Also, federal law isn't simply a grab bag of "really important" laws, with states only existing to handle smaller, more trivial things. In theory, federal law is restricted to addressing the things enumerated in the Constitution. In practice, one of those is regulating interstate commerce, which since [1] has steadily increased in scope. Nonetheless, a federal law banning capital punishment would still need to be written with that in mind.
Considering 8th Amendment incorporation under the 14th Amendment and the enforcement clause of the 14th Amendment, that shouldn't be too difficult, without even coming anywhere near the Commerce Clause.
Meanwhile: if capital punishment ever is held to be "cruel and unusual", no federal legislative action will be needed to abolish it; SCOTUS will do it by fiat.
SCOTUS has never held that disadvantaging the disabled is intrinsically a violation of the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment (relevant, as the provision under which it has incorporated the 8th against the states), nonetheless, it has held that Congress acted within its power under the enforcement clause of the 14th (and did not violate State reserved powers under the 11th) in, under the ADA, requiring access to courthouses.
While the enforcement clause of the 14th is a fairly lightly litigated power, its pretty clear that it does extend beyond the things where legislation is not necessary because any violation of the law Congress might impose to under the enforcement clause would already necessary be prohibited by the bare text of the Amendment, which seems to be your position.
The federal government can bind state courts not to violate the constitutional rights of the accused, and so for instance Washington can't pass laws requiring judges to apply mandatory sentences based on facts not established by juries. But those actions belong to the federal courts, not Congress.
I don't think Congress can pass a law banning state capital sentences.
Under the dubious justification of the Tsarnaev case, shoplifting candy from the corner store is under federal jurisdiction since in the age of social media it could incite people in other states to do the same.
On the other hand, I thought maybe you were suggesting that Congress could pass a law relying on the "Godel inconsistency" of Filburn to usurp state authority. Well, no, they can't; they're bound by the judicial precedents that fence Commerce Power authority in.
The entire idea of a written constitution is to independently limit a state's otherwise arbitrary power. This is not done through a formal process (as that would be part of the government itself, by definition). Stating that there are laws the government itself is bound to is a direct inducement to enforce those laws through informal methods (eg whistleblowers, insubordination, civil disobedience, revolution).
So, it is important for everyone to be independently judging whether their government is still bound by its original charter or if it has broken free and is essentially lawless. I don't expect that we'll agree on this judgment (it's a distributed consensus). My practical aim is to highlight that SCOTUS is not the final arbiter of the law lest this ultimate check be categorically forgotten.
Sure, by SCOTUS. If you are just arguing that SCOTUS can reverse itself, why even invoke Filburn? Its superfluous to the argument.
At any rate: every state that abolishes capital punishment gets us closer to a consistent country-wide federally enforced abolition of capital punishment.
7 more states need to defect from capital punishment, and then the majority of US states will have abolished it. Unfortunately, the three most populous US states (California, Texas, and Florida) are all staunchly pro-execution (the next two, NY and IL, have both abolished).
Though a Supreme Court ruling did effectively abolish the death penalty federally from 1972-1976.
The US Constitution is set up to give states some power and the feds other power.
Simplistic explanation - There are two kinds of courts in the US - federal courts and state courts. Federal courts hear cases involving US law while Nebraska courts hear cases involving Nebraska law.
Here's an overview - http://www.fjc.gov/federal/courts.nsf/autoframe!openform&nav...
>Criminal cases involving federal laws can be tried only in federal court, but most criminal cases involve violations of state law and are tried in state court. We all know, for example, that robbery is a crime, but what law says it is a crime? By and large, state laws, not federal laws, make robbery a crime. There are only a few federal laws about robbery, such as the law that makes it a federal crime to rob a bank whose deposits are insured by a federal agency. Examples of other federal crimes are bringing illegal drugs into the country or across state lines and use of the U.S. mails to swindle consumers. Crimes committed on federal property, such as national parks or military reservations, are also prosecuted in federal court.
>Federal courts may also hear cases concerning state laws if the issue is whether the state law violates the federal Constitution. Suppose a state law forbids slaughtering animals outside of certain limited areas. A neighborhood association brings a case in state court against a defendant who sacrifices goats in his backyard. When the court issues an order (called an injunction) forbidding the defendant from further sacrifices, the defendant challenges the state law in federal court as an unconstitutional infringement of his religious freedom.
>Some kinds of conduct are illegal under both federal and state laws. For example, federal laws prohibit employment discrimination, and the states have added their own laws. A person can go to federal or state court to bring a case under the federal law or both the federal and state laws. A case that only involves a state law can be brought only in state court.
So Nebraska writes its own laws and uses its own courts to enforce said laws which it decides the punishment for.
However, said punishment has to follow the US Constitution - if it isn't federal court can "override" Nebraska law, but only if they are breaking the Constitution. The Constitution prohibits "cruel and unusual punishment" however the Supreme Court of the United States says the death penalty isn't "cruel and unusual punishment." - here is some cases involving capital punishment - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_Supreme_C...
So yes, the feds can get rid of the death penalty two ways. Either the US Supreme Court declares death penalty as unconstitutional or the US Constitution is specifically amended to prohibit the death penalty.
>does the federal government have a position on capital punishment?
Yes, there is a federal death penalty for certain federal crimes.
That's not quite accurate. The states declared independence from the UK. Each state was a sovereign nation. Those states then combined to delegate some of their authority to the federal government. So in effect, the United States is a nation of 50 countries with one federal authority that was formed to handle matters of international importance, as well as, of course, matters of an interstate relations.
America fought this battle at the ballot box during the ratification of the Constitution, the federalists won. And again during the Civil War, the unionists won. It is a settled matter.
If we want to be annoying pedantic the US fought against Great Britain for independence, the UK didn't even exist then.
Good to see another state abolish this but as someone not too familiar with how the US law system works why is something like this decided at the state level? Shouldn't something like government sanctioned killing of humans be controlled at a federal level? Also does the federal government have a position on capital punishment?