I think Google stumbled on a very great idea with Chromecast. I don't want a smart TV with tons of features and a shitty interface that I have to navigate through with an awkward pad.
I want an extremely dumb TV that only displays what my other terminals (laptop, tablet and phone) tell it to display.
NO REMOTE IN THE WORLD will ever beat an app on a tablet or phone. I can search and browse so easily on my tablet to find what I want. I can start a video and then explore other stuff. It's the perfect setup.
If only I could pay the NFL for a streaming-only HD football package, I would have literally everything I need for consuming video. But I don't think that will ever happen (at least without having to get a cable/satellite subscription which I refuse to ever do again).
The little exclusivity pact the NFL and the major Cable companies have makes me have zero qualms about just straight stealing the content. If they have me a legitimate way to pay for every Packers game (directly through the NFL, not a cable provider) I would do it in a heartbeat, but they haven't, so screw 'em.
Apparently there's a way to signup and pay for NFL game pass using a VPN and pretending to be in Europe but I won't do that on sheer principle. It's insane to me I could legally pay for NFL outside of the US but inside the US I have to go through a third party (cable company) to get streaming access.
0 - http://www.theverge.com/2014/10/15/6982049/hbo-go-will-offer...
I wouldn't be surprised if DirectTV has some sort of exclusive contract to provide all of the games, but that can't last forever.
There is also a service called NFL GamePass which lets you watch games live if you live outside the North American market. I think the geographic restriction can be gotten around using VPNs & other geo-location defeating measures, but I've never tried.
The games for both NFL Rewind & GamePass are streamed via their website, and there is an official Android app, as well as a Plex app, and an XBMC plugin. The quality is not great, but it is better than nothing.
I'm pretty sure I'd regret giving those things up.
(I couldn't seem to reply to you directly for whatever reason)
It's not a technical limitation by the cable companies/NFL, it's literally just bureaucratic bullshit.
Except when you want to quickly pause.
Amazingly enough, living smack dab in the middle of a massive city (San Diego), I can't get this offer. The NFL and the cable/satellite companies are practically begging me to steal their content when they come out with stupid shit like this.
If this were a national offering, I'd get it in a heartbeat. Why it's not a national offering I have no idea.
Phone batteries get low every day. Having to walk to where your phone is charging to change the channel is a bad experience.
Using the phone as a remote is anti-social. I can't pick out what to watch with the person who's sitting in the chair across the room.
Chromecast is good for accidental discovery. You come across an interesting talk on YouTube, Chromecast is good for that.
Chromecast is also good for content that "lives" on your phone, like podcasts.
But Chromecast is bad for picking out a movie or TV show to watch, especially in the company of others.
> Phone batteries get low every day. Having to walk to where your phone is charging to change the channel is a bad experience.
I have solved the fairly rare occurrence of my phone dying when I want to watch a movie by having a charger next to my coffee table. I mean, maybe we just have different experiences, but has this actually happened to you? Regularly? Does it take up more or less time than hunting down a lost remote control?
> Using the phone as a remote is anti-social. I can't pick out what to watch with the person who's sitting in the chair across the room.
You'll have to instead talk to them, or have them sit closer and look over your shoulder. Not more or less social, just a different type of social. And add to that, the ability to have multiple people use their individual devices to queue videos is an excellent social experience
I have a charger next to my coffee table too, but then I have to sit in the seat next to the coffee table every time. And I have to reach over to use the phone because the charger cord isn't very long.
> Does it take up more or less time than hunting down a lost remote control?
Far less time. The remote isn't an object that gets moved around. It spends most of it's lifetime in a single room. If you lose it there's a 90% chance it's in the couch cushions.
> You'll have to instead talk to them, or have them sit closer and look over your shoulder. Not more or less social, just a different type of social. And add to that, the ability to have multiple people use their individual devices to queue videos is an excellent social experience
Multiple people staring at their own screens looking at different things is not social.
A: "Oh this one looks interesting"
B: "Which one"?
A: "Third row down, second movie."
B: "The one with the snowman?"
A: "No, it's got the actors smiling"
B: "Hm, third row down, second movie? I see a snowman"
No, its not, any more than using a regular remote as a remote is.
> Having to walk to where your phone is charging to change the channel is a bad experience.
Yes, it is, but that's not fundamental to the Chromecast, its just bad app UI design (for instance, you don't have the same issue if you are tab casting a regular web page that provides the selection before getting to the streaming media). There's no reason that an mobile app that uses the Google Cast API can't have a similar [or even better] optimized casting UI to a dumb tab-casted web page, its just that most so far don't. Extending the line of Google Cast devices -- if it extends reach -- may indirectly improve this, by getting app developers to spend more effort on the UX of their Cast support.
Apps on your phone should be able to control apps on the player, and the apps on the player can be used standalone. We'll have to see if apps from the Play Store gets Google Cast control, or if this only happens for the Chromecast-style web apps.
This has the advantage that you can select content on phone and then use the phone or remote on the player to control playback.
[1]: Reported by TechCrunch. Regular Chromecast is $35.
[2]: Possibly with 5GHz band? Regular Chromecast is 2.4GHz 802.11n only.
[3]: http://blog.laptopmag.com/intel-bay-trail-tablets-benchmarks... regular Chromecast maxes out at 1080p. EDIT: Aww, its specs say that it only outputs in 1080p.
The Roku is so much better. Everything is centralised, and the remote is a better interface than a phone screen. So I'm excited for the Nexus Player, as I want my Roku to be more hackable than it is. A Nexus Player with XBMC will be a dream.
I definitely find the phone/tablet much more comfortable for searching content and flinging it to the TV. Typing to search for a specific show on Netflix on my TV is a huge pain to me.
And casting through Netflix was painful in itself. So slow. But maybe that was just my phone/setup somehow.
On the other hand when you're interested in something specific. Car reviews for example. The TV-Queue is really sweet.
But I just cast from Youtube to my Sony Bravia or Roku's. I'm not sure if that's Google Cast or not. I just discovered it by accident last week.
Luckily, Mozilla is developing a very similar device (Matchstick [1]), and looking to do it better. I am unable to find the link at the moment, but they already support like 3 or 4 times as many media formats as chromecast. And Mozilla has a pretty good track record with hackable, open projects.
Chromecast pretty much just mirrors a screen, it also requires a separate device to control it. You could browse the web on this without requiring a phone or laptop.
But, again, like what? The Chromecast is able to display pretty complex HTML and JavaScript apps. And perhaps a new updated Chromecast with more horsepower would be able to do an even better job... But give me an example of something you think the Chromecast couldn't do that you'd want it to? It can do HD video, and has a decent HTML rendering engine....
Since the Nexus Player will have Chromecast support built-in (like all Android TV devices), software will hopefully continue to add support on their end.
The airwaves are crowded where I live. There are so many networks and sources of interference that any 2.4GHz network I set up inevitably drops out constantly. I've had 3 different routers.
The solution was to move to 5GHz. Pretty much everything else in the house can run on 5GHz and stay connected to the internet that way. Chromecast can only connect to 2.4GHz networks, so I have to run one for it, but it doesn't see devices on the 5GHz network even though they're on the same LAN.
Source: I couldn't use anything but "low quality mode" in my old apartment building unless i wanted artifacts and buffering every 30 seconds
This is a good point... it's not missing much in terms of features and functionality.
A pie in the sky idea, that none of these devices have tried to incorporate, is to have a webcam peripheral support to enable video chatting. This is the primary thing I still use my HTPC for. Being able to gather my wfie and/or friends into the living room to video chat with friends that live elsewhere, having those friends be able to see the whole room where we're able to sit comfortably, is really a great experience. And at this point, using an HTPC for that is overkill, in terms of horsepower needed. Incorporating a feature like this into a media device would be a killer feature for me. "Casting" a Skype or Hangout video chat.... I'd be all over that.
Captive portal support would also help in getting on more wireless networks. Chromecast is small enough to take traveling and would be useful to plug into hotel TV. But most hotels networks have captive portals.
At least Chromecast had updates and worked. My Nexus Q never worked as expected.
I'm looking forward to the Mozilla clone which will let me cast VLC directly to the TV. That will useful for me.
To me, they are just one more thing to keep track of and keep charged. I think connecting the remote control of things to the one device that is always around, instead of an assortment of tailor made devices, is brilliant.
I guess I'm just not the average user, but the Chromecast handily beats what this (and other options in this genre, i.e., Apple TV / Fire TV / Roku) have to offer. I don't want another remote control. And making my phone the best remote control is an awesome solution. And the Chromecast doesn't take up any room in my living room / entertainment center. And it's only thrity-five-goddamn-dollars.
I guess the downside is that I can't play crappy games on my big screen. Darn.