News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by ryandrake on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:13PM (#9667464)
Why not? If I, as a US Citizen, moved to China or Germany to work there, I still owe US taxes on my income there.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:22PM (#9667525)
The USA is _VERY_ unique in the world this way. Every other citizen of the world has the freedom to move away and stop paying taxes to their home country if they make no income from it.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tanderson92 on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:54PM (#9667720)
That hardly is an excuse for US corporations to avoid tax obligations. Rather it shows the two standards of treatment of the US towards real people and corporation "people".
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Friday June 05, 2015 @07:58PM (#9668944)
Think of multinational corporations as multinational families, each one with their own singular citizenship. It makes no sense to tax the family members of other countries until they send money to the family member in your country.

If the other family members decided it was a bad idea to send you money to your country because it will be taxed to death, can you blame them?

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tanderson92 on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:04PM (#9668971)
>Think of multinational corporations as multinational families, each one with their own singular citizenship.

Why should I? Of course this is not actually what they are, or at least what they claim to be. That is, since money is fungible in a global economy they can in effect use untaxed funds to influence U.S. political campaigns while they claim they are a single person deserving of the same rights afforded by the constitution.

U.S. persons cannot do that. This is what I mean by the double standard.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by mahyarm on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:12AM (#9669795)
What you describe is something any rich lower-taxed non-american can do to the usa effectively. That is a thing of money, not of corporations.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by tanderson92 on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:03AM (#9669894)
> rich lower-taxed non-american

Right, but of course being as many of the companies in question here were founded in the U.S. and made use of U.S. infrastructure to build their business, and are headquartered in the U.S., and rely on the U.S. labor force for a large part of their enterprise, it isn't accurate to call them non-american.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by IkmoIkmo on Friday June 05, 2015 @08:40PM (#9669080)
Which is globally considered completely ridiculous and only the US does it. The moment you move abroad and live there, and perform work there, you ought to be taxed there. After all, you live there. You enjoy the streets, the parks, the police, the infrastructure etc etc, paid for by taxes, to which you ought to contribute.

But what Apple does is enjoy all of that in the US to which it contributes sub-standard taxes, manufactures in China, sells in Germany, but pays Ireland a large portion of its taxes, which in Ireland are diminished to a small amount. That's quite silly.

Sure if Apple created an EU HQ and did a large amount of design, manufacturing, sales, engineering etc, then it's fine if pays taxes there. But it does all its engineering and design (the bulk of the company) in the US, but pays little taxes there.

Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by misterbee on Friday June 05, 2015 @10:14PM (#9669328)
Even worse, Apple etc do engineering work in EU, and then lie to regulators to say that "no innovation happens in Europe" to avoid local taxes.
Re:Apple Is the New Pimco by sliverstorm on Friday June 05, 2015 @05:51PM (#9668408)
(If you make more than ~$100k)