News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Igglyboo on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:25PM (#8320474)
You could easily argue that everything that ever was or will be is natural, not really sure why the word is still used to describe products.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by sp332 on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:32PM (#8320525)
Hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen are natural. But this arrangement of the atoms does not occur unless humans want it to. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tramadol
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by spacehome on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:49PM (#8320629)
Eh. If you leave hydrogen alone for long enough, it will turn into tramadol.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by rbanffy on Monday September 15, 2014 @11:11PM (#8322844)
Yes, but you'll need a lot of it. Even a full universe sample takes almost 20 billion years to synthesize a relatively small amount.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by dalke on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @05:42AM (#8323705)
And that was with a helium booster, along with a smidge of lithium. My guess is that with only hydrogen it would have taken even longer.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Igglyboo on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:52PM (#8320650)
Yes that's what I'm saying, "unless humans want it to" still qualifies as natural. Humans are natural and a part of nature and so anything they create is as well.

If a beehive or beaver dam is considered natural then so is the empire state building, all three were created by animals native to this planet.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by dllthomas on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:02PM (#8320731)
Sure, you can redefine the word in a way that makes it meaningless. Or you can use it the way the rest of the world does - where "natural" means "not the result of human intervention". By that definition, it's obvious why a beehive and beaver dam are "natural" and the Empire State Building is not. There is a degree to which this focus is arbitrary, but given that we are humans, it's sometimes a worthwhile focus to have. That in turn, of course, does not mean it's correct to care about it everywhere we seem to.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by teddyh on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:17PM (#8321232)
Zhuangzi had something to say about this:

“'What do you mean,' pursued the earl, 'by the Heavenly, and by the Human?' Ruo replied, 'Oxen and horses have four feet - that is what I call their Heavenly (constitution). When horses' heads are haltered, and the noses of oxen are pierced, that is what I call (the doing of) Man. Hence it is said, "Do not by the Human (doing) extinguish the Heavenly (constitution); do not for your (Human) purpose extinguish the appointment (of Heaven); do not bury your (proper) fame in (such) a pursuit of it; carefully guard (the Way) and do not lose it: this is what I call reverting to your True (Nature)."'”

— Zhuangzi, chapter 17 (“The Floods of Autumn”)

http://ctext.org/zhuangzi/floods-of-autumn#n42150

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by mason240 on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:27PM (#8321292)
That's the point, it is a meaningless term.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by dllthomas on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:36PM (#8321357)
No. The way most people use the term it has a meaning. It's the redefinition that is meaningless, and should thus be rejected as useless. That doesn't mean that people always reason correctly about it, but that should be confronted directly not by playing semantic games.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Houshalter on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:36PM (#8321352)
You have redefined a word to be entirely useless and then get upset when other people don't subscribe to your new definition of the word.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by pyre on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:02PM (#8320732)
Doesn't that devalue the term if everything ever is 'natural' making it impossible for anything to be unnatural?
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by qnaal on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:26PM (#8320905)
The idea, I think, is that humans have been sharing the planet with everything else for so long that anything especially dangerous that occurs "naturally" is likely to have been already tested- ie "artificial" drugs should be more unpredictable, and therefore potentially more dangerous, than whatever stuff some exotic culture has been fucking with for hundreds of generations (which is pretty much any interesting compound you can find "naturally").

Of course, unscrupulous-types will lean on whatever marketing stunt they feel will sell some short-term product, with little respect for the long-term dangers/benefits, so naturally words like "natural" and "organic" get abused.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by eru on Monday September 15, 2014 @07:47PM (#8322255)
Alcohol is natural, and dangerous. But at least we know the long term effects.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by alexjeffrey on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:43PM (#8320595)
more importantly, the use of "natural" to describe a product with the implication that it being synthetic would be a bad thing is a fallacy.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by rjurney on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:54PM (#8320673)
Still, there is something nice about a chemical appearing in nature. Gives evidence that it doesn't do batshit crazy things to life.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by pron on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:05PM (#8320751)
Have you heard of the very natural Oxygen Catastrophe[1] that wiped out much of the life on Earth? Some organisms began dumping a toxic chemical (oxygen) into the atmosphere in such large quantities that it practically killed off everyone except for those weird mutants that evolved to actually breathe that dangerous toxin synthesized by the killers!

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by gohrt on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @02:06AM (#8323259)
Right. Oxygen was very bad for life when it appeared. Oxygen is good for life now, that evolved in its wake. I don't want massive quantities of stuff appearing that is bad for life now.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by pron on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @10:08AM (#8324509)
But that "bad stuff" is just as likely to be a natural product (as was oxygen during the catastrophe) as it's likely to be synthetic.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Dylan16807 on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:41PM (#8320993)
Yeah yeah it's not 100% but it's still reasonably strong evidence. If you find something in a plant that's eaten by many things then it's probably not very toxic.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by pron on Monday September 15, 2014 @03:55PM (#8321092)
Maybe that's some evidence, but it's certainly not reasonably strong (in fact, it's very weak evidence). First, some of those "many things" would need to have a metabolism that's close to ours. Secondly, even if those unaffected organisms are similar to us, we would need to consume that molecule at similar concentrations. Most toxins have adverse effect only beyond a certain dosage. Something can be harmless (like cyanide) in it's "naturally occurring" concentrations, and positively lethal in higher doses. Besides, synthetic molecules are tested before they're approved for human consumption, and they are usually tested on animals with similar metabolism to us, and at the appropriate dose. So actually, FDA approval is a much, much, much stronger evidence for a drug's safety than it being extracted from "nature".
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Dylan16807 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @03:29AM (#8323425)
'toxic' is a much weaker assertion than 'does batshit crazy things to life'
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by freehunter on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:59PM (#8320703)
That idea might make you feel better, but it's not grounded in reality at all. Chemicals appearing in nature do batshit crazy things to life all the time.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by gone35 on Monday September 15, 2014 @06:13PM (#8321862)
If by "batshit crazy" you meant toxicity, then yes that's clearly incorrect, as others have repeatedly pointed out. Perhaps you meant chemical affinity in some general way --eg homochirality, or presence of commonly targeted functional groups?

If so, note this is the exact opposite of 'biocompatible' in the usual sense (as in 'inert'): biosynthesized molecules evolved precisely to be exceedingly good at reacting/interfering with biological processes, not the other way around. So if anything, it would be evidence they could well do batshit crazy, unintended things to life --as they often do.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by teekert on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:59PM (#8320699)
Because no naturally occurring substances do batshit crazy things to life? It's all about the dosage.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Igglyboo on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:58PM (#8320691)
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by teekert on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:57PM (#8320685)
Exactly, cyanobacteria are also natural as is tobacco. One can synthesize many natural products in purer and safer forms.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by Gravityloss on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:51PM (#8321460)
Cigarettes are very far from just dried tobacco leaves, as they've been engineered to maximize addiction with additives.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_additives_in_cigarettes

http://ec.europa.eu/health/scientific_committees/opinions_la...

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by 80ProofPudding on Monday September 15, 2014 @02:52PM (#8320651)
Agreed. "Organic" is pretty widely abused, too - want to drink some crude oil? It's organic...
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:00PM (#8321110)
Crude oil is [primarily] organic if your context is [petro]chemistry. It's not an organic foodstuff however.

Shock, horror, words have contexts which cause them to mean different things.

Why is it that you don't wish people to know where their food has come from and how it has been produced. What is the problem with that for you? If you don't care that your children's food is saturated with growth hormones, fungicides, hormones and pesticides or that the farmers you buy from use so much Tramadol that the environment tests positively for it [as in the current case], fine, but why does it matter so much if other people want to know the conditions their food has been grown in? Say, by looking for organic food certifications. [There see I included "food" in case it confused you, words can be so hard, huh.]

There's no great logic to the insistence that words can't be used for multiple well defined meanings - yes even in associated fields like chemistry and food science/agriculture - and AFAICT there's no detriment to you in others choosing to care more about the rearing or growing conditions of their food (which you don't have to eat).

So what is your problem?

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by tjradcliffe on Monday September 15, 2014 @05:53PM (#8321747)
"Shock, horror, words have contexts which cause them to mean different things."

Dunno what his problem is, but my problem is the context in which "organic" gets used with respect to foods: a massively expensive, misleading, anti-science marketing campaign by huge corporations intent on profiting from people's mistaken belief that "organic" products are--by virtue of being "organic"--healthier or better for the environment.

Since the people behind this huge corporate marketing campaign are also promulgating lies about GMOs in an attempt to force labeling on them and prevent their development, your claim "there's no detriment" to others from those who support them is false.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday September 17, 2014 @11:09AM (#8330354)
>an attempt to force labeling on them and prevent their development //

Labelling only provides people with the ability to chose. Against choice? Consumers can make uninformed choices, sure, but that choice is central to a democratic system.

Who are the corporations that you're referring to? The majority of organic stuff we get in the UK is from small corporations or local farms, it is the bigger corps that stand to lose most from a desire from the public to have organic (and similar ethos) production of food. For example factory farming chicken relies on being able to pump them full of antibiotics.

You say it's a mistaken belief that organic food is better - the meta-studies I've seen seem to flip between the two positions pretty rapidly. Can you cite maybe one or two studies that you would say show incontrovertibly that organic production is no better for people, animal welfare and/or the environment? Thanks.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by alexjeffrey on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:49PM (#8321440)
I'm not the parent (I'm GP), but my position is that organic certification is good, but the universal association of "natural = good, synthetic = bad" is only harmful.

Yes, farmers pump animals full of chemicals and this should be documented and, if you are concerned about this, it's a good thing that there are organic food certs out there. However, whole industries fuelled by bullshit have sprung up off the back of this very common fallacy. There are people out there who don't take scientifically-proven medicine because it's "not natural" and lean towards quackery like homeopathy, and this is what I'm opposed to.

To reiterate, IMO organic or free-range farm produce is a good thing and I'm sure most people would agree with that. That's not what I was talking about so don't get rude with people based on a misinterpretation of the subject, it's unnecessarily disruptive.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by 80ProofPudding on Monday September 15, 2014 @04:30PM (#8321317)
I think you're casting me as a proxy in a larger argument.

You're also being pretty insulting about it.

Life's too short. I've no time for people like that.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by CamperBob2 on Monday September 15, 2014 @07:38PM (#8322218)
Can't speak for the GP, but in my case, I object to laws requiring labels on GMO, etc. foodstuffs simply because I don't want to live in California, where literally everything has one or more dire warning labels attached to it. When everything is dangerous, nothing is. The labels end up not being taken seriously, and the consumer ends up less-informed than they otherwise would have been.
Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @12:41AM (#8323045)
"Literally" applies, by the way, when the whole building you're in has a sign in the lobby that reads "This building contains substances known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects, and itchy rashes."

I'm worried that this is where the slippery slope of GMO labeling will lead.

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by gohrt on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @02:09AM (#8323265)
So the solution is to label nothing, and actively mislabel everything? That doesn't sound right.

https://www.google.com/search?q=john+oliver+food+labels

Re:Tramadol Is Not a Natural Product After All by CamperBob2 on Tuesday September 16, 2014 @02:19AM (#8323291)
No, you label things when there is scientific evidence, of the peer-reviewed and -reproduced kind, that there is a non-obvious risk associated with a given foodstuff or other item. GMO labeling falls well short of that standard.