News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:43AM (#8947926)
Coinbase is insured against hacking, internal theft, and accidental loss in an amount that covers maximum value of bitcoin we hold in online storage at any given time.

When marketers advertise in bad faith, you could end up with a bad product. In this case, however, you could end up losing your money.

Unless you have multisig control over your coins, do not put large sums into this exchange unless you want to lose your money.

98% of customer bitcoin is stored entirely offline.

This means the vast majority of users don't have multisig control over their coins, since multisig-protected coins can't be put into offline storage.

Let's recap Coinbase's technical problems over the years:

Here's someone who sent $35k to Coinbase and never received coins until they made a big deal about it on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6929705

Here's someone with the same story, but $10k instead of $35k: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6933360

Here's Coinbase leaking emails and full names: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7507493

Here's a Coinbase engineer saying "there are a few lingering issues" in response to transactions being delayed for days (sometimes over a week) and BTC not being able to be withdrawn: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5427985

And now they're trying to pretend like your coins are completely safe. They're not. If Coinbase becomes insolvent and goes bankrupt, you won't get your coins back. It happened to Mt. Gox, it sucked for me, and if it happens to Coinbase it's going to suck for you.

Don't put more than a few bucks into this, or whatever you're comfortable with losing.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by kyledrake on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:46PM (#8948731)
I think having healthy reservations about trusting central services is a good thing (read: don't hold all your money in a single place), but I also don't see centralized services going away. We can talk about "decentralizing exchanges" all we want, but at the end of the day, you need direct access to the ACH/banking networks to streamline transfers between the system everybody uses today, and the only way to do that is with a centralized service. Anybody that thinks the banking system is going to let a decentralized service pull money out of people's bank accounts needs to stop grinding up their copy of Atlas Shrugged and smoking it.

I have my concerns about some of their tech choices (NONE of which involve security, except the simple fact of control of private keys), and I wasn't happy with the way they handled their tech interviews (I'm not going there, everybody learned from it, it's not relevant anymore).

But I also see them doing a pretty good job overall, and I see all the other exchanges screwing up really badly. This move makes sense. They need a stable exchange service, they have the capacity to build one, and there's demand. So why not? I would have done the exact same thing.

This also adds a lot of context to the recent raise, of course. Another less obvious thing that adds context is that Coinbase is now a very programmable fiat bank account, which is something that could, with a little work, put a serious dent into Paypal and the rest of the banking industry, which still does not provide good APIs for their banking services.

Coinbase might not be a Bitcoin wallet (the provider not being able to read the private key is my personal standard for this), but Coinbase is becoming one hell of a Bitcoin/fiat bank account. And we need those, too.

Even if Bitcoin fell apart, a pivot to a highly programmable fiat bank would be a cake walk for them, and there's plenty of money to be made. Probably worth the investment at this point in the game.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by stream_fusion on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:51PM (#8950425)
> Anybody that thinks the banking system is going to let a decentralized service pull money out of people's bank accounts...

I don't think that's completely clear. There will certainly be co-ordinated resistance from many entrenched interests, but that resistance also creates a profit-opportunity to break ranks to provide the service to customers who want it. It's more likely we'll see a split amongst banks and their policies to digital/alternative banking services.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by gcb0 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @05:06AM (#8952247)
you defined it well. it's a bridge to the current system.

anyone who uses it for anything other than quick, small transfers is a complete moron.

it's akin to calling a escrow that just opened shop and giving them thousands of dollar that you don't plan to spend.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:16PM (#8948162)
I don't think this is reasonable. They have their online coins insured, so if they lose them, they can reimburse you.

This is a serious, professionally-run company backed by a lot of VCs we all recognize, plus banks and the NYSE. And regulated. They also have an overall good track record for a small company (all such companies have some growing pains).

They have everything to gain by honesty and everything to lose by committing fraud, including prison (and dishonesty is the only reason they would become insolvent).

The whole situation could not be more unlike Gox, and it is not reasonable to judge them by that standard.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:24PM (#8948228)
They have their online coins insured, so if they lose them, they can reimburse you.

That's a little irrelevant, because their hot storage wallet (their online coins) should be a small subset of their total coins. The whole point of a hot storage wallet is that if you lose them, it doesn't matter. So insuring those is pointless except as a marketing stunt to confuse people, which is why saying "We're insured" is bad faith.

This is a serious, professionally-run company backed by a lot of VCs we all recognize, plus banks and the NYSE.

Indeed, and if Coinbase loses all the coins, none of those people will step in to replace them, because nobody is going to put up hundreds of mullions or a billion dollars just to reimburse customers.

They have everything to gain by honesty and everything to lose by committing fraud, including prison (and that is the only reason they would become insolvent).

I disagree that technical problems can't make them insolvent. All it would take is an unhappy accident in their cold storage procedures.

But beyond tech problems, consider a thought experiment: If you're a gambling person, would you trade 20 years of your life in exchange for becoming a billionaire?

Banks are nice because if someone takes money, the money can be retrieved. Not the case for bitcoin. Someone is in charge of the cold storage procedures, so that person is in control over all the coins. If they decide to take all of them, there's nothing anyone can do about it except throw them into prison.

Obviously, bitcoin may be completely irrelevant by the time you're out of prison. In fact, emptying Coinbase's cold storage reserves might even cause that. But money does strange things to people, and this technology has changed the power dynamic. Some of those changes are good. But are you sure you want to trust a single person with your entire fortune? Worse, you're trusting multiple people where any single person can take your fortune. Even if they require several people to sign off, that's a very small number of people in complete control of your fate.

It probably sounds like I'm anti-Coinbase. I'm not. I'm pro-consumer. As soon as Coinbase insures all of their coins or offers true protection to consumers (by default!) then I'll be their biggest fan, because they'll have become an awesome bank.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by tlrobinson on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:44PM (#8948337)
"But are you sure you want to trust a single person with your entire fortune? Worse, you're trusting multiple people where any single person can take your fortune."

Coinbase is hopefully not entrusting individual employees with cold storage keys. Their security page suggests they're using Shamir's Secret Sharing or similar (https://www.coinbase.com/security), though multisig would be even better.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jafaku on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:52PM (#8948383)
I can't believe they aren't using multi-signature internally. This is crazy.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by danielweber on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:31PM (#8948635)
Can they demonstrate the procedure works well enough that an insurance company would underwrite them for the full value of the cold wallet?
Re:Coinbase Exchange by tedunangst on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:52PM (#8949163)
What happens after an accident when they come up one secret short? The 98% are apparently not insured.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by tlrobinson on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:54PM (#8949498)
Shamir's Secret Sharing and multisig Bitcoin transactions support arbitrary n-of-m pieces/keys, e.x. a 3-of-6 scheme would require 3 of the 6 pieces to reconstitute the key/sign a transaction, so any 3 pieces could be lost.

2-of-3 is common for end-user multisig. Generally you'd have 1 key physically backed up on paper in a secure place, 1 key on one of your devices (phone or computer), and 1 key either on another device (hardware wallet or phone) or controlled by a 3rd party that does risk analysis/fraud detection on your transactions.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:55PM (#8948413)
> So insuring those is pointless except as a marketing stunt to confuse people, which is why saying "We're insured" is bad faith.

I don't think it's in bad faith. Bitstamp just lost its hot wallet recently, and people were panicking, because they didn't know what the situation was. Now, with Coinbase, if that happens, we don't have to panic. It's hard to tell people something that is true and have it be "in bad faith."

> I disagree that technical problems can't make them insolvent.

I agree with you here, I just think the chance is so low that it's not worth mentioning. I don't have any insider info, but I seem to recall reading a post a long time ago where they explained having some kind of x-of-y system of paper wallets stored in bank safety deposit boxes all over the country with a lot of redundancy.

If you are willing to assume they have even a minimal level of common sense and competency, they have an offline storage system that is very robust.

> But beyond tech problems, consider a thought experiment: If you're a gambling person, would you trade 20 years of your life in exchange for becoming a billionaire?

I think this is an interesting thought experiment. I don't completely disagree, but I am still willing to trust coinbase with my money.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:09PM (#8948492)
Well, Bitstamp was incompetent enough to keep $5M USD (almost 20k BTC) in their hot wallet. That's half their most recent funding round, so the panic is probably warranted.

I think we're at an impasse because you believe in Coinbase's competency. That's commendable, but I saw firsthand how incompetent an exchange can be without anybody noticing. If I'd researched Mt. Gox, I would have found a history of tech problems not dissimilar to Coinbase's, so the goal with my original comment was to remind people that this situation is very similar to Mt. Gox. They're based in the US, they have good investors, but still fundamentally similar to Mt. Gox.

Don't get me wrong, making an exchange is a hard problem, so it's pretty amazing that Coinbase has gotten this far with "only" four or five high-profile issues. Everyone loves a story of some small group of people surmounting a difficult problem. But when that problem puts people's livelihoods at risk, we need to make sure everybody is fully informed about the risks.

I also want to thank you for the interesting conversation. Much appreciated!

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @02:08PM (#8955003)
> They're based in the US, they have good investors, but still fundamentally similar to Mt. Gox.

I just don't agree with that. Those two things make them fundamentally different than Mt. Gox. The other fundamental difference is that they are not run by Mark Karpeles. I have to believe Karpeles is an exceptionally immoral/careless (or something, I'm not exactly sure) person, not anywhere close to the average.

But there is definitely some validity in what you are saying. I mean, nobody should trust to any bitcoin exchange more than they can afford to lose.

> I also want to thank you for the interesting conversation. Much appreciated!

Same to you!

Re:Coinbase Exchange by adrianmacneil on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:35PM (#8948658)
I'm not sure I would call Bitstamp incompetent for keeping $5M USD worth of bitcoin in their hot wallet.

A hot wallet needs to contain enough to cover the largest reasonably-sized transaction which a user may want to withdraw (and then some), and a global exchange like Bitstamp would have many institutional customers who may withdraw that much on a weekly basis.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by blfr on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:41PM (#8948705)
are you sure you want to trust a single person with your entire fortune?

What "entire fortune"? Who keeps their "entire fortune" with an exchange anyway? Or a significant chunk of it in cash for that matter?

They provide completely reasonable assurances for what they're doing.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:47PM (#8948735)
These people: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1yv26o/gox_horror_...

Specifically this person: https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1yv26o/gox_horror_...

I am the biggest loser at 4700+ BTC. Screenshot from a few days ago for the purposes of record keeping. http://imgur.com/IDbM0BP

This behavior isn't uncommon. Check out the rest of the thread. Everyone is expressing their faith in Coinbase's competence, so if that's your position, trusting your fortune to them wouldn't seem unreasonable. It's how I lost money on Mt. Gox.

Wanna see a scary survey? https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2bjefu/results_of_...

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1FTW8ec0KAzmK8DVYEhFIRVbmYTH...

Check out this chart: http://i.imgur.com/qHYLeXz.png

A whopping third of people surveyed had more than 20-30% of their net worth in bitcoin. I wonder how many of those people are storing it themselves vs storing them with Coinbase or some other exchange?

Re:Coinbase Exchange by blfr on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:03PM (#8948844)
You can hurt yourself with a powertool, even a kitchen knife or a kettle. Do more damage than you ever could with bitcoin. That doesn't mean the manufacturer should buy you healthcare insurance.

Storing 4700BTC with an exchange is far, far beyond intended use. My position is that you shouldn't be doing it.

I understand the pro-consumer position. Yes, maybe the exchange should push you into cashing out. But this is starting to turn into padding every room.

We allow people to speculate on forex. We allow them to play carpenter. I don't see why this shouldn't extend to bitcoin.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:15PM (#8948919)
My intent wasn't to argue that Coinbase should be illegal. That would be silly. My goal was to show that regardless of how we feel consumers should act, those links show how they do act.

Consumers take risks far beyond what's reasonable. It's up to Coinbase to protect them, and for them to inform consumers if they can't. But Coinbase is doing just the opposite: they're advertising that they're insured while handwaving the fact that they only insure 2% of their coins. And so on.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:54PM (#8949178)
I guess the question is, why are they making such a big deal about their insurance, if it's both unnecessary and not useful? It sounds like they're trying to run the exchange as you say (with the vast majority of assets not insured) but trying to convince people that it's a safe place to store any amount ("we are insured").
Re:Coinbase Exchange by blfr on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:10PM (#8949258)
The insurance covers the riskiest part of their operation: hot wallets. And it's meant to convince people that it's a safe place to exchange money. Seems rather straight-forward to me.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @03:47PM (#8949474)
The whole point of a hot wallet is that it doesn't matter if it disappears. The only point of insuring it is to give a false sense of safety.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by blfr on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:29PM (#8949687)
How can it not matter if 3% of assets under your management disappear?
Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:47PM (#8949791)
If it matters, then you're keeping too much in your hot wallet. The definition of "hot wallet" is "we keep a small enough assets here to cover day-to-day operations, but not so much that we're in trouble if they disappear." There's no other reason to have a hot wallet.

Insuring their hot wallet might let Coinbase increase its size, but it offers no extra protection for consumers. None whatsoever.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @12:20AM (#8951380)
You're crazy. How easily you can lose the funds in a hot wallet is not part of the definition.

Also, I feel safer using a business that can't lose 3% of its assets in seconds, no matter if it would be stable either way. I'm surprised that you don't. (And yes, safety is the same thing as protection.)

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @11:08AM (#8953790)
I agree that this definition of a hot wallet is wacky. The definition of a hot wallet is easy: it's a wallet that's online and can be accessed by automated systems without human intervention. How you use it is entirely up to you, and nothing says you can't put 100% of your assets in a hot wallet, it's just a really bad idea.

However, I still think it's really odd to only insure the hot wallet and to call so much attention to the fact that it's insured. Imagine if your bank called attention to the fact that they were insured with large, high-rated insurers for any conceivable loss... and then they mention at the end that the insurance only covers what's in the tellers' drawers, not what's in the vault. Personally I'd run far, far away if I saw something like that.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @12:59PM (#8954560)
The analogy is tricky, because in many banks the vault is effectively the hot wallet. Most of the money is in the form of debts or loans, and the vault only holds enough cash for normal withdrawals.

It's bad that they have no insurance on the cold storage, but that's something you can't really get anywhere as far as I know. I take it more as a risk of bitcoin in general.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by celticninja on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:12PM (#8950274)
A whopping third of people surveyed had more than 20-30% of their net worth in bitcoin. I wonder how many of those people are storing it themselves vs storing them with Coinbase or some other exchange?

I imagine most of these people saw a medium sized investment increase in value significantly, which made it a larger part of their net worth as opposed to putting 25% of their net worth into bitcoin.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by celticninja on Monday January 26, 2015 @06:09PM (#8950262)
I bet the $ value is insured. Will that be at the price they were when they were stolen or at the price they are when they pay out your claim? I'm betting which ever is the cheapest.

What I mean is if they are stolen today priced at $200, let's say you have 100btc on there,that is $20k. You claim but it is 2 months later any payout is made. Now bitcoin is only worth $100 each so you they give you $10k to rebuy your 100btc or do they give you the $20k it was worth when it was stolen. How about if the price of btc goes up? 100btc might now cost $200k to replace, so now they want to give you the dollar value at the time it was stolen.

I would not want the be the person putting it to the test regardless of the outcome.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by tedunangst on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:49PM (#8949137)
> This is a serious, professionally-run company backed by a lot of VCs we all recognize, plus banks and the NYSE.

So nothing like mtgox. More like Enron? "serious professionally run" isn't some magic ward of protection.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:58PM (#8950192)
What about the vast majority of large, publicly-traded American companies that are honest and do good business?

Pointing out Enron is cherry-picking. I can point out 499 other business on the Fortune 500 that aren't Enron.

The point is, they, maybe Coinbase is just as corrupt and shady and incompetent as Mark Karpeles (i.e. Mt. Gox), but there is just no reason to assume that. Its a leap of faith. It's much more likely that they are not exceptionally shady/incompetent/dishonest/whatever Karpeles is.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by tedunangst on Monday January 26, 2015 @07:14PM (#8950516)
The point isn't to decide whether they are good people or not; it's about the protections in place that should make that irrelevant. I buy all sorts of stuff from some surely shady characters, but I do so through amazon who I'm confident will make things right when they go wrong.

Coinbase is promising that if something goes wrong, they can make as much as 2% of it right. Let's hope that when something goes wrong, it's with that 2%.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by serf on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:09PM (#8949911)
what I take from that phrasing is :

"Like Mt.Gox but on the East Coast near Wallstreet, so HFT should push the nobodies out."

It doesn't make me feel any more secure on that particular exchange.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by vanzard on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:05PM (#8948473)
> They're trying to pretend like your coins are completely safe. They're not.

Nothing is completely safe, not even traditional banks. FDIC insurance has many limits and restrictions (eg. it does not cover safe deposit boxes). In 2014 the national bank in Bulgaria had a catastrophic bank run who left depositors like you and me unable to access their money (to this day they still don't have their money - http://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2014/08/18/the-bu...). In 2013 customers of the bank of Cyprus lost between 50% and 100% of their deposits over 100 000 euros (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-07-30/cyprus-sets-levy-on...). And so on. It is a good reminder that a crisis causing you to lose money can happen at ANY financial institution. Every year there are millions of people losing money who thought was "safe".

That's why it is always a good advice to diversify, to not keep all your eggs in one basket, etc. Bitcoin is no exception.

With that said, it is fair to remark that Coinbase is still probably one of the safest places to keep your coins "online" for day to day usage.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by pistle on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:03PM (#8948842)
There's 0% safe and 100%, for everything else it's equal?

FDIC is tested and backed by something beyond corporate assurances about insurance policies.

Does that policy pay out upon bankruptcy?

Agreed. Diversify. But, US banks are still demonstrably lower risk (with stipulations) thanks to FDIC than, currently, a bitcoin exchange.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:52PM (#8949157)
Diversification is a great idea and I think your advice is sound, but I'd also like to point out that there are limits to it. FDIC doesn't quite belong in the same category as Bulgaria or Cyprus. When small countries have a shock like that, it's bad for the people with money in their banks. If the same thing happened in the US, it would either happen because of a massive worldwide economic crisis, or it would cause one. I'm not sure there's anywhere you can diversify and be safe with something like that.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by kaa2102 on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:04PM (#8949560)
The bank failures you cited are outside of the US and the FDIC is not applicable. Yet, FIDC only covers deposits up to $250,000.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by jafaku on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:49AM (#8947964)
> This means 98% of customers don't have multisig control over their coins, since multisig-protected coins can't be put into offline storage.

What makes you think you can't use multi-sig and offline storage at the same time? That's just false. You don't need an internet connection to sign a multi-sig transaction.

But I agree on everything else: 98% of funds aren't insured, and to me Coinbase has always been just another Rails startup (not necessarily a bad thing, but they made tons of mistakes typical of having web developer talent only).

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:00PM (#8948043)
Well, the goal of multisig is to retain control over your own coins. If someone can take your coins offline, then you no longer have control over them.

Here's an explanation of multisig: https://bitcoinmagazine.com/11108/multisig-future-bitcoin/

Multisignature escrow works as follows. When Alice wants to send $20 to Bob in exchange for a product, Alice first picks a mutually trusted arbitrator, whom we’ll call Martin, and sends the $20 to a multisig between Alice, Martin and Bob. Bob sees that the payment was made, and confirms the order and ships the product. When Alice receives the product, Alice finalizes the transaction by creating a transaction sending the $20 from the multisig to Bob, signing it, and passing it to Bob. Bob then signs the transcation, and publishes it with the required two signatures.

In this case, Bob is Coinbase and Alice is you. Alice plus Martin always retain control over the coins, so Bob alone can't take them offline.

The way that a multisignature wallet works is simple. Instead of the Bitcoin address having one private key, it has three. One private key is stored semi-securely, just as in a traditional Bitcoin wallet. The second key the user is instructed to store safely (eg. in a safety deposit box), and the third key is stored on the server.

Basically, the user would be the one storing it in offline storage, not Coinbase. But since Coinbase is claiming 98% of coins are stored offline, that means at least 98% of coins aren't using multisig.

EDIT: Thank you to kanzure's comment below. Updated.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jafaku on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:47PM (#8948350)
The goal of multi-signature is to decentralize the ownership (or control) of the coins. In the case of Coinbase's offline storage, they could very well be using multi-signature (and they probably are) so that no single employee can run with the coins. Instead, every time they need to refill their hot wallet, the three or five or whatever employees needed to sign the the transaction have to agree and provide their signature.

Edit: Actually, apparently they aren't using multi-signature internally: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8948337

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:56PM (#8948421)
I agree that Coinbase itself should be using multisig, but the point of my comment is that if customers themselves aren't using multisig, their coins' fate is completely in Coinbase's hands. And Coinbase multisig won't save those coins from tech problems, willful theft, or a breach in their security model. Multisig offers you no benefits if you're not the one in control.

Are you sure you want to trust your fortune to three or five employees?

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jafaku on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:06PM (#8948479)
> Multisig offers you no benefits if you're not the one in control.

That's a little extreme. I would trust a lot more in five employees than in one. If done right, each one of them could even not know who the other employees are.

> Are you sure you want to trust your fortune to three or five employees?

I wouldn't trust anyone with my precious coins :p. I'm just saying the same way we (supposedly) decentralize control on nuclear bombs, we can decentralize control on bitcoins. I feel safer knowing that no single soldier can launch a nuclear bomb, even if I don't have any control over that.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jsprogrammer on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @02:35AM (#8951895)
What happens if one of the five employees loses their key? Aren't you increasing the risk of bricked coins with each signature that you require? Do you really want your coins to be at risk of brick by three or five CoinBase employees?
Re:Coinbase Exchange by jafaku on Thursday January 29, 2015 @11:02PM (#8970403)
Then make the scheme 4 of 5, or 3 of 5. Besides, the company could keep a backup of the keys in physical locations, and secure them with traditional physical security.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by kanzure on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:14PM (#8948148)
> But since Coinbase is claiming 98% of coins are stored offline, that means at least 98% of users aren't using multisig.

Almost... you should say instead: "that means at least 98% of coins aren't using multisig" because without having their internal account metrics it is wrong to assume to that 98% of Coinbase users deposited 98% of BTC at Coinbase...

Re:Coinbase Exchange by bsmith on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:53PM (#8948395)
> . . . to me Coinbase has always been just another Rails startup (not necessarily a bad thing, but they made tons of mistakes typical of having web developer talent only).

Re-read that with the word 'internet' in place of the word 'Rails.'

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jes5199 on Monday January 26, 2015 @02:22PM (#8948967)
and you get the same level of confidence. Internet startups just don't have the quality necessary to be banks.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by lordnacho on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:50PM (#8948373)
>but they made tons of mistakes typical of having web developer talent only

What do you mean by this?

Re:Coinbase Exchange by danielweber on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:16PM (#8948524)
I read it as "a bunch of front-end devs who have no idea what the back-end is doing."

Which, in many cases, is A-OK. If lots of developers don't ever learn to write their own SQL queries, that's not that bad. There are lots of things to learn out there, and by necessity any professional is going to have lots of stuff she doesn't know. Doctors and lawyers specialize out the wazoo.

But when it comes time to realize that you had the wrong version of SQLAlchemy installed and now strangers can pass in arbitrary SQL code via any LIMIT parameter you exposed, and you are sitting there wondering "huh? whu?", well, that's probably not the end of the world for your cat-picture site. But if you are handling money, you need to know what's going on.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jafaku on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:00PM (#8948440)
For example: You can only have so much security if you don't have security experts. Same with every other area. I don't remember the details now, but their first iterations were pretty lame.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by benjaminjackman on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:55PM (#8948417)
Well for one example this exchange is really poorly designed in several ways with respect to the standards and expectations set by other exchanges.

Though the benefit of the web-developer talent is that is also years (perhaps decades) ahead of them in others.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:03PM (#8948066)
The insurance situation confuses me. The linked page seems to indicate that only their online coins (i.e. 2% of the total) are insured. If I then click "Read More" I get: "Coinbase is insured against employee theft and hacking in an amount that exceeds the average value of online bitcoin it holds at any given time." I think this means that the 2% is not insured, but that the 98% in offline storage is. What's going on?
Re:Coinbase Exchange by tlrobinson on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:22PM (#8948218)
"Coinbase is insured against hacking, internal theft, and accidental loss in an amount that covers maximum value of bitcoin we hold in online storage at any given time."

"Coinbase is insured against employee theft and hacking in an amount that exceeds the average value of online bitcoin it holds at any given time."

Those statements seem mostly consistent to me. The only question is whether the insurance is always more than is in their hot wallet, or exceeds the value on "average" (whatever that means).

I suspect it would be difficult to guarantee the insurance would always exceed the value of online bitcoins, perhaps because the insurance is issued on the USD value and prices can fluctuate wildly, or perhaps because they can't predict when large deposits will be made (though I'm unsure if deposits go directly to hot or cold wallets)

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:28PM (#8948258)
I got confused between what kinds of losses the insurance covers versus how much it covers. Details in the reply to your sibling comment. I see what it means now.
Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:18PM (#8948183)
Just looking at what you've quoted, I don't see what is confusing. Both statements say that the 2% that is stored online is insured. Specifically, in an amount that exceeds the average value at any given time.

That average bit is a bit nebulous, but it doesn't make me think they are insuring the 98% but not the 2%.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Monday January 26, 2015 @12:24PM (#8948232)
How could they lose online bitcoins beyond what they actually hold? Is the idea that if they normally hold X, and one day they hold 2X and it gets ripped off, they can get X back from insurance? Sounds pretty worthless if that's all it is.

Edit: OK, I see where my confusion lies. I kept thinking that "insured... in an amount that exceeds the average value" means that they the insurance only applies to losses that exceed the average value, but they mean that the amount of insurance coverage is greater than what they typically hold in online storage, so insurance should cover any possible losses of online coins.

In that case it all makes sense, although it seems crazy that their offline coins aren't also insured. (If offline means there's little risk of loss then the insurance should be cheap, right?)

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Monday January 26, 2015 @01:00PM (#8948446)
I am just a regular guy, but I would guess it would be super expensive and borderline impossible to insure offline coins.

(a) Who in the "custom" insurance business would be comfortable with that and find it to be worth their time? Why not stick with well-understood risks, like insuring throats, fingers, humongous diamonds, and stuff like that?

(b) More importantly, stealing bitcoins that are insured is almost the perfect crime. There is too much of an incentive for the insuree to steal the bitcoins and claim insurance.

I do think these things could be overcome by an enterprising insurance agency, but insuring a huge amount of bitcoins is still going to be extremely costly.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by late2part on Monday January 26, 2015 @04:21PM (#8949646)
I'll assume your questions are not rhetorcal.

a) the same person who insures the online coins.

b) it may be expensive, but most likely cheaper on a pro-rata basis than the online coins. If it's "cost-prohibitive" offer it as a market driven "add-on" service. Two products, insured and noninsured.

Your arguments apply equally well to that which is insured, unless I Am misunderstanding something somehow.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Monday January 26, 2015 @05:50PM (#8950134)
a) the same person would need to be able to take almost 50x as large a loss

b) I don't think that makes sense because I don't think having insurance for offline coins is something reasonable people are worried about, except a very, very small number. I think it's something people are bringing up to criticize Coinbase because they want to find ways to criticize them.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by mikeash on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @11:13AM (#8953823)
a) That's true but I don't think it matters here. Coinbase is small fry. Heck, all of Bitcoin is small fry. There may be theoretical cases where that insurance is impractical because of this, but there should be no problem finding an insurer that can fully insure Coinbase. For example, I'd wager that Coinbase's total assets are less than the cost of a new A380, and airlines have no trouble insuring their airplanes.

b) Why is it unreasonable to want insurance for offline coins? They're safer but they're hardly going to be invulnerable. Collusion, theft, or accidental loss can still happen. I'm not trying to find ways to criticize them (I have pretty much no opinion about them aside from what I've seen here, and a single Bitcoin transaction I tried with them once that went completely smoothly), I just find it weird that a financial company would go to such lengths to point out that they're insured, but only insure 2% of their total assets, to the point where it sounds dishonest to me.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by javert on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @02:00PM (#8954952)
a) yeah, but if coinbase and bitcoin are successful, that won't be true for long. I'm sure those guys are hoping Wall Street money will start coming in. If the bitcoin price spikes again, they may then have to stop being insured, which is worse than just not having it. Still, fair point.

b) Why unreasonable? Because only a really foolish person would keep a humongous amount of value stored on an exchange. There just isn't any reason to use an exchange like a bank exept laziness. The only exception here would be market makers and maybe big-time day traders who actually have a reason to keep a ton of money on the exchange at all times. Of course, those are the most valued partners/customers for an exchange. I would think it would make sense for Coinbase to make deals with such people to give them "priority" in case of any solvency problems, or to ensure them somehow on an individual basis, but I don't know for certain that that is legally viable.

So in my point (b), in some ways, I'm vindicating what you are saying. But still, for the vast majority of people in bitcoin-land, there is no reason to have more value stored in Coinbase than what you need to do whatever you are doing.

For example, for me personally, if I transfer $10k to Coinbase, I'm not paranoid enough to be worried about their offline coins being insured. And I wouldn't transfer a large enough amount of money to really impact me financially regardless. At least, not all at once; if I really wanted to do that, I would do it in stages.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday January 27, 2015 @07:35PM (#8957237)
Apparently thousands of people are fools, then: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8948705

The fact is, consumers behave in foolish ways, and it's up to Coinbase to protect them. Yet their default protections don't. In fact, Coinbase advertises the opposite: their advertising about "insurance" gives a false sense of security.

You're smart. That's good. I wasn't, and I suffered for it.

There just isn't any reason to use an exchange like a bank exept laziness. The only exception here would be market makers and maybe big-time day traders who actually have a reason to keep a ton of money on the exchange at all times.

Not even big-time day traders. I was a day trader, and the reason to keep money on the exchange was because it took a long time for a deposit to be recognized by the system. Longer than the market opportunities existed. As far as I know, this is true for almost all exchanges due to bitcoin requiring several minutes to confirm transfers. That's why people keep a large amount on exchanges.

Re:Coinbase Exchange by jgeerts on Monday January 26, 2015 @11:47AM (#8947951)
You are completely right but from a legal standpoint their launch is very interesting either way.