The AU example is fascinating, because if true, it really does feel like healthier society.
That is the problem.
Even in the example of unpredictable income you gave two posts above. If you spending all the money you are earning(even if variable) just because you are earning it a little extra every month. Something is badly broken in the way you live your life.
You are essentially not solving any problem at all, all you are doing is delaying your problems one month at a time. Someday that will blow up in your face. And when it does you will back to all the problems you had started with or may be even worse.
You should never be earning to make ends meet(That only delays problems, doesn't solve them). You should be earning towards a framework which enables you to do away with working to make a living(a.k.a retirement).
Not really. Minimum wage jobs rarely cover health insurance.
You might get sued and have to pay lawyers and/or settlements.
You might simply get divorced and spend a bunch of money on that.
Unexpected expenses will of course mess it up and throw you into a spiral if you don't have a buffer. But that's true at any income level. Even if you're a techie making $200k a year, but without a buffer, you will have a huge problem if something unexpected happens.
Of course why you wouldn't have a buffer if you make that much money is a different problem. But hey, Mike Tyson was making millions and when the shit hit the fan, he went bankrupt in a heartbeat.