News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by wodenokoto on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:05AM (#8884918)
I'm not even sure if I would consider this fraud (personally).

I mean, if the initial outstanding orders were at risc of actually being bought and he had to deliver, then I think it is just fine that the market is naive enough to judge the worth of a company on some anonymous seller, rather than company performance and market-place condition of said company.

What's next, you start moving stock prices through twitter bots?

I think stock traders should be punished by the market place for acting on poor signals and acting like sheeps.

If he could in fact not deliver the initial sales, then not only is it fraud, but it is a broken system that allows you to put up stuff for sale that you don't own.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by joosters on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:22AM (#8884958)
It's an odd situation, for sure. After all, these share orders were being entered by humans and could have been sitting in the market order books for several seconds. In that time, anyone could have taken their orders. So they really were genuine offers to sell and buy shares.

Compare that to high frequency traders where it is alleged that 'flash' market orders are submitted and cancelled so fast that no-one could actually take them. How can that be considered OK and yet these human traders are labelled fraudulent?

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:51AM (#8885273)
>So they really were genuine offers to sell and buy shares.

They weren't genuine, that's the point. They were offers made with the express intention and hope that they never get filled.

The orders from high frequency traders in contrast are honest orders, when they are sent they honestly express that the trader wants to trade at that price. The fact that they may then be withdrawn 800 microseconds later when the HFT recalculates its price in response to some stimuli and changes its mind about the price, doesn't change the fact they were honest. They're just fast as well. That's what control systems do, they update their outputs when their inputs change.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by ars on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:03AM (#8885329)
Why does his state of mind matter? I mean it matters for criminal matters, but why for civil?

Either he actually was willing to make good on his offer or he wasn't. His reasons are irrelevant.

"hope that they never get filled" is not a reason to make this a crime. If he actually refused to fill them, then sure. But hoping?

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:30AM (#8885426)
I don't write the rules, I'm just telling you what they are. I guess it boils down to the idea that bluffing is banned in financial markets. What differentiates making a bluff from a regular raise in poker? You have to 'make good' on the bet either way, yes? The difference is that you're 'hoping' that you don't get called, 'hoping' that your opponent folds. Not allowed in markets. Probably a good thing too, or they'd be even more chaotic as they degenerate into bluff and double-bluff. Having said that spoofing is still widespread, likely because it is hard to prove and some regulators aren't as tough on it as they should be.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by FireBeyond on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:08PM (#8887516)
Saying that bluffing is not allowed is disingenuous. Why, then, are sellers allowed to break up big blocks of stocks into smaller orders to avoid triggering algorithms in the market? How is that not bluffing. "I have 1M shares to sell, but if I do that, I'm going to take a bath. But if I trickle them in, break them up, etc..." - what makes one strategy, and the other a bluff?
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:59PM (#8888246)
What you describe is called 'slow playing' in poker, not bluffing. Put it this way, if spoofing (bluffing) were legalized in markets, how do you think it would work out for the little guy? Who has the advantage in no-limit Texas hold em? The guy with the biggest chip stack bullies the pot.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:39PM (#8888113)
One is hiding what you intend to do. The other is lying about the intention.

What makes one worthy of legal rules and the other not? Don't know.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by mhomde on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:25AM (#8885779)
If you're saying that HFT algorithms don't publish trades from a pure manipulation purpose I call BS. There are many HFT firms that been caught with their hand in the cookie jar doing just that, the problem is that they are even more that hasn't.

It's really hard to prove intent when trading is done in microseconds and the truth lies somewhere in the algorithm. Those who got caught got caught mainly because of their email trail

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gizmo686 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @10:47AM (#8886939)
I would think that is is easier to prove intent in HFT (with the appropriate court orders). The source code should make it clear what the intent was.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:41PM (#8888131)
Why? Very rarely will you see something that like:

//spoofing logic goes here.

It is usually expressed in a variety of algorithms in a variety of places. Further, even getting the code is very far down the path of legal proceedings and having the expertise to suss out intent is outside of the skill set of most regulators. Looking through emails/requirements materials and/or having an informant is much more in their skill set.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by FireBeyond on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:06PM (#8887497)
I don't think this makes it fraud. Fraud would be the inability to deliver.

He is putting orders in with the intention and hope that they never get filled, but as long as they are both fillable and filled when matched, what fraud has occurred?

I can send you an offer for something with the intent and hope you won't accept it - maybe it's a lowball offer to sell my car - but as long as I sell it to you when you accept and an accord has been reached, no fraud has been committed.

(edited for tense)

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:42PM (#8888139)
Well ok, it's not fraud. But it is a securities law violation. Because this specific act is illegal.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by celticninja on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:10AM (#8885721)
that the trader did not want them filled does not mean that they could not be filled.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by BogdanCalin on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:27AM (#8884979)
That's exactly what I was thinking. When high frequency traders are doing it it's OK but when this guy tricks them into actually taking some risks it's fraud.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by joosters on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @03:36AM (#8884994)
I think the only evidence for fraud here are the recordings of the people discussing their aims of manipulating the markets. If those didn't exist then it does sound like the trades alone could never be considered market manipulation.

If that is the case, am I breaking the law if I just buy some shares and, during the phone call with my dealer, make a comment that I hope my share purchase drives the price up?

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:00AM (#8885923)
No. Hoping that your trade moves the market one way or the other is completely different than placing orders you hope never trade.

Why is it different? Because the law says it is.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by FireBeyond on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:10PM (#8887527)
"If that is the case, am I breaking the law if I just buy some shares and, during the phone call with my dealer, make a comment that I hope my share purchase drives the price up?"

And if it's not, why isn't it? Basically it's a double standard, because (most of) the markets are too cosy with HFT firms.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:44PM (#8888149)
No. Spoofing harms HFT. They would prefer if it didn't happen (well most would prefer it). If this were the case of regulatory capture by HFT firms (which are not big enough or powerful enough to capture much) they would make spoofing harder to do.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by throwaway183839 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:49AM (#8885490)
When most high frequency traders trade, they are not actively trying to manipulate the market for their own gain (in the cases where they are manipulating the market, they should of course be punished).

Most high frequency traders are trying to make money by providing liquidity, i.e. offering to buy and sell at a better price than the rest of the market. This benefits both the HFT (because they make money) and other market participants (because they can trade at lower spreads).

What these guys were doing was entering orders that they actively didn't want to trade, so that they could push around the price of the stock and repeatedly scalp a small profit. They had no intention of improving the quality of the market (either by narrowing spreads or improving price discovery). In fact they were actively making the market work less well, by impeding the process of price discovery with their "bluff" orders.

The whole point of a market is to be an efficient mechanism for matching buyers and sellers at a fair price. If someone is deliberately trying to distort the fair price, they are undermining the value of the market (and other market participants, not only HFTs, will suffer because their trades will no longer take place at the 'fair' price, but instead at the 'fair' price plus whatever direction the scalpers happen to be pushing it in at the moment).

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by BogdanCalin on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:06AM (#8885540)
95 percent of high-frequency trader orders are cancelled (so fast that nobody can take them). Some high-frequency traders have claimed to be profitable on over 99 percent of their trading days.

I don't buy the "providing liquidity" defense of HFT.

http://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2014/04/03/schwab-on-hft-grow...

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:36AM (#8885617)
>95 percent of high-frequency trader orders are cancelled

So what. 99.9999999% of the pixels blatted onto your screen aren't looked at. Why do you care?

Let's say I'm making a market in a derivative product (A), one where the price is 'derived' from the price of another product (B). By a simple equation. Let's say A = 2 * B. No one likes product A. No one trades it. Lots of people trade B. All day long B moves around. B ticks up, I have to cancel my bid and offer on A and move them up 2 ticks (I do it quickly, cos I'm an evil HFT). B ticks down, I have to cancel my bid and offer on B and move it down 2 ticks. All day long I move my quotes. No one fucking trades. 100% of my orders are cancelled and replaced on a different price.

Why do you care?

A limit order is a limit order. It isn't doing anyone any harm by being there.

>Some high-frequency traders have claimed to be profitable on over 99 percent of their trading days.

McDonalds are profitable on 100% of their trading days. Casinos are likely profitable on 99% of their trading days. If they weren't profitable they wouldn't be doing it. Market-makers like Virtu are more service providers than they are 'traders'. They are the middle men who allow others to trade and take risk, and extract a small fee for doing so. Here's a good analysis to read: http://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2014/11/13/virtus-losing-day-...

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by BogdanCalin on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @09:11AM (#8886292)
I don't have enough technical knowledge about HFT to refute your arguments.

However, thinking logically about the whole HFT business: As I understand it it's something like this:

Let's say I want to buy 100 apples at $1 a piece. A middle man comes and says: I see that you want to buy 100 apples. Let me buy them for you. Here they are (an apple is now $1.001)

Why do I need this middle man to steal from me? You will probably say that they are providing liquidity. It's still stealing and the markets had enough liquidity before the whole HFT gang came.

Maybe I'm wrong, if so please explain me why.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @09:47AM (#8886508)
That is a common but completely incorrect analogy. In the real world, the middle man is the exchange. You pay a fee to sell in their market place (and they provide assumedly acceptable value for this service, as in the modern world there are many exchanges you can take your business to).

The HFT is your counter party. When you say you want to buy apples, you are buying them from the HFT. Like any reseller, they are hoping to have bought those apples at a cheaper price than what you want to buy them, because they are a profit making enterprise. Like any reseller, the service they are providing is being able to sell you those apples right now, when you want them. They have taken on the risk and expense of finding cheaper supplies of apples and held them for the appropriate time to sell them when the price was right.

Like any reseller, you do not have to buy directly from them and pay their mark up. You just need to invest the same energy and expense that they do on supply chain to be able to get apples at cheaper prices than people want to pay. Of course, you are probably not in the apple reselling business, so it might not make sense to do this.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by throwaway283719 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:40AM (#8886111)
But McDonald's makes a profit every time I buy a cheeseburger from them. It's like the know the true price in advance, and set their prices so that they always make a profit.

The cheeseburger market is rigged.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:03AM (#8885932)
> 95 percent of high-frequency trader orders are cancelled

And how does that compare to the pit trader order cancel rates HFT replaced?

> Some high-frequency traders have claimed to be profitable on over 99 percent of their trading days

Are these same traders potentially working on an IPO deal? How about being acquired.

Lets put it this way, it is trivially easy to come up with a strategy that is profitable (also just FYI they mean the buy/sell made money, they dont count their operations cost in that) on 99% of days. Its that 1% that wipes out your whole company that is hard to avoid.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by rtpg on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:32AM (#8885206)
I don't get it, why is it that market orders don't have a lifetime?

I know we used to have a granularity on price that was pretty thick, what would be the issue with having an order have to be on the market for at least a second? I have my doubts about sub-second trading increasing liquidity and making the markets more effecient

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:44AM (#8885245)
The issue would be that market makers would need to inject their orders (quotes) at a greater distance from the mid-price, in order to protect themselves against market movement during the minimum lifetime you propose. If my bid and offer is obligated to sit in the market for x seconds, then it is potentially a sitting duck for any adverse event during that time period, and I would have to quote wider to cover that possibility.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by yummyfajitas on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:01AM (#8885531)
You can take an order, at least probabilistically.

Suppose an HFT has an order on the market from 0.30 to 0.40. If you submit an order at 0.00, your order will arrive at some time uniformly distributed between 0.00 and 1.00. With probability 0.1 you'll get a fill.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by lmm on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:19AM (#8885388)
The order book would quickly become a tragedy of the commons - everyone's free to add quotes to it, and doing so costs everyone else. In a perfect frictionless free market maybe exchanges could charge appropriately to put in an order, and rebate the proceeds to people who use the order book. But that's probably impractical (if nothing else, people would send their orders to other exchanges), and would create bad incentives; we'd lose the public good of the displayed, honest order book.

> If he could in fact not deliver the initial sales, then not only is it fraud, but it is a broken system that allows you to put up stuff for sale that you don't own.

Real world commerce works on trust and sometimes retroactive enforcement. If I order ten tons of timber, the world doesn't force the person selling it to prove they have it in stock, I just get to sue them if they don't deliver. Somehow it all manages to work out.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by throwaway183839 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:41AM (#8885470)
Here's an interesting proposal - you charge a small amount (e.g. 0.001 of a cent) for every single order placement and rebate the proceeds to all market participants in proportion to how much volume they actually traded.

People who enter many quotes that they never trade on would be punished by this system (human traders and "flickering" high frequency traders alike) whereas people providing genuine liquidity, in the form of long-lasting quotes at a good price that they intend to trade, will benefit.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by yummyfajitas on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:56AM (#8885516)
This is already done. There is an per-order fee and a per-trade fee. All your proposal would do is shift the balance slightly between these fees.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by throwaway283719 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @08:43AM (#8886129)
What markets is this done on? On most markets that I'm aware of, there is a fee for passive trades and a fee for aggressive trades. Sometimes the fee for a passive trade is negative (a rebate) which encourages liquidity provision, but I don't know of any market that actually charges per order, and then rebates that proportionally to the liquidity providers.

One proviso is that I've never worked on US equity markets, so if this rule is in place there then I wouldn't know about it.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by yummyfajitas on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @09:01AM (#8886227)
In US markets there is a (very small) per-order fee.

There are also rolling windows and disconnections for people who go crazy with quote spam or have low fill rates.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @04:37AM (#8885231)
No, it is definitely fraud. The rule is that you may not enter an order (quote) that you have no intention of filling. You're perfectly entitled to change your mind afterwards (for whatever reason) and then cancel the order, but if you send an order with the initial objective of never having it execute, it is a fraudulent order and and a case of market manipulation.

Always hard to prove though, since it goes to the intention of the market participant.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by mapt on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:14AM (#8885372)
Pardon my ignorance, but why is it possible to change your mind afterward and cancel the order? Why does the market not clear orders irrevocably (executing automatically) as soon as they are matched? Why this "sending" disengaged from actual market actions?
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by throwaway183839 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:38AM (#8885459)
The market clears any matching orders in effectively zero time (that is, it runs its matching algorithm to clear the book before it allows any new quotes to enter).

After an order is matched, you can't cancel it except in exceptional circumstances (for example, you mistakenly entered an order very far from the bbo - in that case, with the cooperation of your broker and the counterparty to your trade, you may be able to unwind it).

However before the order is matched you are free to cancel it if you decide you no longer want to trade at that price (for example, you see some change in the fundamentals of the stock that causes you to no longer want to buy, or simply that the price moves in such a way that a buy/sell at your original price no longer looks like good value).

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by mapt on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:54AM (#8885507)
So if I offer a trade, and then withdraw the trade because I decide I don't like the idea anymore (or 'any other reason')... that's legal. And routine to do on microsecond timescales.

But offering a trade, and then withdrawing the trade manually a few seconds later because I never intended to execute the trade... that's not legal?

What was the original rational for creating this class of thoughtcrime? Why does it criminalize intent, while the action is perfectly routine, and the outcomes are the same either way? There is, after all, the risk of someone actually calling your bluff and buying your sell order, or selling into your buy order, which is cleared instantly... so where's the fraud?.

Doesn't HTF presuppose that we are hard-coding this behavior, this tactic, into the trading algorithms of automated traders?

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @06:23AM (#8885586)
>So if I offer a trade, and then withdraw the trade because I decide I don't like the idea anymore (or 'any other reason')... that's legal. And routine to do on microsecond timescales.

Yes that's right. So quickly you may as well assume that they are updating the price they are willing to buy/sell continuously in realtime. Which is the idea. And because they are updating their prices continuously and accurately, they can keep the gap between those two prices as small as possible. For some bizarre reason, this is the only field in all of technology where HN contributors get freaked out by this. Name a control system that doesn't update its outputs frequently.

>But offering a trade, and then withdrawing the trade manually a few seconds later because I never intended to execute the trade... that's not legal?

Yes that's right. Markets work on trust, if you don't actually want to buy/sell what you're claiming you want to buy/sell then you are lying. More importantly, if you don't want to trade, what are you doing putting the order in? What does that leave as your motivation? Manipulation, that's what. Which is illegal. It's very hard to define market manipulation, but that's just about the easiest way I can think of - can you think of a simpler definition? They have to settle on some way of describing it, and it's not unusual for crimes to be defined by intent.

>Doesn't HTF presuppose that we are hard-coding this behavior, this tactic, into the trading algorithms of automated traders?

I don't follow

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by FireBeyond on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @12:24PM (#8887642)
"Markets work on trust, if you don't actually want to buy/sell what you're claiming you want to buy/sell then you are lying."

No, that's patently not true. If you are UNWILLING, or UNABLE, to execute a trade when matched, then you are lying.

Plenty of people "don't actually want" to buy/sell, every day - using that phrasing, you could point to people who are forced to cover shorts or dump a stock as it plummets to recoup some of their losses.

"I don't want to sell this stock at this price, but I WILL" should never be considered fraud - for the very least reason that it opens a deep rabbit hole into a form of thought crime that really, do many market participants want opened - when they're asked to explain, with a straight face and credulity, what their market strategies are really intended to do.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:54PM (#8888223)
You seem to be mixing up different levels of wanting and intention. I may not want to eat my brussel sprouts for dinner, but when I poke them with a fork and raise them towards my mouth I am intending to eat them. Not pull them away at the last second. I'm sure no one enjoys dumping a stock as it plummets, or wants to dump a stock when it plummets, but when they are actually carrying out the process of selling that stock, then they do want the trade to go through. It is their intention to successfully complete the sale of the stock. That's what we're referring to.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by kasey_junk on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @01:47PM (#8888186)
> "I don't want to sell this stock at this price, but I WILL" should never be considered fraud

A) it isn't fraud, it is order spoofing, which is precisely defined to be based on intention.

B) lots of our legal system is based on intention. It is a common aspect, not a rabbit hole.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by mapt on Thursday January 15, 2015 @04:22PM (#8895449)
Every single trade is market manipulation. Actions have effects, regardless of intent.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by StavrosK on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:38AM (#8885822)
Because there may be a request in the system already for the price you offered, which means that your trade will go through immediately when it gets offered, and you won't be able to take it back, even in microseconds.

If any amount of time passes, it's considered to just "be sitting there", so you can change your mind and cancel it. Microseconds isn't the same as no time at all, when you can pre-issue buy or sell orders that will get filled at the very instant a matching order goes in.

Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by Mvandenbergh on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:32AM (#8885437)
You can't cancel them after they're matched, these cancellations happen while they're sitting around waiting for someone to take them.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by gd1 on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @05:32AM (#8885443)
These are limit orders under discussion, you seem to be confusing them with market orders.
Re:Spoofers Tricked High-Speed Traders by Hitting Keys Fast by justincormack on Wednesday January 14, 2015 @07:33AM (#8885803)
People are already trying to move stock/fx prices via twitter bots...