming language the article is about, etc.

I know a lot of (startup) companies are in that market and try to be helpful by big data grinding. But neither Google ads, nor any other personalised ads were useful at all to me. Ads that follow me around just because I visited a site two times is just very creepy and "forces" users to investigate how to block ads in the first place. If you work on a ads network please pivot to a "better ads" that allow website owners to install the ads service on their website - this is the only solution that will work despite an adblocker! So write an ad network in Go/Rust, be it a single executable, and website owners can simply add it to their website.

Only the information on Amazon.com below the product page that shows what other people who bought this product also bought works.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by iSnow on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:23AM (#9698156)
Like the Amazon suggestions system that after buying one bicycle pump tries to sell me more of the same because obviously collecting bicycle pumps is a hobby of mine. Exchange bicycle pump with vibrator for an even less welcome example.

Even worse: the social graph mining derived suggestion systems that recommend wares based on the bad taste of my friends instead of my bad taste.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by giancarlostoro on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:37AM (#9698000)
If ads weren't as intrusive as they can be (ie pop-ups, pop unders, auto-played video adverts with audio enable etc) I wouldn't mind them, but when you impose on my expectancy of what a website should work like or behave like then I need to block your advertisements. Otherwise, I would happily allow your ads. Some websites ruin my experience overall, not only do I now have to go out of my way to scour the screen but now I'm ignoring whatever it was I came to your website to begin with, usually at that point I close the website never to return.

I'm all for non-intrusive advertisements.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by raverbashing on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:56AM (#9698063)
I agree.

But advertisers abuse

Maybe it's time for 'ad toning down' instead of blocking all of them, block animated gifs, block big images, etc (though in mobile this is not so bad)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by slavak on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:26AM (#9698175)
Isn't that the entire point of AdBlock's default allowing of non-intrusive ads? People like to rant about them "selling out," but IMO it's a reasonable approach to allow decent sites to make a living, is a good monetization strategy, and they seem to have reasonable and global requirements for what constitutes a "non-intrusive" ad. (i.e.: It's not just a case of "pay us enough to blast loud popup videos in the user's face.")
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by nathan_long on Friday June 12, 2015 @03:51PM (#9708150)
"Allowing non-intrusive ads" seems like a fine goal to help users and advertisers alike. If a community of users maintained the whitelist, it would be a non-issue.

The fact that the list is managed privately and that whether a company pays them influences whether they're blocked does muddy the waters quite a bit.

https://adblockplus.org/acceptable-ads-agreements#payment

Not all ad blockers do this. Eg: https://getadblock.com/ doesn't (disclosure: creator is a friend of mine and I once worked a bit on the product). uBlock also doesn't do this: https://www.ublock.org/

And I'm sure there are others.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mst on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:07AM (#9698338)
This is precisely why I run adblock plus is non-intrusive ad only mode.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by hessenwolf on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:18AM (#9698142)
In mobile? I've shut so many sites down in the last two weeks because I couldn't read on my iphone over the ad. It happens less to me in this period on android devices I notice.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by malka on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:33AM (#9698424)
you add "tracking ads" to this list, and I'm all for it.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mrweasel on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:12AM (#9698118)
>I'm all for non-intrusive advertisements.

I'm pretty sure that the ad companies measure what kind of ads work, and which doesn't and what you're asking is that they leave the ineffective ads in place and remove the ones you can't ignore.

Honestly I don't believe that online ads work very well, they are a waste of money, but it's pretty hard to prove, so companies keeps buying them, just to be sure.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:52AM (#9698273)
What's the solution then, regulation? Imagine how bad our public spaces and television advertising would be if there were no regulation whatsoever. If we're walking towards that eventuality online, something needs to be done to arrest that very soon.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by JonFish85 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:15AM (#9699474)
"I'm all for non-intrusive advertisements."

Is that really true though? Do you want "news" articles to be written by advertisers? Instead of journalism, you have an ad that blurs the line between reporting facts and advertising content. As John Oliver pointed out (and I'm sure others), even the New York Times has done some of these types of articles[1]. Is that the future you want? If an article on juice being sold in schools is really written by Snapple, but you can't tell, do you trust the advertiser to write an article with relevant facts?

[1] http://adage.com/article/media/york-times-runs-native-ad-ora...

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by sprokolopolis on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:50AM (#9698041)
I find the current state of ad services to be morally wrong; therefore, I do not feel bad about using an adblocker. I wouldn't be opposed to tasteful, cookie-less ads that don't attempt to track people around the internet and mine their data. I realize that people need to be paid for their time and content, but maybe there is a better way to manage, serve, and present the ads.

It would also be nice if people could decided on a sane and logical system of standard ad sizes, because the current standards are ridiculous and awkward.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by afishisafish on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:22AM (#9698152)
Without tracking there also wouldn't be ad fraud detection and that would hurt the group of honest publishers financially.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by adslingerssuck on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:40AM (#9698224)
And the malware distributors! Won't someone please think of them - how will they survive if the ads are gone! They have an HN approved business model too! /s
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by sprokolopolis on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:03AM (#9698529)
Then maybe those honest publishers need to find a revenue source that doesn't potentially support the sale of their viewers' private information (ad-based or not). People made money and sold products before internet ad-networks existed.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by PhilipA on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:01AM (#9698079)
If they don't track you they have no way to serve you relevant ads, and I would much rather want relevant ads than ads which promote useless products to me.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by jodrellblank on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:09AM (#9698110)
"Relevant ads" my arse.

They don't want to show me ads for things I'm already interested in, they want to make me interested in things I didn't know about, or more interested in things I knew about but wasn't going to buy.

They don't care about relevant, they want successfully manipulative ads.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by sprokolopolis on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:20AM (#9698387)
Then they should make them relevant to the context of the page, rather than me individually. How am I supposed to trust the opinion of an ad network that is selling my information for their profit? They aren't just using that information to serve me relevant ads. They are selling that data, making more money off my data than they are off of my non-existent purchases.

It is extremely rare that I ever see an ad that is actually relevant to me, with tracking or not. When I do see ads that are relevant to me they are completely useless (ex: showing me the exact product that I just looked at a few minutes ago and nothing new). Furthermore, I have been conditioned to completely ignore anything that might even look like an ad. I can't think of anytime that I have ever bought something because I saw an internet ad for it. I have purchased things that were recommended and/or reviewed by a trusted source online. Context and qualifications are much more convincing and influential than a box telling me to buy something.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by negrit on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:10AM (#9698111)
That's not true. TV, radio, printed newspapers, ... has done it for decades. It's content based. They are tracking because they can make more money out of the tracked data.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by jfoster on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:42AM (#9698234)
Can you explain end-to-end what you mean about advertisers making money out of the tracked data? (eg. what you think they track, what they do with the data, how they make money from the data, etc.)

I think it's very easy for different people to mean different things when having conversations on this topic, so it's good to spell it all out.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by negrit on Friday June 19, 2015 @02:05PM (#9746562)
Google/Facebook knows my friends, my searches, the websites I visit, what pages/product I look at, ...

They sell this data(even if it's anonymized).

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:48AM (#9698260)
This is already a problem with old media; The Daily Telegraph newspaper here in the Uk recently ignored a story about fraud and corruption at HSBC because of commercial interests (although they claim otherwise).

You assert that paywalls aren't working; as someone who has worked for two online publishing businesses whose models rely on a paywall, I disagree. There IS an issue with general interest content, but even that, I believe, is being resolved, albeit slowly. I think the market (or at least part of it) is slowly adjusting to the idea of paying for quality content. When micropayments eventually become a thing, this will only accelerate.

There are alternatives to bot those models. Bear in mind that not every website needs to make a huge profit. Many in the early days took no income whatsoever. Donations and merchandising are popular small income streams for many blogs. Not all advertising is objectionable; The Deck ad network, for example, provides advertising that is tasteful and unobtrusive (much like a polished version of Google AdWords).

Finally, content-based advertising CAN work, providing it's clearly demarcated, highly relevant, and entertaining in its own right. I must've listened to many hours of advertising via TWIT podcasts, and I don't really resent any of it.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by yAnonymous on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:32AM (#9698420)
>I do see it as a moral issue.

The moral issue is on the other side as well: Most malware comes from hacked ad servers and the ad industry doesn't really seem to care.

Until that changes, ads stay blocked and I won't even bother evaluating the other reasons (invasiveness, bandwidth/battery usage).

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by Karunamon on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:48AM (#9699660)
Malware is my #1 reason for blocking ads. Unless you as the website owner are willing to vet every single advertiser on your platform (or alternatively: commit to ads with zero active content), and compensate people if/when you let something through, the ads stay blocked.

My hourly rate is many times more than the few hundredths of a cent you get for the impression.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:15AM (#9698130)
Absolutely, I've been saying this for years. The line between advertisement and content is one that's been around for decades longer than the Web, and for good reason. And yet for some reason, those who defend ad-blockers as 'good for the web' are either too ignorant or too apathetic to understand that if increasing adblocker usage makes it intractable to provide free content when ads are easily distinguishable from content, then the majority of content that survives will break down that barrier. The collateral damage of rendering adblockers useless is skewing every webpage towards the content that the interested party with the deepest pockets wants.

It's particularly ridiculous when you consider that there's easy analogies to this that even the most clueless of adblocker users should be able to understand: if Google stopped distinguishing between ads and organic results, there would (rightly) be a huge outcry. One would have to be a fool not to understand that pushing the entire Web in that direction would be correspondingly more devastating.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by adslingerssuck on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:38AM (#9698217)
Can you hear that? It's the sound of the ad-slingers crying into their breakfast. Can you hear that? It's the sound of users cheering for a faster, sleeker, less malware drived web experience. I would say go cry me a ad river, but it doesn't matter - my browser blocks it!
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by wutbrodo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:09PM (#9700937)
I'm assuming you're a bot, or at the very least some sort of reverse-Turing test performance art in which you send generic and irrelevant replies to comments that match certain substrings. That's very cute, but adults are trying to have a conversation here, so shoo.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by orkoden on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:23PM (#9702548)
Magazines and newspapers have been disguising advertisements as articles for as longs as they have existed. Why is this one restaurant, album, book reviewed and not the other? How are the list of cool and hot fashion articles curated?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by wutbrodo on Friday June 12, 2015 @01:00AM (#9704151)
Just because codes of ethics are sometimes violated doesn't make them not useful. Consider the outcry that happens whenever a serious publication has even a minor failure to disclose (Stephanopoulous, Olbermann, etc). Now consider what kind of deterrent that must have on journalists for taking cash for favorable news coverage.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by InclinedPlane on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:10AM (#9697465)
Plenty of content makers manage to sustain themselves without annoying ads. Just because it's so common doesn't mean we need to just accept it, or that it's somehow "immoral" for content consumers to avoid ads.

Imagine if all content sites funded themselves via spam. When you viewed a site for the first time you'd have to verify your email address, which would then be spammed to oblivion. Would we tolerate that? Would we think it was immoral for people to do an end run around the spam?

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by TTPrograms on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:40PM (#9696937)
Well, there always the possibility of people paying for content voluntarily. Lots of niche creators seem to support themselves fairly well with non-DRM media and various forms of touring. Patreon seems to work for a fair number of creators.

I'm happy to support creators that I connect to. If we can figure out how to better enable this sort of connection I think there's hope.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by vlasev on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:48AM (#9698258)
As of right now you are literally the only person in the thread mentioning Patreon. Yet, it seems that Patreon-like services are one way to solve a lot of the problems.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by makeitsuckless on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:15AM (#9697938)
> "The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content."

The alternative to ads is no ads.

I keep various ad- and tracker- blockers on because I prefer a world that is not polluted by advertising, and in which privacy is respected.

Advertising versus no content is a false dichotomy, just like advertising versus no sport, or copyright versus no music.

It is this sheer propoganda the systematically prevents us from having a meaningful debate on the subject.

I do see it as a moral issue: I find advertising in all its current forms unethical. If you disagree, please have the courtesy of allowing for an honest discussion instead of spreading FUD about how horrific the world would be without advertising.

Also, the advertising industry is not going to draw the line at "native advertising", regardless. It won't stop until it has plastered the planet with advertising. Only the law and countermeasures have ever limited advertising.

tl;dr: There is already shit all over the house, it's naive to think they will stop at the kitchen.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by realityking on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:35AM (#9698206)
Serious question, how do you propose creators are to be paid? Paywall? Paid for content? Internet tax?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by makeitsuckless on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:00AM (#9698520)
It's not a serious question, it's cheap rhetoric.

Just because I'm against the pollution caused by chemical plants dumping unprocessed waste into rivers, doesn't mean I have to come up with solutions that allows the chemical industry to retain the same profit margins.

Personally, if I want to get paid for something I create, I ask for something in return, usually money. I could be wrong, but afaik that's the way we have done things for a very long time.

"If you want this, you also have to swallow this pile of shit, hell, if you even so much as glance in the general direction we'll start throwing shit at you" is a relatively recent business model, and I have a problem with it.

The onus is not on me to come up with alternatives for people who don't like the effort and/or profit margins involved in the way we've traded and bartered goods and services for millennia and prefer to throw shit at people.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by realityking on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:05PM (#9702433)
I have an issue with people who want to consume content but offer nothing in return. Why do you think you're entitled to read the New York Times without paying for it either with money (paywall) or attention (ads). That's why I think the blanket use of ad lockers is unethical.

Note I'm not saying the way we currently deal with ads is great or anything. They violate the users malware, are often infected with malware and sometimes make site plain unusable (usually not something intended by the site's owner)

Since you seem to prefer the paywall, let me ask how many paid subscriptions do you have for websites which are otherwise supported via ads? (e.g. New York Times, Wall Street Journal, ArsTechnica, etc.)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by 72deluxe on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:59AM (#9698686)
I suppose the difficulty is that servers on the Internet are available publicly and therefore people expect free content from them. The problem is that people put content on there for £0.00 and we have expected it to be that cost (ie, nothing) ever since.

It is obvious, however, that hosting servers is not without cost, nor is creating content without cost.

The solution would therefore be to: a. not offer content free, b. attempt to support it with adverts

Since option B is disliked by so many, the only logical option is A.

I believe we should probably have a reintroduction/introduction of HTTP 402. I think that would make sense.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by learnstats2 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:29AM (#9698593)
Serious answer: if you value a creator's work, you should pay them for it.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by realityking on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:07PM (#9702447)
But if I don't value it (e.g. Buzfeed) I should still be free to consume it without paying?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by learnstats2 on Friday June 12, 2015 @07:24AM (#9705172)
I don't want to single out Buzzfeed, but if ads are able to sustain an industry that nobody values - then that's not for the good of mankind.

The people employed in that field are not doing something valuable.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by ekianjo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:55AM (#9698058)
> I keep AdBlock off by default because I prefer a world where creators can make a meaningful articles and a useful apps without caring about who they are supporting, and can, as the price tag, separately attach an ad.

And you don't care about Ad Pushers Tracking what you see and where you go ? You have no morality problem there?

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mcmullen on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:15AM (#9698558)
I disagree with your assertion that "paywalls don't work", which is fundamentally not true. Content produces need to raise revenue to pay for their costs and make a profit. One excellent way to raise this revenue is by raising pay walls. It works for companies like The Times (London), The FT and The Economist. Will you retract this false statement?

What I think you're saying is that "worthless ramblings on the internet aren't (inherently) worth anything and thus no one wants to give them their money willingly", which of course isn't the fault of the paywall but the content.

It comes down to content creation and paying for it. If nobody wants to pay for it then it doesn't get created (unless you're a blogger, or meet your costs in some other way). We shouldn't have any time for people who want to get content for free.

I'm in the unusual position of actually paying for content and use AdBlockers, however I use it because I disagree with tracking on the grounds of consent and privacy. (That said, I will happily disable adblocking for websites who only want to show me banners and not track me.)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by the-dude on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:45AM (#9698644)
Blendle(http://blendle.com) is trying to be the 'micro'-paywall for content providers. After launching in The Netherlands, they have contracts with major German publishers now as well.

Micro-payment system which actually works.

Disclaimer: Dutch

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mcmullen on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:21AM (#9698735)
Thanks for the link. Interesting company! Nice summary here: https://medium.com/on-blendle/one-website-all-newspapers-and....

I like the idea of micro-payments for interesting, long-form content because there are various journalists I like who work for newspapers I don't subscribe to. I would happily pay for in-depth analysis pieces. I remain hopeful about non-click-bait journalism.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by dubyah on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:58AM (#9698074)
> A viewer's ability to distinguish between native ads and regular articles is small and quickly vanishing.

Thankfully, the FTC is helping in that regard. http://adexchanger.com/publishers/ftc-publishers-will-be-hel...

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by chrisdone on Thursday June 11, 2015 @08:21AM (#9699192)
I don't think morality has anything to do with this, unless you want to bring a marketing issue onto a high-ground that it frankly doesn't deserve. What body of ethics has anything to say about this?

I think part of the issue is that most of these services that base themselves on ads are inessential.

I don't care if reddit or gmail or last.fm goes down, I can always get another service that will step up and fill the niche. Grooveshark funded their service by ads, then it got taken down by a lawyer army, now I pay for a Spotify subscription.

When ads are present, they're part of the experience. And that means the experience, for some people, is shitty. People will prefer not to have shitty experiences. Some people decide to start out with the premise that they will make money off of ads, good luck to them. But it's not my moral obligation to accept it.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by minusSeven on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:02AM (#9697889)
Sorry but I am buying it. There certain websites that explicitly tell you to disable adblock to browse their websites. They make sure you can't get to their content without you blocking adblock. It never works. If new york times websites ask to disable adblock will I look at it. Sorry I and most people won't bother. The bigger problem here is companies haven't figured out how to monetize their content better.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by yardie on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:55AM (#9698061)
According to the NYT, they are monetizing pretty well from the paywall. For most of their articles they are the primary source. So, whether you buy a subscription directly or one of their affiliates pays for the content (and then tries to monetize it through ads) they are still getting paid.

They don't care if you don't want to pay for it or read it you are not their intended audience.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by manigandham on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:05AM (#9697908)
What's the better way? I hear this a lot but nobody has any other solutions. The two models that work are paid access or free for ads.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by cactusface on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:41PM (#9696943)
> If separate ads stop reaching people, the path to monetization remaining is to change your content to reflect someone else's agenda.

That said, non-web advertising agencies exert their influence over content too, regardless of whether or not there are separate ads or product placement. Why would the internet be different? Pretty sure you can't run AdSense on a porn site.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by RodericDay on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:21PM (#9696854)
the more walls are put up, the more ad consumption becomes a deliberate choice and not something that is snuck by people as they use social media.

it's a good organic balance we're working towards, the optimum amount of gatekeeping and profit-sharing.

as I said in an earlier post, the amount of money regular people lose bc of ads > the amount of people in the ad business pay out to "content creators"

>> Those families are indirectly paying that price today, through their ad-influenced purchases.

>> Not only are they paying for the end-product, but they're paying for the arms-race between advertisers as well, and that's a huge industry.

>> The amount of money the ad industry deals out to "content providers" must necessarily be less than the amount they get paid by their clients, which in turn must be less than the amount people paid to those clients.

>> If the distribution is not uniform, and some people benefit from the ad-influenced overspending of others, the business is then predatory.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by harperlee on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:58AM (#9698513)
> The alternative to ads alongside my content is ads inside my content.

You are assuming an invariable quantity of ads, which it is false.

This banning makes advertisement more difficult; and more difficult, or less effective, advertising would push towards giving less valuable "for free* (*advertised)". So it pushes towards having to pay for more things, which is good for Apple.

It's also valuable for us, in the sense that our customers are accustomed to get huge amounts of value for free. That's good for us creators.

The issue is that we are also consumers, and that's bad for us - we will need to pay more.

All in all, I believe too many people in this forum are risking their professional lifes a lot, and having a somewhat safer environment can end up being good for the economy. If there is less risk in entrepreneurship, more people will jump into putting effort into creating something good, as it is easier to sell.

It also works against productizing users information, which might be good for our privacy, too.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by 31reasons on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:22PM (#9696857)
I never click on Ads so from advertisers point of view I am using AdBlock. But that AdBlock is in my brain. When I use AdBlock on a browser it helps my brain. Advertisers don't care whether ad is on the side on inside the content, all they care is their ROI, so unless I start clicking on Ads I already run risk of getting ads in my content.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by cissou on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:35PM (#9696920)
Actually some of the biggest spenders are content with your brain just seeing the ad. It builds awareness (as in: you know that they exist, that they are still in business, that they are relevant). It's all they need to "help you" make a decision next time you're in a store and deciding between buying something from them or from their less-known competitor.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by daviross on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:15AM (#9697936)
Which is why I make a point of noting advertising and specifically weighing against them in any relevant purchasing mental calculus. They're definitely helping make a decision, but not in the direction they'd like.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by eli on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:33PM (#9696909)
That's not really true. There's a misconception that publishers only get paid for clicks, when actually many (perhaps even most for certain types) ads are sold by impression. And that's never going to fully go away; if you sell luxury cars you just want to do a branding campaign. You want to get your logo in front of NYTimes.com readers. You don't care how many click.

tl;dr it's much better for publishers if you see ads but never click them vs blocking them.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by frik on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:32AM (#9697990)
Ads should be paid by 1000 views/impressions and be served from the website itself. A pivoted ad network could provide a single Go/Rust binary for website owners. The ad network would scan the website with different IPs to make sure the ads are served to the user and the binary on the website itself sends statistics back to the ad network. Such ads cannot be blocked and would be great for the users privacy. So it would be a win win.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by icebraining on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:45AM (#9698020)
Such ads cannot be blocked

Sure they can. How does the ad network know the ads are being served? It needs some sort of ad detection mechanism, so the ad blocker can implement it too.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by frik on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:21AM (#9698151)
No. The ad picture can use the same URL scheme as the normal pictures of the website. The ad binary app can inform the ad network server which Url links serve the ads, so only the website owner and the ad network know which URLs are ad pics. The same for links. The URLs could also change every few hours. Adblockers work with regex based on URL and usually block third party files (different domain) from ad networks.

I would also encourage new "good ad blockers" that only block bad ads (CPU/memory intense ads that crash your browser on iipad)

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by icebraining on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:55AM (#9698293)
The ad binary app can inform the ad network server which Url links serve the ads, so only the website owner and the ad network know which URLs are ad pics.

How does the ad network confirm the images being served are actually ads and not blank rectangles? It needs to visually confirm their content, which means there's some algorithm the blocker can use to identify ads.

(Why would a site serve blank rectangles? Simple: it'd allow them to serve ads from dozens of ad networks without making the site an unreadable mess)

Adblockers work with regex based on URL and usually block third party files (different domain) from ad networks.

Current adblockers work that way, since it's easier. They'd adapt. For example, Brand Killer[1] (aka Adblock for Real Life) already works by visual detection, and it would certainly be easier to do that online.

[1] http://challengepost.com/software/brand-killer

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by frik on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:38AM (#9698804)
Heard about file hashing? (CRC32/MD5/etc) - problem solved.

Your OpenCV prototype is simply too expensive (CPU, GPU, battery resources) on consumer hardware many more years.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by icebraining on Thursday June 11, 2015 @08:50AM (#9699334)
It's just a question of thinking about it. For example, having an easy way for users to mark an image as "ad" coupled with a shared DB of URLs (many users marked this as ad → auto-hide for everyone).
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by impish19 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:33PM (#9696907)
You can easily check if a person has adblock installed or not (check https://wordpress.org/plugins/anti-adblock/). And say, due to a prominent survey or report or other means it just becomes a widely known & accepted fact that most users are now using AdBlock, the tilt towards running ads in content will only accelerate.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by eli on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:35PM (#9696919)
It's actually really hard to detect adblockers -- they go out of their way to avoid detection and are constantly updating whitelists of test scripts. I haven't tried this particular plugin, but I doubt it detects modern extensions.

A big, high-profile publisher would find it nearly impossible. As soon as they roll out code to lock out adblock uesrs, it would be circumvented in a filter update.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by brikis98 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:27PM (#9696872)
That's a very interesting point that I never fully considered. Of course, there is no doubt that some content providers already are taking money to reflect someone else's agenda, but it's definitely worth considering what happens if advertising fails as a business model for the majority...
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by dunkelheit on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:48AM (#9698652)
I think you raise very valid point. Historically it just made business sense for content creators to put up some ads. It works like a feedback loop: you put some ads -> you can offset your production costs and lower the price or produce more content -> you increase your audience -> you put more ads. And unfortunately for content consumers the equilibrium is near the point when they are irked by the ads but just not enough to leave in droves.

So now when general dissatisfaction with ads seems to rise the choice for content creators is to install paywalls/raise prices (public won't like it either) or accept more surreptitious kinds of ads (morally dubious). Or maybe go freemium?

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by learnstats2 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:24AM (#9698578)
> TL;DR: The bathroom may be dirty, but at least no one's taking a shit in my kitchen.

This is a fallacy. All news agencies are already producing advertorial copy, and have been since before the web: this is nothing new.

They didn't start doing it because ads stopped working. Someone who is willing to show intrusive ads is already willing to plumb any depth for an additional income stream.

> A viewer's ability to distinguish between native ads and regular articles is small and quickly vanishing.

I would suggest that the viewer's ability to distinguish is increasing, since we are more aware of the problem, and we don't have to face the cognitive load of ad-ignoring elsewhere.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by BrainInAJar on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:20AM (#9698563)
> I do see it as a moral issue.

Your ability to get rich is not my moral concern.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by backtoyoujim on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:29PM (#9697115)
So irony is responsible for "punch the monkey" ?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by Terretta on Saturday June 13, 2015 @04:04AM (#9710286)
Traveling in Europe on a limited and expensive 3G connection, I'm acutely aware I'm paying more for the bandwidth these ads consume than the advertiser is paying to display them. The ads consume 20x more bandwidth than the content.

I'm subsidizing the ads! You say ads are moral, I say as implemented, that's immoral.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by fijal on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:24AM (#9698161)
Do you find it equally immoral not to pay/donate for all the open source that you use?
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by scriptproof on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:11AM (#9698114)
There is also the sourceforge example. Since they can not make enough money with ads on the site to survive, they put them in the archives. They will die also at the end, but a lot of projects with them.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by postmeta on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:24PM (#9696864)
Like you said, product placement is already here.

As long as people broadcast content, consumers are free to modify it for personal consumption.

The next level filter might filter all brand names from an article or movie.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by chaostheory on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:56PM (#9697002)
It hasn't just arrived. It's been here for years already.

http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html

I think the only major recent change is what we call them. I could be wrong but today people refer to it as 'native' advertising.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by adamlett on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:07AM (#9698540)
It will not hurt the content producers who publish their content in apps. Like the just announced Apple News or the Facebook thing I can't remember the name of.
Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by coldtea on Thursday June 11, 2015 @07:39AM (#9698998)
>Let's face it: paywalls don't work.

Citation needed.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mercer on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:12AM (#9698364)
You might very well be right that this is what will happen.

And yes, it would be bad if native advertising increases dramatically because everyone has adblockers.

However, the problem I have with your argument is that it rests on preserving something bad and to keep something worse from happening. I think that's generally not the best approach, which is why I'm not 'conservative' in most of my views.

Let's say web content suddenly becomes infested with native ads. Those of us who care, might actually start paying for paywalled content. Those of us who don't, happily read advertising dressed up as proper content.

Or maybe the bigger publishers will not be able to exist anymore, and content becomes either really shitty, or really good with little middle ground. Perhaps we'll finally start paying those individual journalists and writers through donations and crowd funding.

I think a good comparison is music. People started ripping their music, so the industry replied with DRM. People cirsumvrented this, and the DRM became increasingly intrusive. Then downloads and torrents happened. All seems lost. And what do you know? 'Paywalled' music actually starts sort-of working. This may very well happen to video and text once companies get their act together and go with the tide rather than swim against it.

I've been a pretty extreme 'modern', tech-savvy consumer for most of my life. And yet, now that I reached my thirties, and now that I have disposable income:

1. I pay for The Correspondent, a Dutch, pay-walled web-only publication that has been doing well and produces great content by great authors, including some of 'celebrity' journalists here (and soon to be released in English, too). 2. I occasionally buy single articles from any of the newspapers in Holland through Blendle, at prices of around 20/30 eurocents, with the option of a refund that I rarely use. 3. I pay for Spotify, not just because it's convenient, but because it offers (or used to offer) a really nice interface for discovery and curated playlists. 4. I buy ScreenCasts and (e)books direct from programmers/writers in my communities. 5. I've donated to a number of arts/journalistic crowdfunding projects.

While there are many bad things that could happen, I'd argue that the current state of production, consumption, and accompanying advertising is already pretty bad. I'm fine with either: 1) the current models crumbling, and new models coming up that might be worse, so that it might get better quicker, or 2) fighting the fundamental problems and actively working towards a better alternative, or 3) hoping that the changes will end up better altogether.

But preserving a situation that is already pretty shitty just out of fear for something shittier seems like the worse possible approach.

I do realize that I'm leaving out the moral arguments in favor or against bypassing DRM, pirating content, or blocking ads. That's a difficult and perhaps important issue too, but I'd say judging by current behavior it's largely irrelevant to what actually happens.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by wooger on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:55AM (#9699697)
In what way do you think paywalled music is working?

Artists are getting screwed, while a few middlemen and labels are still making decent money. The whole payment model, forced by the major labels, absolutely fucks smaller artists over - meaning that they get only a tiny fraction of the subscription fees, even those from users who only listen to their content.

It does not work.

Pay walled news sites are always going to lose out compared to more open ones, as it's useless to link to them on twitter etc.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mercer on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:53PM (#9701546)
One very popular paywalled news site I use allows you to freely share links to individual pages. For now, that seems to work for them.

As for paywalled music: artists were getting screwed before. Maybe more so, maybe less so, but many were getting screwed. Either way, maintaining the status quo doesn't seem like a good solution, so why try and maintain that. I'd rather see the whole deal collapse so that new things can be tried.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by dzhiurgis on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:21AM (#9697518)
I personally find plenty of great free content in StackExchange, Github, Coursera, etc.

The rest is not really content, it's entertainment.

The entertainers choose how will they get paid.

The reality is that they work is not valuable enough to be paid directly, so they opt-in for a revenue from adverts.

And I choose to opt-out from paying them, because I think that we shouldn't be paying for entertainment. What is worst is that 'news' increasingly becomes entertainment. You only need so much paid journalist to cover main events. If they choose to make farce out of events, it's up to them. But I will not pay that premium, because I do not care and because I don't even want to reach me. And you dot have to do anything for 'news' to reach you.

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by mkartic on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:36AM (#9697587)
Netflix - Essentially a paywall for great CONTENT. You subscribe to their service with regular payments.

Youtube - Ads for free content.

Both seem to be working just fine as far as revenue is concerned. Can you elaborate on why you find only sites like SE or GH "content"? What's your definition? Are you suggesting entertainment doesn't have a value of its own?

Re:The next version of Safari will let users block ads on iP... by dzhiurgis on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:26AM (#9697768)
> Are you suggesting entertainment doesn't have a value of its own?

Yes, exactly.

Netflix is paywall for entertainment. Youtube does have some educational content. Some of it generates revenue from ads. Although those who actually do create educational content, do it for self expression or as a token to return to community.

Just another day there was a top ranking comment about Apple's music streaming service. The TL;DR was that there are millions of great musicians who do not care about profit, they care about music.

I think art is about self expression, not means to making money. Somehow it is much more prominent in tech community with open source and bunch of free information. The information that is actually valuable.

Of course we do have day jobs, but there we get paid for implementing something that people actually need.

I realize this is probably a unusual worldview, but perhaps we are too much entertained and not enough educated?