News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by bandrami on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:39AM (#9616961)
The hardest (ie, best) math prof I ever had (I was in EE, he was in the math department) used to say that "engineers can teach calculus, but their students cannot go on to teach calculus". I'm impressed by someone who knows a subject deeply enough to take that long of a view.

Personally, I just like the engineering view of dx and dy as simply being new variables (with caveats that we immediately forget). Which is why I'll probably not teach calculus any time soon.

But, still, the best "revelation" moment I had was when he off-handedly said "An integral is the inner product of a function and a suitably-dimensioned unit". Light bulb came on, and I "got" integration for the first time. Too bad they can't lead up to it that way in high school.

(Side rant: why do they teach trig before calculus in high school? That's completely backwards. Trig is a bunch of arbitrary formulas if you don't have the calculus behind them.)

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by impendia on Thursday May 28, 2015 @10:26AM (#9618346)
> Trig is a bunch of arbitrary formulas if you don't have the calculus behind them.

Why do you claim this? You don't have to have seen calculus to appreciate how trig functions are defined, how to manipulate them, or how to use them in applications.

As a math professor, I personally like the fact that we teach trig and exponential/logarithmic functions before calculus. They are (as you well know) exceedingly rich examples which illustrate why calculus is interesting and useful, and knowing them already enables the student to study calculus without excessive digressions.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by tokenrove on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:04PM (#9619936)
I don't know, I agree with the parent. I hated trig in my first encounters with it; the thing that made it practical was writing videogames and graphics demos, and the thing that made it interesting was calculus. For many people, it's the last math they're taught, they don't get the applications, and it's no wonder they don't hunger for more.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by stephencanon on Thursday May 28, 2015 @10:37AM (#9618413)
sin and cos are the natural basis of solutions of y'' + y = 0. How do you define them?
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by tarentel on Thursday May 28, 2015 @11:12AM (#9618686)
Ratios in a right triangle perhaps?
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by threatofrain on Thursday May 28, 2015 @11:52AM (#9618966)
How did you get that information? How did you, in a non-magical way, go from information about an angle to information about a ratio?

If students don't know this information, then perhaps they are studying applications. So, what applications are students taught in typical trigonometric texts? Periodic behavior perhaps? Like sound? Only perhaps a brief blurb in the text that application is even possible. Perhaps they look at something about an incline plane. It is unlikely that they will touch projectiles.

It appears that trigonometry is there to give students some sense of mild comfort for future work in physics or engineering. This makes me think, "Why not statistics instead?"

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 28, 2015 @01:13PM (#9619577)
> How did you, in a non-magical way, go from information about an angle to information about a ratio?

By having a right triangle?

The rest of your post seems to show that you want trig to be about periodic behavior, when it really is about triangles. That's what trigonometry means - measuring triangles.

Yes, trig has applications to periodic behavior, projectiles, differential equations, inclined planes, and all kinds of other stuff. But the point of a trig class is not to teach the applications. The point is to teach the tools, and maybe touch on the applications.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by btilly on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:20PM (#9620046)
The problem is this. Using compass and ruler constructions there is a set of angles you can construct, and you can calculate sin and cos for those angles. You can even write the values for those out explicitly. However no part of this construction sheds light on how to find sin and cos for angles that you don't know how to construct. Or even gives good intuition that no matter how you do it, you can define it in a way that makes sense for all angles.

In fact we draw a picture, people look at it, and their intuition tells them that things will work out. Very few students will notice the logical gaps.

But to close the logical gaps, you need to start with Calculus first, and then derive trig formulas from that.

(Yes, I'm aware of the history here. Euclid presented trig reasonably rigorously a very long time before Calculus. Newton invented Calculus in the 1600s, and then used it as a heuristic to figure out answers that he then rederived using trig in The Principia. Leibniz reinvented Calculus in part based on inspiration from Newton's work. None of this was made formally correct until the late 1800s.)

(I have no opinion on pedagogical arguments about which is best to present first. I believe that we present trig first as a holdover from a curriculum where The Elements was the standard textbook until very recently.)

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:41PM (#9620199)
Well... you can use the half-angle formulas and the angle addition formulas to calculate sin and cos for angles that are arbitrarily close to the ones that you want. Add to that the idea that sin and cos must be continuous (I consider that intuitively obvious from a unit circle, but I don't know how to make that argument rigorous), and you can start to interpolate. You can in fact use these methods to calculate sin and cos for an arbitrary angle to any desired degree of precision... if you have the patience. It will be shorter to use the series derived from calculus, I'll admit.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by btilly on Thursday May 28, 2015 @03:21PM (#9620489)
I do not believe that there is an argument for continuity without starting with Calculus. Certainly starting from ruler and compass constructions it is not obvious.

That said, if you have enough Calculus to define how to measure the arclength of a segment of the circle, you can quickly prove that sin and cos in radians exist, have a nice power series, and so on.

It is like x^y with x positive. We can manually define it every rational y. But the easiest way to get a rigorous and straightforward definition is to prove the algebraic properties of the integral of 1/x, use that to define the logarithm, define its inverse function to be the exponential, prove its algebraic properties, then define x^y as e^(y*log(x)). And it all just works.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by JadeNB on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:50PM (#9621086)
It's easy to show more or less directly (by comparing arclength to straight-line length), and certainly without calculus, that the absolute difference between sin(x + delta) and sin(x) is at most |delta|.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by btilly on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:33PM (#9621323)
You're right. And ditto for cos(x+delta) vs cos(x).

Of course that assumes that arclength is well-defined. The standard approach to which is, of course, Calculus.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Friday June 05, 2015 @12:29PM (#9666382)
Replying really late, just in case anybody reads this. (I went on vacation, and this occurred to me then.)

If you don't have calculus, you don't have anything like a delta-epsilon proof of continuity. But without calculus, you also don't know that you need it. So you just assume (correctly) that you can interpolate, and it works just like you expect, and life goes on.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by tel on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:27PM (#9620937)
There's a topological direction... but I have to agree that calculus is much more conceptually immediate to humans anyway.

But even a disembodied being of pure reason might eventually discover continuity via logic->topology.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by replicant on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:46PM (#9621394)
As young students, we are taught that these functions are ratios of sides on right angles. It is fairly intuitive for them that provided they can draw a right triangle, they just need to measure the sides. And it is easy to accept that someone computed sines and cosines for a lot of angles and put it in a table. My point being, that we didn't need (in the past) calculus to compute trigonometric functions, and I don't see how it is a burden for students to be introduced to those functions without the Calculus definition.

And the reality is, that the definition of sine as a ratio of the catheti and hypotenuse is a rigorous definition of the function. Strictly, this sine is different from the sine of calculus. The first, the sine from Euclidean geometry, assigns a real to pair of rays, while the calculus sine, is function from the real numbers to the reals. And it does take some work to link them formally.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by threatofrain on Thursday May 28, 2015 @03:03PM (#9620356)
What kind of pedagogical or pragmatic relevance do you see trig as a building block for? I would answer that question by saying that it most likely comes up again either in physics or engineering contexts, or in a standardized exam like MCAT. And only in the sense of familiarity with the unit circle and trig functions.

What other foundation or learning pathway do you see trig serving as? Somebody else mentioned that trig serves use by teaching students that calculus has rich applications. So then I question, what kind of applications are students learning in trig? And if students are to learn rich examples of calculus applications, then why not statistics, which is also relevant to the bio / social sciences? Also, couldn't we mash trig inside calculus?

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:50PM (#9621089)
It seems to me that if I know trig, I can use it to solve the set of geometric problems to which it is applicable, without having been taught any special applications of trig. That's valuable in itself.

Then I take physics, and I find a whole bunch of other applications. I take calculus, and I find a bunch more uses. I take mechanics, and I find a bunch more. But it is not the job of trig to teach me those applications (though hints would be useful). It's not trig's job to teach me physics - that's a job for physics. But I need trig as a foundation.

I'm not sure that I answered your question, though...

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by bandrami on Thursday May 28, 2015 @08:12PM (#9621989)
But that's my point: it's not really about triangles; that's just a rather mundane application. Trig is really about complex exponentials that solve f'' + f = 0.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by replicant on Friday May 29, 2015 @02:47AM (#9623114)
It is about triangles. The idea that sine is the solution of this ODE for f(0)=0 and f'(0)=1 is quite modern.

I would say a course on trigonometry usually covers (my experience): trigonometric functions exact value of them for the angles 30, 45, 60, 90 ... degrees Trigonometric formulas for the sum and difference of angles. A formuka for the double and the half angle. Law of sine and law of cosine Lots of relations derived from the Pythagoras theorem (sin^2+cos^=1) how to solve trigonometric equations

With all this, you are equipped to completely determine a triangle, knowing some of its and the length of some its sides. As as application, I was taught, how to measure heights and distances provided you can measure angles.

Thus, without trigonometry, it would be fairly hard to take a course on analytic geometry.

Now, how would the course be enhanced by introducing sine as the solution of an ODE?

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by replicant on Thursday May 28, 2015 @01:19PM (#9619613)
I think I am missing something because, I am unable to see why it is huge burden to introduce sine and cosine without their rigorous definition. At which age, are students taught trigonometry? And what does a course on trigonometry covers? What would you think they would be able to do without it?

When we were introduced the sine and the cosine function, we were already familiar with Thales theorem, so therefore we could show that this ratio was a constant.

I am quite sure historically as well sine and cosine predate the more formal construction of those functions, be it as a series, solution of an ODE or inverse of arc sin (and this defined as an integral)...

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by threatofrain on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:50PM (#9620258)
I think I wasn't clear in saying that I believe the current pedagogical value of trigonometry is in giving students a brief familiarity with the trig functions when they see it again in the context of physics or engineering. Or standardized testing. I think those are the likely scenarios where students are going to be seeing relevance in trigonometry.

What other foundation or learning pathway do you see trigonometry serving as? Somebody else mentioned that it gives students a sense of applications, so they know that calculus is not for nothing. So then I question: what applications? And I pose, how about statistics?

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by east2west on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:11PM (#9621210)
It may be because of your math education but I was introduced to trigonometry in junior high in China. I had, and my classmates had, no trouble understanding them as functions of angles coming from ratios. It is the glue that binds circles and triangles and squares and ... . By high school analytic geometry greatly expanded their scope and use. This is the problem I saw in American high school when I moved to US: shallow introduction to mathematical topics made them vapid and jejune. Ancient Greeks were enthralled by trigonometry, ancient Egyptians built Pyramids and ancient Chinese built great dams with trigonometry. Calling it practically useless and pedagogically only useful as a prep for calculus is going too far.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by Someone on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:31PM (#9620122)
"So, what applications are students taught in typical trigonometric texts?"

"If a pyramid is 250 cubits high and the side of its base 360 cubits long, what is its seked?" (http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rhind_Mathematical_Papyrus#Py...)

Well, maybe not that typical, but it is an example without any periodicity in sight.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by stan_rogers on Friday May 29, 2015 @02:15AM (#9623009)
My introduction was through model rocketry. Somewhere along the line, Al-Biruni's method for finding the radius of the earth was brought up. That was in the early '70s, in what would be "junior high" in the US (elementary school in my part of Canada). It was always about right triangles, not periodic functions, at the beginning, which makes a whole lot of sense - trigonometry was both useful and used for a whole lot of years before calculus was invented. And like logarithms in the pre-scientific-calculator days, there was a point where one turned to tables for practical reasons without thinking of the table values as "magicical" - we were taught how to calculate intermediate values to the limits of practicality. Is there any practical sense (a sense that would be useful for people who would be entering the trades track) in being able to calculate much more accurately than you can measure angles?
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by johnaspden on Thursday May 28, 2015 @11:36AM (#9618855)
coordinates of rotaty-thing
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by monochromatic on Thursday May 28, 2015 @11:40AM (#9618876)
Infinite sums are as clean as anything.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by Tloewald on Thursday May 28, 2015 @11:27AM (#9618796)
Trig is the math of triangles and circles — it can be fully understood in geometric terms. Calculus requires far more foundation.

The linked article is interesting but the definition of differentiability looks wrong to me — maybe my brain needs more coffee but it looks like only linear functions are differentiable as defined.

I learned my calculus the pure math way — axioms and analysis. Epsilon delta arguments make more sense to me than "Ball". The fact that to clarify the examples the author resorts to epsilon delta description suggests to me that this approach is clever rather than clear.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by adamtj on Thursday May 28, 2015 @12:35PM (#9619293)
You can find your epsilons and deltas in the definition of an open ball. They are just two different ways of writing the same idea. For example, in Definition 2.1, the 'h' in the open ball F is your epsilon and the 'h' in B is the delta. In an epsilon-delta proof, you show that for all |x - c| < delta, |f(x) - f(c)| < epsilon. The open ball B is just the set of all x satisfying |x - c| < delta and the open ball F is the set of all f(x) satisfying |f(x) - f(c)| < epsilon.

Any epsilon or delta that you choose implies a set of numbers satisfying those conditions. Those sets are open balls. By using them, you don't have to say things like "all 'x' such that ...". Which method you prefer probably depends on what you're more familiar with and how you tend to think. Open balls can be easier to visualize, if that's how you think.

Note that not just any ball will do. Closed balls are open balls that also include their boundary. That is, they use a less-than-or-equal-to instead of less-than. Which you use can make a big difference. An open ball on the real number line is just an open interval, an interval excluding its endpoints. It's easy to generalize: an open ball in a Cartesian plane is a circle excluding its border. In three dimensions, it's a sphere excluding its surface . . . and that's why it's called a ball.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by Tloewald on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:15PM (#9620864)
I understand what an open ball is (and surely if you read my original post carefully this would be clear), I just don't think it actually makes the discussion clearer. In particular, when explaining something to people, starting with creating unfamiliar concepts is a Bad Idea if those concepts don't have a significant payoff.

In particular, because this is not a discussion about arbitrary spaces, the use of the word "Ball" is counter-intuitive. (But I admit I am probably biased by my own experience.)

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by jerf on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:53PM (#9620286)
"(Side rant: why do they teach trig before calculus in high school? That's completely backwards. Trig is a bunch of arbitrary formulas if you don't have the calculus behind them.)"

I'm fairly convinced the answer is that That Is What The Curriculum Does, and Do Not Question It.

None of the subsequent 9 hours of debate since you posted this convinces me otherwise. It's not possible that there's a better way, and we can marshal all sorts of rationalizations about how this is the best way, and the possibility that it might not be simply can not be conceived. If you think that there might be a better way, you just must not be aware of how what we already have is perfect.

Our math curriculum could be significantly improved in many ways, except that this is the general societal attitude towards it that I see, and it turns out that "Fix the math curriculum" becomes an unsolvable problem when you add the constraint "But don't make any changes to it of any kind, not even to merely reorder a few topics". Feh.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by dragonwriter on Thursday May 28, 2015 @03:06PM (#9620374)
> Side rant: why do they teach trig before calculus in high school? That's completely backwards. Trig is a bunch of arbitrary formulas if you don't have the calculus behind them.

Math is hardly the only place where arbitrary facts/formulas are taught, and people taught to apply them, before learning the underlying math/reasoning behind the arbitrary facts/formulas.

And trig is useful in lots of places in the science curriculum without the backing calculus, so teaching it in the math curriculum early to support the broader curriculum makes sense from that perspective.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by rndn on Thursday May 28, 2015 @11:32AM (#9618831)
> An integral is the inner product of a function and a suitably-dimensioned unit.

Does that mean that ∫f(x)dx is f.(dx, dx, …) = f(x_0)·dx + f(x_1)·dx + f(x_2)·dx + … for all x in the domain?

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by stephencanon on Thursday May 28, 2015 @02:51PM (#9620263)
Integral[f(x)g(x)dx] defines an inner product on a space of functions (glossing over exactly what functions) on an interval. So Integral[f(x) dx] is the inner product (f, 1), where "1" is the constant function g(x) = 1 on the interval.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by rndn on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:17PM (#9620880)
So ∫f(x)g(x)dx = (f.g)·dx?
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by stephencanon on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:25PM (#9621278)
No, f·g = ∫f(x)g(x)dx.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by rndn on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:52PM (#9621422)
But don't you need to account for the width dx of the slices you sum up? I.e. wouldn't f.g = f(x_0)g(x_0) + f(x_1)g(x_1) + … over a real interval blow up?
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by JadeNB on Thursday May 28, 2015 @06:45PM (#9621673)
The point is that f.g (or, as a mathematician or physicist might write it, ⟨f, g⟩ or ⟨f|g⟩) has no independent meaning, but must be defined; and one way to define it (for `L^2` functions, the only one compatible with the `L^2` norm) is as stephencanon did at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9620263 .
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by bandrami on Thursday May 28, 2015 @08:37PM (#9622062)
Well, it's not just any arbitrary definition, it's the projection of f onto g. Intuitively, sum(f_i * g_i).
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by JadeNB on Thursday May 28, 2015 @09:40PM (#9622249)
> Well, it's not just any arbitrary definition, it's the projection of f onto g.

'Projection' also has no intuitive (EDIT: I meant 'intrinsic') meaning; "inner product" is the same structure as "projection + norm" (subject to appropriate axioms). Anyway, I didn't mean to claim that the definition was arbitrary, but rather that there was no way to argue against it: definitions can't be wrong (at worst, they can be infelicitous, uninteresting, or uninhabited).

> Intuitively, sum(f_i * g_i).

I think rndn (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9621422 )'s objection applies to this intuition: to get a reasonable approximation of the integral, you need a lot of sample points, and any sum that doesn't take into account the spacing of those sample points has a good chance of diverging. (Consider f = g = 1, so that the sum is just a count of the number of sample points!)

Once you write sum(f(x_i) * g(x_i) * (dx)_i), of course, this becomes just notation for (a sequence of) Riemann sums, whose limit is by definition the integral (for continuous functions).

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by bandrami on Thursday May 28, 2015 @09:54PM (#9622299)
Sampling has nothing to do with this. The inner product of f (x) and g (x) simply is the integral with respect to x of their pointwise scalar products (I suppose in a very broad sense "pointwise" could be seen as analogous to sampling, as could "with respect to x", but the Calculus Gods will smite any who think of dx as a sample of x). The "ah ha" moment was in seeing inner product as the fundamental operation and integration as derived from it.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by JadeNB on Monday June 01, 2015 @05:57PM (#9642453)
> I suppose in a very broad sense "pointwise" could be seen as analogous to sampling

Indeed, I don't understand how it could be otherwise. To multiply functions pointwise, you need to know their values at points. It seems to me that 'sampling' is a very good word to describe the process of evaluating a function at a lot of points.

> as could "with respect to x", but the Calculus Gods will smite any who think of dx as a sample of x

Indeed not! It is the spacing between sample points. That is, the `dx` in an integral literally stands for the "ghost of [the] departed quantity" `x_{i + 1} - x_i` (and, in an infinitesimal approach to calculus, it doesn't just stand for but literally is such a difference).

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by JadeNB on Thursday May 28, 2015 @06:46PM (#9621677)
> Does that mean that ∫f(x)dx is f.(dx, dx, …) = f(x_0)·dx + f(x_1)·dx + f(x_2)·dx + … for all x in the domain?

I think that that is what is meant, except that it's not clear what you mean by "for all `x` in the domain"—`x` occurs bound on both sides. Of course this interpretation requires that one understand it as a philosophy rather than a calculation; for example, as your explicit version points out, one really needs tag points spaced `dx` apart to define the inner product, and (absent infinitesimals) the result will be only an approximation to the true integral.

stephencanon (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9620263) gives another interpretation that is unimpeachably mathematically correct, but (a) it is so nearly circular that I think it must be not what bandrami (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9616961) meant, and (b) (perhaps more importantly) the unit there is built into the definition of the inner product itself, rather than being part of the second "inner multiplicand".

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by bandrami on Thursday May 28, 2015 @08:28PM (#9622036)
No, stephencanon's comment is what I mean, and this may be an example of what my prof. meant that my students would not then be able to teach calculus.

By that point (this course was "differential operators", 700-level stuff) we all had a decent intuition of what inner and outer products are. The prof's comment was that looking at f(x) as an infinite-dimensioned vector, there is a unit *-cube g(x)=1 of compatible dimensions that can produce an inner product f|g (I'm not going to hunt through my character map for the dot or the integral sign). That inner product is the same as Integral(f(x), dx). This was in analogy to the differential operator being the exterior ("wedge") product of a function and its field.

The real point of the definition was relating y' and Integral(y) to div y and grad y: in y' you're going from vectors to tensors, and in Integral(y) you're going from vectors to scalars. Or, Integral(y) is a projection of y on some unit cube, and y' is finding the function of which y is the projection on an appropriate unit cube.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by bandrami on Friday May 29, 2015 @12:00AM (#9622590)
Does that mean that ∫f(x)dx is f.(dx, dx, …) = f(x_0)·dx + f(x_1)·dx + f(x_2)·dx + … for all x in the domain?

No, though it is true that the integral with respect to x, as an operation, is the limit of that summation as dx approaches 0. But the point wasn't about any particular numerical or symbolic manipulation we could do (this was a graduate-level calculus class, after all; we all knew how to actually integrate things).

Generally, when you learn inner products of functions, you learn the definition

f·g = ∫(f(x)g(x))dx where the concatenation there of f(x) and g(x) represents scalar multiplication. We all know how integration works, so this becomes how we define inner products.

My professor's point was to reverse the primacy there. We have a sense from vector operations of what inner products are; that can inform our intuition of what an integral is. That is, rather than saying "I know how to do an integral so I can now take an inner product of two functions", say "I have an intuition of what an inner product is, that is, the projection of one vector onto another to form a scalar, and that should inform my intuition of what an integral is".

The larger motivation for the whole talk was introducing Clifford algebras and the symmetry between dot product generalized to inner product opposed by outer product on the one hand, and cross product generalized to wedge product opposed by interior product on the other hand.

And, just to finish the mathjerking, the whole point of the course was to get to:

(δΩ)∫ω = (Ω)∫dω

ie, the most general case of Stokes' theorem. But that takes a lot of sussing out of what the differential operator d actually is.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by rndn on Friday May 29, 2015 @07:40AM (#9623949)
> mathjerking

Well, a proper math education is something that many people can only dream of.

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by k__ on Thursday May 28, 2015 @08:59AM (#9617780)
Maybe to teach the people how to use formulas they didn't make up themself. This is the part of Math that most of us do after school.