News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by ChrisAntaki on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:22PM (#9667090)
> Apple, Oracle, Google Inc. and seven of their biggest peers now have in excess of $500 billion of cash and marketable securities, up more than three-fold since 2008, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The problem is much of it is stuck overseas.

Stuck overseas in the sense that these corporations aren't willing to pay American taxes [1], insisting on using complex tax loopholes that essentially leave the bill on the doorsteps of normal, hard working American citizens.

[1] http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/10/08/to-cut-corporate-taxe...

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by twoodfin on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:26PM (#9667125)
Stuck overseas in the sense that corporations aren't willing to pay American taxes...

Why should Apple pay American taxes on the profits from a product manufactured in China and sold in Germany? (Albeit "Designed in California"!)

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by jusben1369 on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:03PM (#9667379)
Errr because they're headquartered in the US and rely on the shield of the US government when it comes to rule of law, educating their workforce, providing the infrastructure etc for them to be in the position where they are today? In this day and age it makes _less_ sense to try and tax based on where componentry or network services or consumers start or finish.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by charlesdm on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:24PM (#9667536)
Only an American could have written this answer. All other countries in the world use a non global taxation system.

Two basic scenarios:

1. US entity owns a company in the UK. UK company earns $100, pays 20% tax on that, and is left with $80. Declares a dividend to the US parent, and the US then taxes the difference (35% US tax rate - 20% UK tax rate = another 15% to pay). We're left with $65

2. UK entity owns a company in Sweden. Swedish company earns $100, pays 22% tax on that, and is left with $78. Declares a dividend to the UK parent, which is then left untaxed.

Why does 2 make more sense than 1? Because the money was generated in Sweden, and the fact that some parent/holding entity is UK based does not matter (like, at all).

Scenario 1 pushes US companies to expand abroad (i.e. through foreign M&A), and not repatriate any profits back to the US. It also makes it easier for non US entities to acquire US companies, because they can achieve larger tax synergies than a domestic US acquirer would.

A US company trying to achieve something like that would have to do an inversion, which sometimes can be hard to do.

The current state of the US tax code is a great example why Microsoft paid a whopping $2bn for something like Minecraft (Sweden based), or an even larger amount for Luxembourg based Skype. What can they do with that cash otherwise? It's not like they're going to repatriate (ever) without a tax holiday.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tormeh on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:32PM (#9667592)
You know, I think maybe this taxation system is a part of why US companies become so successful. It basically forces any US company that sells overseas to become a multinational.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by adventured on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:21PM (#9669346)
The world's largest economy under a single unified market speaking the same language, has a lot more to do with it.

By the time companies come out of the US, they're typically already well on their way competitively and have scale.

It's the same reason China is so effective at producing giants like Alibaba, Xiaomi, and Baidu.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by return0 on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:36PM (#9667614)
It looks like the real issue is the high corporate tax rate in the US then. Are there not double-taxation treaties to avoid overtaxing otherwise?

On the other hand, the scenario of a UK company owning a company in a tax-free zone in dubai and thus paying 0% taxes anywhere doesn't sound fair either.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by charlesdm on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:35PM (#9669067)
Well, the second part of this equation is that they are able to funnel a ton of cash to low tax companies (via loans/royalties/other loopholes). So maybe they've only paid 1-5% on the entire amount.

Repatriation of those funds would essentially mean paying close to 35% tax (+ state taxes). DTTs don't fix that, they just make sure you don't pay the same amount twice. I.e. the 20% in the UK AND 35% in the US.

Add to that fact that Apple can pretty much borrow unlimited funds in the market (debt != income, you don't pay tax when you borrow) to fund share buybacks and dividends. Why repatriate? Financially it just does not make sense, since you'd lose so much of your equity. It's better to invest it abroad.

Re Dubai: If an entity is a conduit company, then maybe not. But if you're operating a business or selling stuff there, then I think it is. No income tax is more of an anomaly these days, and a way for countries to attract new business.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by IkmoIkmo on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:31PM (#9669047)
Double tax treaties are pretty common, it depends on the good and the corridor so I don't really know what it's like for Apple. Still, the fact they mention tax as a reason to keep cash offshore probably means the treaties are non-existent or limited at best.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by jusben1369 on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:06PM (#9667792)
You're sort of falling victim to the rules of the current game (US entity owning subsidiary in xyz location) I was working at a higher level and rejecting the notion that a company no longer needs to pay taxes on profits simply because they're outside their borders. The Chinese government can tax worker salaries and levy a consumption tax on goods and services sold into the production. The German government can levy a GST too. And Apple, where applicable, can deduct those taxes before calculating profits. So conceptually that's the cleanest way it should work (same for a German or Australian company. No U S A U S A thing going on here)
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by devmach on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:28PM (#9667568)
This made me think:

* Apple, Google, Microsoft et al. have many foreign workers (green card, H-2B, or maybe L1 visa) and it is easier for american citizens to move/work outside of US than foreigners to get work visa in US. So the question is, if a country (like Spain or Greece) promises tax advantage for next 25 years and makes easier to get visa for employees, would these companies move their hq there?

* If, say, European Union provides better shield, would Apple move its HQ to Germany or Spain?

* Infrastructure: I can say most European counties have better infrastructure than US and it looks like most us companies build their own if needed. With $500 billion on hand, what would prevent these companies to build a better infrastructure in a host country.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by jfuhrman on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:33PM (#9667594)
>So the question is, if a country (like Spain or Greece)

>If, say, European Union provides better shield, would Apple move its HQ to Germany or Spain?

Two words. Labor laws.

http://www.businessinsider.com/ceo-employee-lawsuits-killed-...

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9663421

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by devmach on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:48PM (#9667697)
Good point. But I would like to know other side of the story too, not just from the CEO.

Although, while I'm not an expert on France's labor laws, I agree laws in most EU countries are on the side of employees. But that doesn't mean when you hired someone, he/she will be working at the company for rest of his/her life without doing some work. Maybe someone who's expert on labor laws can clarify.

Edit: Also different countries in the EU has different laws. It might be difficult to `get rid of bad employee` but it might be easier in Spain...

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by lmm on Saturday June 06, 2015 @04:41AM (#9670165)
> Although, while I'm not an expert on France's labor laws, I agree laws in most EU countries are on the side of employees. But that doesn't mean when you hired someone, he/she will be working at the company for rest of his/her life without doing some work. Maybe someone who's expert on labor laws can clarify.

As someone who lives and works in the EU, none of the conditions seems to be particularly unreasonable. If you're talking about someone who isn't working, presumably you'd be firing them for cause. Which you can do: you need to follow a process and document that you're following it, you need to give them explicit warning that their performance is not up to par and give them the opportunity to fix it, and you need to do all of this within a reasonable timeframe.

The Mandriva guy was explicitly not doing that; if you're making people redundant then you're declaring that there was no problem with them specifically, the company just needs to eliminate those positions. If you then rehire people for those positions within the next few months, the courts tend to take a rather dim view of that.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by ulfw on Saturday June 06, 2015 @05:14AM (#9670223)
What infrastructure is needed to sell a product manufactured in China to a customer in the US? Which educated workforce is needed to ship and then sell said product in Germany? What do American 'rules of law' have to do when the product is sold in Germany (under EU consumer laws)?
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by jusben1369 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:29PM (#9673051)
If a country or region implemented tariffs that discriminated against Apple products to grow or protect a mobile industry which government do you think they're going to call? And the US government won't say "sounds like a Chinese manufactured product being sold into a Latin American country. Ask someone else to help" Nope, it'll be the threat of retaliatory measures that'll get that market reopened/fixed and it'll be a costly endeavour.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by ulfw on Sunday June 07, 2015 @09:27AM (#9674543)
The iPhone is extremely high tariffed in for example Argentina because it is not manufactured in the country. I haven't seen any US government putting pressure on the Argentinian government to change that so that the iPhone can be sold more competitively.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:23PM (#9667533)
But apple & co isn't just in the USA, and many of their best workers were educated & raised in other countries.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by fit2rule on Saturday June 06, 2015 @08:21AM (#9670515)
No, in this day and age it makes more sense to tax production and consumption in their respective locations wherever they are on Earth.

It'd do a lot to reduce global warming by humans.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by sbov on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:40PM (#9667209)
Why should Apple be able to pay Irish taxes on a product designed in California, manufactured in China, and sold in Germany.

It makes even less sense.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by Alphasite_ on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:49PM (#9667260)
Which is why these countries are changing the laws, see Google tax in the UK.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by adam419 on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:06PM (#9667399)
Because Apple et al can put the extra capital to better use than the united states government.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tdees40 on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:16PM (#9667491)
Apple appears to be terrible at deploying capital. Most of it is just sitting around in cash. It's actually hard to imagine a worse allocator of capital.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by oldmanjay on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:17PM (#9668239)
I suppose the government could confiscate a hundred billion and use it to invade a small country for a few weeks.

I'm not going to put down your imagination but it didn't take me long to think of a worse use.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by toomuchtodo on Friday June 05, 2015 @06:02PM (#9668474)
I was thinking today that Apple could plow that money into Solar City's SolarBonds [1]. Short maturity dates are available, so they'd be getting their capital back quickly, its a safe investment, and it both helps their image and the environment.

https://solarbonds.solarcity.com/

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by icelancer on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:55AM (#9669987)
> its a safe investment

Anything that returns more money than treasury bills at the same maturity date is de facto not "safe."

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by toomuchtodo on Sunday June 07, 2015 @02:46PM (#9675871)
"less safe".
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by marincounty on Saturday June 06, 2015 @03:41AM (#9670047)
I sometimes wonder if Apple knows more about investing than they let on? They obviously care about money. Why would they let billions sit around in cash? I won't even speculate, but here's a graph of their horde of cash and when we gave it to them. Yes, I said we(the world of course). (Don't want to offend anyone concerning Apple.)

http://www.engadget.com/2014/05/22/charting-apples-growing-s...

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by prostoalex on Friday June 05, 2015 @11:35PM (#9669527)
This way they can attack big projects and commit suppliers to building out new factories, granting exclusivity on contracts, etc., as opposed to someone who's very efficient at deploying, but then has trouble getting liquidity when times get rough.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by adam419 on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:18PM (#9667859)
By Apple et al I meant private enterprise.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by anigbrowl on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:15PM (#9667478)
Besides the fact that they're a US company, enjoying access to the world's deepest capital markets and most sophisticated and responsive legal system (the US legal system works incredibly well from a corporate perspective), you're implying that they're paying the same rate of tax as their domestic competitors in Germany and China/ I'm not sure this is the case, and in any case such local taxes would be deductible from US obligations under tax treaties, as far as I am aware (not a tax lawyer or accountant, consult a professional before setting up a megacorporation of your own).
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by IBM on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:37PM (#9667193)
The answer is they shouldn't and the U.S. needs to get a territorial tax system as soon as possible.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by IkmoIkmo on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:46PM (#9668051)
They pay taxes over there alright (e.g. VAT), which is fine, nobody complains. The issue is they don't pay corporate tax on it in the US, despite the fact Apple is US based and does virtually all of its work in the US, and then commissions factories it doesn't own in China to produce its parts. The end result is that it pays much fewer taxes than citizens do, or companies that don't have a dedicated fiscal team (mostly SMEs which comprise the bulk of American firms, e.g. 90% of firms have less than 20 employees, and 99.9% have less than 500).

Now it's one thing to say it's justified because Apple would have to go out of business and lay off thousands of of their 100k employees. But we can all take a look at that financial situation and make our own moral judgement on whether they should have effective tax rates much lower than a regular business.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by misterbee on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:12PM (#9669321)
thought experiment: What if Apple spun out Apple Design as a US company and paid it contract rates to invent, much like it outsources factories to Chinese companies? then how are the holding-companies profits taxes?
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by rayiner on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:30PM (#9667148)
I think you answered your own question.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by rconti on Friday June 05, 2015 @02:39PM (#9667203)
Is it a moral imperative in your opinion? Is it based on what other countries do? (hint: no)

IMO, it is non-obvious that they are obligated to do so.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by ryandrake on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:13PM (#9667464)
Why not? If I, as a US Citizen, moved to China or Germany to work there, I still owe US taxes on my income there.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:22PM (#9667525)
The USA is _VERY_ unique in the world this way. Every other citizen of the world has the freedom to move away and stop paying taxes to their home country if they make no income from it.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tanderson92 on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:54PM (#9667720)
That hardly is an excuse for US corporations to avoid tax obligations. Rather it shows the two standards of treatment of the US towards real people and corporation "people".
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Friday June 05, 2015 @07:58PM (#9668944)
Think of multinational corporations as multinational families, each one with their own singular citizenship. It makes no sense to tax the family members of other countries until they send money to the family member in your country.

If the other family members decided it was a bad idea to send you money to your country because it will be taxed to death, can you blame them?

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tanderson92 on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:04PM (#9668971)
>Think of multinational corporations as multinational families, each one with their own singular citizenship.

Why should I? Of course this is not actually what they are, or at least what they claim to be. That is, since money is fungible in a global economy they can in effect use untaxed funds to influence U.S. political campaigns while they claim they are a single person deserving of the same rights afforded by the constitution.

U.S. persons cannot do that. This is what I mean by the double standard.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:12AM (#9669795)
What you describe is something any rich lower-taxed non-american can do to the usa effectively. That is a thing of money, not of corporations.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tanderson92 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:03AM (#9669894)
> rich lower-taxed non-american

Right, but of course being as many of the companies in question here were founded in the U.S. and made use of U.S. infrastructure to build their business, and are headquartered in the U.S., and rely on the U.S. labor force for a large part of their enterprise, it isn't accurate to call them non-american.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by IkmoIkmo on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:40PM (#9669080)
Which is globally considered completely ridiculous and only the US does it. The moment you move abroad and live there, and perform work there, you ought to be taxed there. After all, you live there. You enjoy the streets, the parks, the police, the infrastructure etc etc, paid for by taxes, to which you ought to contribute.

But what Apple does is enjoy all of that in the US to which it contributes sub-standard taxes, manufactures in China, sells in Germany, but pays Ireland a large portion of its taxes, which in Ireland are diminished to a small amount. That's quite silly.

Sure if Apple created an EU HQ and did a large amount of design, manufacturing, sales, engineering etc, then it's fine if pays taxes there. But it does all its engineering and design (the bulk of the company) in the US, but pays little taxes there.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by misterbee on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:14PM (#9669328)
Even worse, Apple etc do engineering work in EU, and then lie to regulators to say that "no innovation happens in Europe" to avoid local taxes.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by sliverstorm on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:51PM (#9668408)
(If you make more than ~$100k)
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by cmsmith on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:07PM (#9667404)
And the corporations only hold out for a repatriation holiday because there has been one in the past, and there is a decent chance of there being one in the near future. This is a slippery legislative cliff - once you indicate a willingness to have the holiday, there is no point in not just dropping the tax rate permanently since no one will bring their billions in otherwise.

I wonder what would happen if we passed an un-repealable law (if such a thing existed) that prohibited tax holidays for the next thirty years?

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by Kalium on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:19PM (#9667508)
> I wonder what would happen if we passed an un-repealable law (if such a thing existed) that prohibited tax holidays for the next thirty years?

It's really not possible. We can even repeal constitutional amendments.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by cmsmith on Friday June 05, 2015 @04:52PM (#9668092)
Hence my parenthetical. But since you mentioned amendments, you should look into the Corwin Amendment [1], which was written to preclude its own repeal. The amendment was an all-in attempt to appease the slave states and prevent the Civil War, but was too little and too late. The purpose may be distasteful to the modern reader, and may not have held up in court ('Can Jesus microwave a burrito so hot that he cannot eat it?'), but it's there.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corwin_Amendment

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by 0xffff2 on Friday June 05, 2015 @07:33PM (#9668854)
I'm no lawyer, but I don't see how the text of the amendment would preclude its own repeal. Repealing the amendment in and of itself wouldn't have any effect at all on slavery.

The only argument I can see would be that repealing the amendment would implicitly grant power to abolish slavery, but that seems like thin ice to me.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by progmanal on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:40PM (#9667643)
You could change the amendment process at the same time the amendment was amended that you don't want repealed.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by minthd on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:13PM (#9667463)
If they use their money to purchase other companies or invest in r&d , this isn't taxed, right ?
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by progmanal on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:37PM (#9667624)
I believe one of the only ways to do that is with a constitutional amendment. Those are hard to pass.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by jeffbax on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @11:03PM (#9689834)
I would say that the bill is being left by congress by spending a ludicrous sum of money, not by corporations acting rationally (and taking advantage of/keeping countries competitive with one another).

The real danger is with the upcoming BEPS plan, and whether it will cause a rush of companies moving the high tech jobs fueling the economy as it is today overseas: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/06/10/opinion/obamas-corporate-t...

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by melling on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:41PM (#9667652)
You could change the world with $500 billion if you spent it effectively. Unfortunately, Google is the only company doing moonshot projects. I hope Apple adds a few more products to their lineup.