The roll-call vote I'm looking at [1] only has Cruz, Lee, Heller, and Murkowski voting to move the bill to a vote on passage; Paul supported the filibuster.
[1] http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_c...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USA_Freedom_Act
http://www.paul.senate.gov/?p=press_release&id=1244
He's actually been very consistent in opposing Patriot ACT renewals, and I applaud him for it.
> “In the aftermath of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, Americans were eager to catch and punish the terrorists who attacked us. I, like most Americans, demanded justice. But one common misconception is that the Patriot Act applies only to foreigners—when in reality, the Patriot Act was instituted precisely to widen the surveillance laws to include U.S. citizens,” Sen. Paul said, “As Benjamin Franklin put it, ‘those who trade their liberty for security may wind up with neither.’ Today’s vote to oppose further consideration of the Patriot Act extension proves that we are one step closer to restoring civil liberties in America.”
Please don't make political arguments into personal quarrels on HN, even when someone doesn't bother reading. Political arguments are abrasive to begin with. Let's not add gratuitous abrasiveness.
This comment would be quite a good one without the first sentence.
I am not making any kind of political statement nor a personal quarrel, I am simply pointing out that he got the answer previously but jumped on the comment trigger before reading anything linked. Is saying "Do you bother reading" considered offensive now?
> Some of its opponents, like Senator Saxby Chambliss, Republican of Georgia, believe it went too far in curbing the N.S.A. Others, like Senator Rand Paul, Republican of Kentucky, thought it did not go far enough.
'The Perfect' is the enemy of 'The Good'.
Google, MSFT, Apple, the EFF all supported this bill. Obviously there are further improvements that could be made, but instead of starting from a better platform, we're at ground zero with an incoming congress that has no interest in curbing the 'military' power of the US.
The EFF's case for supporting the bill that was just killed is very clear about this:
https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/08/understanding-new-usa-...
Its a shitty situation no matter what.
Half-measures are often incoherent and worse
than the status quo.
See: banking & healthcare
You just lock yourself into a disaster.
Obama can update the EO's for the NSA without congress[+].
[+] EFF: "Future reform must include significant changes to ... Executive Order 12333, and to the broken classification system that the executive branch counts on to hide unconstitutional surveillance from the public."
He just doesn't want to stick his neck out.
So this bill was a distant 3rd choice for the country.
1) pass a good law
2) administrate the NSA into compliance
3) pass muddled legislation in a lame duck session
Your comment is absurd.
Fixing the EOs is simple.
(That buys time. Time to get
coherent legislation
figured out.)
In fact: the more "grassroots-friendly" this bill had been, the less tenable a yea vote would have been, particularly for Paul.
The following Republican Senators Elect are currently US House Reps and voted:
Yea Tom Cotton
Nay Cory Gardner
Yea Bill Cassidy (assuming win in run off)
Nay Steve Daines
Yea Shelley Wellons Moore Capito
Joni Ernst, Thom Tillis, Mike Rounds are the unknowns.These are not your Goldwater Republicans.
It's why a lot of votes in both houses can seem close, or bipartisan, but in fact they are not - just Congressmen who are owed a favor being allowed to vote in such a way that won't piss off their constituents or hurt their chances of being elected to a higher office someday, or land them a sweet consulting gig after they leave office, or whatever. If the leadership knows they have votes to spare anyway. This is a pretty common and well-known practice I thought, so I don't really understand the downvotes.
I mean, if both Cruz and Paul had voted for cloture and the Senate had moved on cloture with e.g. 61 votes or something (i.e. both their votes actually mattered and were against the party interests), then their votes would be big news and evidence of an actual schism. As it stands, how they voted doesn't mean shit, other than that they are reasonably famous politicians.
Well, there's your problem in a nutshell. That's why we are where we are.
I find it interesting that Barbara Boxer voted for it, given her staunch defense of the NSA's abuses-to-date.
The vote: All D's voted right except Bill Nelson of Florida. All R's voted wrong except Cruz, Lee, Heller, Paul, and Murkowski.
Where "right" means "for the overhaul bill" and "wrong" means the opposite.
You'll also notice that this bill got way over 50 votes, but still failed due to the modern filibuster.