News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by bjelkeman-again on Thursday March 12, 2015 @06:01AM (#9189861)
It is always intriguing that people in the West are so sheltered from the fact that this has been going on for over a decade. And they then are, not surprisingly, surprised that the people at the receiving end of this and those that are from the area are very upset about it.

What if some other nation had been bombing remote villages in your country whilst attempting to target "terrorists and extremists", but often killing civilians because of misstakes and poor intelligence?

Nice timeline for doing your research: http://www.theguardian.com/Iraq/page/0,12438,793802,00.html

Example of airstrikes killing civilians and accusations of poor intelligence preparations being the cause: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2004/jun/14/iraq.usa

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by karmacondon on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:04AM (#9190198)
The links you posted reference Iraq, which was not a very nice place over the last decade. In many cases, a strong personality would emerge as a local leader. He'll usually have access to several small arms and enough money to feed and pay several dozen militia fighters. To legitimize his power he'll coordinate attacks on US personnel, usually ambushes, and make deals with people who have connections to global "terrorist and extremist" organizations who can provide him with resources to pay for more weapons and manpower. This hypothetical leader isn't beholden to the law and makes up the rules for the people in the areas that he controls based on his interpretations of religious teachings and personal views on justice and proper conduct. The government has so many problems to deal with that they aren't in a position to oppose him or restore any kind of rule of law to the people that live in his sphere of influence. As his power increases, he becomes a more useful piece on a larger chess board, controlled by leadership in Mosul, Yemen or Saudi Arabia.

To the US, the solution is clear: Kill that guy. The force of his personality is what's holding his local power structure together, and if he's dead there's a good chance that the whole thing will collapse. This will take a piece off the board for a global opponent and give the national or regional government one less problem to deal with. Given that he lives in a remote area that he knows like the back of his hand, getting close to him would be difficult. But if they can pay someone to tell them where he is at a specific time, all it takes is one drone strike to solve a lot of problems for a lot of people.

It's not a perfect system. Sources will frequently give false locations in order to kill their own enemies or settle personal scores. Sometimes the intelligence is out of date by only a few hours, the target leaves a house and innocent people move in to it behind him. Or the weapons just plain miss.

The question is, do you have a better plan? Because the guys at the Pentagon would really like to hear it. Ceding large swaths of a country to random strong men doesn't seem like a sustainable solution. It's not good for the people in that country, it's not good for global security and it's not good for business. Civilian casualties are always regrettable and make for compelling headlines. But at some point, someone has to have an eye on the bigger picture. If there's a better course of action, then it should be taken immediately. Until then all the US government can do is to use the tools that it has available to deal with the current situation.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by pjc50 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @09:55AM (#9190769)
Kill that guy. The force of his personality is what's holding his local power structure together, and if he's dead there's a good chance that the whole thing will collapse

This is true. But what happens next? A collapsed power structure is not a nice place to live. Someone has to deal with crime, resources, arbitration, and taking out the rubbish (qv http://www.luton-dunstable.co.uk/Luton-ISIS-recruit-Abu-Aziz... ). So another person steps up to fill that role. Unsurprisingly, he has to deal with the power structure of the region that he finds around him, so he makes deals; and he has to deal with bandits, so he makes a militia. Until he makes his way to the top of the US kill list, perhaps by phoning the wrong person.

"Local warlord" is a position, not a person. The replacement for warlordism is an accountable rights-respecting impartial justice system. Nothing less will do. You can't deal with injustice by committing more injustice. You can't eradicate violence with more violence. This isn't a Clint Eastwood movie, you can't just ride in, shoot some designated bad guys, and ride out again with everything fixed.

Also, would the US rather have an anti-US warlord who deals fairly with his own people or a pro-US one who is corrupt? The treatment of Latin America shows quite clearly that they'd prefer the latter.

Unfortunately as soon as you say, "So let's apply justice to the middle east", you trip face-first over the Palestinian question.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by karmacondon on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:08AM (#9190858)
Iraq has a democratically elected government. Whether or not they are accountable, rights-respecting, impartial or even just is up for debate. But they can't govern without being able to impose the rule of law through a monopoly on force.

Warlords do serve a social purpose. But it's better for everyone if a stable government serves that purpose instead. The nature of being a warlord is such that they won't respond to reasoned arguments or give up the power they've risked their lives to build. The only way to get them to step aside to allow democratic governance is to kill them or convince them to surrender.

Killing a warlord has nothing to do with the concept of justice. The term "outlaw" originally applied to people who lived outside of the protection of the legal system, meaning that they could be robbed or killed by anyone. If a local leader wants the protection of justice, they should run for office or go through an official process to wield the sanctioned power of the state. Otherwise, they should be prepared to either get down or lay down when just democratic rule comes to their region.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by pjc50 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:29AM (#9190997)
(Another page on the subject: http://www.counterpunch.org/2015/03/11/why-obamas-hopes-of-d... ; I don't really see what Obama is doing in the title, the policy would continue without him)

You're arguing "force first; justice later". In particular, you're arguing that state justice, and your particular version of it, is the only valid and legitimate kind of justice. This leaves no room for what's called "natural" justice.

But there's no point in trying to convince me. It's the neighbours of the people being bombed that you need to convince, that American death from the air with no trial or public evidence is "justice" and "the sanctioned power of the state". After all, is it how you deliver justice in your own country?

So long as America continues to kill unaccountably and without due process, people (especially those close to the bomb) will regard America as just another warlord, just another outlaw.

get down or lay down when just democratic rule

Get your face in the dirt and submit, citizen! Welcome to democracy! (You may want to work on your messaging here)

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by happyscrappy on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:55AM (#9191145)
It is convenient to pretend that these missions are not being run from Europe, but they are and the battleground will be in Europe where it is much easier to attack.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by Udik on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:29AM (#9190297)
Except that the US are the main cause for those bad guys being there in the first pace, as they waged war (with justifications that later proved worthless) against the dictator that was able to keep the area under control.

So, what the US should do now in Iraq? I have no idea. What should they do in general and in the future? Stop messing with foreign countries, destabilizing governments and waging wars with the silly idea of making the world a safer and more peaceful place. It doesn't work.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by tessierashpool on Thursday March 12, 2015 @09:07AM (#9190481)
What the US should do now in Iraq is learn some restraint, diplomacy, and humility.

In other words, we should learn the lessons everybody but the military had already learned from Vietnam.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @09:36AM (#9190639)
It might be a surprise to you, but it is the military who learned the most from Vietnam. It is the American public and our politicians who seem to have learned the least. The military is simply doing its job when presented with a task, whether it was spawned out of noble intentions or kneejerk reactionism.

They know that they must be careful in pursuing anything that looks vaguely like a target, because the sentiment of the population is far more important than a small victory like that. Hence the multi-billion-dollar communications and failsafes chain described in this article. This is a key concept that seems to be going over people's heads in this thread. Yes, it failed in this case and in many others. But the very fact that it exists at all and is sophisticated as it is should be a clue as to the lessons learned. The military is achieving far more value with far less collateral damage. Contrast this with the Soviet's preferred method of waging war against the Afghani Mujahideen, which was to kill every living thing and totally and utterly raze every structure in the direction from which they were shot at from.

So again, can you conceive a better alternative for dealing with reality as it is now? Time travel is not possible, answers like "don't invade other countries" are pretty worthless. Nobody wants this war(well, nobody with a soul and a modicum of compassion), but it is what it is, and as far I know, it's the best solution to minimize civilian deaths.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by pjc50 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:39AM (#9191049)
The military is simply doing its job when presented with a task

That was presented as a defense of My Lai and was a not successful argument.

The military is achieving far more value

You're going to need to quantify this statement, because from this distance it doesn't look like much is being achieved at all. Yemen has fallen to the rebels and ISIS still hold much of northern Iraq.

answers like "don't invade other countries" are pretty worthless.

Absolutely not! It's a simple, clear, actionable, moral rule. It's also a core principle of international law. I'm not sure why this is so much of a problem.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:22AM (#9191314)
> That was presented as a defense of My Lai and was a not successful argument.

I'm not sure how that's relevant. The "job" here being of far larger scope along the lines of "prevent future terrorist attacks". If you're the military presented with that task, you will go down generally the same route that US has, though perhaps without the same level of consideration for innocents.

The real "solution"(which is only in retrospect) is to identify the factors leading to extremism in the first place(American foreign policy) and change them. But that wasn't done, so here we are. Are you to argue that we simply stop trying to fight them on their soil? Instead we hope they don't retaliate?

> Absolutely not! It's a simple, clear, actionable, moral rule. It's also a core principle of international law. I'm not sure why this is so much of a problem.

I totally agree, but it's not applicable to the current situation. I'm not sure why people think this is a "solution" rather than a "yeah, we should have done that instead".

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by pjc50 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:36PM (#9191892)
same level of consideration for innocents

I'm trying to avoid Godwin territory here, but widespread ignoring of the Geneva conventions is not an excuse. It's not just a consideration, it's international law.

https://www.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/7c4d08d9b287a4214125...

"Persons taking no active part in the hostilities ... [prohibited] violence to life and person, in particular murder of all kinds"

"the passing of sentences and the carrying out of executions without previous judgment pronounced by a regularly constituted court, affording all the judicial guarantees which are recognized as indispensable by civilized peoples"

It is convenient for the US to deem anyone in the same building as a combatant to be "involved in hostilities". That does not make it true, and indeed it's a serious erosion of the concept of "civilian".

simply stop trying to fight them on their soil? Instead we hope they don't retaliate?

Are people more or less likely to retaliate if you murder their relatives and countrymen? This seems to be a fundamental point of disagreement.

In the end, coalition forces have withdrawn from Iraq and Afghanistan. Drone strikes are ongoing in Yemen and Pakistan; I believe NATO airstrikes have been carried out against ISIS positions in Iraq but not Syria. Turkey are holding at the border with occasional sorties. Coalition forces should resist the idea of getting involved in Nigeria, Syria, etc. and withdraw from the internal conflicts in Pakistan and Yemen. Supply defensive assistance to places that request it (Kurdistan and the Yazidis), but no further.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by TeMPOraL on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:44AM (#9191080)
> Absolutely not! It's a simple, clear, actionable, moral rule. It's also a core principle of international law. I'm not sure why this is so much of a problem.

> It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!

This quote seems very fitting here. It is indeed a simple, clear, actionable, moral rule - just one that doesn't bring in profits.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by tessierashpool on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:43AM (#9191073)
So again, can you conceive a better alternative for dealing with reality as it is now?

Of course I can. Learn some humility, diplomacy, and restraint. The military has no business in Iraq and needs to leave. Iraqis have said so countless times.

You're assuming this is a military task. But I said "learn diplomacy." If your "reply" to a "learn diplomacy" comment assumes that this situation remains a military responsibility, then your reply is not a reply at all.

"Learn diplomacy" means "use diplomats." And it also means talk to some countries who know how to do so successfully, and follow their lead.

"Learn humility" means "stop assuming that this is America's problem to solve." It's not our business and all we're doing is fucking it up.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:49AM (#9191102)
> Of course I can. Learn some humility, diplomacy, and restraint.

Huh. The fact that there is a chain of command that this decision must pass sounds like the idea of restraint is not lost on these people. In fact it seems quite the opposite, that there is a directive for restraint. It's not up to the pilots and spotters, no matter how gung-ho they may be(many aren't at all, unlike what is portrayed in the article).

The billions the US is pumping into their communities in the form of assistance seems like some form of diplomacy to me, or at least due diligence for the massive social disturbance. I could be wrong. You'll have to explain to the people receiving said aid that it's either misguided or not enough, though.

> The military has no business in Iraq and needs to leave. Iraqis have said so countless times.

We're talking about Afghanistan, not Iraq. The US involvement in Iraq was totally illegal, but it's worth noting that many Iraqis definitely wanted us there after the invasion. They certainly want us there now.

> Learn diplomacy" means "use diplomats." And it also means talk to some countries who know how to do so successfully, and follow their lead.

This statement sounds buried within ideology rather than facts. The US has a massive diplomat corps and engages in some form of diplomacy every day with every country on the planet, save a few. Even moreso in Afghanistan and Iraq. You'll recall that diplomacy did not work shortly after 9/11 when Afghanistan was identified as a host country to Al Queda.

Again, the situation is as it is today. We cannot go back and alter the past. So what better way is there to proceed? The US spends billions on aid and reconstruction efforts in both countries, are they simply supposed to ignore threats?

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by FD3SA on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:26AM (#9191349)
You are hopelessly mired by incorrect facts and perceived motivations.

Many posts above have alluded to this fact, but I'll repeat it since it may help you in the long run.

Neither of the two American wars being waged in Afghanistan and Iraq are for traditional reasons. There was no threat to the US. This has everything to do with the Military Industrial Complex, and its iron grip on American foreign policy.

The MIC requires war because that's how they sell their products. I would have expected that on a site like HN, this would be obvious. President Eisenhower prophetically warned [1] against the MIC, as he clearly saw how a positive feedback loop would form between private military contractors and US foreign policy, inciting conflict after conflict in order to keep customer demand high for their products.

Although you have obviously been thoroughly steeped in the propaganda offered by these two organizations, who could never acknowledge the truth of their actions, to any rational observer there can be no other justification. The US as a whole has everything to lose, and nothing to gain, by slaughtering defenseless civilians in an impoverished developing country.

Big defense contractors and the politicians they bribe, however, have everything to gain. And they are winning. This is one of the many failures of democracy, one that requires extreme oversight and prosecution. Sadly, we are primates, and we will succumb to our natures sooner or later.

1. http://coursesa.matrix.msu.edu/~hst306/documents/indust.html

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:59AM (#9191569)
No, I am simply approaching this from a balanced point of view. The situation is far more nuanced than the "good guys" are really the "bad guys", and that it's all about the money. That's the plot of a movie, not real life. There are many people at all levels and on all sides who have altruistic intent, just as I'm sure there are those who really are perpetuating further conflict for the money.

I am in no way questioning the existence or influence of the MIC, but to say that across-the-board this is all about blood money is just as narrow minded as blindly defending the US as if what they're doing is morally right. You'll notice that nowhere in my posts do I go about doing such a thing, by the way. Far from it. I could understand you might have preconceived notions about my position though, it's hard to see the nuance in people's opinions when we reduce things to simply "for" or "against". I subscribe to a Sagan-esque view of mankind as I'm sure many do here. But, again, that has to be tempered by reality or we reach solutions only useful in retrospect like "don't invade in the first place".

Anyways, I was originally responding to the commentary that the military had "learned nothing from Vietnam" while "everyone else" did, which is patently false.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by saiya-jin on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:50AM (#9191109)
nobody wants this war? are you kidding sir? there is a lot to earn on every single war, these one being no exception. All companies manufacturing weapons, ammunition, subcontractors etc. Stop wars, they are out of job.

Is it utterly immoral? But yes of course. Is it clear to most people outside of US? Not much doubt there. Is this going to happen again? You bet it will. Why? Just because US can.

There was not so long ago perception that US is the world police, the good guys. Well, these days, you guys are working hard to convince all the rest that China might be more suitable for this task.

Is it really hard to see how much evil is US creating in our tiny world? Did it at least once to people like you occurred, that you really, REALLY cannot well justify waging war half across the world, for laughable reasons?

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:25AM (#9191341)
Did you stop reading immediately after the word "war" or something? I'm really shocked by the level of hivemindism on HN these days. I'm all for idealism but it really needs to be tempered with reality for any real progress to be made towards a better future with less war, more equality, etc.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by happyscrappy on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:09AM (#9191230)
> Is it clear to most people outside of US? Not much doubt there.

And yet all these operations are run from Europe. Where are the protests by Europeans?

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by hereonbusiness on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:53AM (#9191139)
The beginning of the 21st century shall always be remembered as the moment humanity became really sophisticated at killing poor people who live in mud houses from far far away.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by josefresco on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:18AM (#9191285)
...poor people with incredibly wealthy friends who fund their misdeeds. So yeah, relatively speaking they (the foot soldiers) may be poor but those controlling all sides are not.

And I'd say the 90's was the beginning of the "cruise missile" guided bomb era of warfare.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by hereonbusiness on Thursday March 12, 2015 @04:03PM (#9193438)
So you're saying we should just go and kill those incredibly wealthy friends of theirs instead of bothering with the foot soldiers?
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:30AM (#9191377)
Realistically, I think that will be a footnote to the explosion of computers and the Internet - and not because the "winner writes history"(which is rapidly becoming moot as time goes on) but because in the grand scheme of things it's nearly inconsequential compared to developments in doing the exact opposite of killing. Your notion also ignores the fact that the reason this exists in the first place is partially the desire to eliminate collateral damage, not perpetuate more of it.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by hereonbusiness on Thursday March 12, 2015 @03:50PM (#9193327)
> Realistically, I think that will be a footnote to the explosion of computers and the Internet.

> Your notion also ignores the fact that the reason this exists in the first place is partially the desire to eliminate collateral damage, not perpetuate more of it.

Well we'll see, human lives do seem like they're not worth much, especially those in the 3rd world, out of sight out of mind like another poster said. I mean you could probably kill a lot more of those people with the world standing idly by as long as you have some kind of justification, they can be invaded, bombed, displaced, held indefinitely and tortured with impunity, but now they are trying really hard to only kill as many of them as they really want to, are they not merciful ...

But what is the end goal here, what do they hope to accomplish, when will the killing end?

I think that the US government is in somewhat of a pickle, the war on terror is now being fought for more than a decade, has cost trillions of dollars and thousands of soldiers lives, and for what? There's no end in sight, no easy way out, heck we may be even worse off than before, we have an Al Qaeda offshoot building a state of their own as we speak. You can't just pull out completely and cut your losses because this might come back to haunt us all. The only thing they seem to be able to come up with right now is to further streamline killing to prolong the status quo as long as possible, and even that doesn't seem to be going well.

How the hell are we going to resolve this?

Or maybe I'm just crazy and this will all just blow over after a couple more years of targeted killings, all those islamists may just give up and go home to live peaceful lives, who knows.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by tessierashpool on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:56AM (#9191150)
knowaveragejoe: "the billions the US is pumping into these communities"

the actual article: "$5000 and a goat"

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:32AM (#9191387)
What a frustratingly simplistic retort.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by melling on Thursday March 12, 2015 @09:40AM (#9190662)
That's what we tend to do in fact. We support whatever dictator is in power because it's better for business.

With Iraq we believed that they were still hoarding WMD's that they had from the 1980's. As we now know, that turned out to not be the case, and they actually did destroy them. Before the war, it was reported by most media outlets that WMD's were still in Iraq. Then you had the UN weapons inspectors who kept being thrown out of Iraq. If the weapons inspectors had been allowed to remain and do their job, there wouldn't have been a second Iraq war.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by astazangasta on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:44AM (#9191083)
Your narrative is broken. What actually happened was a bunch of ideologues came to power, saw an opportunity to remake the middle east in aid of a "new american century", then lied about wmds to convince the public there were WMDs.

The weapons inspectors were thrown out of Iraq because they were spying for the CIA. They were desperately invited back by Iraq to try and stop the war, to no avail, because WMDs were never the issue: war was.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by melling on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:21AM (#9191302)
And the House and Senate just went along.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_Resolution

Of course, the major news agencies colluded to deceive the American public because they propagated the lie.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by Zigurd on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:05AM (#9191205)
"With Iraq we believed that they were still hoarding WMD's that they had from the 1980's."

Nope. It was a straight up war of aggression. Bush and Blair outright lied.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by melling on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:52AM (#9191520)
You'd think that if they outright lied, many people would step forward to verify your claim. If not because it's the right thing to do, then for the money; book deals, etc. Especially in politics where they love to stick it to each other. CNN can run with the Hillary email server for days, and everyone will weigh in. Imagine what they could do with anyone who could verify that "Bush lied!"
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by Zigurd on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:56PM (#9192082)
"C reported on his recent talks in Washington. There was a perceptible shift in attitude. Military action was now seen as inevitable. Bush wanted to remove Saddam, through military action, justified by the conjunction of terrorism and WMD. But the intelligence and facts were being fixed around the policy."

'C' would be Sir Richard Dearlove, head of MI6 at the time.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by 6d0debc071 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:20AM (#9191298)
> With Iraq we believed that they were still hoarding WMD's that they had from the 1980's

That doesn't explain the necessity of the attack. If he'd had WMDs he'd had them since the 1980s and it's not clear why it was important at that point to remove a capability that had not caused us trouble in twenty years.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by melling on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:37AM (#9191420)
Well, he was clearly fine with using WMD's.

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraqi_chemical_weapons_progra...

I suppose if someone has a weapon, isn't afraid to use it, and actually has used it and many occasions, you'd be a bit foolish to argue that point, "well, he hasn't used them in 20 years..."

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by 6d0debc071 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:49AM (#9191507)
> Well, he was clearly fine with using WMD's

And? He didn't use them against us. To do so would have been suicide. From a strategic perspective, why was it necessary to our interests in the world to remove him from power in Iraq - as it was not during the Gulf War?

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by throwaway9324 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:52AM (#9191132)
"Then you had the UN weapons inspectors who kept being thrown out of Iraq."

One of the reasons Iraq didn't co-operate with weapons inspectors was because they were infiltrated by US and UK intelligence. As far as I know they were never actually "thrown out". The other big reason is that the weapons inspections was the only bargaining chip they had left.

"If the weapons inspectors had been allowed to remain and do their job, there wouldn't have been a second Iraq war."

That is not what happened. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/weapons-inspectors-leave-iraq/

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by gldalmaso on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:23AM (#9190264)
> The question is, do you have a better plan? Because the guys at the Pentagon would really like to hear it.

Stop invading other nations for oil then complain the locals dislike you and kill your troops.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by jessaustin on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:32AM (#9191016)
I doubt the "guys at the Pentagon" would really like to hear that plan. They've got to keep profits up at Raytheon and Lockheed! b^)
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by littletimmy on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:41AM (#9190365)
Here's a better plan: stay out of other countries.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by josefresco on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:07AM (#9191221)
Isolationism is not a winning strategy for any nation. Soon enough, the world comes to your doorstep.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by jjoonathan on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:02PM (#9191589)
There's a pretty huge difference between "not invading other countries on a whim" and "isolationism."
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by zimbu668 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:17PM (#9191731)
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by joyeuse6701 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:51PM (#9192037)
Effective for your own people, but not your neighbors. For example. Let's take WWII for example. If your neighbors house is on fire would you not try to assist them, or would you shut your blinds because that fire is too bright in the middle of the night. That was the official attitude of Switzerland while Europe burned under Nazi occupation.

Isolationism alone is not an end all be all answer, we must use our best judgement to assess if assistance is necessary in international relations. It is true, that it is sometimes best to do nothing, (suppose your neighbor is an arsonist) but time and again people seem to forget that leaving nations to their cruelty because of sovereign rule has lead to catastrophe. For all of Europe (Nazi Germany) for all of Eurasia (Soviet Russia/Stalin), Manchuria (Japan), Rwanda, Mao's Cultural Revolution, North Korea, Burma... the list goes on, and by sheer numbers the consequence of inaction cost more than action.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by zimbu668 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @02:31PM (#9192762)
> Effective for your own people

That's why nation states exist.

> For example. Let's take WWII for example

And your evidence that Switzerland would have helped prevent any of that?

While we're throwing unbacked statements around, had the US tried some "isolationism" in WW1, WW2 never would have happened! The Germans wouldn't have been forced to sign the Treaty of Versailles and the conditions that led to the rise of the Nazis wouldn't have existed.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by knowaveragejoe on Thursday March 12, 2015 @09:38AM (#9190643)
Sounds great - let us know how the time travel thing is coming along. In the mean time, the US will have to deal with the present situation in some way or another. They already spend billions on aid, are they not supposed to deal with the other side of the coin - threats?
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by primroot on Thursday March 12, 2015 @01:44PM (#9192444)
I know it's just utterly besides the point to cite the opinion of the locals regarding a foreign country bombing them in the name of their own country's well-being. Hence I'll choose to cite a Nobel Peace Laureate. "A drone attack may kill two or three terrorists but it will not kill terrorism. If the drones continue terrorism will spread." [1] There you have the better plan.

[1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/samanthasharf/2014/10/21/nobel-p...

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by 6d0debc071 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @11:18AM (#9191289)
> Ceding large swaths of a country to random strong men doesn't seem like a sustainable solution.

Why? At least some of those local strong men are going to be amenable to your ideals. Support them with knock off equipment and let them conquer their enemies. If they become hostile after they've conquered their enemies, you can kill them then and iterate the process with someone else - though ideally you're using the spreading of their influence to spread your culture and dependencies on your support at the same time.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by filoeleven on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:04AM (#9190833)
>To the US, the solution is clear: Kill that guy.

And what happens after you kill that guy?

>In many cases, a strong personality would emerge as a local leader...

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by polynomial on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:20AM (#9190936)
> To the US, the solution is clear: Kill that guy. The force of his personality is what's holding his local power structure together

On the surface of it, they would seem to hold a somewhat naive historical view of power dynamics, and how cultural and socioeconomic and forces really work.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by u23KDd23 on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:08AM (#9190853)
Drones could of given the US a huge tactical advantage in a conflict between nations... their overuse has simply allowed the US's enemies to derive solutions against them removing any tactical advantage we originally had.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by ccvannorman on Thursday March 12, 2015 @12:47PM (#9191990)
>The question is, do you have a better plan? Because the guys at the Pentagon would really like to hear it.

Plan:

1: stop.

2: give civilians money directly instead of buying bombs.

3: Profit.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by marktangotango on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:20AM (#9190250)
This will be down voted, but it does accurately reflect the reality of the situation as perceived by those in power.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by jessaustin on Thursday March 12, 2015 @10:47AM (#9191093)
Those "in power" are motivated by far more prosaic notions than local leadership succession in certain Muslim nations. It's actually all about the money: for contractors, lobbyists, politicians, and those pundits who act as mouthpieces for all of those. Whether they "perceive" their own cupidity is a question the answer to which is of no consequence whatsoever.
Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by EliRivers on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:19AM (#9190244)
The question is, do you have a better plan?

The better plan will take three or perhaps four generations. The Western world simply does not have the ability to do it, for various reasons.

all it takes is one drone strike to solve a lot of problems for a lot of people.

And also create a bunch more angry, humilated people with no recourse other than terror tactics. Hey look, we're creating terrorists! We are so fucking stupid it hurts my head.

Re:Drones and the rise of the high tech assassins by EliRivers on Thursday March 12, 2015 @08:00AM (#9190189)
but often killing civilians

They can simply be reclassified as combatants. I understand any male "of military age" is an enemy combatant [1]. They must be bad guys or else why would we be murdering them.

I happily admit that if this was happening around me, and I was as powerless as these people are, I'd strike back through terror tactics.

[1]http://www.dailykos.com/story/2012/05/29/1095594/-WOW-to-avo...

Yes, of course this is sarcasm (except for the bit where I can understand why terror tactics are what people use; I really can understand that).