Yes, as you say: it's worked into the rates and credit qualification cutoffs, and the UK isn't exactly a hard place to get credit despite these very flexible mechanisms for people to get out of debt.
Here's the other thing: These mechanisms are as flexible as they are because the banks have a duty to not give credit to people who can't afford it. If a large number of people go for IVAs, then the banks are probably failing their in their duty even if it is hard to prove individual cases. So it serves as a safety valve to ensure the banks have an ever stronger reason to not make it easier for people to get themselves into trouble in the first place.
Also, it's not clear that you are correct that this debt was largely written off. Certainly the banks didn't expect 100% recovery, but perhaps they expected a nontrivial amount.
I'm not an expert in these tradeoffs, but the one economist interviewed in the article said: I am not sure that this is the best way to help low-income people. If lenders think this can happen again they will charge very high interest rates to low-income borrowers
Most here also do not note that the balances here are also, by design, small as well.
One can argue that there might be some fear that next time the income requirements will be higher, the debt threshold increased, to make a future forgiveness a problem for companies that carry these assets. I accept that this has some merit but I think most overstate it. (Offsetting this risk in large part is the fact that Croatia has joined the EU recently, foreign banks and companies will have recourse should such a thing happen in future and if such a measure were to hurt them no doubt they would use it.)
>Most here also do not note that the balances here are also, by design, small as well. Can you explain how you think that relates to this discussion? If the debt is small, wouldn't that imply that the person was more likely to pay it off, at least in part?
Small overdue amounts are very expensive to recover, if a letter costs you $1 and a phone call $1.50 you don't need very many contact attempts to make an overdue loan of $80 worth less than the cost to recover it, you certainly can not afford to send a lawyer after someone. (Again, this is from my experience related to debt collection work.)
This means that all of these debts were long-since written off, the risks of these losses already worked into the lending rates and credit qualification cutoffs. It is actually, by most accounting standards, kinda "free".