News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by Tarang on Friday October 03, 2014 @11:57AM (#8406065)
Small/TLDR backstory: Marriott jammed Wifi hotspots and offered its own internet services instead, charging from $250 per device.

Source: http://www.slashgear.com/marriott-fined-600000-for-jamming-g...

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by geetee on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:04PM (#8406094)
In addition to the $600,000 civil penalty, Marriott will have to cease blocking guests, hand over details of any access point containment features to the FCC across its entire portfolio of owned or managed properties, and finally file compliance and usage reports each quarter for the next three years.

And how about refund everyone?

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by smackfu on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:08PM (#8406113)
That would probably require a class action suit.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by kirillzubovsky on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:58PM (#8406349)
Some lawyer somewhere is probably already calling up all and every Marriott guest on this planet.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by toomuchtodo on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:03PM (#8406725)
I had to support the IT functions of a corporate event at the Gaylord Opryland convention center ~18 months ago. Wouldn't mind joining a class action even if I don't see a dime after attempting to mitigate their wifi interference for a week.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by snowwrestler on Friday October 03, 2014 @05:39PM (#8407786)
The power of the class action suit is that you don't need to call everyone up. You just need a representative group of clients (which can be quite small) for standing, and evidence and justification to convince the judge to certify a class.

Most folks are not aware they are in a class until they get a letter from the losing company with their $9 check or whatever is left over after lawyer's fees.

Edit: forgot a word

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by riazrizvi on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:58PM (#8406688)
For the chance to make a couple of million in legal fees, do you blame them?
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by aeturnum on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:44PM (#8406285)
Probably not within the powers of the FCC?
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by haspoken on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:24PM (#8406187)
The FCC thanks you for your generous contribution.
[deleted]
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by eli on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:21PM (#8406821)
It was for exhibitors at the convention hall. That's actually very cheap so far as these things go. You should see what they charge for a trash can or a chair.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by DannyBee on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:29PM (#8406210)
FWIW: It appears as soon as marriot corporate discovered this, they ordered them not to do it again.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by coleca on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:01PM (#8406363)
FWIW I have seen this in practice at other convention centers (not owned by Marriott). We attended a convention (as an exhibitor) this year in MN and had to spend $10k for 3 days of Internet connectivity over WiFi. Your choices were to pay (this was the cheapest plan, others went much higher), or use your own. If they caught you using your own, they would block you and shut down your booth at the convention.

Their rationale/justification was that because WiFi at scale (40k attendees, couple hundred exhibitors) the MiFis and other hotspots are using the bandwidth that the exhibitors have paid (a lot of money) for and caused issues with their demos (which the attendees paid entry fees to see).

Convention centers operate in the world of unrealistically high pricing that is rarely seen outside of airport newsstands . For example, they wanted to charge us $3k for renting a 42" TV for 3 days. We ended up just buying a 27" Thunderbolt display and saved a ton (and had a nice monitor to give to one of our devs after the show).

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by dctoedt on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:19PM (#8406442)
> the MiFis and other hotspots are using the bandwidth that the exhibitors have paid (a lot of money) for

EDITED: In the U.S., all RF bandwidth is administered by the FCC for the benefit of the public. AFAIK, even if there's a "traffic jam" in the local WiFi spectrum, private parties don't get to unilaterally block off the WiFi bandwidth and charge for access. That'd be like a shopping mall's dealing with its Black-Friday traffic jams by setting up toll booths to block the adjoining public highways and charging vehicles to go through.

(My original comment referred to cell-service bandwidth, which of course isn't the only problem, as @coleca correctly points out.)

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by superuser2 on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:16PM (#8406801)
Universities, large corporations, and other building owners frequently disallow "pirate" WiFi and a there are very popular and expensive network security products built for identifying and triangulating pirate WiFi hotspots.

It is the right of universities and employers to disallow WiFi hotspots as a condition of being on the property. Why shouldn't this apply to hotels?

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by Karunamon on Friday October 03, 2014 @03:17PM (#8407121)
If I understand correctly, there's a difference between saying "If you run a hotspot here, we will find it and eject you for violating our terms" and "If you run a hotspot here, we will interfere with its operation"

The first one is perfectly okay, your private property, your rules, the second is in violation of the law.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by bunderbunder on Friday October 03, 2014 @09:32PM (#8408485)
I believe the magic words are:

  This device complies with part 15 of FCC Rules.
  
  1) This device may not cause harmful interference.

  2) This device must accept any interference received,  
  including interference that may cause undesired operation.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by Karunamon on Friday October 03, 2014 @09:51PM (#8408536)
Sounds like the transmitter would be in violation of part 1, then. And I guarantee it's got a sticker along those lines somewhere on it.

My understanding of #2 in rule is that it's meant to protect against incidental interference causing complaints to the FCC. If the ham operator across the street makes your TV/dental fillings act weird, you can't ask the government to go shut him down.

In any case, it also probably depends on the precise legal definition of "interference", "must accept", and so on.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by dctoedt on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:19PM (#8406815)
> It is the right of universities and employers to disallow WiFi hotspots as a condition of being on the property.

Citation, please? This is an area of the law with which I'm not too familiar.

I do recall from dim memory that private-property rights aren't without limits. For example:

+ The (U.S.) National Labor Relations Act puts limits on an employer's right to prohibit employee collective action on the employer's property;

+ Similarly, various civil-rights acts prohibit the owner of a business from refusing service to people on impermissible discriminatory grounds (race, national origin, etc.);

+ [ADDED:] Anti-trust law places limits on a business owner's ability to say, for example, I'll sell you my patented photocopier only if you agree to buy all your unpatented paper from me as well.

[EDITED:] I'm not saying the first two laws apply in this case. I am suggesting that anti-trust law, and perhaps federal communications law, might analogously limit the ability of the owner of a business to require guests, as a condition of admission, to forego their lawful access to the public spectrum. That practice seems roughly analogous to the conference company saying, "you can attend our conference, but only if you travel to the conference center in one of the expensive private limousines that we've arranged for, instead of in a cab."

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by skinnybatch on Friday October 03, 2014 @05:18PM (#8407695)
Or, you can travel in our limousines, which will drop you at the front door, or instead, you may arrange for a cab, which may only drop you off at a designated cab dropping location, conveniently 3.2 miles away from our front door down at the bottom of the hill.

Are we going to treat WiFi according to airspace protocol? Can a company or operation claim ownership to a quasi-physically-contained airspace? Perhaps invoke claims of trespassing by other non-approved, non-financially viable, sources? If you're living/working/visiting under my roof, then my rules, my WiFI.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by dctoedt on Saturday October 04, 2014 @07:06AM (#8409243)
> Can a company or operation claim ownership to a quasi-physically-contained airspace? Perhaps invoke claims of trespassing by other non-approved, non-financially viable, sources? If you're living/working/visiting under my roof, then my rules, my WiFI.

That's one way to look at it. But it doesn't square with an important fact, namely that under U.S. law, you don't own the RF spectrum, even though RF waves happen to exist "on" "your" property.

Keep in mind that in a civil society, property ownership and the autonomy that goes with it are largely social constructs that can and are limited by the rest of us. Marriott might imagine that it "owns" a conference facility and can do what it wants with it. Certainly for most purposes that's a reasonable approximation of the truth. But: Marriott gets to exclude, say, Alice from walking into the conference facility, not by virtue of some natural right, but solely because the rest of us have tacitly agreed that our police and, ultimately, our armed forces will back Marriott up if it chooses to do so.

(That is, of course, unless Marriott happen to have access to a militia or other armed force; @Rayiner has written about related topics in other threads here.)

And whether Marriott likes it or not, the rest of us, via our duly-elected or -appointed representatives, have decreed:

1. that the public airwaves are no one's private property; and

2. that in certain circumstances, "tying" arrangements, in which a seller requires a purchaser to buy an unwanted product or service B as a condition of being able to buy wanted product or service A, are unlawful --- that is to say, the seller's autonomy in respect of its goods and services only goes so far. [1]

It's therefore not an incoherent argument that Marriott may not require Alice, while in the conference facility, to use only Marriott's expensive WiFi network, as opposed to using, say, the phone in her pocket as a WiFi hotspot of her own.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tying_(commerce).

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by jedunnigan on Saturday October 04, 2014 @12:19AM (#8408755)
Refer to jacquesm's post [0]:

>Because (1) a jammer is an unlicensed transmitter and (2) jammers do not just jam with discretion they jam for as far as they reach and it is impossible to operate a jammer in such a way that you cover all the territory without extending beyond it in some places.

Jammers can interfere with people's ability to contact emergency services. Obviously in the case of WiFi this is not an immediate concern because 911 is currently reached through a different wavelength, but WiFi is integrating into infrastructure (WoT, etc...) such that jammers can be a real cause for concern (especially if they are operated by poorly trained people).

>If you're living/working/visiting under my roof, then my rules, my WiFI.

What about the scenario where you have an ISP that offers city-wide WiFi to its subscribers. A Marriott is within the bounds of this area, they block access to a service I pay for and they have approval to provide me with. Who is in the wrong?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8407399

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by halfcat on Friday October 03, 2014 @07:37PM (#8408199)
>It is the right of universities and employers to disallow WiFi hotspots as a condition of being on the property.

You may be confusing a wifi hotspot with a wifi router. It's certainly reasonable for the owners of a physical network to disallow users to plug in their own wifi routers, especially because it can cause problems, even potentially taking down the entire network with loops and rogue DHCP servers. There are ways the owner can prevent those problems, but it comes at higher cost of equipment

I don't see why a hotspot would be any different than a mobile phone. Some places tell you to turn them off, because it interrupts the movie, and they may ask you to leave if you don't. But they don't jam phones and provide high cost alternatives.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by DanBC on Friday October 03, 2014 @07:52PM (#8408231)
US universities ban wireless access points from dorms.

They want to know who is using the network and wireless access points remove some of that control.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by rahimnathwani on Friday October 03, 2014 @11:54PM (#8408719)
Yes but that's about controlling access to their own network. They don't ban you from operating a wifi hotspot using a 3G-connected device like a mifi or a phone with tethering.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by zardeh on Friday October 03, 2014 @11:19PM (#8408668)
Furthermore, at scale, interference sucks.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by jacquesm on Friday October 03, 2014 @04:12PM (#8407399)
Because (1) a jammer is an unlicensed transmitter and (2) jammers do not just jam with discretion they jam for as far as they reach and it is impossible to operate a jammer in such a way that you cover all the territory without extending beyond it in some places.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by wglb on Saturday October 04, 2014 @02:54PM (#8410203)
All wifi devices are unlicensed transmitters.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by anigbrowl on Friday October 03, 2014 @04:40PM (#8407529)
I was doing some research work in a downtown building that was next to a hotel a couple of years ago (not a Marriott) and I couldn't use my laptop next to the window because the hotel wifi seemed to swamp everything else. This wasn't such a big inconvenience and at the time I assumed the wifi of the place I was in was just not that great to start with, but with hindsight it might well have been a case of unlawful interference.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by nanidin on Friday October 03, 2014 @05:14PM (#8407682)
At my university, it was against the rules to plug WiFi routers or AP's into the university's network. The reason for that was that it's a huge security risk to allow anyone to run an AP on the network - if it's not configured correctly, it could allow unauthorized, open access to the network to malicious third parties.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by PhasmaFelis on Friday October 03, 2014 @11:53PM (#8408715)
You say it's a security risk "if your AP isn't configured correctly." It would be much more accurate to say "if the university network isn't configured correctly."

If you expose unrestricted access to sensitive stuff to everyone on the dorm ethernet, sinister wifi hackers on the sidewalk outside is the least of your worries. Your university IT was trying to cover their incompetence with random authoritarianism.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by superuser2 on Saturday October 04, 2014 @01:10AM (#8408829)
University networks generally implement 802.1x, WPA2/EAP, MAC registration, and similar authentication schemes so that every device is tied to an authorized user and malicious activity can be traced to a real person.

When a network device is attached that doesn't pass this authentication requirement onto its users (i.e. by NATing, or offering a public or common-key WiFi network) the university loses its ability to see who is doing what, and to deny access to people it doesn't want on its network. IT departments don't like that.

The security risk is not so much that you can now route certain internal IPs, but that IT has no way of determining who you are, or even your real MAC address, if it has questions about or objections to your traffic (whether

Hopefully no one is placing sensitive services on the same network as dorm rooms with no security, but being on the LAN is often used as a front line. For one thing, sitting on the right part of the campus network gets you access to most scientific journals based on IP whitelisting. The University is contractually not allowed to provide this access to people who aren't students/faculty/staff, so it has to control who can come from those IPs. We operate separate SSIDs for guests that route to the internet through IPs not in the whitelist. We also have certain intranet-only services like Facilities work orders, printing, etc. that could be on the public internet, but don't need to be, so better to those aging, likely vulnerable applications behind a layer than not.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by rahimnathwani on Friday October 03, 2014 @11:51PM (#8408713)
It's reasonable for the university to regulate what you can do on _their_ network.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by driverdan on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:30PM (#8406863)
Disallowing is much different than actively jamming.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by cnst on Monday October 06, 2014 @03:09PM (#8417606)
Doesn't really have to be expensive; OpenBSD's hostapd can do this easily; take a look at `deauth` and `hopping` keywords at http://mdoc.su/o/hostapd.conf.5.

Likewise, it's probably trivial to ignore these deauth packets if you're running your own boxes (although it'll probably be more problematic if you wanted tablet / phone access, too).

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by coleca on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:27PM (#8406488)
I agree with you, but I was talking about the WiFi bandwidth not your 3G/4G bandwidth. There is only so much airspace for all that WiFi traffic when there are tens of thousands of devices using the same spectrum in such a small enclosed area.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by dedward on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:46PM (#8406618)
The distinction doesn't mean anything though. In both cases it is up to the FCC to regulate usage, not you, or a hotel, or a conference organizer.

It's not their spectrum to manage, and everyone else has just as much right to use it as they do, event or no event.

Deliberate interference of the legal use of the airwaves by others is flat out illegal.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by kd0amg on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:34PM (#8406533)
I was talking about the WiFi bandwidth not your 3G/4G bandwidth

Spectrum is spectrum. Convention centers don't own WiFi spectrum any more than they own cell phone spectrum.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by mikeash on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:44PM (#8406606)
Well, that's the downside of using an unlicensed band. Nothing says you can't get a license for a restricted band and set up shop there, then the FCC will help you shut down interlopers instead of smacking you down when you try to do it yourself. Of course, getting the appropriate equipment will be highly troublesome, but so it goes when you want to control what people transmit.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by AndyNemmity on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:07PM (#8406391)
I work conferences, and this is totally true about unrealistically high pricing. Although I've never seen paid WiFi... there's usually 2 sets, a public Wifi, and a Wifi for internal for demos.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by nanidin on Friday October 03, 2014 @05:16PM (#8407689)
At CES, the company I worked for actually piped wireless signals directly from antenna to antenna with coax cable (or whatever it is that carries the signals from wifi) in order to reduce/eliminate the interference from thousands of other nearby devices.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by ansible on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:10PM (#8406404)
Their rationale/justification was that because WiFi at scale (40k attendees, couple hundred exhibitors) the MiFis and other hotspots are using the bandwidth that the exhibitors have paid (a lot of money) for and caused issues with their demos (which the attendees paid entry fees to see).

These high-end WiFi systems are expensive to install and administer. But that those prices they were charging, they've paid for the system in, like, the first day. Maybe by lunch time.

Conference stuff in general is crazy.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by jaynos on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:13PM (#8406420)
Yup, conventions are the world of $100 to vacuum a 10'X10' space.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by diltonm on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:39PM (#8406921)
I don't think what they did to you guys was legal:

"“Consumers who purchase cellular data plans should be able to use them without fear that their personal Internet connection will be blocked by their hotel or conference center,”"

http://transition.fcc.gov/Daily_Releases/Daily_Business/2014... http://www.fcc.gov/document/marriott-pay-600k-resolve-wifi-b...

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by dctoedt on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:24PM (#8406473)
> If they caught you using your own, they would block you and shut down your booth at the convention.

Sounds to me like an unlawful tie-in, in violation of the anti-trust laws.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by ewang1 on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:01PM (#8406711)
Just get one of those routers with 4G/LTE uplink and then go back to old school ethernet cords.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by TeMPOraL on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:08PM (#8406761)
Get few of them, borrow to neighbouring stands, charging fairly for data usage, sell them after event. Congratulations - you just made few friends, some good karma and flipped off convention organizers, all at the same time.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by bronson on Friday October 03, 2014 @03:14PM (#8407106)
Given the shitstorm they threw when they caught me carring a small mat to my booth (turns out I need to pay $100 and wait an hour for one of them to carry it), I can imagine what they'd do if they found cables between booths...

I don't picture this idea ending well.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by fnordfnordfnord on Friday October 03, 2014 @04:30PM (#8407471)
Ahh, teamsters making sure people have reasons to dislike unions.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by Crito on Friday October 03, 2014 @08:29PM (#8408349)
I'd post my rant about teamsters here, but I'm afraid I'm not a teamster so I'm not allowed to do that.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:36PM (#8406552)
Tell it to the Teamsters...
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by AnthonyMouse on Friday October 03, 2014 @03:01PM (#8407036)
Labor unions have an explicit antitrust exemption.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by chris_mahan on Friday October 03, 2014 @06:10PM (#8407906)
Do like me. Don't go to conferences.

Besides, I much prefer spending time with my son reading Asterix the Gaul comic books.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by mikeash on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:21PM (#8406461)
Were they actually jamming the signals?

I imagine that a contract that says, "You won't run a hotspot, and if we catch you doing it, we'll kick you out" would be fine. But actually jamming the radio signals would not be.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by coleca on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:34PM (#8406541)
Yes that was in the lengthy contract.

They weren't using a radio jammer, but using techniques just like were described in the article. We tried getting our gear setup and couldn't get anything working, even trying to use Internet connection sharing over Wifi between a Macbook and an iPad right next to each other wouldn't work. Until we got a hold of the network engineer for the convention and got him to whitelist our MAC addresses on their own APs. Then all of a sudden all our gear sprang to life. He told us they were looking for rogue APs and were sending frames to their clients to disassociate. If you were an attendee and not an exhibitor you could use the free public WiFi that was available. But we were warned that was far too flaky to use for product demos and would require re-registration every hour.

We also had to use commercial grade APs (like Cisco, Aruba, etc.) that could have the signal strength turned way down so it wouldn't bleed too far out of our booth. The WiFi APs at your local Staples don't usually have this option; they only boost the signals, not lower them.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by dedward on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:48PM (#8406631)
And very likely.. that act of "forcing them to disassociate" would count as interference... and be rather illegal if it went to court.

They have no authority to be able to interfere with your use of spectrum, just as you have none to interfere with theirs.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by trhway on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:31PM (#8406869)
> that act of "forcing them to disassociate" would count as interference... and be rather illegal if it went to court.

i think if a teenager did it to the Marriot then a closest DA or an FBI office would be immediately having the teenager on "unauthorized access" at minimum if not on some nice terrorism charge

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by snuxoll on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:41PM (#8406937)
That's precisely what Marriot was doing in this case, so yes, it would be against FCC rules.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by cmdrfred on Friday October 03, 2014 @06:30PM (#8408001)
Next time I stay at the Marriot, I'm going to spam deauth packets. I've already got a raspberry pi set up for just that purpose.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by kngspook on Friday October 03, 2014 @09:34PM (#8408489)
Buy a dozen Raspberry Pis with cash, configure accordingly, wander around Marriotts dropping them in inconspicuous locations (keep an eye out for cameras), leave.

Congratulations, first DDOS of a geographical site instead of a virtual one. :P

Note: This is kinda a dick move because you're probably screwing over the customers more than you are the IT douchebags. Maybe a better plan is to find the Marriott headquarters, mockup a visitor badge, and do it there.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by cmdrfred on Saturday October 04, 2014 @02:29AM (#8408944)
I've even thought about this to more devious levels. Cut a portion of drywall out in the hotel room and seal the pi back up in it (Jacking into the power lines somehow of course) good luck finding it.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by mikeash on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:43PM (#8406598)
Thanks, that's really interesting, especially the report of how it looked from your end. I imagine if I was staying at a hotel that was doing this, I'd be driven absolutely mad when my stuff didn't work and I couldn't figure out why.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by DannyBee on Friday October 03, 2014 @03:27PM (#8407171)
They were sending deauth packets.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by Nullabillity on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:25PM (#8406478)
> unrealistically high pricing that is rarely seen outside of airport newsstands

All the airport newsstands that I've seen have been free.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by digikata on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:44PM (#8406283)
On one hand, if it was jamming guest Wifi in hotel rooms it seems Marriott was acting badly. On the other hand, if this is in the context of trying to provision wifi for a conference, where there may be a lot of users packed into a dense space, I'm not so sure it's as bad. Wouldn't outside Wifi routers be fairly disruptive where you're maybe configuring individual conference service routers to lower their power -- to essentially get smaller than normal wifi range 'cells' and serve more users?
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by kstrauser on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:05PM (#8406377)
The problem is that the FCC says that you can't interfere with legally-operating radio systems. Since conference-goers' Wi-Fi hotspots are operated and licensed under FCC regulation, the hotel had no legal right to block them.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by digikata on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:09PM (#8406400)
So legally Marriott was wrong, but from a technical implementation standpoint does this policy lead to fewer users being able to connect to Wifi at a conference?

Are the regulations in this case meeting the end goal of the FCC - that good use is being made of the RF space?

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by kstrauser on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:16PM (#8406432)
You might be right, technically, but I'd much rather have the situation where no parties are allowed to interfere and manufacturers have incentive to develop sharing-friendly systems (spread spectrum, etc.), than the situation where entities can block my Internet access for their own convenience.

Were that not the case, I could enter an arms race with my neighbors where we all compete for the strongest Wi-Fi blockers so that our own signal is strongest, perhaps to the point that one of us might get a business-class connection and start allowing paid access to it. "Too bad our block can't use Wi-Fi. Say, neighbor, for $100 a month I bet I could let you share mine."

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by CamperBob2 on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:38PM (#8406565)
Exactly. This is the whole reason for the FCC's existence. It's only a popular misconception that their primary job is preventing the display of unwanted nipples on TV.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by fnordfnordfnord on Friday October 03, 2014 @04:42PM (#8407543)
What do you mean "unwanted nipples"; and that's their secondary job.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by anigbrowl on Friday October 03, 2014 @04:45PM (#8407562)
The FCC has to look at use of the RF space as a whole. Blocking Wifi inside a conference center is a good use of RF space for the purposes of the conference, but it's arguably a local maximum - if blocking technology were to come into widespread use the overall environment would be highly degraded. Suppose the landlord of the apartment building next to me wanted to squeeze out a little more rent and offered fast powerful wifi for all his tenants (blocking any attempts by the tenants at establishing sharing), but degraded the wifi in my house at the same time as an unfortunate side-effect.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by TD-Linux on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:04PM (#8406732)
One of the regulations of using the ISM bands is that you must not cause interference with other devices. In the case of wifi, this is achieved using both collision detection, and noise immune modulation methods.

Most of these mobile hotspots are going to be limited by the cell connectivity, not the wifi speed, so it would be pretty easy for multiple APs to exist on the same channel.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by eli on Friday October 03, 2014 @02:22PM (#8406828)
Maybe, but there's a process for updating the rules. Simply ignoring them isn't a great option.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by greyfade on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:06PM (#8406390)
Jamming signals in the US is a federal crime. CFR Title 17 is pretty clear that the FCC thinks it's a heinous offense.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by wglb on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:51PM (#8406314)
I'm not so sure it's as bad.

Completely illegal is not bad? Whatever the reason, this is bad.

Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by djloche on Friday October 03, 2014 @01:16PM (#8406436)
There is a clear difference between the two.
Re:Marriott Hotels fined $600,000 by FCC for jamming Wi-Fi h... by Dylan16807 on Friday October 03, 2014 @12:31PM (#8406228)
And that story is apparently wrong if it was $250 per access point rental, not per device connected.