I agree with your points in general, and choose Australia even though I have the option of either. But Australia started from a different starting point to the US. Adopting Australian policies wouldn't get Australian outcomes because the starting points are so different.
That's not to say that, if I were a US citizen, I wouldn't want change, I would, especially around healthcare. Just the same as I would like Australia to change in some ways as well.
Are you saying Australia doesn't have people living below the poverty line? Wikipedia says 12.5% of the population and 17.5% of children in Australia live below the poverty line.
The US has 16% below poverty line and 20% of children. Not that different than Australia.
It would be good to see some solid data, because one thing that surprised me while travelling in the USA was the extreme poverty I saw just down the road from extremely wealthy neighborhoods.
Not to say that Australia doesn't have its own set of problems, particularly in Indigenous Communities, but this seems to operate at a wholly different level.
I'm not sure why that is. My initial impression is that Canadian cities just don't allow certain sections of their cities to stagnate and crumble (maybe funding?). I remember reading that at one point in time Philadelphia had 16,000 abandoned vehicles in the city. In Canada, if a car looks like it's abandoned on a public street, you'd be lucky if 2-3 weeks passed before it was towed. Maybe that extends to other efforts as well?
How long have you lived in the US?
I'm not saying Australia is perfect (far from it).. I was pointing out that it's sad and unacceptable to have a society where tens of millions of people are working hard and living below the poverty line, when there are many, many examples to show it doesn't have to be like that (Australia just being one of the many)