News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by threatofrain on Thursday May 28, 2015 @03:03PM (#9620356)
What kind of pedagogical or pragmatic relevance do you see trig as a building block for? I would answer that question by saying that it most likely comes up again either in physics or engineering contexts, or in a standardized exam like MCAT. And only in the sense of familiarity with the unit circle and trig functions.

What other foundation or learning pathway do you see trig serving as? Somebody else mentioned that trig serves use by teaching students that calculus has rich applications. So then I question, what kind of applications are students learning in trig? And if students are to learn rich examples of calculus applications, then why not statistics, which is also relevant to the bio / social sciences? Also, couldn't we mash trig inside calculus?

Re:Calculus for mathematicians (1997) [pdf] by AnimalMuppet on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:50PM (#9621089)
It seems to me that if I know trig, I can use it to solve the set of geometric problems to which it is applicable, without having been taught any special applications of trig. That's valuable in itself.

Then I take physics, and I find a whole bunch of other applications. I take calculus, and I find a bunch more uses. I take mechanics, and I find a bunch more. But it is not the job of trig to teach me those applications (though hints would be useful). It's not trig's job to teach me physics - that's a job for physics. But I need trig as a foundation.

I'm not sure that I answered your question, though...