DF skips over this problem because it's more abstract, and it's just not this kinds of game. Another example - Crusader Kingdoms 2 - this game is all about incests, backstabbing and assasination, but somehow it's funny not deep.
I agree it's probably not good idea for games targeted at children.
Later in the series, when I experienced what it's like to BE a Little Sister, it almost made me regret "rescuing them" before, because the way they see the world as a Little Sister is quite beautiful, and they did serve a profound purpose.
The final choice seems to be a moral absolute, but it was a deeply unsettling choice, for me, to make, and to revisit again later.
(See what I did there?)
[0] http://civilization.wikia.com/wiki/Atrocities_%28SMAC%29
I agree with the person you're replying to: having the "final solution" in a city management game would be extremely unpalatable to say the least. We do not expect mayors and city planners to behave like that.
Or say, you decide to create a police state, with full surveillance and all the like. You see everyone is happy... unitl the whole thing goes to hell - because people weren't actually happy, your metrics just were wrong.
The fact that it's illegal to give my friend a sandwich in some cities sickens me.
http://www.infowars.com/feeding-the-homeless-banned-in-major...
Edit: I realize making feeding homeless illegal and outright killing them is different -- But the tragedy of these laws is palpable. Those that vote for them either grossly misunderstand the issue, or would simply do whatever they can to get rid of homeless, or both.
There's an implied benevolence to being a sim mayor - keeping people happy and employed while keeping the city clean and profitable is "success" as defined by the game. I mean, feel free to play it however you want but that's the stated metric for the game.
(It might have been only one NPC that survived, details are fuzzy.)
Players would jump at genocide if it solved their problem. It would be an interesting result if it was not so predictable.
Just like in many RPG games you can make "evil" and "good" choices. In many instances, going with "evil" makes the game much easier - instead of doing a 2 hour long quest to find someone's lost ring, you can just kill the person and take their money you would get as a reward, so the immediate outcome is the same. But people like to roleplay and people don't make decisions just because they make the game easier.
I agree. I find that many games present the moral choices in a way that become a "what possible reward do I want" choice.
One of the best ways moral choices were presented were in Skyrim, with the Deadric Princes' quests. You usully had to do some horrible thing (murder, cannibalism, torture, etc.) and you would be rewarded with a cool magical item. The moral choice is glarangly present while not being explicitly stated. You either do the quest or you don't. And that resonated with me because I believe that while there are many motivations for being evil (selfishness, greed, desire of power, sadism), the motivation and reward for being good is itself.
Not useful for a Melee Class
Or look at few chapters of some The Witcher 2 let's play.
If your game is abstract puzzle (like simcity) then sure - few people would roleplay chess after all.
What to kill, I know shopkeepers, then I can have all the loot
@
You are deadOops