Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:07PM
(#9219417)
I downvoted you, because you purported to summarize the case for readers who haven't been following it, and then provided a very misleading summary. Pao's case does not revolve around delayed reviews, or who took notes in meetings. One needn't have an opinion about the merits of Pao's case to have a negative opinion about the merits of this summary.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
What is the case about then? To me at least the summary seemed aligned well with the media coverage I've been following. But I'll admit I haven't had the time to read the source documents.
[dead]
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by jusben1369 on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:37PM
(#9219707)
Whether you're a troll or actually serious you've given yourself a very appropriate handle/name. What value did you hope to add to this discussion with this inaccurate rant?
What is your concise summary of the biggest accusation that demands justice ? I fail to understand from the bloomberg article as it seems to make all accusations petty and even harmful to her case.
it's really not that hard
Pao and her supervisor hooked up. She stopped fucking him and he retaliated (illegal). She complained to the head of the firm and he didn't stop the retaliation (also illegal).
Ajit Nazre wasn't Pao's supervisor.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:09PM
(#9219437)
Care to provide some links to what you think the case IS about? I'm addressing points raised in the submitted article and the article I provided a link to. How am I being misleading?
Cherry-picking.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @01:49PM
(#9219801)
Please supply the missing information then. I want to be as accurate as possible! I'm not cherry picking, just pointing to actual points being raised in these articles.
It's ok to be uninformed about a random legal case. You don't have a duty to be informed about Pao. What's not OK is to casually and incorrectly declare yourself informed and then to provide an opinionated summary based on that false credential, which is what you've managed to do here.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:14PM
(#9220026)
Aside from Anechoic who gave a very appreciated correction to my comment, not a single person has provided any additional information.
You keep saying I'm uninformed but you've not provided any information to this discussion. Please do! I want to know more.
Possibly the internet at large, or hn, doesn't consider it our jobs to babysit you. Type something like ellen pao lawsuit into google and educate yourself.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:22PM
(#9220095)
I provided data to support my case. Some people are attacking me but not providing a reason.
Saying "I'm right, but I refuse to prove it!" doesn't get you much.
You provided cherry-picked facts, and couldn't even manage get the few you included right.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:27PM
(#9220139)
I'm disengaging with you because you're obviously here to troll. If you want to provide any additional information do it somewhere in this thread.
That commenter is being a bit aggressive, but they don't appear to be trolling; their critique is valid. One of the oldest message board rhetorical tricks in the book is to use a grossly incomplete summary as an ambit claim, and then to retcon facts from the inevitable rebuttals into that argument. It shouldn't surprise you that people don't want to help you do that.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:37PM
(#9220230)
Their critique is: you're wrong but I won't tell you why.
I don't see how that's helpful. I don't know what you're suggesting we do either. You don't want to supply facts because they'll be "retcon"-ed? That's a new one.
If it weren't obvious to anyone who'd been following the case how superficial your summary was, that would be a valid point.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:40PM
(#9220253)
Ok, well if you can't provide any information then I'm afraid there's not much else for us to discuss.
Another one of the oldest message board rhetorical tricks is to claim somebody is wrong because they're supplying incomplete information and then after multiple requests to multiple people to fill in the gaps simply refuse to do so.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by dllthomas on Wednesday March 18, 2015 @11:18AM
(#9226062)
I strongly object to this form of argument. It boils down to "I'm right because you haven't done the work to show I'm right." You can always demand more work, and it doesn't require any correlation with the truth.