News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by icantthinkofone on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:05AM (#8734489)
Theft is theft, not free speech.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by tomp on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:16AM (#8734531)
Theft is a concept that originates from our definition of "property". I oppose the legal definition that copyright == property; I agree that a reasonably short copyright term can encourage the creation of art, but what we have now is outrageous and I don't think the trade-off makes sense for the public.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by canvia on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:38AM (#8734905)
The copyright system worked fine until it was corrupted by corporate bribery of government officials: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by k-mcgrady on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:30AM (#8734592)
>> "I oppose the legal definition that copyright == property"

How about a definition like - "If I create something, I own it and have the right to profit from it." Why should my right to profit from what I create have a limited term? Why should it be ok for someone to copy it just because they have the ability to?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by AndrewDucker on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:35AM (#8734604)
Why should the person who first arrange a series of words in a particular order have the power to prevent other people from arranging words into the same order, in perpetuity?

Copyright prevents the free speech of others. There's some justification for it doing so. But it's not a natural, or absolute, right.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by webXL on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:26AM (#8734840)
The power to prevent others from copying the arrangement is an incentive to arrange in the first place. But it should be limited. Property rights allow me to restrict your speech when your literally on my government sanctioned land. I don't see much difference when it comes to IP.

Edit: copyright should be more limited than physical property rights, so I'm in agreement. But neither can be absolute when the government only has a piece of paper to abide by that prevents them from being revoked.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by k-mcgrady on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:45AM (#8734645)
There are exceptions to copyright to minimise the impact on free speech (satire, news for example). I guess people's opinions on this will ultimately come down to their views on free speech and that varies throughout the world.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by sp332 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:01AM (#8735045)
The US Constitution does not recognize ideas as property. Copyrights and patents are limited-time incentives which may be granted by the government to encourage creativity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Clause

Also, satire isn't protected, but parody is.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by k-mcgrady on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:32AM (#8735261)
The US constitution does not effect me. Thanks for the correction on satire/parody, got them mixed up.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by rjaco31 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:30AM (#8734858)
DMCA is pretty sloppy when it comes to separate copyright infringement from satire..
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by the8472 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:46AM (#8734652)
Your "right to profit" only exists in so far that you can try to profit from it, but naturally that might fail if someone takes your idea and implements it cheaper.

Copyright is only a government-granted, temporary monopoly on that idea to incentivize you to live from creating them in the first place and to create more.

Once you have given your idea to someone else, where does your natural right come from to control what they do with it?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by sp332 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:57AM (#8735019)
Thomas Jefferson disagreed with you.

He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper [candle] at mine, receives light without darkening me. That ideas should freely spread from one to another over the globe, for the moral and mutual instruction of man, and improvement of his condition, seems to have been peculiarly and benevolently designed by nature.... Inventions then cannot, in nature, be a subject of property.

http://www.temple.edu/lawschool/dpost/mcphersonletter.html

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by scardine on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:01AM (#8734705)
The very idea of idea ownership is a dangerous one. Because most ideas are compositions of other ideas; should you pay if you write a poem because someone else invented the concept of poems?
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:02AM (#8734711)
>Why should my right to profit from what I create have a limited term?

This is a much broader question about the rationale behind copyright law and the concept of intellectual property. It is really beyond the scope of the question posed (is copyright violation theft?).

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by izolate on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:17AM (#8734779)
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe."

You are not born in isolation from the rest of us. Everything you create originated from an idea that you learned from somebody else. You have no right of ownership over something that is not entirely yours.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by jkaunisv1 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:57AM (#8735022)
So if you make an apple pie, you don't mind that I come and steal it from your windowsill? You don't own it, after all.

What if you spend a year making a beautiful cabinet? You didn't invent the tree, or the saw, so it's okay if I come by and cart the cabinet over to my house, right?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by anthony_d on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:50AM (#8734981)
That's an argument against the entire idea of personal property. Maybe that's what you want but it's going to be a really tough sell.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by dragonwriter on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:13AM (#8735124)
> That's an argument against the entire idea of personal property.

It doesn't seem to be inherently an argument against the entire idea of "personal property", it seems to be inherently an argument against the idea that property (personal, real, or otherwise) is a matter of absolute right, rather than a matter of an exchange in which owners are granted privilege at the expense of restrictions on everyone else's freedom because of a perceived social benefit to that exchange -- where the parameters, then, of the particular privileges of owners become subject to analysis of whether the exchange really does have net social value.

In regards to intellectual property of the types dependent, in US law, on the Constitution's so-called "Copyright Clause", this is pretty explicitly the premise in the US Constitutional system; in addition, the differences in the privileges and limitations of real and personal property rights (and the particular parameters of particular subclasses of each), as well as things like eminent domain, are very hard to conceptualize under a model of property-as-absolute-right unless you simply define each feature as its own axiom of property rights, except the ones you don't like and define them as violations of axiomatic rights, whereas the whole regime of property rights and its evolution makes a lot more sense under a social benefit exchange view with an evolving view of what provisions actually provide social benefit.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by amalcon on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:20AM (#8734800)
Why should you have that right in the first place?

Note that I agree that you should (or, rather, that as a society we should make sure that it's possible under reasonable conditions), but my reason for agreement is not able to justify perpetual copyright.

My reasoning happens to be similar to what the U.S. Constitution says, but I can imagine others having different reasoning for the same idea.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by sangnoir on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:20AM (#8734550)
What is your opinion of the people who shared the DeCSS key? If "46DCEAD317FE45D80923EB97E4956410D4CDB2C2" is free speech, so is a magnet URI
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by gambiting on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:45AM (#8734647)
Let's say you wrote a book and writing books is your only means of putting food on the table - and then one day you sit next to someone on the train who is reading a scanned copy of your book on their tablet. You ask them about it, and they say "yeah I don't buy books really, I downloaded this off torrents". Sure, the book they have is not "stolen" per se, but would you personally not feel like someone "stole" at least some of your work from you?

I believe that this is a very interesting entry point to a discussion, because the immediate reply to this is - that library books don't generate any extra income to the author. And that is also true. But I feel like even without calling it theft it is not entirely fair.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by the8472 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:02AM (#8734712)
> writing books is your only means of putting food on the table

That's a strange assumption. Many authors fail, or only produce works in their spare time and work other jobs. I mean there's no fundamental right to be a successful author who can live off selling books.

Of course as a society we find it desirable to create an environment where artists can make a living from their works and create more art. That's why copyright exists. It's a tradeoff, all citizens are required to respect the creations of others in exchange for the opportunity for everyone to dedicate their lives to it and make an income with it. (Note: It's just an opportunity to make profit, not a right to profit)

But that societal contract gets perverted by commercial interests to the point where people stop seeing copyright as something positive and instead will refuse to adhere to it.

The internet making copying so much easier than ever before also skews that tradeoff by making it much more difficult for everyone to respect copyright. Breaking copyright is even easier than jaywalking and I don't think private citizens will stop anytime soon.

So ultimately that scheme to incentivize people to be creative used to be "fair", but now that view has somewhat shifted. And the system needs an overhaul.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by vidarh on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:57AM (#8735758)
I'd very much expect most authors that focus on literature rather than short-form paid-by-the-word non-fiction-work to fail or only receive a minority of their income from writing.

Becoming a writer to make money off literature is pretty much like playing the lottery - the odds are badly stacked against you; if you have "success" most of the time you'll make a pittance, and only a tiny proportion of the people who are successful make it big.

If anything, current incentive structures created by current copyright are bad for most people in the creative fields, as the "hit culture" means they're heavily geared towards disproportionally rewarding a very small subset of people. While the hope of striking it big may lure some people to create, I'm more concerned that the bad odds of being able to make ends meet puts a lot of very creative people off those career choices.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by fnordfnordfnord on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:33AM (#8734879)
I think very few people feel that depriving some person of the fruits of his or her labor in the way that you describe is a moral or ethical thing to do. But, it is by definition not theft. Perhaps some new law, or some changes to law are needed to fairly deal with the problem. Treating it as theft is an abuse of the law.

I think it is interesting that you use a hypothetical author as an example since even before technology showed up and wrecked the party, copyright law arguably failed (or at least was never very good) at its supposed purpose.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by clarry on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:22AM (#8734819)
> would you personally not feel like someone "stole" at least some of your work from you?

Absolutely not. If anything, I would be flattered to meet somebody actually reading my book, and I'd probably be eager to have a chat with him, maybe ask for opinions and perhaps tell him about other books I'm working on, if it looks like he could be interested. That'd be an event that could make me very happy.

The reality is that nobody seems to be interested in what I do. Should I feel I'm being treated unfair by all the people in the train who never bought and never used my stuff? Never even heard of me?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by pestaa on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:28AM (#8734852)
Meanwhile, your family could be starving because you could sell exactly zero copies...
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by clarry on Thursday December 11, 2014 @02:25PM (#8736590)
I can't blame people for not wanting to buy my stuff. I'm not entitled to any sales. They don't have to.

So if I'm starving, it's not the fault of the people who aren't interested in buying my stuff. Calling them thieves solves nothing.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by gambiting on Friday December 12, 2014 @04:49AM (#8739273)
They don't have to buy it, but it doesn't change the fact that they are using your work without paying you. It's the same as if you were a street painter selling your work, and someone comes around and takes a picture of what you painted and says "naaah, I'll just print it at home, rather than giving you $50 for it". You are not entitled to any sales. But that person took your work without paying. You have no right to demand that he pays for it, but he had no right to take it without paying.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by egil on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:37AM (#8734609)
I adore them for their pronunciation skills if they literally shared it through speech. (Sorry, I had to :) )
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by hedwall on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:17AM (#8734534)
And he never was jailed for theft, he was jailed for aiding copyright infringement.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by boomlinde on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:31AM (#8734594)
Theft is theft, but copyright infringement isn't.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by jordigh on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:21AM (#8734562)
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by lazylizard on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:19AM (#8734791)
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by the8472 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @08:14AM (#8734524)
529C39CC24553DFE030119BD35E19884F34A65E0

Free speech or theft?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by terrence_giggy on Thursday December 11, 2014 @09:52AM (#8734994)
Context matters. I can yell FIRE in my own home, but I can't go into a crowded theatre and yell it. The hash as you post it here is meaningless. But elsewhere it could be the key to another's property.
Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by the8472 on Thursday December 11, 2014 @10:27AM (#8735220)
Personally I think you should be free to yell "FIRE" in a theater too. If that started a panic and someone came to harm due to it then you might be held partially responsible to that harm, but so should those people who mindlessly trample on others without assessing the situation.

But if nothing happened then there should be no reason to make your exclamation illegal.

Of course you could still be thrown out of the theater for disrupting the performance, providing further disincentive for doing something like that, but that's separate from the legality of your speech.

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by ultramancool on Thursday December 11, 2014 @02:09PM (#8736507)
> The hash as you post it here is meaningless. But elsewhere it could be the key to another's property.

Not really, anyone who knows the basic structure of a magnet link can go...

magnet:?xt=urn:btih:529C39CC24553DFE030119BD35E19884F34A65E0

And it's perfectly useful. Paste it into any BT client, wind up with a copy of... Windows 7 it looks like. Practically the same as finding the link on TPB.

So, is this another's property or not? Did I just make it by appending a short string to turn it into a URL?

Re:Peter Sunde: 'I went to jail for my cause. What did you do?' by 0x5f3759df-i on Thursday December 11, 2014 @11:47AM (#8735704)
So piracy is fine if done in my own home?