News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by iopq on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:22AM (#8252233)
You have to wonder how far people are willing to go to declare things defects. At first it's just serious diseases. But then people will want their children to have correct color vision and other nice things.

However, on the other hand, this could actually be a good direction to move in. We can not only eliminate genetic diseases, but also genes that predispose us to other common diseases like cancer.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by blueskin_ on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:07AM (#8252332)
>At first it's just serious diseases. But then people will want their children to have correct color vision and other nice things.

...and they should. Nobody deserves a suboptimal quality of life due to genetics.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by PostOnce on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:26AM (#8252371)
It's implied that later it won't just be functional things like color vision, but eye color, height, hair color, cleft chin, etc.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by baddox on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:37AM (#8252390)
And the same goes for those as well, if changing them would for some reason improve the child's quality of life.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by mseebach on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:21AM (#8252488)
And then someone isolates a gene that predicts homosexuality.

I'm a strong techno-optimist, and I think we should have an extremely open mind to the possibilities offered to us by these advances, and we should fight the tendency to fortify our little local maximum out of fear - but we also need to recognize that some really dangerous things lie ahead.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by teddyh on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:38AM (#8252535)
If homosexuality really is genetic, isn’t it doomed to eventual extinction?

http://tailsteak.com/archive.php?num=118

Re:A girl with three biological parents by tzs on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:31PM (#8253895)
Look up (1) kin selection, and (2) sickle cell anemia for information on a couple ways by which genetic traits that can discourage those who have them from reproducing can persist and even thrive in a population.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by oafitupa on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:03PM (#8253788)
Not necessarily; it could be, but it certainly wouldn't happen quickly. Here you have several possibilities explained by Dawkins:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MHDCAllQgS0

Re:A girl with three biological parents by mseebach on Monday September 01, 2014 @09:12AM (#8252639)
Apparently there's some influence: http://www.theguardian.com/science/2014/feb/14/genes-influen...

But genes or not, I brought it up as an example of something that we're clearly NOT comfortable removing (even if we could), although there's still plenty of communities where not being gay "would for some reason improve the child's quality of life".

Re:A girl with three biological parents by afafsd on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:05PM (#8253792)
>But genes or not, I brought it up as an example of something that we're clearly NOT comfortable removing (even if we could)

Why are "we" clearly not comfortable with that?

Indeed, if "we" are all uncomfortable with that then we needn't worry about anyone doing it. You seem to be worried that some people are going to want to specify non-gay children but think they ought to have them anyway. For some reason.

On the other hand I admit it might make me queasy to think of parents deliberately engineering their children to be gay. As in "Oh honey, let's make our third child gay, it'll be fun!"

Re:A girl with three biological parents by lutusp on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:08PM (#8253805)
> On the other hand I admit it might make me queasy to think of parents deliberately engineering their children to be gay. As in "Oh honey, let's make our third child gay, it'll be fun!"

Yes, especially given the fact that the only reason people have children is because nature intends to replace the parents with their offspring, using rules crafted by natural selection, not the parents' tastes.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by afafsd on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:26PM (#8253877)
>nature intends to replace the parents with their offspring, using rules crafted by natural selection, not the parents' tastes.

In fairness, sex was invented at least 1.2 billion years before parents could have possibly had "tastes". The reason we reproduce sexually rather than just churning out clones of ourselves appears to be that we're more resistant to parasites/diseases if our genes keep constantly shifting into new combinations rather than hanging around for too long looking exactly the same.

This wouldn't necessarily be impacted by the parents' deliberate choice of a few specific alleles.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by lutusp on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:49PM (#8253963)
> The reason we reproduce sexually rather than just churning out clones of ourselves appears to be that we're more resistant to parasites/diseases if our genes keep constantly shifting into new combinations rather than hanging around for too long looking exactly the same.

That's certainly high on the list, but replacing one population with another on a regular basis is also on the list.

> This wouldn't necessarily be impacted by the parents' deliberate choice of a few specific alleles.

Of course it would. Evolution can be a complex topic, but there's one simple fact at the center -- nature knows more than we do. An organism's ability to survive, to prevail over other genotypes, speaks louder than any of our expressed tastes and choices. That means if parents make the wrong choices, nature will step in and correct them.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by oldmanjay on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:23PM (#8254931)
Nature doesn't intend. It accidentally achieves. There's no point trying to divine direction where none was given. Particularly since we are part of nature.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by mseebach on Monday September 01, 2014 @12:19PM (#8253582)
I'd be very interested in knowing what's so objectionable about what I wrote?
Re:A girl with three biological parents by jychang on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:13AM (#8252342)
But then we go full GATTACA.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by afafsd on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:18PM (#8253846)
So? The world of GATTACA seemed pretty awesome. Everyone was smart and fit and healthy and good-looking.

In fact, life was so perfect that the writers had to postulate the existence of non-genetically-engineered people in order to have any drama at all. "Wouldn't it suck if you were born into this society without any genetic enhancement?" the movie asks. And the answer is: yeah, so you should genetically engineer your children.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by blueskin_ on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:15AM (#8252348)
AKA Affirmative Action Is Good: The Movie.

We already bar people with heart defects from participating in space programs.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by maxerickson on Monday September 01, 2014 @10:10AM (#8252882)
I thought the whole point was that the main character got into space on merit, even though all the fancy genetic screening predicted that he wouldn't be able to. The human spirit of an individual triumphs over a short sighted and capricious society.

You mention the heart defect. In the movie, the heart defect is only genetically potential, it is implied that if the character had it they would be dead before the events of the film.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by adrianN on Monday September 01, 2014 @12:44PM (#8253704)
He does cheat on both the medical and the physical exams.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by maxerickson on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:32PM (#8253896)
Sure, I guess I would refine it and say that he made it into space based on some standard of merit that I was defining, not based on the one the short sighted and capricious society defined.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by sampo on Monday September 01, 2014 @12:45PM (#8253705)
> But then we go full GATTACA.

Gattaca is just a scifi movie, not particularly good at science realism. We should not take guidelines for Artificial Intelligence research from the Terminator movies, and we should not take genetics guidelines from Gattaca.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by Filligree on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:31AM (#8252381)
You don't like that outcome?

Meh. Neither does anyone else, and it won't happen by itself.

If GATTACA was the cost of everyone being healthy, I might take it, but it won't be. We get the world we want, by and large.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by philbarr on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:38AM (#8252534)
> We get the world we want, by and large.

Hmm, not sure about that. The rich get the world they want, by and large.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by jacquesm on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:42AM (#8252553)
There are a lot of undesirable scenarios where 'everyone is healthy'.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by exratione on Monday September 01, 2014 @12:18PM (#8253578)
Everyone should have the option of upgrading to better, damage resistant mitochondria, or the option to purchase effective maintenance of mitochondrial function. Some haplotypes are objectively better than others, allowing greater athletic ability or resistance to age-related disease, but we can go beyond even just picking haplotype.

Progressive damage to mitochondrial DNA is an important contribution to degenerative aging. Wholesale replacement of either mitochondria or mitochondrial DNA (via any one of four or five different approaches) is a very viable near term goal. All of the necessary component of such a treatment have been demonstrated in animals and human cells in the laboratory over the past decade, leaving just the painfully slow regulatory and development process.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by emilsedgh on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:51AM (#8252297)
As a third party observer, I think I agree with you here.

However, when I put myself in place of people actually being harmed by this, I think it totally makes sense.

And this process you (and I) are afraid of...This is not the beginning. It has begun since we started to vaccinate people.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by tomp on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:49AM (#8252291)
> this could actually be a good direction to move in. We can not only eliminate genetic diseases, but also genes that predispose us to other common diseases like cancer.

But where does this stop? Replace a gene -> replace mitochondria -> replace a whole chromosome -> replace the sperm/egg -> replace the whole child. We've come back to the real world, i.e. adoption.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by baddox on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:43AM (#8252401)
I'm not sure why you think adoption is at this end of the continuum. I would say that complete genetic engineering of a zygote "from scratch" would be at this end of the continuum. Somewhere in between would be selecting exactly which of your and your partner's genes go into the zygote.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by jebus989 on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:56AM (#8252425)
Most uses of "gene" in this thread should be replaced by allele.
Re:A girl with three biological parents by guard-of-terra on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:15AM (#8252345)
However, adoption is not quality controlled, and with the "whole child", we are presumed to control the outcome.

However if this becomes widespread, we should be fighting to preserve diversity of benign genes.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by jacquesm on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:27AM (#8252246)
There are other, less nice implications too.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eugenics

Is a good read, also the movie Gattaca (obviously fiction, but raises some interesting questions).

Re:A girl with three biological parents by netcan on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:45AM (#8252283)
Eugenics is one of those words steeped in 20th century baggage.

I think there is a parallel to geo-engineering. It sounds like it'll lead someplace troublesome. people can't be trusted with it. OTOH, we have international conferences where they're trying to reach some sort of decisions about how much carbon there should be in the atmosphere. Maybe they'll be deciding how warm it should be, or how much rain europe should be getting.

Once we have the ability to influence these things we are geo-engineers, eugenicists, etc. It's not a choice. Not any more than we chose to take horses, ship rats and house cats to every part of the world.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by jacquesm on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:41AM (#8252548)
Most words that were not invented in the last 15 years are steeped in historical baggage. That doesn't mean that we should not learn from that history.

In fact, if people start inventing words for things that we already have words for it's a good time to start paying attention, likely you're being sold on something.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 01, 2014 @04:33PM (#8254569)
So because Hitler wanted to wipe out Jewish people we shouldn't suggest that those with hereditary genetic diseases don't have children, or for example make genetic tests available to those who are [hoping to get] pregnant?

All of these are called eugenics (though the first is not really focussed on genetic traits); pretending that "eugenics" doesn't carry any baggage because of it's association with Nazi Germany seems pretty disingenuous.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by netcan on Monday September 01, 2014 @09:28AM (#8252693)
I think its more than just the words, it's the concepts themselves.

Eugenics is scary, morally complicated, exciting and possibly inevitable. It has some historical associations with fascism and 20th century modernism in general.

The whole thing make people uncomfortable. It's hard to criticize when people just get creeped out by the idea.

Perhaps this is best left to our grandchildren.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by arethuza on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:57AM (#8252311)
Any mention of eugenics makes me distinctly queasy as I learned from my mother in my mid 20s that I was almost aborted as an embryo on the recommendation of doctors as two of my older siblings are (mildy) physically disabled and they judged there was a risk I could suffer the same problem.

Fortunately for me, my mother's GP discussed the matter with her and actually argued against the recommendations of specialists and I turned out perfectly healthy.

This matter only came up in conversation when she mentioned that the GP in question had died and I said I had never liked him as a kid and she pointed out how ironic that was as he saved my life.....

Re:A girl with three biological parents by jacquesm on Monday September 01, 2014 @07:07AM (#8252330)
Lucky you. Lots of kids were not that lucky.

The problem with any kind of structural attempt at removing undesirable traits/children with defects from the population before they are born is the false positive rates are very high. Fortunately for you you're here and healthy. The flip side is that you might not have been healthy and then there would be a significant burden on those around you and society. These are very difficult problems and the harshness and ease with which people talk about them and pass judgement are in stark contrast with what a more informed person would probably conclude.

The wikipedia article is particularly precise when it comes to articulating the problems stemming from slippery slope arguments around this subject.

In the end, Eugenics is a tool that can be used for good and bad, just like every other tool. But it needs very good oversight and the use cases displayed so far are not all positive in my opinion.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by tiatia on Monday September 01, 2014 @06:44AM (#8252280)
Do you know what a disease is?
Re:A girl with three biological parents by tiatia on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:04AM (#8252446)
I don't get it why I am always getting voted done. And the parent poster of my comment obviously does not understand anything about what a disease is (feel free to give a definition without googleing it), why genetic variance exists and pleiotropic genes. But thanks for voting me down.

Hint: What a disease is and what not, depends a lot on the environment.

Re:A girl with three biological parents by geographomics on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:21AM (#8252492)
I suspect it was because your comment was quite unconstructive, and comes across as a mildly sarcastic taunt rather than a genuine question.

If instead you had explained why you disagree with the parent poster and offered some information on how best to define a disease, you most likely would not have been downvoted.