Apparently you're not looking at both side of the ledger. The 31 million didn't disappear, it just stayed with the poor. So the poor have (had) 31m more to spend. And poor people do spend all their money, most likely on products that corporations sell. So this was effectively a stimulus measure supported by a tax on lenders.
I also don't see why you can think of raising taxes on the poor, but not on corporations. In fact, the government could easily raise taxes only on corporations. They may even have considered this, but the whole debt forgiveness thing is actually preferable to corporations since it's a one time thing.
There is no such thing as a tax that will ONLY be paid by corporations. They are either paid by the employee's, the customers or the shareholders.
So all you are doing is giving shareholders a chance to distribute that tax amongst the three groups at their own discretion.
Keep in mind that many countries have laws that allow private individuals to declare bankruptcy and default on their debt. Yet, banks still lend money to poor people in those countries.
Banks will factor the possibility into their costs (and hence interest rates), and it might reduce their willingness to lend slightly, but this is far from the picture you're painting.
All things being equal, people will borrow money smartly or stupidly, but the consequences, good or bad, are faced by the people who borrow.
There is a saying that goes something like this: If somebody owes you 100€, it's their problem. If somebody owes you 100 million €, it's your problem.
A loan is a two-way street, and it makes good (social, moral, economic, game-theoretic) sense that the lenders also face part of the consequence.
This means that all of these debts were long-since written off, the risks of these losses already worked into the lending rates and credit qualification cutoffs. It is actually, by most accounting standards, kinda "free".
Yes, as you say: it's worked into the rates and credit qualification cutoffs, and the UK isn't exactly a hard place to get credit despite these very flexible mechanisms for people to get out of debt.
Here's the other thing: These mechanisms are as flexible as they are because the banks have a duty to not give credit to people who can't afford it. If a large number of people go for IVAs, then the banks are probably failing their in their duty even if it is hard to prove individual cases. So it serves as a safety valve to ensure the banks have an ever stronger reason to not make it easier for people to get themselves into trouble in the first place.
Also, it's not clear that you are correct that this debt was largely written off. Certainly the banks didn't expect 100% recovery, but perhaps they expected a nontrivial amount.
I'm not an expert in these tradeoffs, but the one economist interviewed in the article said: I am not sure that this is the best way to help low-income people. If lenders think this can happen again they will charge very high interest rates to low-income borrowers
Most here also do not note that the balances here are also, by design, small as well.
One can argue that there might be some fear that next time the income requirements will be higher, the debt threshold increased, to make a future forgiveness a problem for companies that carry these assets. I accept that this has some merit but I think most overstate it. (Offsetting this risk in large part is the fact that Croatia has joined the EU recently, foreign banks and companies will have recourse should such a thing happen in future and if such a measure were to hurt them no doubt they would use it.)
>Most here also do not note that the balances here are also, by design, small as well. Can you explain how you think that relates to this discussion? If the debt is small, wouldn't that imply that the person was more likely to pay it off, at least in part?
Small overdue amounts are very expensive to recover, if a letter costs you $1 and a phone call $1.50 you don't need very many contact attempts to make an overdue loan of $80 worth less than the cost to recover it, you certainly can not afford to send a lawyer after someone. (Again, this is from my experience related to debt collection work.)
You make a good point and I do not want to undermine it. However, it is worth pointing out that people don't have to take out educational and healthcare loans in most of the civilised world (Croatia included).
1 & 2) There will be no "full stop" on lending money to poor people. If you're a bank and you're managing say $1B, some percentage of that is allocated to high risk loans. Your job is to make money from lending money, and there are only so many borrowers. Banks don't lend money to poor people out of altruism, but because they have to make enough money from interest to at least beat inflation. They'll continue to make high risk loans until they have some new pool of borrowers to replace them, albeit at higher interest rates now.
Most of the people relieved by this cancellation didn't have a very good chance of being approved for a loan anyway. Now their chances will be somewhat reduced, but not completely eliminated.
3) The $31MM didn't disappear, it was effectively removed from the balance sheets of the debtors. If some of them eventually get jobs and build assets, that money will reappear in the economy but be distributed to different businesses. Instead of the banks receiving that $31MM from their paychecks, they'll spend it on food or gas or whatever. Probably still a net loss, but not of the whole $31MM and instead some fraction of it.
4) The concept of moral hazard is a real thing, but it's effects on any given economy vary wildly. In general, most people don't think "Well the government bailed us out once, so I'll borrow way more than I can afford and just hope that they do it again.". It's possible and I can understand why someone would believe it to be a problem, but it's far from being a law of physics or even economics.
In short, the Croatian government and their finance ministers/advisers probably aren't stupid. They have actual data and a knowledge of their own people and situation to go on. They aren't just playing armchair economist. And though I couldn't name one of them, I'm willing to bet that they thought this move through. Doesn't mean that there won't be any of the dire consequences that you've predicted here, but they've probably weighed the odds more carefully than you think.
Or they're a bunch of politicians trying to score a win in the next election, by any means necessary.
You think this move is bad for the banks and telco's? I bet it was their idea in the first place, government is too impotent and incompetent for anything. Throwing whole families out on the street is bad PR, for them and the government, and this way they can pay it off with some change money they were never going to see anyway.
In theory banks price risk using interest rates. That is to say that high risk individuals have to pay a higher interest rate on their debt than lower risk individuals. This reflects the banks concern that they won't get paid back.
If they (the banks) are doing their jobs right then having their highest risk people default is already covered by the interest rates other less risky clients are paying.
The trick though is actually making the bank take the loss which is something they have worked around with the help of the various governments. And that is where we get a conflict of interest where the bank is pricing the loans with the expected risk but actually taking much less risk due to government back stops. That difference is, as you would expect, profit for the bank.
Having said that, I'm thinking out loud here and not convinced of it myself. Mainly because whenever the government steps in like this it means that someone somewhere is getting screwed.
Agree that the free (black) market will move to fill the gap.
> Prime Minister Zoran Milanovic has convinced multiple cities, public and private companies, the country's major telecommunications providers, as well as nine banks to clear some of their citizens of their debt.
This means that the losses happen with consent of the corporations involved.
Not saying that the convincing is necessarily done via threats, or is a bad thing at all, but "convincing" has many meanings.
Either that, or the somewhat more plausible explanation, that the word "convinced" just doesn't quite describe the process that is taking place.
I wouldn't put much stake in that. What choice do you have when the government is trying to "convince" you to do something? You play ball.
1 The bussiness of the banks is to lend money to poor people, Rich people don't need to pay interests, they have lots of money yet. The bank can choose to lend to poor and maybe to earn money or to not risk a single dollar, not earn money, and probably dissapear. You can skyrocket the interest rates all that you want and feel like the big bad bank, but if you put the level too high the people simply will stop entering your bank. You are useless now. People will find another way, and now you are just a dead shark.
2 The money was stolen by rich people, not by the poors, and the bankers know this perfectly.
I'd like to bet against that prediction. I suggest $100 to the winner's favorite charity at even odds? I predict that one year from now, I'll be able to find an example of a Croatian corporation having loaned money to a Croat with income below 1,250 kuna. My contact details are in my profile.
> $31M less in spending, economic growth, job creation...
Wouldn't there also be a corresponding $31M increase in spending from the people who got their debts canceled, making it a wash? They'll spend it quickly I'd imagine, on food or other necessities. Just the money would flow into the economy via a different route.
Most importantly, the companies agreed to this, it wasn't forced by the government.
We're talking about poor people who are very likely unable to pay off their debt. Why? It only applies to people whose monthly income is $138, try paying your rent, food etc on that, and then pay off a debt whose interest alone would already be a significant chunk of your monthly income.
Interest rates already account for these risks and banks have largely already written off these loans as money that won't be paid back. The notion that these were awesome loans that would get paid back and suddenly get cancelled just isn't true. Which is why interest rates aren't likely to skyrocket and why they don't constitute losses, they have already materialized even if the debt isn't cancelled.
Talks of the poor being burdened by taxes the hardest, come on. First, it's just 0.75% of debt. Second, the revenue on this is minimal. If you borrow $100 at a 10% interest rate that's $10 of interest revenue (the rest is principal paid back), and that $10 interest revenue is then taxed at say 20% capital gains tax. So if 0.75% of the debt is cancelled, that's only 0.015% lost tax revenue from debt, it's not going to cause any national tax disasters for the poor. Especially because, again, these loans weren't going to get paid off anyway, it doesn't change much in extra losses.
On the contrary, cancelling 0.75% of the debt makes 20% of the indebted debt-free. They become economic actors again, who previously had no access to their bank account and no room to make personal investments into education or small enterprise. Things you mentioned like sex slavery are more likely to drop because of this than anything else.
Lastly, your point on smart/stupid borrowing, we're talking about a country which was extremely hard-hit by the crisis, one which the PhDs and CEOs at the top financial institutions didn't see coming any better than the world's dumbest person. We mustn't assume 20% of the indebted people who will become economic actors again were borrowing for gambling, it seems like a lot of these people have been put into economic paralysis due to a crisis just like the large financial institutions, yet the large corporations and banks got bailed out and they weren't. And they're in no position to pull themselves out of this with a blocked off bank account and less than $138 in monthly income.
So what's the solution? Ask corporations to do the right and smart thing: write-off 1% of your debts that you had already written off anyway, turn 20% of your debtors into economic actors again who regain buying power, start businesses and participate in the economy, get good will from the public and government and get your country on the road again.
I fully appreciate that this isn't black and white and there are definite cons, but it seems to me to be a positive decision on aggregate.
I think it helps to see it as an investment. Imagine you take 0.75% of your debt, the bottom 0.75% that was extremely likely to ever get paid off, the part that was already part of your cashflow and solvency modelling and whose likely potential losses have already been accounted for.
Then take that amount, and go to the board and say, we can invest this amount, buy legal good-will from the government, buy good-will/marketing from our national customer base, and we get access to a new market increasing our long-term customers by a substantial percentage (20% of its debtors). The cost? Just forgo 0.75% of the debt that wasn't actually going to make us much money anyway.
That's why corporations chose this themselves, it's not a bad idea for them.
Or, keep bank accounts frozen for 20% of the indebted people who got hit by the financial crisis and make $138 a month, bail out financial institutions, and try to run a country where a significant portion of your population are so paralyzed by debts that they turn to sources of income which won't be taxed or absorbed immediately by debt-payback, the type of jobs paid in cash, the criminal kind, the exploitative kind, the kind that's not taxed, that doesn't create jobs or small to medium sized enterprises, the kind that increases costs of policing and regulations, the kind that increases the class divide and pits people against each other. And do exactly to the poorest (leave them to figure it out by themselves) what we weren't willing to do to our largest companies (who we bailed out because it made more sense than to let things crash and burn out of a fetish for non-interventionism market principles right after an economic crisis.
Say hello to life outside the US. In most of Europe you don't need loans to get an education, healthcare or to buy a car.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspi...
The low density of car-oriented US suburbs was mandated by socialist central land use planning from Washington and the motorcar industry that wanted to require Americans to each own a car. Standards were written centrally and local governments were required to make them law with grants, national bank regulations that required them for lending, and professional standards organizations that made civil engineers agree to them for licensure.
The more market driven land use in European cities promotes walking and transit more than personal motoring.
And yes, less need as well.
We used to use hire cars for special trips and use public transport for other things (for a time having no vehicle by choice); then we got a scooter (as a couple) to help with going out and doing shopping trips and such (definitely cheaper than getting taxis).
Then work necessitated having a van, once you have a vehicle then it's only ever cheaper [where I am] to use public transport for long trips for an individual - once a couple or more travel together it's cheaper in a car (including a proportion allowed for road tax, ongoing license costs, depreciation, repairs and petrol [using Gov mileage allowances; not including learning to drive!]).
Problem is, as with many things when you're poorer, the upfront costs for a car mean that those less well off can be barred from ownership and so barred from the per-mile savings and convenience.
Having a car for our family now means I can't afford to take the bus and watching near empty buses go past as you walk home in the dark, cold and wet, isn't much fun ...
Scrap values being high has pushed the price of the lowest costs second-hand cars up a bit. Not so long ago I had to pay to have a still usable car scrapped to avoid paying the license fee. Bangers then were essentially free.
Worth cycling home from work?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_vehicles_p...
shows the US at 809 cars per 1000, vs Italy at 682, Germany 588, and so on. Which I would interpret as "Europe has slightly fewer cars per person", not "Europe has NO NEED for cars". It's hard with a straight face for anyone who's visited Paris or Rome to observe there's not serious traffic. (And, in fact, woe to any pedestrians who get in their way.)
1) Banks and other corporations will never lend money to poor people again. Full stop. If there is a chance that the government will write off that debt (effectively stealing future earnings from banks) for these loans, banks just won't issue them. Say goodbye to educational loans, healthcare loans, car loans. Say goodbye to home loans and mortgages. If you're poor, you just became a ward of the state. And you thought being in debt was bad...
2) If a legitimate institution do want to lend money to poor people, interest rates will skyrocket to compensate for this additional government-cancellation risk. If they skyrocket above usury laws, then legitimate institutions will no longer be in the market and the job of lending at-risk capital will turn to the black market. Look out for loan sharks and indentured servitude, including sex slavery, on the rise in Croatia in the future.
3) The money has to come from somewhere--it isn't free. By canceling $31M in debt, the government is causing $31M in losses to corporations and institutions that were owed that money. That means $31M less in spending, economic growth, job creation, not to mention taxes, which will have to go up to compensate for the loss. These taxes (or inflation) will hit the poorest people while the rich horde more money or offshore it to prevent it being taken away.
4) Lending is the foundation of economic growth, especially for the poor, by allowing borrowers to leverage their limited assets in exchange for future earnings. All things being equal, people will borrow money smartly or stupidly, but the consequences, good or bad, are faced by the people who borrow. If the government cancels debt, it is incentivizing bad borrowing and making it harder for good borrowers to get the capital they need.
It's the worst kind of pandering to the voters with long-term destructive consequences to the people of Croatia.
In other words, exactly what you'd expect from politicians. Keep up the good work!