News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by sschueller on Friday March 13, 2015 @06:44AM (#9196463)
These apple craftsmanship videos are trying to appeal to the high end watch enthusiast but this is not going to work.

Just look at the Patek Philippe 5175R grandmaster chime watch video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SGPjFFMD3c0 . You can't compare these hand made masterpieces with a mass produced item.

It's like trying to get Pagani Zonda owner to buy a Corvette.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by felipeerias on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:43AM (#9197021)
Clearly, Apple will not be able to compete with the most expensive watches in the world, at $2.6 million each.

Patek Philippe will flood the market by selling all six of them.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dogma1138 on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:39AM (#9197700)
Not with a 2.5M watch, but you can buy a Rolex, TAG, Omega or many other hand made swiss masterpieces for under 10K, all of them tbh look much more appealing than a square piece of gold on your hand.

It's also quite sad that the base watch has a freaking sport strap even in the "gold edition" if you want to actually have a classical watch strap you'll have to cough up 17K....

CH was right, the only use of this watch is to show just how much money you are willing to spend on a piece of crap.

A classical luxury watch has at least a heirloom factor, i got a pretty expensive watch for my 18th Birthday and i still keep it as one. This watch will be obsolete after 18 months, not to mention not maintainable after 3-4 years.

What happens when the battery dies out? what happens when you no longer can run WatchOS 3 cuz IWatch 2 is out? :)

Give me a nice breitling or an omega any day these watches will last for centuries and still keep working and keep true time.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by nilkn on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:58PM (#9199178)
I actually do not agree with you that a Rolex necessarily looks better than an Apple Watch Edition. To me, most Rolex watches just look like massive hunks of metal. Seriously, the size and weight of some of these watches is really ridiculous to me.

Also, mechanical watches do not last centuries without being serviced repeatedly every ~5 years. Servicing a high-end mechanical watch can easily cost many hundreds, if not more.

Many mechanical watches are also not automatic, which means you do indeed have to "charge" them every day (hand-wind them). For instance, Nomos is my personal favorite watch brand of all time, and while they have a mixture of manual and automatic watches, their highest-end offerings (about $20k) are all manual.

Finally, you mentioned TAG, and one of their best known watches is square: the Monaco.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by nvarsj on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:34PM (#9199453)
> I actually do not agree with you that a Rolex necessarily looks better than an Apple Watch Edition. To me, most Rolex watches just look like massive hunks of metal. Seriously, the size and weight of some of these watches is really ridiculous to me.

Rolex datejust and explorer are both pretty classy without being oversized. But yeah, the oversizing of watches has gotten a bit silly (this is across all brands, not just rolex).

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by thoughtsimple on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:13PM (#9198289)
Battery is replaceable obviously. Why would you doubt that?
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dogma1138 on Friday March 13, 2015 @04:37PM (#9199881)
And for how long will apple continue to make the battery? If any part of the electronics will die, and it will it's game over for that watch.

If you have a mechanical movement then there are replacement parts for watches made over 150 years ago still being made.

With the potted mess of consumer electronics these days GL fixing it in 5 years from now. 10K for a paper weight.

On another note Apple just increased it's loan scheme in the UK to 8K GBP which is the price for the entry gold model.

So now with 48 easy payments and 15% interest you can own yourself a real peace of wannabe richness.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by outworlder on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:27PM (#9198007)
They could perhaps replace the 'movement' - what an odd name for a fully electronic watch.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by mackey on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:13AM (#9197539)
I disagree that appealing to high end watch enthusiasts is Apple's goal with these videos.

Apple creates these type of videos for almost every product they sell. Take a look at the new macbook video and you will see the same kind of theatrics. They just really enjoy showing this stuff off. They have some of the best manufacturing in the industry and they are proud of it.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by PuffinBlue on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:11AM (#9196534)
Wow, I've never seen such a thing as that Grandmaster Chime watch. My father in law is a watch enthusiast but everything he has talked about has been an order of magnitude less exquisite than the one in that video.

I enjoy moments like these, and there have been many in my life, where the scales fall from my eyes are I get a glimpse of the adjacent possible.

Thank you!

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by McUsr on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:27AM (#9196581)
I agree, that was just amazing.

Thanks!

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by josefresco on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:21AM (#9196949)
Pagani owners most likely own multiple cars. And if they wanted a "daily driver" the very capable Corvette would be high on most enthusiasts lists.

Apple does not want to make a Pagani and sell a dozen each year.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by easytiger on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:43AM (#9197341)
> very capable Corvette would be high on most enthusiasts lists

It really isn't, not in europe.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by bane on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:54AM (#9196855)
You'll notice too that many of the shots show lots of mass manufactured duplicates, that's because the iWatch is particularly interesting as a watch design, there's not that many little precise mechanisms in it.

So in order to not just show a boring milled component of the face assembly or whatever they show lots of boring milled face assemblies.

There's nothing interesting to see here so we'll show you lots of uninteresting things to see if that makes up for it.

Having also spent some time learning about how PR firms work, I'm also deeply suspicious of articles like this as having been generated because somebody was so moved by the beauty of the watch they had to write a post about it. There are arguably better or equal looking watches on the market (smart or otherwise) that haven't received this attention.

The previous post on this blog is about the Mac Pro, which is usually compared to looking like a small trash can or a large ashtray -- even by obsessive fans.

It's surprising how much content we read as blog posts and even mainstream news articles are simply content produced by PR firms for their clients.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by stevesearer on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:20AM (#9197204)
This is very true. My moderately successful office design website is pitched for pre-written content from PR firms all the time. Before I understood that they just wanted their clients on my website I felt very flattered that I was getting some sort of "scoop".

EDIT: I also see these videos as trying to appeal to normal people and make them feel like watch enthusiasts. The video is well-made, but as you say, the components themselves aren't particularly interesting for actual watch enthusiasts.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by bane on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:52PM (#9201079)
I wish I could still edit my old post. Here's a great example of this in action

http://www.imore.com/truth-behind-apple-watch-hit-piece

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by Spearchucker on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:00AM (#9196509)
The Corvette/Zonda compare demonstrates the point well. It doesn't account for Apple's target market though. The person that wears an expensive watch on the wrist, rather than the arm. The person that drives a Bentley convertible, or paints their Lamborghini matt black. These people don't buy a gold Apple Watch because they think it's beautiful. They buy an Apple Watch because they think other people think it's beautiful. They have an inherent need to parade their wealth to others.

They're easy to spot, too. Expensive clothes, no sense of style. Usually loud, if not vulgar. Lack of empathy, coupled with an overdeveloped sense of entitlement. They won't buy a Murakami because it appeals to them aesthetically, they'll buy one because their rich friend bought one "for the kid's room". And enough disposable cash to buy an Apple Watch for no other reason than that they can. In Europe they're often called nouveau riche, or even Euro-trash.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by stephencanon on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:42AM (#9196635)
> The person that paints their Lamborghini matt[e] black.

This person buys the Grandmaster Chime, which is truly hideous, expensive, and has no sense of style. I would not wear it if you gave me one.

... or maybe, just maybe, taste is subjective, and old-money aristocrats and their lapdogs don't have a monopoly on it.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by Spearchucker on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:15AM (#9196930)
Taste is very subjective. It's about the manifestation of taste. You might like the feel of a silver plated, rhodium-coated Varius carbon Caran d'Arche. You might love the graceful swirls and curves it can produce. With brown ink from Montblanc.

Or you could be the guy that walks into meetings, waits until everyone is settled before opening a leather-bound, monogrammed notebook, pulls that same pen out, put elbows on table and slowly unscrews the cap, before setting the pen down on the notepad, without having written a word.

Extrinsic vs. intrinsic.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by leonroy on Saturday March 14, 2015 @10:41AM (#9202757)
Heheh, I love using my fountain pen at meetings with brown ink from Montblanc. Always raises an appreciative glance or two.

That said how the heck do you manage the dreaded question 'can I borrow your pen?' ;)

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by Spearchucker on Saturday March 14, 2015 @04:33PM (#9204067)
Usually have a ballpoint on me too. Gets awkward when I don't. There must be a socially-acceptable way out of that corner...
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by TheOtherHobbes on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:45AM (#9196640)
Unfortunately I think that's exactly the market Apple aren't aiming for - but will probably get.

Watch is a slow-motion PR disaster. It's doing a lot of damage to the Apple brand, because Apple seem to have stopped pretending to make useful, affordable, luxury, and are now trying to make unaffordable, useless, luxury - which is a completely different market, for completely customers, with completely different rules.

This would be fine if the product itself had clear Veblen-differentiation. But it doesn't. Watch Edition is just Sport Watch in a blingy case with a nicer strap.

That is so not how the luxury market works.

High-end luxury is defined by evidence that you can command some other human's skill and work. So, you can't have mass-produced or machine-made high-end luxury, by definition.

If it's not hand-made, or hand-marketed, or hand-concierged, or very strictly limited, of fundamentally different and exclusive in a way that proves that someone has had to work hard for you personally to make it, it doesn't tweak those luxury neurons - no matter how much gold it has, or how much it costs.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by tptacek on Friday March 13, 2015 @05:39PM (#9200265)
It's a weird perceptual twist that has Apple losing its dominance in affordable consumer electronics.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by ceejayoz on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:09AM (#9197516)
> Watch Edition is just Sport Watch in a blingy case with a nicer strap. That is so not how the luxury market works.

Have you been to an upscale mall? That perfectly describes Williams-Sonoma, Coach, etc.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by amyjess on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:15PM (#9197929)
I wouldn't call Williams-Sonoma and Coach the luxury market.

At upscale malls, those kind of stores are squarely in the mid-range session, not the part of the mall with the designer boutique shops.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by seanmcdirmid on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:02AM (#9196698)
They don't paint their Lamborghini matte black, its most definitely a sticker job for a few thousand dollars, or even less. The tech behind that is actually quite nice.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by mbel on Friday March 13, 2015 @06:51AM (#9196484)
> These apple craftsmanship videos are trying to appeal to the high end watch enthusiast but this is not going to work.

I think they were rather created to appeal to people, who would like to be considered high end watch enthusiast, but not necessarily are able to afford the kind of high end watch that you mention.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by Mikeb85 on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:57AM (#9196863)
Patek Phillippe's minute repeater watches are an extreme example, but you can find very nice, well made mechanical watches from every price point starting at around $1000, up to a million or more dollars....

Here's a video of a Nomos Glashuette watch being made: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UwpP_s8LV_Y

And their website: http://www.nomos-glashuette.com/

They've got an aesthetic that isn't unlike Apple's (minimalistic), and they're among the more affordable mechanical watch brands (while still creating high quality, in-house movements).

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dagw on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:51AM (#9197052)
If you want to be considered a high end watch enthusiast then there are plenty of cool and interesting watched for less than $10k. Something like a "low end" Jaeger-LeCoultre, Zenith or IWC is far more likely to catch a watch enthusiasts eye. Or dig around the vintage market and try to find something there.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dagw on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:32AM (#9196989)
Patek Philippe 5175R grandmaster owners need something cheap but decent to wear while out jogging or playing with their kids in the park, just like Pagani Zonda owners need something cheap but decent to take down to the food store to pick up some milk. Both the Apple watch and the Corvette could fill those roles nicely.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by evol262 on Friday March 13, 2015 @11:19AM (#9197569)
Watch people would much rather wear a cheaper mechanical than a gimmicky smartwatch.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dagw on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:58PM (#9198211)
Actually I'm starting to wonder if Apple isn't going after watch people at all. I wonder if perhaps they're instead trying to target rich members of the cell phone generation who've never really owned any watch and who've never had any aspirations towards ever owning an expensive mechanical watch. Basically trying to carve out a new niche of high end consumer electronics.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by tajen on Friday March 13, 2015 @01:30PM (#9198398)
> carve out a new niche of high end consumer electronics

Yes! That's the concept I was looking for! In a few years we'll look back at this segment like we look back at the iPhone today: We didn't know it could exist, yet at was a vast blue ocean. However I wonder whether Apple nails it properly and what are the key pillars: If you started a gold electronic movement, wouldn't you auction and number the first series? "This watch, kid, was the 1000th ever made by Apple. I own a very particular moment in History. Look, in that series they hadn't even designed the Digital Crown to its final form." Isn't the current Apple Watch missing a bit of storytelling? Is 5 or 10 videos about the factory enough?

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dagw on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:52PM (#9199122)
Nokia kind of tried something similar with Vertu. Offering basically the same $500 Nokia phone for $5000 - $15000, by just making the case out of more and more expensive material. Vertu seems to have been reasonably successful, but probably not a level Apple would be happy with.

The big difference is that while Nokia actively tried to hide the fact the Vertu was basically just a Nokia phone in a more expensive shell, Apple is making no secret of the fact.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by narrowrail on Friday March 13, 2015 @02:55PM (#9199150)
Didn't Vertu also come with concierge service?
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by dagw on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:16PM (#9199327)
Kind of. The first year was free, then it was $2000-$3000 a year.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by Htsthbjig on Friday March 13, 2015 @09:10AM (#9196912)
It is quite interesting how when someone does the job to create something, someone, that probably has not created anything meaningful in their live,because if they had they will at least respect those that try, has to say it is not going to work.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9IvnptQJ__U

I believe that Apple has probably better information that you have. The world is tremendously big. I have been with Chinese oligarchs with several hundreds of millions of dollars of wealth, the puppet oligarchs in Ukraine and Saudi Arabia supported by the US or Russia,Africa leaders,Brazil wealthy, the owners of fortune 500 companies. These people could spend 10.000 dollars with the blink of an eye. In day to day decisions they risk millions.

I don't like this, but not liking it does not make part of the reality banish.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by blub on Friday March 13, 2015 @10:02AM (#9197108)
He said watch enthusiasts, not rich people. By definition these people shouldn't be impressed by something coming with a 1 year warranty (extendable to two years). They are also interested in the mechanical wizardry happening on the inside, not just in how it looks. Apple watch is pretty much a computer, even if a pretty nifty one by our standards.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by itchyouch on Friday March 13, 2015 @03:40PM (#9199490)
It's amazing how irreverent we can be towards just "computers" due to their apparent ubiquity and widespread availability, yet not appreciate that a single fabrication of a silicon wafer is far more complex than the couple hundred components that are put together in a watch.

We can fathom the difficulty, craftsmanship and effort that goes into combining several hundred components together in a watch, yet scoff at hundreds of millions of transistors that are just as artfully designed and brought together to bring to the masses leverage to human ability that was unfathomable just a century ago.

Sure, a silicon wafer is built by machines, and does not have the "hand craftsmanship" of say a watch, yet, I would argue that far more collective effort went into designing circuits than did into designing the gear combinations that went into building a watch.

When it comes to buying high-end, high-end has been about exclusivity, multiplied by the effort put into building such a product. However, when one considers the effort necessary to complete a given task, exclusive or not, being impressive can be quantified by the effort placed.

Thus we are sometimes impressed when someone does something through the hard route, when an obviously easier route existed, (a la, "I'm not even mad, that's amazing"). The wealthy (and the commonors as well) like to purchase the exclusivity of effort (custom) within the bounds of their understanding as it either stirs their innate appreciations or scratches their ego. Either way, people can only appreciate the efforts of what they understand, while the efforts of what is not understood gets belittled. And the caliber of complexity occasionally peeks it heads out amongst the ultra-rich. The ultra-rich who appreciate watches and boats, versus the ultra-rich who appreciate rockets and education.

As children are easily impressed at young ages and become less so as they age, our ability to be impressed should grow with our growth. IMO, If the pinnacle of "craftsmanship" is in very small turning gears, it's a shame, because there is so much more beyond that barrier.

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by drinchev on Friday March 13, 2015 @07:15AM (#9196547)
Amazing video. What I noticed is that they also use 10:10 as a time to display when advertising the watch [1].

http://mentalfloss.com/article/22461/why-1010-default-settin...

Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by asadlionpk on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:32AM (#9196778)
That grandmaster video is truly great. I remember watching similar videos of Tag Heuer. Apple's making videos are nothing compared to these.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by jhallenworld on Friday March 13, 2015 @12:24PM (#9197987)
Watches are boring; instead they should make a Curta mechanical calculator with this level of quality.
Re:How Apple Makes the Watch by bla2 on Friday March 13, 2015 @08:51AM (#9196843)
That reversible watch face seems pretty gimicky. That looks more like something they did because it's hard to do, not like something that's useful or good looking.