That's a bad solution, because it solves the wrong problem. The real problem is overage charges.
Of all the other companies who provide me with metered service, not a single one uses the same pricing structure where I purchase an initial quota for one price, and then have to pay out the nose if I go over it. Everyone else just charges a flat unit price. It's a flat $x/gal for water, $x/kW/h for electricity, $x/m^3 for gas, $x/min for land line phone service, $x/min for Azure compute time, etc. etc.
That style of pricing is good. It's a straightforward, easy-to-understand "pay for what you use" model. Cell phone style pricing is worse because it's unpredictable and consumer-hostile because it makes you feel punished for using more of their service. Unlimited cell phone pricing is worse yet. It's supremely consumer-hostile because it forces light users to subsidize folks who watch Netflix while riding the city bus. As a light user (and informed consumer) I find that offer to be downright insulting; I hate it just as much as I'd hate if the gas station wanted to charge me the same flat monthly fee for me to buy gas for my economy car that I only use on weekend as they charge my neighbor to top off his Escalade that he uses for a 45-minute commute.
Except that consumers don't like those kinds of billing plans.
Consumers like fixed bill per month. Period. A plan that charges more per month than metered would still wins because the consumer sees it as a fixed charge.
[CITATION NEEDED.]
It depends. I have no particular problem paying for electricity, oil, water, and Amazon S3 based on usage and it does provide me with the appropriate incentives to conserve. Obviously I'd have no problem paying a fixed rate for these services if doing so cost me less than I pay today but I have no particular preference for a fixed charge provided that my usage is relatively predictable and transparent.
I doubt that I'm atypical. As someone who tends to turn the lights off when I leave a room and keeps the thermostat relatively low in the winter, I don't have any particular desire to subsidize someone who leaves all their lights blazing and cranks the heat up to 75 degrees.
I find it somewhat interesting that people seem to be more accepting of usage-based pricing in some scenarios than others. I expect part of it is what we're used to--pricey per-minute domestic long distance phone pricing seemed quite normal until relatively recently. But I expect things like degree of predictability and control-ability factor in as well.
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/04/why-we-should-wor...
That flat price is going to depend on things like marginal costs, to what degree flat pricing drives up average costs, and how much the heavy users drive up costs for others. As the link suggests, flat pricing seems to work pretty well for broadband but it's unclear how practical it is (today) for wireless.
Not necessarily. The combination of the value of the services you decided to forgo to not rack up metering charges and the mental cost of doing those calculations can be arbitrarily large, because the mental cost is a sunk cost[1] by the time you know whether paying for the additional metered bandwidth is worth it. You could theoretically spend all day worrying about using too much bandwidth without ultimately deciding to use any at all, so your bill would be much lower but at the cost of spending all day worrying about it.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunk_costs
There are also knock-on effects of not having unmetered service. It causes people to use less bandwidth (obviously) but that means they're deriving less value from the network, which means they're not willing to pay as much for service, which means slower upgrades, which means potentially higher customer costs in the long term as the price per GB stays higher longer.
> That flat price is going to depend on things like marginal costs, to what degree flat pricing drives up average costs, and how much the heavy users drive up costs for others. As the link suggests, flat pricing seems to work pretty well for broadband but it's unclear how practical it is (today) for wireless.
The strange thing about wireless is that it seems likely to eat itself. Spectrum is scarce and towers are expensive, but charging a high monthly fee for unlimited usage or a high metered rate is likely to drive customers to use WiFi rather than cellular whenever possible, which reduces demand for cellular and pushes the prices back down.
I suspect the equilibrium is going to be "unlimited" wireless service where only the first X amount of MB per month is "fast" and then the service works but is throttled. The result then is that everybody uses WiFi whenever they can to preserve their "fast" cellular bandwidth (or because they've already used it and then WiFi is much faster) but nobody actually has to worry about using too much because there is never any bill for the overage. And then you start demanding that WiFi access points be installed at whatever locations you were in where you used all your cellular bandwidth.
OTOH, as you suggest, there need to be proper incentives around scarce resources--such as using WiFi where available rather than cellular. The equilibrium you describe seems sensible--perhaps with throttling less extreme than AT&T's current version seems to be and with greater transparency.
But everyone learned their lesson with the old limited minute/text plans. You pay $25 a month for service with occasional bills of $500.
It wasn't your fault. A bunch of people mistyped the phone number for a content and sent you texts by mistake and you got charged for them. You probably won't have to pay, but it will take three hours on the phone to sort that out. And you're busy. And they already took the money from your account so maybe something bounced.
Or maybe you just accidentally triggered the data on your old feature phone without a plan to the tune of $100/mb.
So no one trusts the phone companies. Everyone wants unlimited because the billing systems are so broken and byzantine at least you can predict what the bill will be. It's very hard for normal people to budget accidental $500 charges for making a trivial mistake.
Why are consumers okay with paying a metered fee for electricity, water, and gasoline?
There's competition and/or regulations pushing those prices into reasonable ranges. Usage is fairly predictable. These are things that are horrible to have suddenly shut off without warning (like what effectively happens when you're throttled into unusability). They are things that people need in order to be a functioning member of society in the majority of places on Earth (in places with good public transit, gasoline gets removed from this list).
Aside from point #1, those also sound like the Internet.
They're not. But normally they don't have a choice.
However, some of the utilities in the Northeast have plans wherein your bill is mostly constant year round even in spite of the spikes at certain times of the year. Lots of people like them even though they almost always wind up paying more than they would otherwise.
> They're not. But normally they don't have a choice.
Wait, what? Says who? I certainly don't speak for everyone, but I'm perfectly happy paying just for my usage of these things.
I think the difference is predictability and that the costs aren't astronomical if you have a high-usage month. If it's colder than usual, I'd perhaps expect to pay another 10% on my utility bill. That's reasonable and not a hardship.
If I were to spend, say, $30/mo on a plan with 500 minutes of voice calling, and went 100 minutes over, but was only charged, say, $6 for that overage, I'd have no problem with that (because 30/500=0.06 and 0.06100=6). But instead I get charged something like $20, which is way out of proportion to the overage. That's* the objection.
And I think part of it is related to an understanding of actually "using something up". When I use more electricity, I know that I actually used something up: that extra power came from more coal being burned, or more water falling from a dam, or something of that nature. When I use more water, I know that my use of it drained a reservoir a little bit more than it otherwise would. I used up a physical good, and I'm paying for that use. If I use more than what a regulator has decided is my "fair share", I might pay a premium for that extra (many utilities have tiered pricing), but I'm ok with that because I do recognize I'm using more than usual, and the added cost of the higher tier isn't unreasonable or burdensome.
But the cost of me spending 100 extra minutes on the phone costs the carrier basically nothing. Sure, if everyone did that in a month, perhaps it would strain the carrier's network (not that it would cause the carrier to spend capital on increased capacity; they'd likely be fine with more dropped/failed calls that month). In general, though, the marginal cost to the carrier when you use more minutes than your plan provides is near zero -- and yet the carrier charges an exorbitant markup for that overage.
Here's an analogy that's closer to cell phone unlimited plans: Imagine if it were instead the same flat fee for everyone across the country. I imagine you'd find the family that lives in a small apartment and keeps the house cool in the winter isn't too happy to find out that very little of their gas bill is explained by their own energy usage, and the vast majority of it is paying to heat the mansions of the rich people across town.
I don't think they are; certainly in my country people hate metered water. And people love fixed-rate mortgages even when they'd pay less on floating. If people had the option of unmetered electricity or gasoline, I think they'd take it.
You are in the vast minority in preferring metering.
One of the interesting ones is the following nugget: "to limit your data overage charges to $50 a month and your data roaming charges to $100 a month."[3]
[1] http://www.crtc.gc.ca/eng/info_sht/t13.htm
We just need truth in advertising. Do what you will, just tell me what it is, and I can figure out the rest. I personally like metered wireless plans because I know that my incentives align with those of the provider, and I'm comfortable with the overage charges. If unlimited-with-throttling is better for others, great! But don't try to sell me "unlimited, period" and then not deliver.
That said, they are not transparent about it. They refused to call it throttling or even agree that they were throttling me. They used misleading language like "fair-share for the antenna you're on."
At least T-Mobile Germany is throttling users to 64kbit/s after the cap is reached, which is so slow that you can't use most online services (logins over https just time out). Of course you can buy more uncapped gigabytes.
This is a perverse incentive scheme for the providers: they have no reason to upgrade the network capacity, because they can use the "network is overloaded" argument to limit the data volume, and to charge more from their users.
What bothers me is that half of our regulatory system is basically a jumble of patches designed to fix the problems caused by lack of competition, which is often artificially introduced by the other half of the regulatory system.
Not to say this is the case, though. I think the FTC is completely right here - unlimited should mean nothing is curtailed based on your usage. Anything else is misleading, bordering on fraud.
It's basically a scam and NOT what most people want.
The essentially offer 1GB for $10 ... so 5GB is $50, 6GB is $60...
Flat seems fair to me and keeps both parties honest.
I just wish they were honest about 'unlimited'.
The problem is the surprise bill when they charge you exponentially for going over their commited rate.
T-Mobile does this? I use my phone a LOT with them and haven't noticed any throttling.
It might be that you don't use as much data as you think. I use my phone for data stuff all day long, but don't stream music or video, and it's the rare month I go over a gigabyte. Apparently perusing stock prices and weather reports doesn't use all that much. However, on a recent motorcycle trip in Canada it hit some limit and got throttled. Non-https would work if I was really patient. Apple Maps worked okay, if slowly. Google Maps: don't even bother.
EDIT: I got it wrong. I got throttled because a 3rd-party contractor dug up Frontier's FioS lines, so I used my phone as the house hotspot on a 5Gb plan. Then we tried to watch something on the Apple TV. In HD. Oopsie. Upgraded to unlimited high-speed data after that. The Canada thing was T-Mo's "unlimited data in select countries". Problem there is that high-speed is quite tiny (200Mb?), then it's throttled. They'll sell you an international roaming pass for a reasonable price, though.
> Up to 3 GB of 4G LTE data. Speeds reduced after 3 GB. No overage fees.
(1) They're still heavy users for that portion of the month when they have 2GB or 10GB or whatever of full access data (2) When they're using non-peak hours or less populated towers they're still throttled even though there is no service impact
A better service would be an aggressive QoS that prioritizes users who haven't used their fair share of the network and allows those heavy hitters to wreck havok when they're up streaming 1080p videos at 4AM.
No cap.
The difference between T-Mobile and AT&T is that one is unlimited, the other is 3-5GB for "unlimited"
"Unlimited" or otherwise, throttling has been done for a long time by other carriers as well. I would like a refund.
and to be sure, throttling is a limit. for those on unlimited plans and according to the way it was advertised, you should be able to get up to the physical limit of the network every month. if that's 500GB/month, the you should be able to use 500GB/month every month according to the agreement. allowing you to use 5GB at the normal rate and 5GB more (or whatever it is) at a drastically reduced rate is not unlimited. the fact that they didn't consider bandwidth requirements when they made the offer is not the concern of the customer who accepted that offer.
AT&T's problem is that they just one day up and decided to start throttling unlimited customers (down to 10-20% of their normal speed) without a warning, and without it being made clear in any of their marketing material or contracts.
The reason why I call these programs "good" is that they all but eliminate overage charges from a consumer's bill. With limited data, you often get charged excessive amounts if you go over your cap (disproportionately large amounts at times).
So for example, if a consumer got their teenager 2 GB of data, and that teenager ran up a 5 GB usage bill one month, that could be an additional $60 charge ($20/GB) out of the blue. Unlimited-throttled data averts that possibility (and the teenager in this example is the only one negatively impacted by the excess usage).
This is how T-Mobile currently operates on all of their Simple Choice plans (both unlimited and limited). They have scrapped overage charges (so there is no bill-shock) and instead just throttle you down.
The only major difference between what T-Mobile currently do and what AT&T were doing, is that AT&T lied and hid it, and worse still charged customers ETF if they left as a result. T-mobile is completely upfront about the policy and how it is enforced.
PS - T-Mobile also do the same thing for roaming data, no overage charges.