News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by qwerta on Saturday September 13, 2014 @09:52AM (#8312370)
I think Lem wrote sci-fi just by coincidence. Soviets would not allow any sort of criticism on serious stuff. But they adored sci-fi and cosmic future of mankind. Lem could write undisturbed on this field.

Western sci-fi authors such as Asimov and Clarke were great, but they were not best what literature can offer. In many cases they use story as boilerplate to present some technical marvel. Lem was one of the best authors, even outside sci-fi.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:16AM (#8312426)
Lem had a genuine and lifelong interest in technology. Polish authors found plenty of ways to be critical without having to divert into genre fiction. Lem wrote it because he loved it.

I wholeheartedly agree that the need to read between the lines politically, and the belief that science fiction is a serious literary endeavor, put Polish and Soviet scifi on a completely different level of quality than in the West. (The same is likely true for other countries in the Eastern Bloc, but I'm out of my depth there).

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by EthanHeilman on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:59AM (#8312535)
>Polish and Soviet scifi on a completely different level of quality than in the West

That isn't entirely true, Lem praised the work of Philip K. Dick (American)[0][1] and Olaf Stapledon (English). He has two essays in which he analyzes Stapledon two great works: Last and First Men, and Star Maker[2].

I think you might also be suffering from a filter. The best of Polish writers were translated, whereas you have access to the glut of all American writers. It is probably true that there was a greater number of bad American writers.

[0]: http://www.depauw.edu/sfs/backissues/5/lem5art.htm

[1]: Dick returned the favor by reporting Lem to the FBI as a communist conspiracy against the west. Arguing that Lem was in fact a committee and not a person. Read the letter here: http://english.lem.pl/faq#P.K.Dick

[2]: http://dpuadweb.depauw.edu/icronay_web/lem%20stapledon.html

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:14PM (#8312754)
Those are good points, and I hadn't even heard of Stapledon. Thank you!
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by kybernetikos on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:23PM (#8313133)
Last and First Men isn't really a story in the normal sense, so if you're quite plot and character driven it can be fairly hard to get through, but the perspective it gives you is like being woken up by a blast of icy air in the face.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by jacquesm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:33PM (#8312821)
Last & First men and Starmaker are in a single book, and it's great. One of the classics of SF, if you can't find a copy let me know and I'll send you mine when I'm back in NL.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by EthanHeilman on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:52PM (#8313040)
'Last and First Men' tends to be a book that science fiction authors read and borrow from.

I suspect that there is a slight conspiracy: "the first rule of science fiction writers club is that you don't talk about Stapledon". It inspired most of modern science fiction but very few outside of the field have heard about it. Accelerando, The Shape of Things to Come, 1984, That Hideous Strength, 2001, Blindsight, most of HP Lovecraft, etc... all borrow from him.

To C.S. Lewis and AC Clarke's credit, they do acknowledge the importance of Stapledon to their work.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by jacquesm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:07PM (#8313089)
I got quite seriously ill when I was 22, right after starting my first company. Bad timing. 3 months in bed with nothing to do. My neighbour Erik donated me his entire SF collection, which he'd been putting together for more than 2 decades, a gift for which I'll be eternally grateful. This was one of the gems in that stack of books. I'd have never heard of it until this thread today otherwise.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by EthanHeilman on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:40PM (#8313178)
I often encourage people to view current events from the 30,000 foot view of Stapledon, but people don't this naturally. Recent events loom extremely large in our minds. To my surprise US policy people have told me that the United States will "never end".

Do you think 'Last and First Men' changed your perspective?

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by jacquesm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @03:03PM (#8313229)
Absolutely, and the 'everything is temporary' bit really hit me. It makes you look in a completely different way at your own life, both the parts already past and the parts still in the future. Think 'total perspective vortex' but without cheating.

The timescale of the book is staggering. It's like that 'pale blue dot' picture.

http://www.wscribe.com/parables/pass.html

For those that haven't read the book or that don't have access to it, the book follows the 'first men' (us) and their successors across billions of years. Not all movement in time is progress and not all change is natural. Very much recommended, I won't write any more here to not spoil the book for future readers.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by rbanffy on Sunday September 14, 2014 @08:44AM (#8315103)
> US policy people have told me that the United States will "never end".

Cut them some slack. If they say anything different it's likely some lunatic will label them "unamerican". While the country, as it presently stands, will not endure for long in a planetary timescale, we'll be fortunate if some of the core ideals behind its foundation last for a longer time and help guide our descendants into the deep future.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:00AM (#8312537)
> Polish authors found plenty of ways to be critical without having to divert into genre fiction.

There is this misconception popular even among young Poles that the communism in Poland was a period of hardship and oppression. Sure, many things were bad, but if one talks to one's parents and grandparents, they seem to be mostly happy with that period and in many ways would gladly trade it for what we have today.

Especially censorship in Poland was mostly a façade. The system paid lip service to it, but generally people were free to criticize the government, communist reality and made a great lot of self-criticizing works of art.

Living might have been harder in other Soviet states. It definitely was bad in Russia. But here in Poland, we had as benevolent socialist system as one could be. You could be known as a religious person and not a member of the Party, and still hold a top accounting position in a strategic government enterprise.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by jacquesm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:32AM (#8312635)
Beware of romanticizing of the past by the older generation, who will be good at remembering their own relatively trouble free lives while ignoring the hardships that others endured.

Poland had a ton of things that were very very wrong, look no further than the SB and their victims. The fact that 98% of a nation experienced no significant hardships does not detract from that at all.

It is very well possible to have a totalitarian dictatorship in which everybody has a job and there is food on the table and an outward appearance of relative prosperity, but totally rotten underneath.

Poland did not have a 'benevolent socialist system' by any measure.

I'll just leave this link here, you can research the SB and Jaruzelski on your own good time:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerzy_Popie%C5%82uszko

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by galfarragem on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:08PM (#8312738)
Anyway I wouldn't trade a 'benevolent socialist system' (somehow Polish case) for a 'benevolent fascist system' (somehow Portuguese case). Average life standards in Portugal were light-years distance from Polish ones.

Ex: While living in Poland, once I commented to a friend that my grandparents could barely read and one grandmother couldn't read at all. He thought I was joking. Or another example: my grandfather got his first shoes when he went to military service. These situations were unthinkable in Poland during communist times. In Poland at the same time lots of people were having university education and most people from lower classes were having holidays.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:13PM (#8312751)
When I think "benevolent socialist system", I think Denmark rather than tanks in the street. But this is a thread about scifi, so I'll stop there.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by qwerta on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:49AM (#8312502)
I think he could be best compared to earlier authors such as Karel Čapek (inventor of word robot),

I think he would call himself 'futurologist'. Scifi on west was defined by laser-guns and girls in bikini on comic covers. East scifi just adored soviet ideal of future. Hard scifi was recognized much later.

Lem had complicated approach to technology. From his wiki page:

> His criticism of most science fiction surfaced in literary and philosophical essays (Fantastyka i futurologia) and interviews.[24] In the 1990s Lem forswore science fiction and returned to futurological prognostications, most notably those expressed in Okamgnienie (Blink of an Eye). He became increasingly critical of modern technology in his later life, criticizing inventions such as the Internet.[25]

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by ableal on Saturday September 13, 2014 @04:37PM (#8313479)
> Karel Čapek (inventor of word robot)

Funnily enough, his robots were actually androids - biological, rather than mechanical, beings.

He also wrote, in 1922, a pantheistic gem called The Absolute at Large: mankind finds out how to get energy from matter annihilation. But that frees up "the absolute", which inspires religious devotion ...

(Pierre Boule, in "Les jeux de l'esprit", probably wrote up the opposite premise, general triumph of rationalism, with pretty much the same result, general conflict.)

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by Squarex on Sunday September 14, 2014 @02:41AM (#8314677)
Actually the word robot was invented by his brother Josef Čapek.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by cageface on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:31AM (#8312457)
What other Polish or Soviet authors are worth reading? (and translated into English)

I love Lem's work but that's the extent of my familiarity with Eastern Bloc sci-fi.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:40AM (#8312479)
I highly recommend the Strugatsky brothers. There's a new translation of "Roadside Picnic" out, that would be a great place to start.

Another good one is "We" by Evgenii Zamyatin. It's a dystopian novel Orwell cribbed from for 1984.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by qwerta on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:54AM (#8312522)
I mostly know Czech authors by name. Some are probably not translated to english:

Karel Čapek (pre soviet)

František_Běhounek (part of Italia north pole expedition) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franti%C5%A1ek_B%C4%9Bhounek

J. M. Troska https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&js=y&pr...

Ondřej Neff (post soviet) and his stories around Clarkes monoliths.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by ajuc on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:20PM (#8312774)
Jacek Dukaj is great, but I don't know when he will be translated.

He mostly writes hard sci-fi with political and philosophical elements, often about transhumanism, but he also did weird philosophical alternative history book - "Lód" (Ice).

Some English reviews of his books:

http://greglewicki.wordpress.com/2012/01/24/perfect-imperfec...

http://www.terminally-incoherent.com/blog/2012/02/10/black-o...

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by mtobi on Sunday September 14, 2014 @08:24AM (#8315072)
Actually, on a polish fantasy convention Polcon Dukaj told a story about the attempted translation of "Lód". Hea gathered a group of seven people, Polish to English translators, russophiles, cultural experts and what not. He said, that after two days they gave up after not being able to agree on the first page. The historical and cultural baggage this book carries is just too great to be even remotely translated into english, although he also mentioned that there is a steggering amount of pirate translations into russian.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by ajuc on Monday September 15, 2014 @05:27AM (#8317938)
Yeah I wonder how you can translate "Pomyślało się" :)
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by kgabis on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:53PM (#8313041)
Dukaj is amazing, his "Other Songs" ("Inne Pieśni" in polish) is one of the best books I've ever read. I really hope it gets translated to english so non-polish speakers can read it.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by TeMPOraL on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:03AM (#8312545)
I strongly recommend the works of Jacek Dukaj. His "Black Oceans" is one of the most idea-dense science fiction book I have ever read. And eerily relevant to our times, especially wrt. HFT and proliferation of surveillance.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by vdaniuk on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:42AM (#8312483)
I am from xUSSR and happy to recommend Strugatsky brothers. Their sci-fi books are deep, thoughtful and authentic.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:44AM (#8312487)
Can't agree enough.

Is there any more recent Russian sci-fi that you recommend too?

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by vdaniuk on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:51AM (#8312512)
Not really :(

I've heard some good things about Metro 2033 by Gluhovskiy, a post-apocalyptic novel about survivors living in Moscow underground train system after the nuclear war in 2013, but haven't read it myself.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by flohofwoe on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:25AM (#8312610)
Metro 2033 is a good read, I've been reading the German translation, and this still had that specific 'Russian soul' in it which is hard to describe. I was shocked how bad Metro 2034 is though in comparison, and I am not sure whether it was just a very bad German translation or whether the original book was also 'soul-less'.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by sigsergv on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:03AM (#8312544)
Unfortunately there not so many soviet and contemporary russian authors are translated. So besides already recommended Strugatskie borthers there almost nothing.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by selimthegrim on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:05PM (#8312912)
Does Pelevin count as sci-fi? Omon-Ra?
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by sigsergv on Saturday September 13, 2014 @01:14PM (#8312936)
Why not? Pelevin and Vonnegut are in the same boat.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:15PM (#8312760)
Which ones should we translate? :-)
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by sigsergv on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:55PM (#8312886)
Vyacheslav Rybakov and Andrey Lazarchuk
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by scotty79 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @03:27PM (#8313295)
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by arafalov on Saturday September 13, 2014 @05:30PM (#8313672)
Try Sergei Lukyanenko (multiple spellings). Most of his works are not translated in English (German has many more), but at least the Night Watch and Day Watch are. They were both made into movies too, though the movies absolutely sucked comparing to the books.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by lafar6502 on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:47PM (#8312863)
I can recommend Kir Bulychov and his funny stories about Great Guslar (fictional city somewhere in USSR that was frequently visited by aliens). I'm not sure, however, if this has been translated to english. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kir_Bulychov
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by Joeri on Sunday September 14, 2014 @03:14AM (#8314712)
I would argue that the best science fiction is about putting humans in unlikely places and seeing how they adapt. Great sci-fi is definitely not about technology, with technology merely being the instrument to set a stage that couldn't exist in a non-scifi work. See asimov's foundation or leguin's left hand of darkness as examples of technology being just a stage-setting device to tell a great story.

I have read a lot of non scifi literature, and I would argue that quite a few of those books are more about impressing with linguistic marvels than about telling a great story. For example, I had such a hard time getting to the story behind the writing in books like Ulysses and The Satanic Verses that I didn't even finish reading them.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by hristov on Saturday September 13, 2014 @06:04PM (#8313755)
I have to strongly disagree there. There may have been some anti-establishment satire in his writing, but that is not the main thing he wrote about.

Lem was probably one of the most pure sci-fi authors out there. He was not that interested in using sci-fi as a metaphor for everyday issues, but he genuinely wanted to explore issues that were outside of our everyday lives. Such as what would an artificial intelligence or an artificial consciousness look like, what would an alien intelligence or consciousness look like, how could we possibly communicate with a being that is truly alien, i.e., it is completely different than everything we know about life and biological development on earth. His two most famous novels -- Solaris and Fiasco were both about communicating with an alien intelligence, and did not have any anti-communist or anti-soviet satire in them.

I agree he is a great writer. But I do not like it when people say "he was not really a sci-fi writer" as a precursor to saying "he is a great writer", as if one could not be a great writer while being a sci-fi writer. Lem is a great writer and a sci-fi writer. He possessed the most important thing in a sci-fi writer he could think up of interesting and/or important ideas, and he could describe them in an engaging manner and explore the consequences.

By the way, now that sci-fi is a billions of dollars a year business, sci-fi writers still have not bothered to deal with the ideas suggested by Lem. Aliens in modern sci-fi are almost always based on humans in one way or another. Today's sci-fi authors are committing the same mistake the scientists of Fiasco did by thinking too much about themselves when trying to imagine a being that is truly alien to humanity.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by mtobi on Sunday September 14, 2014 @08:30AM (#8315081)
And just to get at the topic of anti-establishement satire in poish literature, the prime example has always been Janusz Zajdel. Especially his late two most aacknowledged works, "Limes Inferior" and "Pardyzja" primarily depict totalitarian, dystopian systems and the means of people to game them. It is a great shame that he has been taken by cancer at a relatively young age because the world view he presented in his books was darker and more bitter compared to Lem.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by praptak on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:10AM (#8312565)
Lem was actually pretty critical of the whole "SF by coincidence". By his own definition, if you can easily replace lasers and spaceships with cloaks and daggers, then it is not SF.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by atombender on Saturday September 13, 2014 @05:16PM (#8313608)
I disagree wholeheartedly (except for your last sentence). Books such as Eden and Fiasco are firmly rooted in the tradition of the sci-fi adventure, even if he adds additional philosophical and scientific concerns that were completely his own. But Lem's work is mostly explicitly grounded in scifi.

As an aside, I find Lem's prose to be rather dry, most of the time (though The Cyberiad is a notable exception). I don't know if this is something one can blame on the translators. In his scientist-focused novels, especially Solaris and The Futurological Congress, this works well; also, those are short works where the stodgy prose doesn't overwhelm. In other, longer works such as Fiasco and His Master's Voice, I find the prose almost unbearable. (Those latter two could really use some editing, too. Fiasco opens up with a seemingly endless chapter wherein a guy wanders around on an ice planet in an exosuit, and the prose catalogues nearly every single step the guy takes; it's infuritating and sleep-inducing at the same time.)

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by kybernetikos on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:30PM (#8313154)
> they were not best what literature can offer. In many cases they use story as boilerplate to present some technical marvel.

There's an awful lot of sneering at science fiction writing as subpar literature and it's completely unfair. Some of Asimovs work actually is good literature, despite the fact that some is just filler that he wrote because he was more or less forced to by his publishers. I've never particularly rated Clarke, so perhaps your criticisms there are fair. What about Ray Bradbury, or Philip K Dick or Frank Herbert or Zelazny? There are more I could mention too, including some writing today.

Having said that Lem is pretty special. I loved some of The Star Diaries and there's a scene in the Futurological Congress that still brings a smile to my face (sewer rats on hallucinogens hallucinating they're human and playing bridge).

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by DonHopkins on Sunday September 14, 2014 @01:55AM (#8314622)
I just watched The Congress -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Congress_(2013_film) -- and WOW, it was excellent. Quite different from the book The Futurological Conference that it's based on: for example, it had cockroaches playing poker instead of sewer rats playing bridge. ;) But well worth watching for its unique take on the entertainment dictatorship. If you liked Who Framed Roger Rabbit, Looker, and Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas, you won't be disappointed! Something weird happens in the middle of the film, that's all I'll say...

>According to director Ari Folman, some elements of the film were inspired by the science fiction novel The Futurological Congress by Stanisław Lem in that similarly to Lem's Ijon Tichy, the actress is split between delusional and real mental states. Later, at the official website of the film, in an interview, Folman says that the idea to put Lem's work to film came to him during his film school. He describes how he reconsidered Lem's allegory of communist dictatorship into a more current setting, namely, the dictatorship in the entertainment business, and expresses his belief that he preserved the spirit of the book despite going far away from it.

It took longer than its length of two hours to watch, because I had to stop and rewind to replay and and freeze frames frequently. (Check out what's going on in the fish tank while she's saying "I wish you could see me animated, it's pretty sick. It's like a genius designer on a bad acid trip. Oh my god, I don't know, I look like a combination between Cinderella on heroin and an Egyptian queen on a bad hair day".)

I'm going to have to watch it many more times, because there were a lot of details to absorb -- time will tell if it's up there with Blade Runner as one of my favorite movies very loosely based on a great book.

http://culture.pl/en/article/ari-folman-on-the-genius-of-sta...

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by tspiteri on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:45AM (#8312672)
In many cases they use story as boilerplate to present some technical marvel.

I find that to be more true for Clarke than for Asimov. Clarke likes to present technical marvels, and the stories themselves are quite bare, but Asimov focuses more on the characters, leaving the technical marvels in the background.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by Nursie on Saturday September 13, 2014 @02:42PM (#8313185)
That's incredibly unfair. Scifi is a very broad category. Some of the best imagines just a small change to the world and watches how people live around it. Some is imaginative flights of fantasy, some is realistic futurism. And yes some is the presentation of technological ideas using the story as a simple vehicle.

Lem is great, as are a variety of other eastern authors, but they're not head and shoulders above their western counterparts nor is the genre lacking in literary skill in the west.

See for examples - Phillip K Dick, Iain M Banks, Daniel Keyes, Frank Herbert and many others.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by dredmorbius on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:17AM (#8312582)
Setting critical literature in fantastical or allegorical contexts is as old as writing. You'll find it in Aesop's fables, Dante, Shakespeare, Swift, and more. Soviet rule was particularly harsh in this regard, and music was another outlet (Shostakovich in particular wrote a number of pieces now considered highly subversive).

Lem is excellent, though.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by lmm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @11:56AM (#8312710)
And doing it in SF is as old as the genre itself - Wells wrote War of the Worlds so that he could criticize British colonialism at one remove.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by dredmorbius on Saturday September 13, 2014 @07:43PM (#8314043)
Shelley, Poe, and Verne had the jump on Wells. Their works also had an element of social criticism. It's hard for any adult writing not to.

As I said, it's part of literature. Sci Fi filled that role as it came into existence, in part a result of science emerging as a thing in the 19th century, distinct from natural philosophy.

Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by copperx on Saturday September 13, 2014 @04:27PM (#8313457)
Just to be clear: Lem is critical of such literature.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by dredmorbius on Sunday September 14, 2014 @06:38AM (#8314941)
Any specific references on that?
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by ploj on Saturday September 13, 2014 @12:31PM (#8312809)
There's also the fact that society during his time was extremely techno-utopian. That was just as true in the Soviet Union.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by jacquesm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:12AM (#8312414)
I thought he was Polish.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:18AM (#8312429)
He was.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by jacquesm on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:21AM (#8312435)
Censorship in Poland had a funny element, as weird as that may sound. It wasn't un-typical for postcards or letters to contain 'greetings to the censor' at the end or even as the salutation.
Re:The Future According to Stanisław Lem by idlewords on Saturday September 13, 2014 @10:39AM (#8312475)
It was a surreal society where everyone had to pretend to be living in an imaginary world. Luckily there weren't too many hard-liners; the jackboot was applied without much enthusiasm after 1956. Life was way harder for the Russians.