I'm willing to wager that many readers here have never looked for a minimum wage job. If you haven't, you may not realize how much competition there can be. It's really shocking. This is especially true in smaller towns, where there are very few jobs that aren't minimum wage. I remember, years ago when I was in high school, my dad was a local business owner in a small town and was connected with all the other business owners. On several occasions, a friend or family member needed a minimum wage job and literally couldn't get one due to scarcity; my dad had to approach the owners of other businesses and put in direct recommendations so someone could get on at, say, a Dairy Queen or a car wash.
In Australia, the exact opposite is true - employers are lucky to have employees (who could, at any moment quit and do perfectly fine on welfare) and so employers know it and are extremely kind and thankful to their employees.
Holes in employment, sketchy details, questionable descriptions.
Or you could go the complete opposite route, and blatantly lie on your resume. As long as you actually know the skills, lie and say you have them. What's the worst they do to you? Fire you?
Just don't do that with a professional degree. Pissing off gov't is a bad idea.
Now of course there is another side to this equation: the remuneration is capped by the (perceived) value derived from the work done.
Now we're back to the point where minimum wage jobs are poverty level at best and significantly below poverty at worst.
To really put this into perspective, I know families who have immigrated here from Mexico who actually regret it because they didn't realize how low the standard of living is for minimum wage jobs.
I will refrain from commenting on how tragic the situation is in the United States for the simple reason that I don't live there. But your description of the situation doesn't make me want to move there except for a very cushy job.
Here in Japan unemployment is quite low, and health-care is nationalized, so the situation may not be as dramatic as the one you describe. But contractors at low paying jobs certainly hold the shitty end of the stick: all my friends in this situation live with their parents, they simply cannot afford to live alone.
That does not sound like a healthy economy to me.
Minimum wage is for employees with minimal skills. Almost always that should mean entry level positions. You don't want to run a business where the bulk of your workforce is barely qualified. You want a balance between the noobs, the competent young ones, and the old dogs who know all the ropes.
So even if for a position that has an "imbalance between the number of job seekers and the available positions", I would expect the average employee to make somewhere between 2x and 4x the minimum wage. Otherwise, what you are telling me is that an average high school kid can do the job equally well as a person with 10+ years of experience.
Japan used to run the other way around, where the salary was solely a function of age (or rather, how long a worker had been working in a company, but that was essentially the same). I don't think it makes for a healthy economy either. But I'm also not entirely convinced it's that much worse than the "free market" you have in the US.
I don't have any form of competence in terms of economy, but sometimes it feels like the economy we are living in right now is optimizing for the wrong things. It is becoming more and more efficient, more and more optimized, but not at all for the common good. Maybe for quarterly results?
For instance, a clothing store pays a number of people minimum wage to work the registers, keep the racks/shelves stocked and organized, and clean the place. Then they pay (not substantially) more for a few managers to keep things running smoothly. Usually there are many more employees than managers, and while an employee might be promoted to manager, there are so few openings that the average employee can't expect to rise at all. There's no reason to give these people any significant raise because they can be replaced in a week with another kid at minimum wage. The only incentive to pay a little bit more for someone who sticks around long term is because they tend to be more reliable in terms of showing up for their scheduled shift, but even that isn't uncommon enough to be worth much.
It's the same for any position that doesn't require a developed skill. Stocking shelves, unloading trucks, cashiers, cleaners, some basic customer service positions like a host(ess) at a cheap restaurant (the people who greet you at the door and show you to your seat for $8/hour).
I would guess that there are at least in the tens of millions of these positions in the US, so probably at least 5-10% of the population. Some of these are students who will rise out of it by getting a degree and landing an entry level position elsewhere, but I doubt that covers the majority.
And people will fight over these jobs, simply because they don't have skills to get a better one, and need to either work 2-3 jobs at once to get by, or pool their resources and live in a group with a number of other people who work the same jobs or only slightly better.
Here's some examples [1][2] that cover a small group of the described jobs. This accounts for a bit under 8 millions jobs. The site there isn't granular enough to get many other positions, as they are lumped in with others that earn more, like "Hand Laborers" which has a median income a couple dollars higher and adds a few million more jobs.
[1] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/sales/cashiers.htm [2] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/food-preparation-and-serving/food-and... [3] http://www.bls.gov/ooh/transportation-and-material-moving/ha...
NOTE: I'm not saying any of this is right, or good, or the way it should be or has to be, just that this is the way things are.
The Australian demographic time bomb is starting to go off, as well. The amount of healthcare and aged care spending is starting to take off like a rocket and this will-inevitably- lead to reductions in eligibility and payments, including what treatments are avialable from the health system.
What Australia does have is a lack of a large poverty stricken underclass, mainly because of the last 50-100 years of the countries history, which includes a lot of prosperity from agriculture and mining so that just about everyone has always had a job and intergenerational poverty has not been able to get a wide hold.
Those things are not guaranteed to last forever. Australia might just look like California in the 1950s right now, with a troubled future ahead.
This is mainly because the Aussie dollar was so high for so long, things haven't caught up yet. Pay is a lot higher in Australia as well, with a high minimum wage.
I was in Oz a couple of weeks ago and the government announced they're "reviewing" Medicare. The way they kept stressing that they're working with doctors and it's not a cost-cutting exercise made it painfully obvious they're going to do cost-cutting.
It has to happen sooner or later. You can avoid most things except for demographics.
How long have you lived in the US?
I'm not saying Australia is perfect (far from it).. I was pointing out that it's sad and unacceptable to have a society where tens of millions of people are working hard and living below the poverty line, when there are many, many examples to show it doesn't have to be like that (Australia just being one of the many)
I agree with your points in general, and choose Australia even though I have the option of either. But Australia started from a different starting point to the US. Adopting Australian policies wouldn't get Australian outcomes because the starting points are so different.
That's not to say that, if I were a US citizen, I wouldn't want change, I would, especially around healthcare. Just the same as I would like Australia to change in some ways as well.
Are you saying Australia doesn't have people living below the poverty line? Wikipedia says 12.5% of the population and 17.5% of children in Australia live below the poverty line.
The US has 16% below poverty line and 20% of children. Not that different than Australia.
It would be good to see some solid data, because one thing that surprised me while travelling in the USA was the extreme poverty I saw just down the road from extremely wealthy neighborhoods.
Not to say that Australia doesn't have its own set of problems, particularly in Indigenous Communities, but this seems to operate at a wholly different level.
I'm not sure why that is. My initial impression is that Canadian cities just don't allow certain sections of their cities to stagnate and crumble (maybe funding?). I remember reading that at one point in time Philadelphia had 16,000 abandoned vehicles in the city. In Canada, if a car looks like it's abandoned on a public street, you'd be lucky if 2-3 weeks passed before it was towed. Maybe that extends to other efforts as well?
There's a big difference between getting minimum wage every 5th of the month on the dot, or getting $2k one month, $10k next month, $1k third month and so on.
Minimum wage in California is $9/h. That means that if you work minimum wage full-time (160h/month), you get $1440 per month. You won't have luxury, but I imagine that managing your money when $1440 appears on your bank account every 5th of the month at 3pm isn't that difficult.
But when the deposits look like this:
- Jan 10th: $800
- Feb 4th: $2500
- Mar 15th: $1400
- Apr 29th: $1060
Managing cashflow is hard. But the average monthly income in this example is still minimum wage.I can't speak for US or Australia, but in New Zealand if you're an employee minimum wage IS minimum wage. Some employers hate it and would rather that not be the case, but we have contract workers for that style of employment, which are more-or-less at will, but the rules are different surrounding those and it much harder to "prove" someone is a contractor rather than an employee (it'll come down to things like: having sick days=employee, having a uniform provided=employee, organizing your own leave=contractor, it actually get's quite complex to prove someone is a contractor even if it states they are one in their employment agreement).
Exactly the situation described in the article, people being forced to stay just under the legal limit of becoming proper employees.
We have the same issue in Slovenia right now. If you're an employee, you get minimum wage (or more). Every month. But more and more people are being pushed into contracting because nobody will give them a job otherwise.
It's not a problem for people who embrace contracting and like all the freedom it provides, but it's a big problem for the person folding discarded clothes at H&M who is technically a contractor.
The government came up with a simple solution: if more than 80% of your income in a given year comes from a single company, they have to employ you.
This is bizarre. It gives contractors the power to unilaterally force companies to make them full employees by turning down work. Why?
Sometimes, you have to balance the damage done by two wrongs. :)
Companies probably should have thought of that before they switched to JIT staffing and forced the government to do that...
I guess this is where New Zealand works things out differently, it's really not clear cut about where the legal limit is for employee/contractor which makes it harder to stay closely under it and if the individual case isn't clear cut, the governing body almost always sides with the employee being an employee. I suspect in the US, things are much more favored towards the at-will type employment.
>if more than 80% of your income in a given year comes from a single company, they have to employ you.
That's quite an interesting solution, I really like it. I feel like it doesn't answer the fundamental legal meaning of contractor vs. employee, but practically it's way easier to test for and I think probably would work better than drawing some vague line in the sand about the meanings in law.
(edit: I agree that uncertainty certainly doesn't help the problem.)
If your expenses don't show equal flexibility, you'll find yourself cash-strapped: hungry, utilities cut, possibly on the street.
It's part of the great risk shift, creating a new social an political class, the precariat.
The American Precariat http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/11/opinion/brooks-the-america...
Plutonomy and the Precariat http://www.huffingtonpost.com/noam-chomsky/plutonomy-and-the...
Why the precariat is not a “bogus concept” https://www.opendemocracy.net/guy-standing/why-precariat-is-...
I think my point was exactly that now we're just comparing degrees of impossibility.
Unexpected expenses will of course mess it up and throw you into a spiral if you don't have a buffer. But that's true at any income level. Even if you're a techie making $200k a year, but without a buffer, you will have a huge problem if something unexpected happens.
Of course why you wouldn't have a buffer if you make that much money is a different problem. But hey, Mike Tyson was making millions and when the shit hit the fan, he went bankrupt in a heartbeat.
The AU example is fascinating, because if true, it really does feel like healthier society.
That is the problem.
Even in the example of unpredictable income you gave two posts above. If you spending all the money you are earning(even if variable) just because you are earning it a little extra every month. Something is badly broken in the way you live your life.
You are essentially not solving any problem at all, all you are doing is delaying your problems one month at a time. Someday that will blow up in your face. And when it does you will back to all the problems you had started with or may be even worse.
You should never be earning to make ends meet(That only delays problems, doesn't solve them). You should be earning towards a framework which enables you to do away with working to make a living(a.k.a retirement).
Not really. Minimum wage jobs rarely cover health insurance.
You might get sued and have to pay lawyers and/or settlements.
You might simply get divorced and spend a bunch of money on that.
Don't pay them. Nothing at all happens if you don't pay medical bills. Just ignore the bill collectors, don't answer the calls or even open the envelopes.
New rules mean that it has no effect on your credit score.
http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/payday-lenders-use-co...
http://blog.credit.com/2012/08/in-missouri-debtors-prison-is...
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/the-new-bill-collecto...
Don't outright not pay your debts; negotiate with the creditors for pennies on the dollar, but advising people to straight up ignore them is extremely reckless advice.
> you can have your wages garnished
Only if they win in court. And in practice if you don't have any money anyway, what do you have to loose? Why go into non-medical debt to pay off medical debt?
Just ignore the debt till you have some money. If you lose in court (which is unlikely) you are no worse off.
If you don't show up in court, they win by default. Have you never heard of "summary judgement"?
Then don't do that? Of course show up in court! Why in the world would you suggest not showing up in court?
Tell them you have no money. They'll make you prove you have no money. At worse they'll put you on a payment plan., and you be no worse off than before. At best they'll never take you to court in the first place.
"Don't pay them. Nothing at all happens if you don't pay medical bills. Just ignore the bill collectors, don't answer the calls or even open the envelopes."
I took that to mean ignore any court summons as well.
Obviously you should open mail from a court.
You need a $640 cash cushion and you can handle variation like what you list. On minimum wage it's hard to collect that cushion, I'm sure. But much harder is the discipline not to use it.
So when you don't have reliable income, money just kind of starts disappearing because you fall through the cracks of the banking system. Low balance? Service fee. Cut things too close with that rent check? Overdraft fee. Can't deposit your check in the bank because you literally need the money today to pay a bill and it will take three days to clear? Check-cashing fee.
As a result, you get conditioned (especially if this is the only way of handling money you've ever known) to think "crap, this money is going to disappear pretty soon -- better spend it now so I'll at least have stuff rather than have it get taken away." Luckily I joined the military and took their personal finance classes later, but I still (20 years later) have bad financial habits I have to consciously check from that time in my life.
That's like the WORST possible way to run your finances if you want to get out of poverty!
People in poverty mostly don't even see themselves as having any hope of getting out of it, so why bother trying to save? These are the people who spend 40% of their income on lotto tickets because there's just no light at the end of the tunnel unless a miracle happens.
> She seeks out private clients too, especially around the 27th of the month, when her credit-card bill, with its $90 minimum payment, is due.
Thats just poor money management no matter which way you throw it.
Don't buy things on credit you can't afford, its not your money; its not even money, its debt.
ETA: and that's assuming 40 a week, which for minimum wage employees is an awful assumption.
Sentences like that make me sad about the reality of life for tens of millions of working Americans.
I just visited Australia after 9 years in North America, and it's like a slap in the face to realize there are no desperate people there. Almost everybody has enough money for basic essentials, and nobody is crushed with student debt or the fear of not being able to pay medical bills.
It really does feel like another planet when people earning "minimum wage" are doing just fine, are extremely happy, and likely less stressed than the career workers in North America, simply because they earn "enough to live comfortably"