News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty by mindslight on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @07:53PM (#9615210)
And?
Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty by tptacek on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @08:18PM (#9615314)
It's not very interesting to argue that a state might change its mind on some question, because that's always true, and there's no way to rebut or even engage that argument.

On the other hand, I thought maybe you were suggesting that Congress could pass a law relying on the "Godel inconsistency" of Filburn to usurp state authority. Well, no, they can't; they're bound by the judicial precedents that fence Commerce Power authority in.

Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty by mindslight on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @09:26PM (#9615543)
> a state might change its mind on some question, because that's always true

The entire idea of a written constitution is to independently limit a state's otherwise arbitrary power. This is not done through a formal process (as that would be part of the government itself, by definition). Stating that there are laws the government itself is bound to is a direct inducement to enforce those laws through informal methods (eg whistleblowers, insubordination, civil disobedience, revolution).

So, it is important for everyone to be independently judging whether their government is still bound by its original charter or if it has broken free and is essentially lawless. I don't expect that we'll agree on this judgment (it's a distributed consensus). My practical aim is to highlight that SCOTUS is not the final arbiter of the law lest this ultimate check be categorically forgotten.