Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by tptacek on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:34PM
(#9220208)
That commenter is being a bit aggressive, but they don't appear to be trolling; their critique is valid. One of the oldest message board rhetorical tricks in the book is to use a grossly incomplete summary as an ambit claim, and then to retcon facts from the inevitable rebuttals into that argument. It shouldn't surprise you that people don't want to help you do that.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:37PM
(#9220230)
Their critique is: you're wrong but I won't tell you why.
I don't see how that's helpful. I don't know what you're suggesting we do either. You don't want to supply facts because they'll be "retcon"-ed? That's a new one.
If it weren't obvious to anyone who'd been following the case how superficial your summary was, that would be a valid point.
Re:The Ellen Pao Trial and Silicon Valley
by malvosenior on Tuesday March 17, 2015 @02:40PM
(#9220253)
Ok, well if you can't provide any information then I'm afraid there's not much else for us to discuss.
Another one of the oldest message board rhetorical tricks is to claim somebody is wrong because they're supplying incomplete information and then after multiple requests to multiple people to fill in the gaps simply refuse to do so.