Either he actually was willing to make good on his offer or he wasn't. His reasons are irrelevant.
"hope that they never get filled" is not a reason to make this a crime. If he actually refused to fill them, then sure. But hoping?
What makes one worthy of legal rules and the other not? Don't know.
It's really hard to prove intent when trading is done in microseconds and the truth lies somewhere in the algorithm. Those who got caught got caught mainly because of their email trail
//spoofing logic goes here.
It is usually expressed in a variety of algorithms in a variety of places. Further, even getting the code is very far down the path of legal proceedings and having the expertise to suss out intent is outside of the skill set of most regulators. Looking through emails/requirements materials and/or having an informant is much more in their skill set.
He is putting orders in with the intention and hope that they never get filled, but as long as they are both fillable and filled when matched, what fraud has occurred?
I can send you an offer for something with the intent and hope you won't accept it - maybe it's a lowball offer to sell my car - but as long as I sell it to you when you accept and an accord has been reached, no fraud has been committed.
(edited for tense)
They weren't genuine, that's the point. They were offers made with the express intention and hope that they never get filled.
The orders from high frequency traders in contrast are honest orders, when they are sent they honestly express that the trader wants to trade at that price. The fact that they may then be withdrawn 800 microseconds later when the HFT recalculates its price in response to some stimuli and changes its mind about the price, doesn't change the fact they were honest. They're just fast as well. That's what control systems do, they update their outputs when their inputs change.