The US does not allow states to secede. Guam or Puerto Rica may have better chances though...
From wikipedia:
"In Texas v. White, the United States Supreme Court ruled unilateral secession unconstitutional, while commenting that revolution or consent of the states could lead to a successful secession."
The constitution could be amended to explicitly allow this but I don't foresee that happening anytime soon. So yes, the US is firmly in #2.
Given the stream of world political and business leaders who have felt the need to pass comment (inevitably in favour of the "No" campaign) I really do wonder what is going on.
[NB OK OK I shouldn't have said "minor economic power" and the UK has superb (but horribly equipped and under-funded) armed forces].
[NB Doesn't matter what a bank economist or business leader says, they aren't going to change my vote.]
It was a huge fad across all the infotainment sites about three or four weeks ago.
The UK isn't some pauper state where everyone's living on the breadline, we just take a different approach to the USA.
[edit] replaced GDP with PPP for better clarity/relevance.
The UK's GDP is substantially bigger than that of any state of the US. (UK: about $2.5T; California: about $1.9T.)
The innumerable articles on the topic seem to miss the point that its not necessarily a poverty thing as a quality of living thing.
Poverty in the USA means poor health and very high crime and awful living conditions. And there's a cultural correlation with trash blowing around in the streets and run down buildings. I've spent some time in Ireland (I don't like on the US coasts so I can afford international travel) and poverty in Ireland merely means they can't afford luxuries. I never really found a slum in my wanderings of Galway and Dublin but all US cities have slums.
I have also spent time in Huntsville Alabama, mostly in the neighboring military base, decades ago. I can hear the coasties snickering already, but its really quite nice other than the humidity. So Britain being as poor as the deep south really isn't all that bad.
http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/DC-Decoder/Decoder-Voices/2014/...
It's actually quite an interesting thought exercise to contrive as many reasons as you can why the information presented there is pretty much meaningless.
A very interesting article on the UK's "independent" deterrent by Charlie Stross can be found at:
http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/04/on-the-u...
http://www.snp.org/media-centre/news/2014/mar/westminster-ad...
If true, this would certainly explain why people with no conceivable direct interest in the constitutional settlement of the British Isles (Vladimir Putin, anyone? Tony Abbot?) have been speaking out strongly against the independence campaign: it costs nothing and keeps the British ambassador's boss happy.
We are anticipating what will happen if "yes" succeeds and what that means to Scotland (and its economy). World leaders do not want successfully countries with desirable/friendly leaders to break up.
In the long run, about as much as Ireland. This is not the first piece of land the British Empire has lost. Not uncharted territory at all.
My music teacher at secondary school (a staunch SNP supporter) spent a significant amount of time teaching us songs about a war 700 years ago (NB guess why the referendum is in 2014?).
Personally, I would forget the Declaration of Arbroath, no matter how stirring it may be, and focus on the Declaration of Calton Hill which is all about a better future:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_Calton_Hill
[Ignore its origins with the SSP - entertaining bunch of lunatics though they are].
Either way most people in the US know about some of them. Thats why I chose to say: "Insert Braveheart reference here" instead of "It's all for nothing if you don't have freedom."
...for, as long as but a hundred of us remain alive, never will we on any conditions be brought under English rule. It is in truth not for glory, nor riches, nor honours that we are fighting, but for freedom – for that alone, which no honest man gives up but with life itself.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_Arbroath
Which, as an aside, has some quite interesting stuff about sacking a King if he isn't good at his job...
[NB This has no real relevance to the current referendum - but I'd be lying if I didn't admit to liking this kind of stuff.]
I favor the No campaign because I favor federalism, in general - though as someone who grew up in Ireland, I can also empathize with the desire for a separate national identity. Overall, though, the practical freedom of being able to cross borders without having to account for one's movements or accept inequitable monetary transactions is a far more valuable liberty than nominal participation in some abstract sovereignty. I have my doubts about whether Irish independence from the UK was really advantageous and feel that my European citizenship - nebulous though European political identity may be - is of far greater value than my Irish citizenship.
As far as Scotland in particular is concerned, I think independence is a very mixed blessing - whether or not I'm right about the long-term value in the short term I would anticipate a period of vicious factional politicking.
I didn't say we shouldn't. I think that is ultimately the direction we should be aiming towards. True democracy, where the people decide.
Independence, Independence with a currency union, further devolution, the current status quo and what it was like a decade ago are all points on a spectrum rather than a black and white thing.
There is certainly a spectrum of different levels of devolution, but make no mistake: there is a massive chasm at the point of actual independence. It changes everything.
1. This is great, throwing it back to government for the people and really should shake up big federal governments.
2. Or maybe not so great, because of number of pitfalls. Getting something like secession right is hard, chances are economies will suffer hard. There will be some superpowers that will never allow this is current political climate such as China, Russia, and potentially India. This will be effectively strengthening their positions. If countries split up into smaller states, while local governance will likely improve, international gridlock will not.