News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jofer on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:35PM (#9063636)
First off, a caveat: I'm about to complain about a lot of people I respect and rather like. I'll probably take a lot of heat for it, but it needs to be said.

I feel like a lot of the closing of niche questions these days comes from the chat communities. (By "chat", I mean: http://chat.stackoverflow.com/)

There's a huge rash of "cv-pls" in the chat rooms. I don't have a problem with it in general, but the culture around it has become rather toxic. It effectively gives anyone there an automatic close hammer. Furthermore, it's not the current "dupehammer", but a close hammer for any reason, as you can pretty instantly get 5 votes to close.

Somehow, every question involving anything than popular web frameworks is apt to be closed as "too localized".

I can't count the number of times I've been in the middle of answering an admittedly niche, but well-phrased and on-topic question, when it's closed before I can answer. The source of the sudden rash of close votes? Almost always a "cv-pls" in relevant tag's chat room.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by codinghorror on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:16PM (#9064666)
We will look into this. Not very different than voting rings on HN or other places. You want vote diversity.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by rbobby on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:13PM (#9066155)
An auto-unclose process that examined web logs for direct hits from google might be nice too. And closed question that gets N hits from google probably deserves to be reopened with a special "google wants an answer" tag.

I usually (always) search google for my problem de jour. And frequently (enough so I remember) the first stackoverflow result is my exact question... but closed. Probably happens once or twice a month, and usually on something "thorny" (i.e. no clear cut answer... so "primarily opinion based" answers are fine... I can compare the top voted answers and decide for myself).

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by shagie on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @07:41AM (#9068166)
Sometimes I find a two year old post on HN that I want to comment on, but it's "closed" - the reply button is gone. HN should implement that when N hits from Google occur, it bumps it back to the front page and makes it able to be discussed again.

More seriously though, Stack Exchanges platform isn't designed to handle opinion polls and endless discussions. You might want to consider asking the question on a site geared to opinions and discussions such as quora or reddit.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by m_mueller on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:40AM (#9067302)
Also, are answers to closed questions stored? If not, and there is a new often used unclose workflow, it would be nice to let users still store their answer, to become visible when it becomes unclosed. This would help with the timing issue and would also give mods a way to see 'oh wait, looking at this answer it is actually too interesting to deserve these close votes'.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by alecco on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:04PM (#9065407)
Once I saw a clique of mathematica.SE guys doing vote ring on reddit/r/programming and other places to promote their site. Some of them looked like working for Wolfram itself, based on simple online searches for other forums. It's possible they were just Wolfram fanatics, maybe.

They crafted a particular question/answer and submitted and vote brigaded it everywhere. They were quite obvious and denied everything when confronted. After pointing out the obvious ring (same people pushing the same link with similar comments on all sites) they ganged up on me and sent me horrible private messages.

This pissed me off and I overreacted, exactly what they wanted... After cooling down, I went to their chat rooms to apologize for my angry replies language and removed comments on reddit. But they never, ever accepted they did any wrongdoing and pat themselves in the back. Oh, and never apologized for their harassment that triggered me in the first place.

This is why SO, reddit, HN are slowly getting long time users disenchanted. If you are not part of some virtual gang you are just meat, like a ghetto.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:34PM (#9065596)
> This is why SO, reddit, HN are slowly getting long time users disenchanted

Can't speak for reddit but I think HN is quite much better than SO. Specifically it seems:

* somehow grasping the house rules seems to be easier for people here than on SO. This might be because HN attracts another audience though, I don't know for sure.

* maybe because redditism and stupidity is mostly downvoted swiftly?

* spam and politics is dealt with before it hits the front page

* but contrary to SO moderators the ones on HN don't seem to get a kick out of finding something, anything that can be banned with the correct reading of the guidelines

I sometimes see what I consider to be abuse of downvotes but 1.) it doesn't seem to be rings and 2.) downvote abuse is very often corrected by the rest of the members.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by alecco on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:48PM (#9065680)
According to the mods, it's not them but users clicking the report button. If so, it's abused and any story that is negative for any YC/HN related company, against bad social norms in tech hubs, denouncing anti-privacy issues at Google/Faceboo, talking against celebrities like Bill Gates, or anything about NSA tends to go quickly below the fold and mostly ignored. The ranking system is gamed.

I used to come here several times a day, submit stories, try to add interesting comments to discussion (even playing devil's advocate). Now I mostly just skim the front page on slow days and get sad on how concentrated the opinions get.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by tptacek on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:38PM (#9066705)
There is a huge availability bias at work here. You don't notice the stories that you don't like getting flagged off the site, but you naturally do notice when it happens to stories you like.

For at least some of these topics, Occam's Razor suggests it's the bias that's stinging you, not gamesmanship. What plausible gaming could be at work on behalf of Bill Gates?

For others, I have a really hard time believing that the gamesmanship has the directionality you think it does. NSA stories, for instance, have enormous support on HN. It is draining to express any skepticism on those stories at all. They also seem to be continually bolted to the top of the front page.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by alecco on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:00PM (#9066765)
Availability bias? A major story about a chain of suicides of entrepreneurs on a Las Vegas tech hub was moved below the fold in spite of deserving the top position. And it quickly went to page 2 after that.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8404207

There were many HN stories promoting that place for a good while. But when things go sour HN looks the other way.

Dropbox problem story first moved below the fold, then deleted.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7568267

Those are just 2 examples. I'm not all day on the site, so I very likely miss most of these cases. This is just a tip of an iceberg.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by dredmorbius on Thursday February 19, 2015 @10:14PM (#9078698)
Though not a frequent occurrence, I agree largely with tptacek here. My own most successful submissions have been almost exclusively about concerns with Google and privacy. At one point, the top three HN stories were all indirectly about my own G+ issues: https://i.imgur.com/YgEjUuI.jpg

Google and Facebook get a lot of flack here (and some support). Gates has his defenders and detractors (I heavily criticise his business practices, I'm modestly approving of his philanthropy), and there are numerous NSA stories.

What you likely don't see is how many stories total simply fall off the submissions page. I check it every so often -- perhaps several times a week, perhaps only every few weeks. But there's a lot of inflow and much of it sinks. That's typical of any curated site. An editor's job is to say "no". Hopefully their accuracy in doing this is better than random.

As sites grow in popularity, if the front page keeps the same capacity, any given submission's odds will fall. reddit's answer was subreddits -- there are now well over a half million: http://redditmetrics.com/history

HN's going to have to resolve this conflict somehow eventually.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:09PM (#9065810)
> against bad social norms in tech hubs, denouncing anti-privacy issues at Google/Faceboo, talking against celebrities like Bill Gates, or anything about NSA tends to go quickly below the fold and mostly ignored. The ranking system is gamed.

Interesting. I usually find the mix that hits the front page about perfect.

A few times I have seen what I consider interesting topics being flagged of after an initial boost but I can live with that, I guess unlike me quite a few people are fed up after the nth discussion about open floor plans and I can live with that.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by alecco on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:02PM (#9066774)
I'm not talking about repetitive insignificant content. I'm talking about original and relevant content that is censored or allowed to be censored by small groups of users with financial/personal stakes.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by spinlock on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @08:30PM (#9066479)
> somehow grasping the house rules seems to be easier for people here than on SO.

When the house rules include not saying "Thank you" your going to see a race to the bottom in terms of human kindness.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by smackfu on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:38PM (#9065225)
Chat rooms are pretty toxic on a discussion site where the majority of users are not on the chat room.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by aaronchall on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:01PM (#9064941)
I'm close to being able to close Python duplicates in a single vote when I get my Python gold badge (9/10 of the way there.) http://meta.stackoverflow.com/a/254590/541136 - Also, considering the huge close vote queue, I can see why SO would want to close-close-close (or at least vote-vote-vote). What you really need are more voters voting. Not sure how you get there, though.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by eitland on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:41PM (#9065248)
Careful, this maybe isn't the correct place for telling everybody how easily you can crush them : )

> What you really need are more voters voting. Not sure how you get there, though.

I guess a whole lot of the people who could have helped you left long ago because of your fellow moderators. A reasonable first step would be by adjusting the attitude.

Maybe part of the problem is we just don't see all those "primarily opinion based" and "ugly discussions" questions that seems to be oh such a serious problem.

We definitely see a whole lot of the most useful questions closed, often for technicalities. It doesn't exactly encourage participation, does it?

HN somehow seems to be better at dealing with the problems without scaring good community members away. Of course HN has issues as well but so far the moderation team is doing a very good job of keeping politics and promotion away while leaving to the broader community to vote if something is interesting or not.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by aaronchall on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:42PM (#9065647)
Yes it's definitely difficult to get a foot-hold on the site, now isn't it. Maybe they need a real sort of wiki, or some sort of discussion community built around them. Seems like they started doing that, then killed it.

The problem with discussion boards is that it is absolutely painful to dig through a post until you stumble on a solution, and even then, you're in no way sure it's a good solution.

They need to harness that opinion/discussion/off-topic-subject energy in a way that doesn't work against their strategy. I think they are losing a lot of opportunity along the way.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by acjohnson55 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:35AM (#9067166)
They need to harness that opinion/discussion/off-topic-subject energy in a way that doesn't work against their strategy. I think they are losing a lot of opportunity along the way.

I totally agree. This manifests itself in the worst way at http://programmers.stackexchange.com/. Or at least it did when I bothered with that site at all.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:36PM (#9065954)
> What you really need are more voters voting. Not sure how you get there, though.

Or maybe, as I have already answered ircmaxell, Stack Overflow could raise the bar for asking questions ever so slightly from being the one thing you can do without rep?

If torrents of new users asking stupid questions are the biggest problem on the site this seems like a first obvious step.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by speeder on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:06PM (#9066118)
I bet that most new users became new users to ask questions, including users that are not high rep veterans.

I think that if you do what you propose, the site will just freeze in terms of user base.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by mlitchard on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:56PM (#9066353)
Would it be reasonable to have an invitation from a person with x reputation bump someone up to the required rep to ask questions? One could spend time in meta, and the chat room where people could get to know them. For the well-intended but naive, this would encourage getting to know the site and expectations of the culture. For the people who are just a bad fit, they could be filtered with minimal effort. Would there be any undesirable consequences from this approach?
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by Larrikin on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @08:29PM (#9066475)
Who do you imagine would be the user that would bother going through this interview process? If you've used the site before you already know how strict the moderation is on questions keeping people from asking questions already, do you really want to add a process where the user has to kiss up to the moderators for a couple weeks before asking their question as well?

It just would not be worth any new users time, especially given that when a user wants a question answered, it tends be slightly time sensitive.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by aaronchall on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:48PM (#9066731)
I've given this some consideration, but they have put the barrier to entry to the chat feature above a minimal reputation ranking.

One can easily overcome that with ten skillful edits, 2 upvotes (or 1 upvote and an accept) on an answer, or 4 upvotes on a question (20 rep is required for chat).

It's fairly easy for an individual to get into the chat, if they want.

That barrier does keep spammers from flooding the chat, though. And if you consider it an interview process, that's what the earning of reputation points accomplishes, and I'd argue it does so rather elegantly.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by z3t4 on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:39AM (#9067560)
You can make it so that if a closed question gets an answer, the question will only be visible for the one making the question and the one answering the question.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by angersock on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:25PM (#9064722)
Sure, but my job isn't affected by voting rings on HN, nor does YCombinator justify a totalitarian moderation policy by claiming to be the best google-able SEO-optimized source for whatever it is I'm questioning.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by apetresc on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:38PM (#9064794)
He's agreeing with you. He said they're going to look into [preventing] it.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jrochkind1 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @08:08PM (#9066404)
How is your job affected by voting rings on SO? I'm not challenging you, just asking for more clarification because I don't follow and am curious!
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jghn on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @08:49PM (#9066546)
An argument could be made that many people are hitting SO multiple times a day in the course of doing their jobs. If the questions and answers are biased by voting rings the results might not be optimal
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by angersock on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @10:16PM (#9066797)
So, GP suggested that the behavior of people in the chats was to basically rally to close questions, and likened it to voting rings on HN (which are, I believe, algorithmically regulated or at least are supposed to be).

My issue is that SO is a dominating first-hit for lots of technical questions, and that by setting themselves into that position they kind of owe it to the community to make sure they don't have jerks (via voting rings or any such analogue) screwing up the quality of their results.

For example, I've searched for "what is the best x for y?" or "what are the tradeoffs for x vs y", and had even (a long time ago) contributed answers to similar questions in their game development exchange--however, they (or their users) have decided that there is no value whatsoever in fielding questions of that variety.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by monksy on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:42PM (#9064117)
I was going to ask the following question [on 2 different situations] in the last 2 weeks:

Are there any [lang] libraries that are backings for the [service] API?

I stopped myself before going to SO because I knew that topic would get closed within seconds and I'd comments berating me for asking the wrong question.

For the most part the only use I've gotten from SO has been from basic questions when I'm starting out with a language/tool/library. I haven't found it very useful for complex problems.

Oh well. I've written about my rants on SO before. [I won't link here but it is in my submission history]

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by gnarbarian on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:46PM (#9064510)
Rather than outright closing a question it would be more productive if moderators could move the question to the forum it belongs. This type of question is quite common and if the powers that be have decreed that it doesn't belong in the general stack overflow area then a place for these questions should be created.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by i3arnon on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:29PM (#9065156)
What forum is that? SO doesn't have forums AFAIK, only questions and answers.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by worldsayshi on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:53PM (#9066038)
I would assume that previous poster was referring to stackexchange forum other than stackoverflow.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by gnarbarian on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:05AM (#9067068)
I was referring to the different stack exchange sites as forums.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by Arnt on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:51PM (#9064536)
Why would you ask that instead of browsing through the most recent 50 questions on http://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/lang+service ?
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by dhimes on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:33PM (#9065186)
I don't know much about how SO works but your query got truncated to:

  http://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/lang
It didn't seem particularly useful for such a question. I could see why the poster might be tempted to ask.

Perhaps there is a particular way that SO should be searched? The recursive irony is both amusing and annoying: doing a google search, coming to an SO answer where a commenter rants "why don't you spend a few seconds with Google."

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by Arnt on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @04:04AM (#9067619)
It was truncated because monksy and I used placeholders. If you use real values for lang and service you get good results, here's an example: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/tagged/java+oauth

Do you notice that all the questions in the result are tagged both java and oauth?

monksy didn't say which particular languages and services he's interested in (the male pronoun seems safe in his case) but I venture to guess that if suitable libraries do exist, then there'll be SO questions about them already and they're easy to find.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by Danack on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:05PM (#9065792)
"Are there any [lang] libraries that are backings for the [service] API?"

This is explicitly listed as off-topic:

Questions asking us to recommend or find a book, tool, "software library, tutorial or other off-site resource are off-topic for Stack Overflow as they tend to attract opinionated answers and spam. Instead, describe the problem and what has been done so far to solve it."

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by sirclueless on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:01PM (#9066583)
And this is precisely why I left SO. Without fail, the most interesting and useful questions for me on the site were more or less surveys of the population -- "What's a good library for reading XML in C#?", "XYZ looks like it was abandoned, is there a good replacement?", "Why is Python 3's virtualenv different" and that kind of thing.

Maybe that's just me, because if there ever is a question with one correct technical answer, it's easy to figure out on your own. The things I want to interact with a human to figure out are universally to do with historical reasons for things, ergonomic choices, and opinions on quality. I want a smart person with strong opinions, not a politically correct karma grinder who can type quickly.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by spinlock on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @08:33PM (#9066486)
I disagree. The question does not ask to find a library but rather it asks about the internal workings of a service.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jobu on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:55PM (#9063800)
Wasn't there a similar debate over Quality vs Quantity with the Wikipedia community a few years back? It's been a while, but I remember seeing complaints about thousands of articles getting culled for being trivial (comic books, movies, anime, moderately famous people or places).

It's hard to find many articles about it anymore, but I did find this from 2007: http://grouplens.org/wikipedia-quality-over-quantity/

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by mkremins on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:45PM (#9064500)
You might get more results searching for "deletionism vs inclusionism", which seems to be the most widely used name for the debate: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deletionism_and_inclusionism_in...
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by angersock on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:24PM (#9064715)
What's the current general stance on that these days I wonder? What's the prevailing wind?
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by VLM on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:56PM (#9064910)
The deletionists won and quite a few people refuse to participate anymore. Which leads to declining quality of article and moderation...
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by chris_mahan on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:32PM (#9065930)
I was one of those who left. I let my adminship elapse after 10 years.

I also don't contribute much to SO, or to any SE properties, despite being on the early public beta. (remember the signup as a google spreadhseet). I'm ID 479 on SO.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by merrua on Saturday February 21, 2015 @09:14AM (#9085550)
Yep. And the deletionists where more often the "majority" culture and male, which resulted in a feedback loop for the nonminority and female. New minority turn up, have a bad experience and leaves. I think it was studied let me see if I can find the paper. I know the results were replicated with comment bots.

Update, not the ones I was thinking of but a good read. HBS Cases: How Wikipedia Works (or Doesn't) http://hbswk.hbs.edu/pdf/item/5605.pdf

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by indymike on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:29PM (#9065157)
That discussion has been deleted.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by quanticle on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:13PM (#9065057)
Well, it was more than a few years ago at this point, and the long and short of it is that the deletionists won.

Gwern has a fairly thorough elegy for the (now dead) inclusionist beliefs: http://www.gwern.net/In%20Defense%20Of%20Inclusionism.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:55PM (#9065342)
The funny thing is that the fanboys fight back against this tactic by putting in hundreds of citations to "legitmize" articles about video games. Browse through some of them and you'll often see more citations than most of the math and science articles. Meanwhile, worthwhile articles that don't have rabid fans get deleted due to lack of "noteworthiness" (by someone's arbitrary standard of the day) or citations.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:41PM (#9065638)
If that is what it takes to get the deletionists away then feel free to add any valid reference I say.

I have given up though.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by InclinedPlane on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:46PM (#9064149)
The problem is that the people who originally headed the community and drove the site have checked out. That means that the very serious institutional and design problems related around the community moderation features of SO are not going to get fixed, they're just going to be gamed by the people with the most effort and free time. There are very few checks and balances on abuse of power at SO, even though that's where you need them the most. The assumption is that users with high enough rep will simply be more polite, logical, and kind, without any sort of agenda to propel. That, of course, was a naive assumption which is slowly blowing up in their faces, if they notice.

Meanwhile, nobody at the top cares because Jeff has moved on and everyone else just cares about site traffic and ad revenue (or at least that's my impression).

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by codinghorror on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:15PM (#9064660)
This isn't true. Shog, Jay, and many others were hired from the community precisely because they were avid long term users who had demonstrated deep insight into the culture and organization of Stack. I would easily rate them as equal to myself if not, frankly, better at helping the Stack community govern itself.

The reality is that good Q&A takes a fair bit of discipline to get right, and that means rules and standards. This rubs some people the wrong way, but it is the ONLY way to achieve reliable, sustainable, long term quality.

If you have specific examples of where things went wrong in a question, take it to meta and discuss it so that the community can adapt and change. That is how community works, and Stack is a democracy in that sense -- anyone can provide evidence and push for change.

(warning, though, scroll down in the comments here to see an example that turned out to be an anti-example when examined closely. A lot of times people just complain when they don't like rules, and the rules don't favor their personal needs versus the needs of the community or the greater Internet)

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by phaker on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @02:14PM (#9070357)
I'm afraid that many of the people you'll find in meta are the "soup nazis" the article complains about.

Any community is a sieve. It takes effort to join and the more you get involved the more time and effort it consumes and at every step someone gives up and drops out. The meta subsite is not easy to stumble into, very few people will have any questions to ask there and very few will have a good answer to contribute so it takes a lot of effort to get there. That means that the crowd that hangs out in meta will be very different from the bulk of SO/SE.

Several meta discussions were linked by ircmaxell above and another was posted in the r/programming discussion - http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/286299/closing-quest... - so let's take a look: those of questions that are expressing disagreement with how things are run (that cv-pls is a bad idea and that often questions are closed when they shouldn't) are currently at -20, -14, -24 and -13 points. But let's ignore the votes and look at the answers: the absolutely overwhelming consensus is that everything is right an nothing should be done. I'm not saying that "they" are wrong and "we" are wrong, just take note that there's zero overlap in opinions expressed here and there.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by InclinedPlane on Friday February 20, 2015 @09:35PM (#9084436)
It's unrealistic to say that the community folks are a perfect replacement for you and Joel being engaged because they too are engaged. That may be so, they may be more engaged than you ever were, but that's only half the equation. They don't have the authority and power that you did. It's not their baby, they're just baby sitters. They can't make sweeping changes because they think it's a good idea. They can't easily change the featureset of the system to support something they want. They have to go through a long process of getting buy off from folks for features, and then waiting until they're implemented.

When was the last time a major feature change happened with the software? It's unrealistic to imagine that there hasn't been a need for change and that the tools that were necessary for managing the community, say, 4 years ago are precisely identical to the ones that are needed today. That implies the community hasn't changed or that the tools were somehow perfect. Both are very unlikely.

Discipline is completely beside the point here. Of course good Q&A sites need discipline, and that loops back to authority figures exercising their powers (mods, admins, etc.) And sure there are people who will complain that SO is a harsh place and they just want to have fun. But that fails to address the many very well founded criticisms of the mod community on SO that numerous people have made, especially concerning abuse of power and twisting the site toward a different vision than it launched with. Imagine a sheriff making a statement that police brutality is justified because criminals exist.

Spammers exist, and low quality questions are a menace, but that doesn't stop the problems with stack overflow from being real.

Moreover, it's all too easy to fall into the complacency trap of saying that SO still has significant value to a lot of people, is still hugely popular, etc. That doesn't indicate that SO is fine, it merely shows that it might not be too late to fix the serious systemic and endemic problems it has. If you were to look at some magical graph of the "successfulness" or "popularity" of stack overflow over time, the point where things "went wrong" would not be at the peak. It wouldn't even be at the inflection point where things went from accelerating upwards to accelerating downwards. It would be before that, when the conditions that caused the inflection point to occur were in effect.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by PinnBrain on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:21PM (#9063984)
I really thought you were talking about a curriculum vitae there, but I suppose it's "close vote".
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by tvon on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:42PM (#9065254)
Yeah, FWIW I had to google the terms and found this:

https://gist.github.com/cspray/1689430

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by afandian on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:50PM (#9063758)
That's really depressing. Makes me question my participation in the site a little bit (never joined the chat or wanted to).

Do you have any actual examples?

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by 3JPLW on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @12:59PM (#9063834)
It's the first agenda item on the Python SO team's winter meeting: http://sopython.com/transcript/3/winter-2015-general-meeting...

They were just discussing it on chat today: http://chat.stackoverflow.com/transcript/6/15-16

I've never gotten involved in Chat before, either, but just searching the most active chatroom for `cv-` brought that up immediately.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jobu on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:00PM (#9064230)
"Better to have a bad question closed quickly than have it accumulate bad answers and rude comments and downvotes."

Unless it's offensive in some way, this seems like a terribly short-sighted way of handling bad questions. Ask questions back or offer suggestions for improving the question. Closing or deleting it doesn't teach the person anything, and it doesn't help the community.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by tjradcliffe on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @02:32PM (#9064437)
Furthermore, it assumes excellent judgement on the part of the closers, who by definition don't have the full context. They are confident in imagining that a particular question will accumulate bad answers etc, but do they have any data to demonstrate that their imagination is any good? It may be, but then again, it may not be. It's not like no one has ever had bad judgement before.

So it might be useful to bias the site toward leaving questions open, and let people make weighted votes for closing. Initially, the weight of a vote would be zero. This would allow the quality of an individual's judgement to be established, and their vote given more weight as it proved to be more predictive of whether or not an issue was eventually closed.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by afandian on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @10:12AM (#9068880)
Totally. I do come across duplicates and bad questions which necessarily must be closed, but I always do my best to help solve the problem that the human on the other end of the question is experiencing via the comments. There are rules, mostly good, mostly in need of enforcement to keep quality up, and I think they work in the individual human context.

There's a balance of rights / responsibilities, and if you have the right to closevote questions and earn magical rep points, you have the responsibility to explain why and try to help.

Herd-mentality and behaviour (demonstrated as closevote requests) seem like the opposite of this.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by spinlock on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @04:22PM (#9065113)
This is a fantasic point. My highest rated most viewed question was one that I thought was stupid when I asked it. 5 years later it has tons of votes answers and backlinks.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by r00fus on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:20PM (#9065512)
What would solve the problem is if these "bad questions" were simply invisible to crawling.

Rude comments and inappropriate downvotes sounds like a community issue - why are those not punished or otherwise dis-incentivized?

Maybe they need a metamod function.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jofer on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:02PM (#9063860)
Huh, I didn't see that discussion before I wrote the comment, but I was specifically referring to sopython.

They mean well, but it does feel a bit like a mob at times.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ffisegydd on Friday February 20, 2015 @11:14AM (#9081012)
I'm sorry you feel that way Joe.

The Room Owners have felt for a while now that it can sometimes get out of hand, that's why we had this discussion in our Room Meeting. As davidism has mentioned, we've put some extra guidelines down now. The main one being that unless it's necessary (something like spam, offensive, dupe, etc, where the OP isn't going to be able to improve the post) we're adding a 10 minute "grace period" before requesting a cv-pls. This gives OPs the chance to edit their question, to respond to comments, etc.

I disagree with a few of your points, but I'm not really interested in getting drawn into a debate here. If you want to discuss it further then drop by chat.

I know you've come into the room in the past to ask/speak about some particular cv-pls. If, in the future, you have anything to bring up, come and speak to us.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by davidism on Friday February 20, 2015 @10:33AM (#9080803)
We recognize that it's gotten a bit out of control lately, hence the topic during the meeting. I think we ended up with some good guidelines for managing it.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by apetresc on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:36PM (#9064781)
Is that really as widespread as you say? I looked at the last few hours of the six most popular chat rooms and control-f'ed for "cv-pls" on all of them, and found a grand total of ONE hit: http://stackoverflow.com/questions/28568303/python-3-object-...

The question was closed because the asker himself answered it apologizing for posting it, the problem being something completely unrelated to the code he had pasted. Everybody agreed.

I don't think it happens that frequently.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jofer on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:44PM (#9064826)
At least looking through sopython, with the exception of today, it's an average of 1 every ~20 minutes during "peak" hours. There are deliberately fewer today, due to the room's discussion of them this morning, but have a look at: http://chat.stackoverflow.com/search?q=[cv-pls]&Room=6&sort=... as an example (particular days before today).

The majority of those are questions that should be closed.

It's just that a lot of wheat gets thrown out along with the chaff.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by teh_klev on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:04PM (#9063875)
The PHP chat room is/was quite bad in that respect and there's a small handful of particularly caustic individuals who go out of their way to spread unpleasantness for less well informed users.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by mschuster91 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @01:50PM (#9064175)
You mean the freenode channel ##php? Oh, I know what you mean.

The problem is that very many people are not able to google and then ask in IRC. On the other side (the regulars), all they see every day is a torrent of "stupid noobs".

And I totally understand everyone who either retires from answering questions or turning into a sarcastic a..hole towards noobs.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ircmaxell on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:09PM (#9065811)
That's absolutely a valid experience.

There are plenty of others who've had positive experiences as well.

And those "caustic individuals" have a LOT to share if you're willing to engage in an open and healthy way.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by teh_klev on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:55PM (#9066052)
Sure, but they don't have to be caustic and quite so unpleasant in the chat room.

I am outing, specifically, Terenko. In all my years as a forum contributor/mod I don't think I've encountered such a poisonous dick as that person.

I know you do a lot of good work for the PHP community, along with Gordon and many others, but, my friend terenko is truly a knob end and sadly encourages others who are up and coming PHP debutants to behave the same.

It really made me weep as a diamond mod why you guys tolerated his snide comments and activities.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ircmaxell on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:59PM (#9066080)
Why did we tolerate it? Because we weren't given the tools to do anything about it. We couldn't kick or ban people. We couldn't moderate our own room. All we (as owners) could do was move messages or flag. We got yelled at every time we flagged something, so we learned to live with it. The only other option we had was to leave (which many users did, even leaders).

Today, we have the ability to kick-ban. Awesome. But he's also calmed down a lot. And is seen as a resource.

It's gotten a lot better over the years, but there is still work to be done in there. But now we're starting to get the tools to handle it. Which is awesome.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by teh_klev on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @09:16PM (#9066642)
Problem was that you and Gordon and the reasonable crowd ignored it, allowed him to keep being a snidey tool. I'm not blaming you specifically, but that individual was never complained about by you guys - there were ways to reach out to mods outside of the regular chat room tools. In fact, Tim Post and I tried for a while to assist the PHP community with stuff like creating canonical questions and answers, you knew where who we were, we were on your side, my email address was always on my profile.

If I'd gotten a message from yourself or Gordon about this kinda thing (out of band), I knew who you guys were, you are the life and soul of the PHP community on SO. We'd have acted, you're too good to lose.

But...as mods we kept a fairly light touch with regards to stomping into chat rooms and reading the riot act (even politely) because otherwise we'd be meta'd as Nazis's, Fascists and Stalinists. I remember many occasions us being lambasted for trying to "moderate" out unpleasantness (in the PHP and C++ rooms), I eventually gave up my mod diamond because I'd run out of "trying to be nice and diplomatic" energy.

Such is the way of curating a community.

I used to sit in the PHP chat room and become quite depressed that his attitude became the standard.

You know something, as a developer/ops for a web hoster I was about to throw my weight into the PHP project back in ~2010, i.e. contributions, bug reporting from live bulk hosted environments (we probably host around 12k busy PHP sites on Linux and IIS - sure not huge, we're a business focused hoster, uptime and rapid support is paramount [and we do ASP.NET, Perl, Classic ASP], but for a ten man company with some heavily customised environments it's a chunk of work), that kinda thing...but that room turned me off (that and the PHP dev mailing list - but that's another story).

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by joelthelion on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @03:06PM (#9064621)
cv-pls should be forbidden, plain and simple. It is detrimental to the quality and atmosphere of the site.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ircmaxell on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:06PM (#9065803)
How do you solve the torrent of duplicates and low quality questions then? The review queue is backed up all the time (currently 11900 questions with 1+ close-vote).

Ignoring the problem does not make it go away. If you think one of the ways people are trying to solve it should be forbidden, that's fine. Please share an effective alternative.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ProAm on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @12:34AM (#9067164)
> How do you solve the torrent of duplicates and low quality questions then

This is what voting/scoring is for on all the SE sites. The cream will rise to the top. It would be easy enough for SE to disallow questions to show up in google results with a low or negative score, but leave it open for people to discuss, clarify or solve. The moderators on SO don't give the real community a chance by closing things within minutes. Duplicates aren't even a real problem, there is nothing wrong with seeing the same questions answered from a different approach or method.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:30PM (#9065919)
> If you think one of the ways people are trying to solve it should be forbidden, that's fine. Please share an effective alternative.

We all agree about "send me teh codez", obvious duplicates etc.

If however this is the biggest problem then why is asking a question still one of a few things you can do without having rep?

If this is really the problem then raise the bar oh so slightly until you don't need to organize voting rings and detect duplicates at a speed that results in more than a few false positives.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ircmaxell on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:52PM (#9065707)
This has been discussed time and time again:

- http://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/256501/338665 - http://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/271899/338665 - http://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/278092/338665 - http://meta.stackoverflow.com/q/285471/338665

Etc...

And especially: http://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/120275/is-asking-oth...

Basically, there's nothing wrong with the concept, unless it's used incorrectly. So if someone closes something incorrectly (you can point to a definite reason it's incorrectly closed), then re-open it or raise a meta post.

If you want to remove the ability for the people helping moderate a community to moderate, then how do you expect it to be moderated?

The big issue is that there are a LOT of low quality questions being asked. Duplicates. Many times literally copy/pasting the the question title into Google will give you the answer. Should these questions remain open because you want to repwhore? Should they remain open and further reduce the ability for Google to take you to a good canonical answer?

Or should they be closed and point to the good canonical answer? That way people can find their way to good content, rather than littering the site with duplication and poor copies of other answers.

The meaning of the CV reasons has changed over time as the community matures and figures out what works and what doesn't.

I do disagree with closing questions about particular framework (unless there's a dedicated SE site for it).

But bitching doesn't help. Raise a question on Meta. Step into the chat rooms and have a discussion. Get involved and help us fix things.

All bitching does is make the people who are putting time and effort into the community feel like they are doing something bad. Which is the fastest way to kill a community.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:12PM (#9065829)
And still the audience here find it interesting.

Happily this isn't Stack Overflow and this discussion hasn't been closed yet just because a few admins didn't think think it would fit within "Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups."

Edit: to clarify - there are a number of reasons why this topic is interesting to quite a few of us[1]. Here are two:

* the usability issue of what we experience as someone someone destroying a good resource.

* reputation systems: a facinating thing in itself.

[1]: as can be seen by the simple fact that this post is still on the frontpage despite - I guess - having been flagged multiple times : )

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by ircmaxell on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:55PM (#9066053)
That's definitely valid. However, in the vast majority of cases where someone complains about CV-PLS in my experience, it's because they had their question closed.

For example: http://meta.stackexchange.com/q/158712/147370

Look in this very thread. You have people saying it's a horrible practice. Yet nobody really saying what should be done instead.

The fact of the matter is that there is a huge problem on SO of under-moderation. Over 11,000 questions have >=1 closevote right now. CV-PLS is one technique that the community has found effective in keeping the site searchable and with good content.

The people who are against it, I'd love to hear ideas on other effective methods. But to say it should be forbidden is a bit short-sighted.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by reitanqild on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:01PM (#9066094)
> The people who are against it, I'd love to hear ideas on other effective methods. But to say it should be forbidden is a bit short-sighted.

As I mentioned earlier: If this is the biggest problem the raise the bar for asking questions.

Today the site practically begs new users to ask questions as it is one of a few options that are always available for unexperienced users.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by whiddershins on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:18PM (#9066964)
Are we SURE closing questions is that important? Maybe the original article is on to something: if Stack Overflow was built on a more google-like assumption, relevance would influence rankings and visibility of questions/answers/posts ... but there would be less need for outright removal/closing, which is alienating to posters on a human an emotional level.

What is the argument for closing questions ... logistical? Database is too big?

I am sure there are valid reasons, but maybe they should be reexamined in the context of the human cost, and some tweaks could be made.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by danielweber on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @11:31AM (#9069335)
I've stumbled upon "too localized" a few times and it's BS. Just because I'm daring to build a desktop app on OpenBSD doesn't mean it's not a real question.

Google is very good at extracting needles from haystacks. If this SO mention is the only mention of an error message on the Internet, then someone else can find it in the future now.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by jaydles on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @01:56PM (#9070264)
I work at SE... and you're right. We eliminated this close reason because a huge percent of the cases it was used weren't appropriate.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by Danack on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @05:54PM (#9065721)
The problem doesn't stem from people just being wankers in a chat room, it's a deeper problem than that. It's hard to know exactly why people voted to close the 'niche' question you're talking about, but I had to rant recently to someone else who was complaining about how their 'recommend me a library' question was closed unjustly.

What is Stack Overflow's goal

-----------------------------

To be a large repository of reasonably correct answers to small technical problems, where there is only one reasonably correct* answer. Everything else is considered off topic, and unfortunately not a good fit for the site, due to the lack of tools to manage other types of questions

Although there are lots of other things that could be asked and answered, if they are out of that scope then they are considered off-topic and should be closed, according to the people who own StackOverflow. They're closed, not just to annoy people who want those other types of questions answered but because SO really lacks the tools to manage the answers to those questions reasonably.

For example the question "how do you install and configure nginx on different operating systems" is definitely a question that could be asked. However it would require a massively long answer, without a provably correct answer, with different approaches based on how you prefer to configure stuff. i.e. not a single probably correct answer.

Questions that ask for a recommendation for which library to use don't also meet the criteria of having a single reasonably correct answer. Which library you should use depends on lots of factors, and there's probably several, if not a hell of a lot more, possible libraries to use.

Also, questions like that invite debate, multiple answers, spamming by companies trying to promote their software etc. Although people might like to ask all sorts of questions SO have decided to try to limit the number of off-topic questions.

But hasn't the goal of being the large repository of answers already been achieved?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yup, which is why StackOverflow is a considered a shit-show by people who used to find it very useful. If I had to guess, I'd say that something like 95% of all questions that are 'on topic' have already been asked and answered.

Although I've been using it a while, it's just incredibly rare for me to find a technical question that would be on topic for SO, that doing a google search for doesn't have an answer on SO in the top 5 results.

I think the people who run StackOverflow are either morons or have business reasons for not dealing with this problem.

Although the 'find me a library' questions are off-topic they aren't really a big problem - what is a big problem is just the same set of questions being asked day in, day out by people who are too stupid to be able to use Google to find answers to questions like "Q) Why is my compiler saying there is a syntax error on this line?" "A) There's a syntax error on that line."

The vast majority of people who are asking questions on StackOverflow are people who either read their compiler's error message, or do a google search - so it's really unlikely that they're going to spend time trying to understand the ethos behind StackOverflow or spending much time formulating a short, self-contained, correct example.

Because it's so easy for people to sign up to StackOverflow it only takes people a minute to post their badly formed question, which leads to the current torrent of the same questions day in day out. Without increasing either the 'cost' of asking a question or other barrier to prevent people who fail at using google, then it's inevitable that SO will continue to be besieged by bad questions.

-------------

As I said, I think the real problem is that the vast majority of on topic questions have already been asked. The site needs better tools for finding duplicates or expanding into a wider set of questions, for which some answers will be longer, non-authoritative answers which just currently aren't a good fit for the site as it currently exists.

The current system lacks lots of tools that would be required to manage questions and answers that are currently off-topic. Personally I'd prefer it if they improved the site to allow more wide ranging questions and answers and better filtering of 'questions' (e.g. why is the only tool available to mark a question as something that is asking for a recommendation of a library to close it? Why can't we just tag it as 'find me a library' so that people who are interested in answering that can answer it?

*Note - even if an answer is provably incorrect, it won't get deleted unless it's downvoted into oblivion. Which leads to raising of eyebrows when answers to security questions have wrong answers that have been voted to 40+

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by e12e on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @11:16PM (#9066958)
> I think the real problem is that the vast majority of on topic questions have already been asked.

I think this is mostly a problem in so far as answers aren't updated. I'd say that for most "well formed" question belonging on SO that was answered correctly years ago -- most of those answers might no longer be entirely correct and/or the questions themselves might "block" newer (up to date) formulations of the same question.

Things like new versions of compilers, libraries, programming languages, kernel/drivers (and accompanying new hardware) shifts previously correct answers (and "correct" questions) into not-quite-correct-anymore -- but still "too similar" for opening up new questions.

And as questions cease, so does answers, which means the community dissipates/moves on -- and SO becomes irrelevant again. That I think is the danger.

Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by danielweber on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @11:38AM (#9069380)
I have experienced this. Asking questions about a new version of something, and having it closed with a pointed to a prior version of things that explicitly does not work any more.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by davidism on Friday February 20, 2015 @10:29AM (#9080787)
Then edit your question to acknowledge the "duplicate" and clearly explain why your question is different. It will automatically go into a Reopen Queue where users will evaluate it and vote to reopen. The system's not perfect, so if it still doesn't get reopened, open a discussion on meta.
Re:My Love-Hate Relationship with Stack Overflow by DonHopkins on Wednesday February 18, 2015 @03:30AM (#9067542)
Could you please explain what the motivation is to close questions? Who is benefiting from it, and who is it hurting?