News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Death of the Login by codingdave on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:02AM (#9145094)
"The primary use cases for requiring a login are customization, multi-device sync and being able to reach out to the user."

No, the primary use case for a login is when you need to actually authenticate to be authorized to access secure data.

Re:The Death of the Login by Someone1234 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:14AM (#9145208)
That cannot be right, that explanation doesn't contain enough buzzwords and web-2.0 nonsense. Almost sounds very 1980s...

But really, does anyone else find that quote eye-rollingly tech-hipsterish?

Re:The Death of the Login by username223 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:19AM (#9145266)
I've been desensitized enough that it doesn't seem that bad. At least he wrote "reach out" rather than "initiate the onboarding funnel."
Re:The Death of the Login by warfangle on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:31AM (#9145366)
I prefer the term 'lead gavage'
Re:The Death of the Login by neeleshs on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:21PM (#9145762)
While I do not agree with the premise of the quote, I don't find "customization" and "multi-device synch" tech-hipsterish - its exactly what happens with many phone app/webapp combinations.
Re:The Death of the Login by wmeredith on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:41AM (#9145456)
They've since edited the article to say, "The primary use cases for requiring a login are providing security ,[sic] customization, multi-device sync and being able to reach out to the user."
Re:The Death of the Login by pkaye on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:01PM (#9145615)
I also see a login required on websites so they can monetize their customer base. For example pinterest or Houzz. Both websites should be able to operate without login.
Re:The Death of the Login by randomdata on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:21AM (#9145285)
Wouldn't that technically fall under customization? i.e. The customization of available data.
Re:The Death of the Login by barrkel on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:26AM (#9145323)
In a multi-user system, authorization isn't a personal custom configuration. One way or another, it's a social problem involving multiple actors, and those actors have identity that the system needs to distinguish.
Re:The Death of the Login by nly on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:23PM (#9145774)
Right. Everything they list can be achieved using session tokens and cookies.
Re:The Death of the Login by Heewg9 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:04AM (#9145116)
Exactly.
Re:The Death of the Login by daigoba66 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:55AM (#9145018)
Everything in the article until the topic of "Multi-device support" is really just talking about how locally installed software has worked long before the Internet and SaaS.

If I buy and install a piece of software like Photoshop (pre-Adobe subscription Photoshop), I don't have to login to use it. It "remembers" my settings and customizations simply by storing them in a file on my computer. There's nothing stopping an app on my phone or tablet from doing the same.

When talking about "Multi-device support" we're really talking about device synchronization. You could consider a web browser/web app as a "device" for the purposes of this discussion. Since most devices can't do peer-to-peer synchronization, we often rely on the software vendor to provide centralized services. This requires identification and security which is typically implemented with username/password credentials.

Re:The Death of the Login by mbesto on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:59AM (#9145060)
> Multi-device support is when users are using your app on multiple devices...For most apps, this is really an over-rated feature.

Uhh, it's not? What happens when a user upgrades their phone? Or loses it? Since the OP has basically admitted they'll fall back on logins at some point, I think they're going to have a much harder time explaining to users that they need to add an email address later in the process (or worse, try to retrieve someone's data when it's too late). On the other hand, it is interesting to think that maybe there is a decent strategy here, where you gracefully migrate an app user without a login (high conversion) into identifiable user (lower conversion).

Re:The Death of the Login by Eyas on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:46PM (#9145947)
Agreed. What the poster doesn't seem to realize in the analysis on multiple device users is that the use case is not only about using multiple devices concurrently, but transferring from one device to another.
Re:The Death of the Login by s_kilk on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:40AM (#9144866)
> The primary use cases for requiring a login are customization, multi-device sync and being able to reach out to the user.

And security, which is kind of a big deal if you have data the user would prefer be kept in their own secure space.

Re:The Death of the Login by connerbryan on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:46AM (#9144930)
Agreed. I think it's important to keep in mind the context of your application when considering implementing a system like OP mentions. Although, it would interesting to provide the user a choice between a password/"secure" login and a device/"anonymous" login (with the option to later switch).
Re:The Death of the Login by nothrabannosir on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:47AM (#9145510)
One caveat to the cookie-to-password switch: I am very good at saying, "Tomorrow." "Yeah, yeah, I'll do that tomorrow." Tomorrow comes and goes, I or a friend clear my history, whoops! Session lost.

At that point I am easily discouraged enough to stop using it.

E.g.: this happened to me with Khan Academy. I had watched so many videos on that cookie-only session, by the time it disappeared I'd long forgotten which ones I'd seen. Feeling a little discouraged, I thought, Okay, I'll get back to Khan tomorrow. Tomorrow never came.

If more people are like that, that could be a good reason not to allow cookie-only sessions for too long.

Or am I the only one?

Re:The Death of the Login by rp_yogat on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:56AM (#9145026)
yes, definitely. for an app like ours, where its not mission critical or the user is not communicating and contributing with/to the community, anonymous works 90% of the time.
Re:The Death of the Login by rp_yogat on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:57AM (#9145036)
yes, updating the article. sort of glossed over that!thank s_killk
Re:The Death of the Login by currysausage on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:25AM (#9145306)
So, you wrote an article about "The Death of the Login" before even looking up "Login" on Wikipedia?
Re:The Death of the Login by andrewmutz on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:46AM (#9145502)
"Been a few days since you have come back to the app? You get a nice welcome back notification."

Do any users actually like these sorts of notifications? It's clear to me why application authors use them, but do users really like this stuff?

It is notifications like this that make it so that whenever an app asks for permission notify these days, I say no.

Re:The Death of the Login by mavrc on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:59AM (#9145599)
I was thinking this as well. I wonder, there must be statistics that show that annoying your users gets results, or they wouldn't be used so frequently.
Re:The Death of the Login by et1337 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:50AM (#9144963)
I'm a big fan of the "email-only" login. Type your email address, hit login, switch to your email app, click the link, and you're logged in forever. If you don't have a password manager, it's probably what you do most of the time anyway via the forgotten password interface.
Re:The Death of the Login by crazygringo on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:32AM (#9145380)
Except for when you click the 'refresh' button 20 times in your e-mail app and the e-mail still hasn't arrived. And then you check your spam folder, maybe it went there? Nope. And then for some reason, ten minutes later the e-mail shows up.

I don't know whether it's sites that add outgoing e-mails to a backed-up queue, or if it's an anti-spam heuristic somewhere adding the delay, or delay on the servers of your own webmail service, or whatever combination of these, but unfortunately it's certainly not always as simple as "switch to your email app, click the link".

Re:The Death of the Login by zanny on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:03PM (#9145622)
I'm more a fan of how Persona does it, where you don't click a link at all, just enter your email and the Persona server checks a cookie secret you have to authenticate you.

Fundamentally the solution to all this is that you should have a signin at least once (to get your identifier keys securely) but then every website should authenticate against your keys, not against a username and password, and it should be transparent so as long as you are logged into an "account" you have personal keys for that identity that correspond to all the other services you use.

Really, its how the desktop works, and it is how the web should work, since they are converging and all.

Re:The Death of the Login by shillster on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:57AM (#9145035)
Passing tokens around via email isn't very secure. Its not like email is encrypted.
Re:The Death of the Login by username223 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:17AM (#9145238)
Right, but an expiring, single-use link that will send a second email saying "someone from X place just logged in, so contact us if this wasn't you" is still good enough in most cases. To see that, ask which sites will send you a password reset mail when you forget your password. My bank certainly won't -- I have to talk to a person -- but most others do, making their passwords useless.
Re:The Death of the Login by rp_yogat on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @08:43PM (#9148739)
This is not necessarily through email. I was referring to the scenario where the the user has both screens open and is being shown the token on one and typing it on the other. I agree about the insecurity of email.
Re:The Death of the Login by snowwrestler on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @01:42PM (#9146350)
Email is just about the least-secure authentication path I can think of. Knowing what we know now, it shouldn't even be used for "forgot password," really. SMS, a phone call, heck even a Facebook message would be more secure.
Re:The Death of the Login by rp_yogat on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:55AM (#9145016)
agree! HN has this and i love it
Re:The Death of the Login by mattmanser on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:33AM (#9145388)
No it doesn't. It has a standard username/password/forgotten email me setup.

What et1337 means is that you never even create a password, you literally login by putting just your email in, switching to your email, and clicking the link provided.

Given that most sites require you to do this when you first create an account to prove you own the email anyway, what was the point of having a password?

Re:The Death of the Login by gear54rus on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:44AM (#9145485)
For cases when you want to trust this computer for logging you into X, but not into your email (compromised it lets anyone use anything that is yours), obviously.
Re:The Death of the Login by brandonwamboldt on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:04AM (#9145117)
I'm not sure if it's just me, but I'm getting tired of the blog post formula:

> The Death of XYZ that is actually not really going anywhere for most people

The death of login, gamers, angular, react, PHP, etc, etc.

Re:The Death of the Login by Karunamon on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:18PM (#9145741)
It's the current fad.

A few years ago, it was "Why I quit my job, and why you should too".

Then it was "Why $social_network sucks, and why you should leave".

Every now and then, you see "Why X sucks, and why you should stop using it (alternatively: X considered harmful)".

Now it's "The death of X"

Re:The Death of the Login by l0c0b0x on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:58PM (#9146035)
Not just that, but "The death of X" (title)... then blablabla, then conclusion: "This really isn't the death of x".

:\

Re:The Death of the Login by pionar on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:50AM (#9145532)
This piece is the least thought-out piece I've seen either on Medium or HN in a while. Why all the upvotes?
Re:The Death of the Login by ezegolub on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:42AM (#9144897)
So, in this scenario, losing the device (phone, tablet, computer) will mean losing access to the account right? It is coupled to device ID or some cookie right?
Re:The Death of the Login by rp_yogat on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @10:54AM (#9145012)
I am going to add an addendum about this which I will do now. On the app we are developing, the app installation has a unique id. Every once in a while, all of the "history" is stored in a secure fashion back on the server. So a device migration can be done. I must admit, losing a device is trickier because you wouldnt which id to use to restore on a new device. Let me think about this a bit
Re:The Death of the Login by nkohari on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:35AM (#9145406)
Have you considered adding logins? :)

But seriously, this is literally the problem that logins were designed to solve. With a login, you are defining an external concept of "user" that is distinct from the device.

Available security factors are: something you are, something you possess, something you know. Right now, you're using something you possess (the device). The problem is, if I lose the device, I've lost my security credential, and no longer "own" my account.

To fix this, you could collect an email, and when installing your app, you could prompt the user if they want to use an existing account or create another. But then, you probably want to add some security in the form of a password... and then you've created a login.

Re:The Death of the Login by jasonlotito on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @12:17PM (#9145736)
> I must admit, losing a device is trickier because you wouldnt which id to use to restore on a new device.

This will happen. It will happen all the time. And when it does, people will be disappointed. People will stop using your app because they lost everything. I've seen this happen.

This system can work if the data is not important. But the nature of apps that store data or have a concept of "your data is stored" needs to account for cases where the original device is no longer accessible/usable.

> So a device migration can be done.

Relying on device migration is foolish. It will fail. And I will blame your app for losing my data.

Re:The Death of the Login by sg47 on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:41AM (#9145460)
Unrelated but the link to the app in your biography has a typo in it.
Re:The Death of the Login by skorecky on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:35AM (#9145412)
"Does this mean the login is dead? Of course not." Ugh.
Re:The Death of the Login by aytekin on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:22AM (#9145289)
We have this on JotForm. You can use JotForm fully without creating an account. I think it is important to give people freedom to roam your product freely before making a decision to create an account.
Re:The Death of the Login by pvsub on Thursday March 05, 2015 @12:41PM (#9152350)
All my devices and apps seem to cache logins, so for the login is dead (missing) until I need to change devices (and then there is the cloud-backup)
Re:The Death of the Login by EugeneOZ on Wednesday March 04, 2015 @11:36AM (#9145419)
the "login" has even more lives than cat.