Re:Why Scotland looks like the canary in the independence co...
by collyw on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @05:10PM
(#8327136)
Its a step closer to democracy, where your voting power is not diluted ten times.
Re:Why Scotland looks like the canary in the independence co...
by anigbrowl on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @05:18PM
(#8327177)
Why not make every street into its own republic? Because more voting power within a less powerful entity isn't necessarily an overall improvement. I'm unconvinced that sovereignty is infinitely divisible or effectively fungible (and I promise you that this is not for lack of exploring radically different concepts).
Re:Why Scotland looks like the canary in the independence co...
by collyw on Thursday September 18, 2014 @06:28AM
(#8334506)
>Why not make every street into its own republic?
I didn't say we shouldn't. I think that is ultimately the direction we should be aiming towards. True democracy, where the people decide.
I favor the No campaign because I favor federalism, in general - though as someone who grew up in Ireland, I can also empathize with the desire for a separate national identity. Overall, though, the practical freedom of being able to cross borders without having to account for one's movements or accept inequitable monetary transactions is a far more valuable liberty than nominal participation in some abstract sovereignty. I have my doubts about whether Irish independence from the UK was really advantageous and feel that my European citizenship - nebulous though European political identity may be - is of far greater value than my Irish citizenship.
As far as Scotland in particular is concerned, I think independence is a very mixed blessing - whether or not I'm right about the long-term value in the short term I would anticipate a period of vicious factional politicking.