News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:48PM (#9219247)
> That said, a Kleiner victory is well within the realm of the possible. Many women in the tech industry are concerned that Pao’s case is weak and that her accusations might exacerbate bias in the workplace. "I worry that it will make a lot more men feel that—being nice to and mentoring and trying to be a good person toward women colleagues—they, too, will be hauled before a jury," says Melinda Riechert, managing partner in the Silicon Valley office of law firm Morgan Lewis. For example, a key allegation in the case is that a Kleiner partner, Randy Komisar, behaved inappropriately when he gave Pao a volume of Leonard Cohen’s poems and drawings (entitled Book of Longing) on Valentine’s Day and asked her out to dinner on a night when his wife was out of town. Komisar says it was completely friendly and that his wife bought the book for Pao. Will men now retreat from cordial gestures toward female colleagues?

Does anyone else not see the immediate disconnect here?

I agree that Pao's case is weak but:

It juxtaposes that with a woman saying something about "being nice and mentoring" while pointing out at the same time a married man is handing out gifts on Valentine's Day.

I mean, come on. Does anyone seriously think that was anything other than hitting on Pao?

Any other day of the year it would have been fine. That specific day out of the 365 options was picked solely for that implication. It just feels weird to me that they'd compose things that way in the article.

"Being nice" - Doing nice things for a woman on days other than those dedicated to romance.

"Hitting on a woman" - Doing nice things and inviting her to be alone with you on a day dedicated to romance.

How is this not a clear line?

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by lisa_henderson on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:07PM (#9219412)
Agree strongly with this: "Does anyone seriously think that was anything other than hitting on Pao?"

Any man who is beyond college age, and who sincerely does not realize the meaning of handing out gifts and asking women out to dinner, is an idiot and should be removed from any position of authority. Emphasis on "sincerely" -- Randy Komisar is not that stupid, and his denials are hardly sincere.

The line "his wife bought the gift for her" has become something of a cliche which married couples use when the husband has been caught flirting but the wife is not yet ready to end the marriage.

Gifts given in public, for work well done, are always welcome, but a pattern of private gifts and requests for dinner are universally understood to be requests to initiate a sexual relationship.

One last word about "sincerely" -- there are some men who sincerely are that stupid. I have known at least 2. They somehow reach middle age and it does not occur to them that the gifts they are giving to an attractive young woman are being interpreted as sexual overtures. As Schiller said, "Against stupidity, the gods themselves struggle in vain." There is no cure for such men, but they need to be kept out of positions of power.

[dead]
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:27PM (#9219611)
I'd say it is pretty easy to avoid buying them gifts on Valentine's day and inviting them to private dinners with your SO out of town.

If you can't help but spontaneously give gifts to attractive women on Valentine's day...I'm at a loss, I'll admit.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by StopWhining on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:40PM (#9219729)
Just because the collective assumes Valentine's Day to be of importance has no bearing on my interactions. In fact, my SO and I do NOT celebrate Valentine's day. At all.

My SO also goes out drinking with other men. Without me. In private.

Why bring any of this up? Because I do not condemn expressions of affection just because the collective makes some childish assumption that grown adults must feel one emotion at a time per person.

Plot twist: You can feel affection for someone and not desire sexual activity from them in the same exact way you can feel bloodthirsty rage for someone and not desire to kill them. Yes, I know, it's a mind-blowing concept... the idea of people having complex and nuanced relationships instead of easily codified stateful interactions. (Once again, programmer bias trying to dictate how life should be)

Because we must all strive to make life easier for faceless administrators to conduct their soulless policies. /s

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:49PM (#9219803)
The argument you reject social norms and have no responsibility to communicate effectively with people who embrace social norms is absurd.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by StopWhining on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:08PM (#9219966)
Not my argument. I'm saying that social norms have failed and to hold them up as some infallible moral authority of how we should conduct ourselves is absurb. I will not let Generation Helicopter Parent dictate what emotions are acceptable and which ones aren't... especially since they themselves have ZERO experience with emotional nuance and leadership.

You go treat people like robots for administrative ease and CYA legalisms, and I'll go treat people like complex humans capable of handling their own lives. Let's see who gets to the top first.

[deleted]
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by DanBC on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:30PM (#9221194)
Stop feeding the troll.
[dead]
[deleted]
[dead]
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by dang on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:32PM (#9221212)
Please stop, both of you.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by rhino369 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:08PM (#9219429)
Hitting on a woman isn't even illegal unless there is a threat of coercion or it is so frequent/severe that it creates a hostile work environment.

I'm sure Pao's attorneys are arguing it is a part of a larger hostile work environment. But itself isn't sexual harassment.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:13PM (#9219479)
It was in reference to the quote and the implication that the two were equivalent and equal.

Mentoring and being nice to a woman is very, very different than flirting with her. Implying they are the same is gross.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by rhino369 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:16PM (#9219519)
Ah, I should have seen that. I agree.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:23PM (#9219576)
No worries, written communication isn't perfect.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by anaximander on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:15PM (#9219495)
I think the author of this article made it (perhaps deliberately) ambiguous as to when these events took place.

he gave Pao a volume of Leonard Cohen’s poems and drawings (entitled Book of Longing) on Valentine’s Day and asked her out to dinner on a night when his wife was out of town

These could very well be two completely separate occasions. I suspect the author created this juxtaposition to elicit your precise reaction.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by adevine on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:26PM (#9219601)
This is why I feel it's just better to refrain from any sort of judgment on this case based on what you read in the news. You're right - as it's written, it looks like "Duh, he's hitting on her." But did he give a gift to everyone on Valentine's Day? When he "asked her out to dinner on a night when his wife was out of town", was it a date or a "Let's talk about a potential investment at a popular VC haunt"?

I have no idea which is true, and I don't think I'm going to be able to find out based on summaries in the news.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:22PM (#9219567)
Why do you think that?

There are plenty of articles that agree the gift was given on Valentine's Day?

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by adevine on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:27PM (#9219605)
I think he is saying the dinner wasn't on Valentine's Day.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:32PM (#9219659)
The timing of the dinner request isn't relevant.

The problem is the choice of gift on Valentines and the fact the author of the article basically equated buying erotic poetry with being "nice and mentoring".

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by anaximander on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @08:24PM (#9222670)
I agree that the gift was inappropriate. I was responding to your comment:

"Hitting on a woman" - Doing nice things and inviting her to be alone with you on a day dedicated to romance.

The invitation to have dinner may have happened anytime.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by Shivetya on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:53PM (#9219291)
well she did have an affair with a married coworker, so how are other men supposed to judge her? You make that kind of serious mistake in a professional environment and people are right to judge your competence. They did try/fire the guy involved over her objection.

As for handing out valentine gifts, hell my entire work place would be in trouble for gifts, cards, and the like. We celebrate a lot different events, though you learn real quick whom to avoid as some people look to take offense; not saying she did. The can subpoena the gift giver's wife to see if that side of his story holds up. As for asking her out, she already demonstrated that marriage was no barrier.

Let's be honest. We only get a picture, one tinted by personal views and time. It will be interesting what the court digs up and how the final determination comes about.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by rimunroe on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:15PM (#9219498)
Having an affair with one married coworker doesn't give other coworkers license to hit on you.

The argument you're using is basically, "She slept with someone else, so why should other people not expect to be able to get to have privileged relationships with her too?"

And even if you ignore that, you obviously shouldn't be hitting on people at work.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by ObviousScience on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:34PM (#9219679)
> The argument you're using is basically, "She slept with someone else, so why should other people not expect to be able to get to have privileged relationships with her too?"

Actually, the argument is "She slept with someone else, so why shouldn't I be allowed to see if she's interested in sleeping with me?"

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by rimunroe on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:10PM (#9219991)
> Actually, the argument is "She slept with someone else, so why shouldn't I be allowed to see if she's interested in sleeping with me?"

Finding out if she's interested in sleeping with you is a privileged relationship. You don't just find that out from random coworkers. The "privileged relationship" I was referring to was one where you get to find that sort of thing out, not one where you automatically get to sleep with them.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by jquery on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:32PM (#9219662)
> Having an affair with one married coworker doesn't give other coworkers license to hit on you.

Coworkers don't need a license, because it's not illegal to make a pass at a coworker.

> you obviously shouldn't be hitting on people at work.

"Hitting on" is a crude way to describe buying a gift. Is love now banned at work?

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by jsmthrowaway on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:50PM (#9219811)
I don't even make friendships at work anymore, given the ugly fallout that can result from something negative in the friendship impacting a professional relationship. It is wise to completely disconnect your professional life and private one in this climate, as this Pao case demonstrates in some ways.

Drinks with the team? Sure, but I leave after one. Gifts to a coworker and an invitation to dinner? Not a chance. It's just too unpredictable no matter what you mean by it. I respect my coworkers enough not to force them into ambiguity with me as a person. Personal relationships have so many opportunities to go south. Why would I complicate my workplace?

Is that unfair? Maybe. I'm not there to make friends. Silicon Valley is pretty bad at this in general. The last thing I want to do on a weekend anyway is see the same people I see all week and do something social, and have to pretend that business stays at the office.

You should try it. I haven't been burnt out for years, like I was when I left work only to go socialize with the same people. It was like living in Groundhog Day. The startups that force this culture on its employees are part of the problem. I do not devote my life to a company. I'm sorry.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by rimunroe on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:08PM (#9219972)
> Coworkers don't need a license, because it's not illegal to make a pass at a coworker.

I never said anything about legality. Ethics should not strictly be a reflection of laws, laws should be a reflection of ethics. Using laws as the only things that guide your ethical decisions works fine if you want to be a major asshole to people, but not if you want to exist in a healthy community.

> "Hitting on" is a crude way to describe buying a gift. Is love now banned at work?

This isn't about "love" being "banned" at work or anything, this is about what constitutes appropriate behavior. You should try to not make things uncomfortable for others. The immediate personal cost you incur when you work to make a group of people less uncomfortable is tiny compared to the costs that they have to deal with from society handing them a raw deal, and it can help a lot.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by fweespeech on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:59PM (#9219352)
> As for handing out valentine gifts, hell my entire work place would be in trouble for gifts, cards, and the like.

Oddly enough, where I work, the accepted standard is you simply don't hand out stuff to coworkers on Valentines.

I mean it is one f'n day of the year, how hard is it to avoid that unless your sole goal is to entice someone?

> We celebrate a lot different events

I think you are making my point for me. Any event except Valentines/romance related, the behavior would have been appropriate. Specifically doing it on Valentines with the unspoken implication of he'd be alone with her and his wife would be out of town....? :/

> Let's be honest. We only get a picture, one tinted by personal views and time. It will be interesting what the court digs up and how the final determination comes about.

Of course. However, it disgusts me that the article seems to imply that "hitting on a woman" and "being nice/mentoring" is the same behavior as the positioning of that quote implied.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by kzhahou on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @05:14PM (#9221529)
I don't find the dinner invitation to be damning in the slightest. Have you all not been around VCs? They're always having dinner, having multiple dinners in one night, flitting from one company to another, to some new prospect, whatever. On this night, he has no plans, his wife is out, so he invites a coworker to grab food after work. So what? Things will get steamy at University Cafe?
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:49PM (#9219255)
I don't think this trial has much to do with larger women in tech issues. There's a lot of politics at play for ALL employees of VC firms and this doesn't sound any different.

If you've been following all of the coverage of this case, Pao isn't coming off well.

She states that it was discriminatory that she didn't get her review on time. Unprofessional to have a delayed review? Yes. Gender harassment? No. Instead of doing her review, they just gave her a bonus of $150,000 and a $40,000 raise (that she claims not to remember).

http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/03/ellen-pao-was-res...

From this article:

> Pao has also raised an incident in which one of the firm’s senior partners, former Hewlett-Packard Chairman Ray Lane, asked her and a second female colleague to takes notes at a partners' meeting. "I just froze, I wasn’t sure what to do," Pao testified on the stand.

I'm a man in a managerial position. I've been asked to take notes many times in meetings. Sometimes I do, sometimes I have to talk a lot and so someone else has to.

> Kleiner waited too long to fire a male partner who seemed to be treating the firm as his own private dating website.

Pao and Nazre were dating and both married at the time. There's a ton of he said she said, but to put it all on Nazre isn't fair.

[EDIT] I was incorrect about this. See Anechoic's comment below.

Pao has stated that she took the Reddit CEO role because she couldn't get a job as an investor. Honestly, Reddit CEO sounds like a much better job than all but the most senior of investment positions.

There's a lot to this story, and it's getting legs because gender issues in tech are a HOT topic right now. I don't see any of this case having larger implications though.

[EDIT] Please don't just downvote me. If you disagree, leave a reply.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by ditonal on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @12:58PM (#9219343)
I don't see how you could possibly not see how it has larger implications. For years we've been told that the reason there's no women in tech is because of all us sexist brogrammers, despite the typical programmer being the opposite of a 'bro', while the VCs very much resemble them, and somehow VCs being 96% male with most top firms having NO women as partners slips by unnoticed. VCs intentionally create frat house cultures at the tech companies they invest in because they assume it saves them money to hire misfit programmers who need a workplace to provide a social life rather than act like processionals and demand professional compensation, and that frat house culture is also antagonistic to people who aren't young males. Finally, I don't see how you could read a case where a VC firm made mis-step after mis-step, and a highly qualified woman suggested they invest in winners like Twitter only to be ignored, and brushed off for invites to the Democrats the VCs are in bed with like Al Gore, and not see how she clearly as an extremely strong case of gender discrimination against a rich and powerful sect of elite VCs who have hidden their sickening behavior in the shadows for far too long.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:06PM (#9219407)
You're throwing a lot of opinion out there that's not backed by evidence or even anecdote.

I currently work for a VC funded company and have worked for several in the past. I would not describe any of them as "frat house cultures". You're making some pretty sweeping generalizations.

The dinner with Al Gore was for senior partners and there WAS women invited, they just couldn't make it. Here's Mary Meeker on the subject:

http://recode.net/2015/03/16/liveblog-mary-meeker-testifies-...

> a highly qualified woman suggested they invest in winners like Twitter only to be ignored

We don't know the fully story here. They had already looked at investing in Twitter and passed. A mistake? Sure. But anti-portfolios are famous. Whether Pao is "highly qualified" or not is debatable. Has she made any successful investments? Was she previously a successful entrepreneur? Those are things that would make you highly qualified to be a VC.

I don't see anything "sickening" here.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by ditonal on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:14PM (#9219482)
Wrong, I do have facts on my side, and we do have a big chunk of the story because it's being aired out in a high profile court case for those of us paying attention.

I've been to several VC-funded companies that involved things like excessive drinking, happy hours as part of the interviews, etc. For some bizarre reason involving an algorithm called Future Founders that looks for potential founders, I also got invited to a VC lunch where they talked about these strategies, ways to effectively outsource, etc. I am going to write a tell-all about it eventually but I'm still too mid-career for it to be a good idea.

VCs are throwing around a lot of intangibles and "we just can't know for sure" for why there field is 96% male, and yet the woman who objectively outperforms them doesn't get promoted. You can easily fact check the sexism I'm talking about by just looking up top VC firms and scrolling through their list of partners, and I would also recommend every tech employee look at the gender makeup of their board of directors, and reading more about this case.

Are you joking about saying her qualifications are debatable? She has an engineering degree from Princeton, an MBA and JD from Harvard, and the only thing that prevents her from having a track record of successful investments is the sexism being demonstrated in this case!

96% male, paying yourselevs $3 million a year but running to Democrats like Obama and DeBlasio to spend taxpayer money to fill your "talent shortage", harassing and retaliating against the few female VCs you do have, I do see sickening behavior, and the reason you can't is because you're a corporate shill.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by bane on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:14PM (#9219488)
Yes, this case is exposing the sordid 1950's style inner workings at a modern VC, as it should.

The issue is that Pao is a lousy person to get behind on many of the issues she's the complainant on. She appeared to have routinely crossed good social boundaries that she's now complaining about, and was well rewarded for her work, receiving sizable bonuses for missing a performance eval.

I wish on my wildest dreams my reviews went as poorly as the ones she's taking issue with.

She still has plenty of valid complaints, but it's like she's infected with a logical fallacy disease, and any attempt to rationally examine her case almost forces one to wrongly dismiss her due to a list of fallacies that infect any examination of her claims.

She was hit on by a married man at work? That's genuinely unprofessional. But then she had an affair with a married coworker. It makes it easy to dismiss her on this, even if her complaint is still valid.

She was discriminated against? She received six figure bonuses and huge pay raises for missing a performance review that she then "forgot"! Again, did everybody else get 7 figure bonuses and even bigger raises? Maybe her claim is still valid even if it's easy to lose sight of it in the logical fallacy bait she keeps throwing into the case.

And so on.

Maybe she was lousy at her job and that's why she missed out on opportunities. Maybe she missed out because she's a minority class who was discriminated against.

Maybe she's just an unpleasant person to be around and people didn't invite her to parties, where he easier to get along with peers made good networking connections. Is that discrimination? Not if she wasn't invited for being a whiny bore (I don't know that she is), but it is if she wasn't invited for being a woman or a minority or whatever.

Whatever the case is, it's not entirely clear that she was personally discriminated against, even if the VC firm she was part discriminates in other cases. What is clear is that she definitely played in the same game as many of the people she's now complaining about post-facto, and this soils her arguments.

One of the reasons it's important to try and maintain a good reputation based on strong personal integrity is that if a case like this comes up with you, it's much easier for an arbiter to parse out the bad doings against you from the bad doings you committed.

edit here she is in action https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LJp3sTM2oeo

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by ditonal on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:16PM (#9219517)
There's no doubt she was playing the same games. Doesn't change the fact that she was discriminated against for being a woman, and in retaliation she's looking for the millions she wasn't paid and letting all of us lowly engineers know what games the VCs are playing.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by bane on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:22PM (#9219570)
And how underpaid we are?

I'd trade what I'm getting paid right now to take on what sounds like a far easier job that pays quite a bit more in a bad year than what I make in a great year.

But qualifications don't get you into these kinds of clubs, connections and pedigree do.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by thejaredhooper on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:02PM (#9219378)
I think that she just might've just been a bad egg, given the facts presented in the article.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by ditonal on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:05PM (#9219401)
Very convenient that this 'bad egg' in VC happens to be one of the 4% women in the field, and who again, seemed to do a far, far more competent job at the actual job description of picking the right companies to invest in, rather than total intangibles like 'thought leadership' and 'owning the room'. Read more articles about the case, read about how she wanted to invest in Twitter but they picked a bunch of losers instead, and still ignored her for promotion for intangibles that can straightfowardly be construed as gender-biased.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by thejaredhooper on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @08:11PM (#9222594)
I'll read more into it like you suggest.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by Anechoic on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:15PM (#9219502)
Pao and Nazre were dating and both married at the time.

Implied in the Ars article, and stated directly in other articles [0,1,2], the affair happened in 2006, but according to Wiki [3] Pao wasn't married until 2007.

[0] http://www.siliconbeat.com/2015/02/17/ellen-pao-vs-kleiner-p...

[1] http://www.theverge.com/2015/3/3/8141053/ellen-pao-kleiner-p...

[2] http://www.wired.com/2015/02/ellen-pao-trial-day-two/

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ellen_Pao#Personal_life

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:18PM (#9219526)
Thank you for this. I'll add it to my comment.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:07PM (#9219417)
I downvoted you, because you purported to summarize the case for readers who haven't been following it, and then provided a very misleading summary. Pao's case does not revolve around delayed reviews, or who took notes in meetings. One needn't have an opinion about the merits of Pao's case to have a negative opinion about the merits of this summary.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by bane on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:16PM (#9219507)
What is the case about then? To me at least the summary seemed aligned well with the media coverage I've been following. But I'll admit I haven't had the time to read the source documents.
[dead]
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by jusben1369 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:37PM (#9219707)
Whether you're a troll or actually serious you've given yourself a very appropriate handle/name. What value did you hope to add to this discussion with this inaccurate rant?
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by nyrulez on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:31PM (#9219646)
What is your concise summary of the biggest accusation that demands justice ? I fail to understand from the bloomberg article as it seems to make all accusations petty and even harmful to her case.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by x0x0 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:03PM (#9219922)
it's really not that hard

Pao and her supervisor hooked up. She stopped fucking him and he retaliated (illegal). She complained to the head of the firm and he didn't stop the retaliation (also illegal).

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @05:32PM (#9221669)
Ajit Nazre wasn't Pao's supervisor.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:09PM (#9219437)
Care to provide some links to what you think the case IS about? I'm addressing points raised in the submitted article and the article I provided a link to. How am I being misleading?
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by dasil003 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:14PM (#9219491)
Cherry-picking.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:49PM (#9219801)
Please supply the missing information then. I want to be as accurate as possible! I'm not cherry picking, just pointing to actual points being raised in these articles.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:06PM (#9219948)
It's ok to be uninformed about a random legal case. You don't have a duty to be informed about Pao. What's not OK is to casually and incorrectly declare yourself informed and then to provide an opinionated summary based on that false credential, which is what you've managed to do here.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:14PM (#9220026)
Aside from Anechoic who gave a very appreciated correction to my comment, not a single person has provided any additional information.

You keep saying I'm uninformed but you've not provided any information to this discussion. Please do! I want to know more.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by x0x0 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:20PM (#9220083)
Possibly the internet at large, or hn, doesn't consider it our jobs to babysit you. Type something like ellen pao lawsuit into google and educate yourself.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:22PM (#9220095)
I provided data to support my case. Some people are attacking me but not providing a reason.

Saying "I'm right, but I refuse to prove it!" doesn't get you much.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by x0x0 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:24PM (#9220111)
You provided cherry-picked facts, and couldn't even manage get the few you included right.

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=ellen+pao+lawsuit

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:27PM (#9220139)
I'm disengaging with you because you're obviously here to troll. If you want to provide any additional information do it somewhere in this thread.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:34PM (#9220208)
That commenter is being a bit aggressive, but they don't appear to be trolling; their critique is valid. One of the oldest message board rhetorical tricks in the book is to use a grossly incomplete summary as an ambit claim, and then to retcon facts from the inevitable rebuttals into that argument. It shouldn't surprise you that people don't want to help you do that.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:37PM (#9220230)
Their critique is: you're wrong but I won't tell you why.

I don't see how that's helpful. I don't know what you're suggesting we do either. You don't want to supply facts because they'll be "retcon"-ed? That's a new one.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:39PM (#9220247)
If it weren't obvious to anyone who'd been following the case how superficial your summary was, that would be a valid point.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:40PM (#9220253)
Ok, well if you can't provide any information then I'm afraid there's not much else for us to discuss.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by bane on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @05:00PM (#9221418)
Another one of the oldest message board rhetorical tricks is to claim somebody is wrong because they're supplying incomplete information and then after multiple requests to multiple people to fill in the gaps simply refuse to do so.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by dllthomas on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @11:18AM (#9226062)
I strongly object to this form of argument. It boils down to "I'm right because you haven't done the work to show I'm right." You can always demand more work, and it doesn't require any correlation with the truth.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by gadders on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:19PM (#9220073)
The Kleiner Perkins pre-trial brief also implied that the case was launched due to Pao's husband's money problems.

"F. Pao Files A Complaint Full of Unnecessary and Salacious Details

In May 2012, Pao filed this lawsuit alleging gender discrimination, retaliation (for allegedly complaining that Nazre sexually harassed her in 2007), and failure to prevent discrimination. Simultaneously, Pao’s husband, Alphonse “Buddy” Fletcher Jr., filed for bankruptcy on behalf of his hedge fund Fletcher Asset Management (“PAM”) when PAM failed to pay back pension funds that requested reimbursement of their investments.8 The appointed bankruptcy trustee ultimately issued a report stating that PAM had not had a single profitable investment since 2007 (the year Fletcher married Pea) and had committed several improper acts..."

http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/256174...

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by MollyR on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @04:10PM (#9221021)
I know I haven't been keeping up on this hot topic.

But Wow, I didn't know that.

It adds a whole new dimension to this case.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by lawnchair_larry on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:22PM (#9219566)
This is a women in VC story, nothing to do with women in tech.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by michaelochurch on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:29PM (#9219637)
VCs are the bosses of tech. VCs are the real executives in Silicon Valley and "founders" are upper-mid-level project managers in the world's first postmodern corporation.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by michaelochurch on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:34PM (#9219676)
If you've been following all of the coverage of this case, Pao isn't coming off well.

In the worst case for her, Ellen Pao turns out to be like Michael Brown: not sympathetic, not a victim, but the case still illustrates a lot of systemic bias and moral failure.

(Not to say that is how it is playing out or will play out.)

I think she probably did have her reputation (internal to the firm) damaged for reasons that constitute gender harassment. I also think that she was passed over and fired not because she was a woman, but because her reputation was damaged and she probably couldn't get much done. The question is how responsible the firm itself is for spotting problems like that and allowing people to clear their own names.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by sockshirt on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:25PM (#9219600)
Stories like this make me feel ambivalent.

Gender inequality being brought to the forefront fairly commonly has definitely forced me to evaluate my own actions and words. It sounds silly (and it is because it's mostly beneficial), but I certainly treat female colleagues differently: I'm much more thoughtful about what I say and do, and try to be as explicit as possible if I think there's any way that my words/actions could be misconstrued. Thoughtful in a way that I'm absolutely not around male colleagues.

And maybe that's totally fine: I really doubt I'll ever regret being more thoughtful. I certainly do this to some extent with people from other cultural backgrounds, so applying it to people from other gender backgrounds (so-to-speak) is probably appropriate.

But it does absolutely setup this "othering" in my mind - I don't see Jennifer as just my coworker, she's my coworker and she's also a woman and I need to be cognizant of how I act and talk around her. I'm careful to think about my words and actions before they materialize, whereas with men I'm much more likely to just act/talk and explain later if necessary. "Asking permission" vs. "Seeking forgiveness".

I don't envy being John Doerr - unless Pao was an absolutely clear frontrunner for becoming a senior partner, you're damned if you do and damned if you don't.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by jusben1369 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:50PM (#9219808)
"Tracy DiNunzio, chief executive officer of Tradesy, an online fashion site in which Kleiner Perkins has invested, says she was recently told by a male chief executive officer that he doesn’t know how to talk to female colleagues any more and that it’s become too easy to say the wrong thing. The case "may make it harder for men to feel free to give women the kinds of constructive criticism that men receive regularly and that they benefit from," she says."

I found this paragraph to be the most interesting. We're clearly moving from a sexist world to a less sexist world. The transition involves moving norms of what's acceptable and that's creating a lot of angst for both men and women. The above paragraph (and the one before it in the article) represent one common response "Why can't it just be like it was before?" but there's no going backward. Eventually we'll settle at a new equilibrium but Sandy's book and this trial and some other events will be viewed as pivotal moments when they write the textbooks in 20 to 30 years.

Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley by AndrewWright on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:37PM (#9219704)
It's a PR victory for KP that the media generally refers to this as the "Ellen Pao Trial" rather than the "Kleiner Perkins Trial"