News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by JeffL on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:01PM (#8706206)
How does this compare to what SpaceX is doing? Does it make sense for NASA to be doing this in parallel with Dragon?
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by trhway on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:45PM (#8706788)
>Does it make sense for NASA to be doing this in parallel with Dragon?

it is called competition - a best known way to get 2 of something at the total cost of 2X when otherwise it would be only 1 inferior version of that something at the cost of 10X

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by InclinedPlane on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:12PM (#8707226)
In my opinion, Orion is pretty much worthless, although that's a strong opinion. Realistically it is at the very least a hugely flawed program.

Orion has no mission yet, it's really just a component of a larger system, but that larger system hasn't been designed or funded.

Worse, Orion has several design flaws that limit its usefulness. For example, it's designed with an old-fashioned tractor abort system, a huge solid fueled rocket that will be attached to the capsule during launches. However, in most realistic scenarios the crew for a mission that would use Orion would not actually be launched from Earth on Orion, rendering that feature nearly useless. Except that it's a feature that takes away literal tons of useful hardware from the spacecraft since it is a heavy (7.5 tonnes) component that steals payload mass from the rest of the vehicle.

That sort of issue is endemic to the entire Orion project, and even worse for SLS. It's a hugely expensive hypothetically useful system designed around hypothetical constraints for missions that haven't even been designed, let alone funded, yet. Realistically it'll probably end up not being useful for whatever mission architectures we end up with for future manned interplanetary missions, and more flexible designs or newer systems are, I suspect, far more likely to be useful and practical when that time comes.

Orion is particularly interesting since it's sort of the cornerstone of a potential manned Mars mission. But when you compare it against competing designs such as SpaceX's "MCT" architecture there is about 1-2 orders of magnitude greater cost, significantly greater complexity, and yet less capability. At this point there is a very high likelihood that no human crew will ever end up in an Orion spacecraft, and the more likely outcome is that the project will be abandoned prior to anything interesting happening with it.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by danielweber on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:15PM (#8707236)
[ ] has no mission yet, it's really just a component of a larger system, but that larger system hasn't been designed or funded

Fill in the blank and you've described a good fraction of NASA's technology over the past 20 years.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by smacktoward on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:01PM (#8707168)
Sky & Telescope editor Kelly Beatty drew a pretty strong distinction between the two in an interview on the public radio show Here & Now a couple days back (http://hereandnow.wbur.org/2014/12/03/nasa-orion-mars):

INTERVIEWER JEREMY HOBSON: Do you think it's possible that the private sector beats NASA in getting to Mars?

BEATTY: Not with people.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by catfish on Friday December 05, 2014 @08:54PM (#8708062)
BEATTY is wrong of course. SpaceX entire premise is the mission to Mars. By the time Orion ferries its first astronaut to space, SpaceX will be the low cost operator to the ISS.

Orion uses a parachute to land, Red Dragon will use Super Draco based thrusters to land.

Nasa throws away the tanks used to get Orion to Space, SpaceX will land the tanks and reuse them to lower overall mission cost.

Nasa spent 60 billion dollars to get this far, won't be ready to test its new SLS system for 3-5 years, won't fly a human for 10+ years. SpaceX will fly astronauts to space by 2017.

SpaceX spent 3 billion getting this far and resupplies the ISS. Multiple times.

Beatty is short sighted and underestimates Elon Musk.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by ghayes on Friday December 05, 2014 @09:12PM (#8708093)
I hope you're right about the future, but I wouldn't be so confident in what hasn't yet happened.

Alternatively, SpaceX hasn't launched people into space; NASA has. SpaceX hasn't launched a space station; NASA (and others) have. NASA has larger budgets, but they solve that problem by having larger budgets.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by danielweber on Friday December 05, 2014 @10:18PM (#8708227)
NASA doesn't have any hardware to put people into space, either. The Orion is them trying to get back into that business, which is just what SpaceX is trying to get into.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by jkimmel on Saturday December 06, 2014 @12:32PM (#8709640)
I'm bullish on SpaceX when it comes to launch systems and vehicles, but to the best of my knowledge they haven't demonstrated any expertise in Life Support Systems.

The hardest part about getting to Mars isn't flinging a metal tube off the Earth. That part we know how to do.

The hard part is keeping people alive for 6 months there, 6 months back, and providing all the equipment necessary to do meaningful science on the surface.

This isn't to say that an adequate launch system isn't essential to the mission, but I would be very surprised if SpaceX developed life support systems independently and more efficiently than NASA. More likely, I can imagine a news headline in which a SpaceX rocket sends a NASA capsule and living module to an off-world mission.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by Joeri on Saturday December 06, 2014 @03:27PM (#8710073)
Why wouldn't SpaceX be capable of doing life support systems? What's so magically complicated about those compared to the rockets themselves? You have to be aware of the shifting goal posts scenario here. At every stop people said SpaceX wasn't going to be able to do what they were going to do, because there was some kind of magic fairy dust that only government space organizations have. And each time that they achieve a milestone, people just keep shifting the goalposts. They've already done things NASA was never able to do, like build a reusable rocket and land it vertically. Clearly they are more capable than NASA in some ways. Personally, I think SpaceX will be able to do everything they say they will do, up to and including putting people on Mars. They've come this far, why wouldn't they go all the way?
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by jccooper on Saturday December 06, 2014 @06:34PM (#8710608)
That's about entirely backwards. Flinging a metal tube off of Earth is much harder than keeping a few apes alive in a can. The tolerances and requirements in rocketry are much more severe, the dimensions unfortunately super-human scale, and the ability to test the system limited by the scale, expense, and speed of the final product, not to mention the usually-100% chance of destroying your machine in the process. (Even reusable systems, which are rare, are expensive to run simply due to scale.)

The actual spacecraft part is easy in comparison. It's of reasonable dimension, you can test and fiddle with it on the ground, and plenty of common practice is available due to submarines and high-altitude aircraft as well as decades of continuous operation in space.

The history of manned space systems will present plenty of examples of the booster being the pacing element. But we don't have to look much further than the very system we're talking about here. Orion is ready and flying a projected 4 years (and probably longer in reality) before its booster. And that's not because they got a head start.

That's not to say that rockets and manned space craft are similar problem domains; they're not. Any expertise SpaceX will need in that area will have to be developed separately. But the techniques are well known (thanks largely to NASA, who make no secret of it) and are just plain not that hard. They're already flying a pressurized and temperature-controlled Dragon (which spends time as part of the ISS), and are in development of a crewed one.

It is true that SpaceX has yet to operate any space stations, which NASA has, and which are the closest analogues we have to an interplanetary spacecraft. But again, ISS systems are a known quantity, and SpaceX could easily replicate them. Or, if they don't want to bother, could contract with Bigelow, who is currently flying two (unmanned) pressurized space stations, with designs for manned versions ready to go and awaiting a way to get there. SpaceX and Bigelow have already announced plans to partner for orbital station operations.

A Dragon and a Bigelow station would provide a nice ride to Mars. Getting to the surface and back would be a bit of a problem, but a SpaceX/Bigelow team could possibly land on Phobos and return in the next 5 years. And on a darn low budget, too. If you want to walk on Mars without too much tech development, Dragon 2 should be able to land just as it does on Earth. Dunno how you'd get back up, though. Maybe you could land a Falcon-ish booster loaded with a storable oxidizer (like peroxide) on little enough juice that it could get back into orbit. Haven't looked into the numbers there; F9-1 is certainly single stage to orbit on Mars, but down-and-up on the same fuel load seems unlikely. It'd certainly work with ISRU propellants, but that's a nice can of worms.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by mmanfrin on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:03PM (#8706215)
SpaceX is building a shuttle to get people to orbit and back -- Orion is meant to get people to Mars. I think the scale is different.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by ChuckMcM on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:21PM (#8706321)
Actually SpaceX is also building a system to get people to Mars and back. It is focused on the current money making opportunities however.

I've not heard whether or not SpaceX has done the on-pad abort test they were planning for last month.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by yock on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:42PM (#8706437)
There hasn't been any official word, as far as I know, but the rumor has been that the pad abort originally intended for November might happen in January sometime.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by cdash on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:36PM (#8707059)
This is not really true either. Orion can in no way shape or form get anyone to Mars. Maybe a modified Orion will be used as part of a plan to take humans to Mars but it is not capable of that on its own.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by knorby on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:08PM (#8707206)
Yep, the Mars line is sales. NASA has been aiming for the moon as a more realistic possibility with this thing, which is why they rebuilt Apollo with modern rockets.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by mmanfrin on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:02PM (#8707174)
"Orion, which could one day take astronauts to Mars..." [1]

"NASA just tested Orion — a spacecraft that might someday carry people to Mars" [2]

"NASA and its commercial partners are designing Orion to take astronauts to a near-Earth asteroid in the 2020s, and to Mars and its moons in the 2030s" [3]

"Orion will facilitate human exploration of the Moon, asteroids, and Mars." [4]

"This time, the rocket was unnamed, but the craft is designed eventually to carry humans to Mars" [5]

[1] http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2014/12/05/368652770/a-s...

[2] http://www.vox.com/2014/12/3/7322909/orion-test-flight

[3] http://www.nbcnews.com/science/space/splashdown-orion-spaces...

[4] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orion_%28spacecraft%29

[5] http://www.theguardian.com/science/2014/dec/05/nasa-launches...

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by danielweber on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:22PM (#8707267)
You are repeating news sources that are repeating press releases.

The Orion has less than 214 square feet of room. This isn't enough for 4 people to live in for 6 months.

NASA says it's for Mars because it gets people excited. But Congress has not instructed them to do a mission to Mars, and Congress is in charge, for better or for worse. There is no mission to Mars.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by ceejayoz on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:11PM (#8707489)
I would expect a Mars mission to be coupled to a living space during transit. Bigelow's inflatable modules might be a good fit, and they're testing one soon on the ISS.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by sehugg on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:00PM (#8707438)
Orion was originally designed for extended lunar missions. There were studies that envisioned it as a component of asteroid missions. Probably there are studies applying it to Mars, but I'm not aware of those.

http://www.universetoday.com/88434/human-mission-to-an-aster...

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by colordrops on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:04PM (#8707453)
The majority of news sources are commonly just echo chambers. They all repeat the same incorrect improperly sourced information regularly.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by shmerl on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:05PM (#8706232)
Aren't SpaceX also working on the Mars mission long term? How are they addressing the interplanetary flight?
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by guardian5x on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:11PM (#8706265)
Maybe in the very longterm. SpaceX is at the moment in orbit where NASA was in the 60s. Going to the moon is a much greater distance than most people imagine. Not even speaking of Mars.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by TkTech on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:23PM (#8706339)
All of the planets in our solar system, including the gas giants, fit between the earth and the moon with a little bit of room to spare.

http://i.imgur.com/CLqdeKf.jpg

People severely underestimate the distance to the moon!

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by Lambdanaut on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:42PM (#8706436)
For some more perspective. The layman should know that actually getting into Low Earth Orbit is BY FAR the most fuel-consuming burn of any rocket mission. Even on a mission to Mars, the most predominantly fuel-consuming burn will be to LEO.

Getting to the moon from LEO takes less than half the delta-v that it takes to get to LEO, and WAY less fuel (because by this time you've dropped so much weight getting to LEO)

So the real problem will always be the stupidly inefficient method by which we conduct space flight. We send all of our supplies out of an enormous gravity well with a thick atmosphere.

Imagine what we could build if we already had everything in space for us already.

The only way we'll be able to become truly space-fairing is if we either become an astroid-mining civilization, or if we build something that lets us virtually ignore Earth's gravity well, like a space elevator.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by azernik on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:56PM (#8706849)
This is all true, and is all well and good for unmanned space exploration (yes, getting to LEO is halfway to anywhere), but for manned spaceflight time is also expensive - every day spent in flight adds mass for life support and supplies, and also increases the human risk of a failure.

For yet more perspective - an astronaut on the ISS in LEO is at most a couple of hours from the ground-based facilities in an emergency, probably more accessible than researchers at the South Pole. Sending people to Mars (on the order of magnitude of a year round trip, with very limited opportunities for early return) would require them to carry with them not only more expensive redundant systems, but also more advanced medical equipment and repair systems than anyone has had to carry into space before (which requires yet more mass, and hence a bigger and better launcher).

Of course, Orion itself doesn't deal with any of these issues - it's meant to be used for ascent and Earth return only, and to be attached to the larger systems that deal with the challenges of a Mars journey. Which indicates pretty well how little of the engineering work has been done towards NASA's Mars mission.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by grecy on Friday December 05, 2014 @08:35PM (#8708003)
> So the real problem will always be the stupidly inefficient method by which we conduct space flight. We send all of our supplies out of an enormous gravity well with a thick atmosphere.

True, but it doesn't actually cost very much to do so. The cost of fuel for getting into orbit is only 0.3% of the total cost for the rocket [1], so if we could rapidly re-use them, we could potentially launch them every day of the year for not a lot of money.

[1]http://www.space.com/21386-spacex-reusable-rockets-cost.html

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by CodeGenie on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:42PM (#8706778)
I ask you this question because you seem to know what you're talking about, whereas I simply don't.

Watching the launch today, I couldn't help wonder why they don't use standard jets to get the vehicle to a height where a rocket could take over.

The highest a jet has flown is about 37km and LEO is considered to start at about 160km. That 37km though in my mind would be the toughest and most fuel costly to ascend.

Would it not save both weight and money to use jets and fixed wings up through the low altitudes before turning to rockets for the higher altitude ascent?

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by ash on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:20PM (#8706970)
"The reason it's hard to get to orbit isn't that space is high up. It's hard to get to orbit because you have to go so fast."

https://what-if.xkcd.com/58/

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by keypusher on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:20PM (#8707261)
I don't entirely buy this. You don't get to go any slower if you are going to Mars, which is not orbiting the Earth in any way. Or if I just want to escape Earth orbit and go drift in space, why do I need to be moving fast relative to the Earth? Why can't I be moving slowly but steadily away?
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by scott_s on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:21PM (#8707522)
Everyone's responses are spot-on. But I can understand that it still may not be intuitive to you.

The difficulty is that we see pictures and videos of our satellites and shuttles in orbit, and they look peaceful and serene. What's missing from those images and videos is a visceral feel that they are going over 17,000 mph. If they went less, they would leave orbit, and hit the Earth.

Objects in orbit are not "outside" of Earth's gravity; they are not just up there, just floating in space. The reason they don't "fall to Earth" is that they are falling to Earth. Constantly. It's just that their horizontal speed relative to the Earth is so large that they are - literally - falling around the Earth.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by dragonwriter on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:26PM (#8707292)
> Or if I just want to escape Earth orbit and go drift in space, why do I need to be moving fast relative to the Earth?

Because gravity. If you aren't going fast relative to Earth, you aren't going to escape Earth orbit [0]. Heck, if you aren't going fast relative to Earth, you aren't even going to be in Earth orbit [1], you are going to be falling back to the surface.

[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escape_velocity

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_speed

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by lukeschlather on Friday December 05, 2014 @10:00PM (#8708190)
The premise of your question is wrong. If you are in Earth orbit, you are moving fast. It's actually being in orbit that allows you to move slowly away, because you can take as long as you want to apply the force. If you're not in orbit you have to quickly apply enough force to escape Earth's influence in one go or you will fall back to Earth.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by jameshart on Saturday December 06, 2014 @10:56AM (#8709403)
I can highly recommend having a play with Kerbal Space Program to get an intuitive grasp of orbital mechanics.

Basically, if you don't go fast enough, you're going to come back down to earth. Once you get to a speed that's fast enough that you aren't going to come back to earth, you'll find you are now in orbit around the sun, in a path remarkably similar to the one the earth is on. To get to Mars you need to get up into a higher orbit around the sun, so you need to go even faster.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by wiredfool on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:06PM (#8706893)
It's not the height, it's the speed. (Though, Virgin is trying something like this for their rocket).

LEO isn't that far away, but it goes by _really_ quickly. And getting going that fast requires a lot of propellant mass, and that's judged by the tyranny of the rocket equation.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by drgath on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:04PM (#8706877)
That's pretty much the approach of Virgin Galactic. Reasons why it works for them, but not for NASA would have to be explained by someone more qualified. I do know that VG barely gets into LEO, whereas NASA's requirements are much higher. In any case, I presume the scientists at NASA (and SpaceX & co) have considered just about every alternative, and the current approach still remains the most efficient for their needs.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by danielweber on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:31PM (#8707313)
Orbital Sciences is doing something similar, IIRC.

They are the two big approaches to cheap space being done now. 1) Be cost-effective at making rockets, 2) launch from jets. My money is on #1, which SpaceX is doing, but #2 has some things going for it that could prove me wrong. #2 is also strictly limited in just how big you can make a payload, while for #1 you can get up to around 200 ton payloads before things start working against you.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by danieldyer on Friday December 05, 2014 @08:03PM (#8707918)
The issue is that people confuse getting into space with getting into LEO. Virgin Galactic are not even close to getting into LEO – their plan is to fly a ballistic trajectory which takes them just above 100km before falling back to Earth.

Since they don't need to achieve anywhere near the required velocity to enter LEO, they can use a much smaller solid-fuel rocket engine and launch from a jet.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by dragonwriter on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:35PM (#8707330)
I think there are strength/scaling issues with winged aircraft that, given the fuel requirements for any sizable payload to orbit even from the speed/altitude a jet can achieve, makes this extremely challenging, but its something people keep working on.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by sehugg on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:16PM (#8707747)
I'm sure this has been studied to death, but my guess is that the extra risk during flight/separation, and the extra weight of designing the rocket to handle the different forces encountered when attached to the mothership are not compelling enough to make it worth the extra few % in delta-V. (SpaceShipOne went to Mach 3, not 25, so the boost was greater by percentage)
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by teraflop on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:24PM (#8707003)
Not even LEO; so far, all of Virgin's flights have been strictly suborbital.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by higherpurpose on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:19PM (#8706640)
384,000 KM doesn't sound that much in space scale. Don't our rockets travel at something like 30,000+ KM/h in space?
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by dandelany on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:47PM (#8706798)
Orbital velocity at LEO is ~28,000 km/hr, but as you get further away from the Earth, your velocity decreases. Orbital velocity at the distance of the moon is only ~3,700 km/hr. (Obviously this all depends on your reference frame...)
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by zalzane on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:47PM (#8706803)
when talking about space travel, speeds and distances aren't relevant the same way they are planetside. in space travel, it's all about who's gravity well you're stuck in, and how much delta V itll take to transfer to a different gravity well.

if we're talking about probes, the delta V aspect becomes a lot more fun when you consider the web of gravity slingshots that can be pulled off to up your dV

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by iamcreasy on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:32PM (#8706387)
Not really. Planetary Robotics Laboratory at Carnegie Mellon University is building a lunar rover named Andy and they have already purchased a launch slot from SpaceX to send their rover to the moon. The projected launch date is October 2015. This team are also competiting for Google Lunar X Prize.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by sriram_sun on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:21PM (#8706325)
True. NASA is now where NASA would have been in the 70s or 80s if the initial momentum of going to the moon was maintained.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by DavidSJ on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:21PM (#8706976)
> SpaceX is at the moment in orbit

Not for long: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deep_Space_Climate_Observatory

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by melling on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:26PM (#8706680)
How much of NASA's $20 billion budget is spent on spent flight? It's budget is quite small. Apple made $100 billion in fiscal 2014. Now can you imagine what a SpaceX with that kind of revenue could do? A self-sustaining business model is the better way to develop space technologies.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by valarauca1 on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:44PM (#8706783)
I strongly disagree.

While for profit sounds great, and does work amazingly well at a large number of US, EU, and multi-national corporations. It also doesn't.

Complex scientific programs can have developmental studies measured in decades. Which even very healthy multi-nations can't stomach. Selling a 50+ year ROI R&D program is really hard, and will likely get you laughed out of the boardroom.

But this is ultimately something that happens in academia. Due to largely public funding. Because as an charitable entity profit doesn't necessarily interfere with development and/or research of new ideas. Your goal is literally to piss away money experimenting on things.

While business and innovation to go hand in hand very happily. Business by definition don't transcend profitability. It is their goal. So while they do join hands for the short term, this is a short fling, not a life long love affair.

:.:.:

Also SpaceX does seem impressive. But everything they've currently done was done in the 1960's, without modern computing, or even integrated circuits. I like SpaceX but they are literally riding NASA's coat tails.

A structural analysis of a rocket engine can be done in a CAD simulation. Instead of by 5 guys with slide rules, and an IBM batch processing computer barely performing 100 KFLOPS.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by trhway on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:59PM (#8706866)
>But everything they've currently done was done in the 1960's, without modern computing, or even integrated circuits. I like SpaceX but they are literally riding NASA's coat tails.

has been for now. Significant differences though start to appear -

1. their rockets are modular from the start (even Russia has trouble to get similar system - Angara - off the ground)

2. GrassHoper - self-explanatory

3. "Raptor" full flow staged combustion engine - once they get that one, they will become way ahead of any previous development.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by valarauca1 on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:08PM (#8706903)
>Has been for now.

So you confirm my argument.

> their rockets are modular from the start (even Russia has trouble to get similar system

I'm glad a US company can do in 2014, what a cash strapped USSR couldn't in 1970/1980. Luckily there have been few technological innovations in the past 30 years to allow this to be a fair comparison.

>3

Once again, we are hedging our bets on what may happen. Not what has. Until it happens its vaporware.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by trhway on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:43PM (#8707090)
>I'm glad a US company can do in 2014, what a cash strapped USSR couldn't in 1970/1980.

actually it is cash rich Russia which is trying to do it today with much less success than SpaceX.

>So you confirm my argument.

my point here is that while the both functions have the same value, the SpaceX's has much higher first derivative at present and that, for all practical purposes, guarantees that it will be well ahead tomorrow

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by lukeschlather on Friday December 05, 2014 @10:17PM (#8708225)
> actually it is cash rich Russia which is trying to do it today with much less success than SpaceX.

Russia has put people in orbit on a yearly basis since the 60's. SpaceX is successful at coming up with promising designs, but it's quite a bit early to call them more successful than Russia.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by ceejayoz on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:10PM (#8707481)
That Russia's oligarchs are rich doesn't really make Russia rich.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by trhway on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:35PM (#8707591)
Russia as its government (not its people) has been very oil rich during the last decade. It is another question where it has directed the money though. It didn't have any issues to spend $50B for Olympic Games for example (of course most of this money were stolen by those oligarchs, like childhood friends of Putin).

The issues with Russian space isn't money. It is widespread corruption which is able to drain any amount of money and lack of educated professionals. The "old guard" is retiring and new people are too young/inexperienced. People who should have come into the industry during the 199x are pretty much missing. Add to that especial Russian government and near-government corporate ineptitude, lack of modern technological base across the country, especially in electronics/communication...

You should read how US (DoD) buys rocket engines from Russia - US buys them from Florida 5-guys shop (all guys are very well connected Russian guys, some of them are even officially sanctioned by US :) for say $10/engine while the Florida shop buys them from the Russian state corporation at $1/engine while the cost of the engine is something like $2/engine, so the Russian state is something like losing the money here :)

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by ceejayoz on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:43PM (#8706779)
> A self-sustaining business model is the better way to develop space technologies.

It's a good way to improve space technologies. SpaceX builds on a lot of the research and development NASA did with taxpayer dollars, just as Apple benefited from government subsidy and investment in things like early computers and the Internet.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by smackfu on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:23PM (#8706338)
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by shmerl on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:31PM (#8706382)
Thanks. SapceX never made it a secret that their whole goal is flying to other planets. So the claim above about different scale sounded quite off.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by mikeash on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:13PM (#8706606)
I think it's worth noting that the working name for the rocket to launch this thing is the BFR. It stands for Big Rocket, and I'll let you figure out what the F stands for.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by InclinedPlane on Friday December 05, 2014 @05:16PM (#8707244)
SpaceX is also working on a vehicle to transport humans and cargo (at incredible scale) to Mars routinely using reusable vehicles.

And to be 100% clear, Orion is not capable of making the journey to Mars. Orion is envisioned as potentially being a key component of a larger system that could be used for Mars exploration, but by itself it is perhaps only maybe 10-20% or so of what would be needed for such a trip.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by kevin_thibedeau on Friday December 05, 2014 @07:21PM (#8707771)
Any practical Mars mission is going to require a staging area in LEO or a Lagrange point to assemble a larger interplanetary craft. Dragon will be up to that task.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by smackfu on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:14PM (#8706285)
Probably not, but NASA paid for the development of Dragon as part of the Commercial Resupply Services program.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by catfish on Friday December 05, 2014 @09:05PM (#8708083)
This is not correct. Dragon was in production before the NASA contract was signed. SpaceX was paid to develop a commercial crew variant called Dragon V2.

Spacex was from its start conceived by Musk to develop low cost systems that will be used to colonize Mars. He has said this from the start.

Nasa contracts were never necessary for SpaceX to succeed as they have contracts world wide to lift payloads to space for many nations. These contracts help to accelerate the company timeline for crewed missions to the Moon and Mars.

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by efuquen on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:18PM (#8706307)
The two spacecraft are meant to do two completely different things. Orion was designed for deep space exploration, Dragon is not.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by jwcooper on Friday December 05, 2014 @02:24PM (#8706345)
Sort of. According to Wikipedia the plans are for the Dragon to be modified into the "Red Dragon" for future mars missions.

"Red Dragon is a modified SpaceX Dragon capsule for low-cost Mars lander missions using Falcon Heavy rockets. Plans call for a sample return rover to be delivered to the Martian surface while also testing techniques to enter the Martian atmosphere with equipment a human crew could eventually use."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Dragon_(spacecraft)

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by chrisMn on Friday December 05, 2014 @03:24PM (#8706668)
Note, for all you "SpaceX and NASA are competitors" people, that the Red Dragon design study was something that NASA paid for.[1] SpaceX and NASA are are on the same side in reality. Only in magical internet flamewarland, carried out by people who don't do any of this for a living, are they in opposition.

[1]: http://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/2012001...

Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by austinz on Friday December 05, 2014 @04:36PM (#8707061)
It would make more sense to contrast SpaceX with ULA or any of the other rocketry startups. Whatever long-term plans SpaceX have aren't very relevant to the current supplier-contractor partnership that SpaceX and NASA share.
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by seanflyon on Friday December 05, 2014 @06:29PM (#8707567)
You point is correct, but SpaceX is competing directly with the SLS which according to Wikipedia is designed by NASA. I am under the impression that the ULA will produce the SLS, but after a quick search I can only find reference to ULA producing the upper stage (http://www.ulalaunch.com/united-launch-alliance-hosts-nasa.a...). NASA as a whole is not competing with SpaceX, but some parts of it are, unless "designed by" really just means "funded by".
Re:NASA’s Orion Spacecraft Splashes Down in Pacific After Te... by 32faction on Saturday December 06, 2014 @05:31PM (#8710445)
SpaceX as of right now only has medium class rockets which is aimed at space station resupply. The Space Launch System that Boeing uses to carry the Orion is a heavy lift class. The difference is in carrying capacity. Think star destroyer and super star destroyer.