News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by toasted on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:36PM (#8247174)
Non-US anaesthesiologist here. I love my job and relish going to work each morning. I spend almost no time on non-clinical paperwork. I work reasonable hours, have some busy on-call shifts but am generally well supported by my department. I earn good money in the state system - enough to raise a family comfortably and have a nice house, but not silly money. I pay no malpractice insurance, but pay $400 annually to a non-profit society for medico-legal cover. If I want to I can do additional private sector work to earn more (but I don't). I live in a country where a high standard of medical care and longer life expectancy is provided for less than half the per capita health spend of USA, and the public health system is so good that the private health sector really does struggle to offer much additional benefit.

There are many great examples of socialised health systems in the world, I'm not sure why the US ignores them? Some of the WSJ comments list all the problems inherent in the US system and then blame socialism for them when the problem is completely the opposite?

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jval on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:14AM (#8249027)
The problem is that the United States isn't a 'country' in the way the UK, or Denmark, or Australia is. The entire population of Denmark is 5.59 million, the size of a single second or third tier city in the US. Australia is 22 million, the size of the NYC metro area. You can socialise and centralise healthcare in countries on such a small scale, but it becomes exponentially more difficult to do in a country like the US (pop: 313 M).

The United States is an enormous country comprised of 50 separate state governments, where the powers of the federal government are extremely limited (both by the constitution itself, and by the fact that it is practically impossible to do anything at that kind of scale).

As a result, it is extremely hard to pass any sort of massive reforms. Can you imagine how difficult it would be to pass one single, uniform system of health care for all Europeans?

Talking about solutions that work well in smaller countries is all well and good, but the reality is you need different solutions if you want them to work at scale. It's the same reason why most of Facebook's backend is now written in C++ instead of PHP. It is much more painstaking to work with and harder to pick up but when you're building a huge system of interconnected parts you want something that isn't going to fall over and die suddenly.

The supposed chaos and gridlock of the US political system is a feature, not a bug. It's the reason why if you look at a list of the world's oldest nations the United States is right at the top, and is one of the largest.

EDIT: Sorry - not saying the US's healthcare system is the best it can be and didn't make that clear enough. Just saying that comparing it to other countries won't help as the US has a unique political reality.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Spooky23 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:53AM (#8249419)
The Feds pretty much mastered the "how do I make 50 states do stuff" problem -- they give the states money and threaten to take it away.

We've had Medicare and Medicaid for almost 50 years now, and it works reasonably well, despite significant differences in administrative practices between states. So it absolutely can be done.

We've figured out how to build a national road system, healthcare for old people, healthcare for destitute people, a national tax collection system, and 1,000 other examples. It's a solvable problem.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jval on Monday September 01, 2014 @01:41AM (#8251664)
Not saying it's impossible, just saying it's difficult and comparisons with other countries are not helpful in addressing those difficulties.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ceejayoz on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:16AM (#8249333)
> You can socialise and centralise healthcare in countries on such a small scale, but it becomes exponentially more difficult to do in a country like the US (pop: 313 M).

First, as with the EU, the US is divided into fairly independent states who already manage most parts of their own healthcare/insurance systems.

Second, the idea that 30 million versus 300 million makes a huge difference in scaling healthcare is pretty silly. Sure, a healthcare system for 1,000 people would have different challenges than one for 1,000,000 people, but on nation-sized scales? You have regional divisions to keep it manageable.

What exactly makes Australia or the UK's system unscalable to the size of a US state?

> It's the reason why if you look at a list of the world's oldest nations the United States is right at the top, and is one of the largest.

Massive amounts of minimally populated land to expand into likely played a more significant role, as well as a lack of aristocracy - if you look at European upheaval it's usually an issue of one of the two.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by hvidgaard on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:32AM (#8249051)
I can understand the political barriers to socialized healthcare in the US, for starters it would require a federal tax.

However, I am not buying the scale argument. What exactly makes it hard to scale? The only argument I've heard is that managing all doctors and hospitals, but that is trying to control everything, something that never works when you try to scale out, and isn't necessary either.

If anything the scale enables you to build large and very specialized hospitals that only deal with one particular aspect, e.g. cancer, and do some serious research as well.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jval on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:46AM (#8249071)
Politics is all about the money. Obviously administration is worse at scale too, but it comes down to political will in having the money to do it.

The way you keep a political union together without having it break apart is by limiting the amount of things the members of the union have to share. If you start taxing rich states and funnelling the money over to poor states, you give people a reason to want to break out of the union. Ultimately people only stay if they're getting a good deal.

Taxpayers in New York will definitely be happy if their money goes into the military, as having a New York rather than a US military wouldn't work. But to have all their money go into universal healthcare in Idaho would just piss them off, because people in Idaho can pay for that themselves. That's why healthcare is largely a state matter in the US - you'll find some states have great healthcare, others don't.

I'm not saying the US can't do it better (they clearly can), I'm just saying comparisons with other countries are useless because they don't take into account the unique political realities of the United States.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by hvidgaard on Sunday August 31, 2014 @11:06AM (#8249443)
New Yorkers aren't going to "pay for Idaho". NY may be paying more in tax for the entire state, but their budget would also be much larger. For obvious reasons NY can be more efficient, but that doesn't mean that they'll be paying a significant amount of the budget in Idaho.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by mcguire on Sunday August 31, 2014 @01:03PM (#8249751)
Well, actually, they would, for the same reasons that the postal service will make money in populated areas and lose money in less populated areas.

Say you need a trauma center within 1 hour of anywhere in the country. A trauma center in Manhattan is going to see a lot of traffic, while one in Clayton, NM, isn't. But the centers have the same basic cost in staff and gizmos.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ThomPete on Sunday August 31, 2014 @01:59PM (#8249877)
It's not a once size fits all. You would of course look at the size of the area and the amount of traffic. So areas with higher traffic would get more resources allocated.

The real problem with healthcare is that you can never have enough. Even if everyone paid 100% in taxes it wouldn't be enough.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by DanBC on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:32AM (#8252517)
> But the centers have the same basic cost in staff and gizmos.

Hang on: A busier unit is going to have more staff. Staff is not a trivial cost.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by mcguire on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @11:12AM (#8258004)
In my simple model here, staff is per-capita; fixed costs like property, plant, and equipment are per-unit-area. Which wins in this case? I don't actually know, but I don't believe it is a trivial calculation. (Further, the medical events are not necessarily comparable in the two cases---rural means farming and resource extraction, etc., and that shit's dangerous, compared to white-collar work. And then there's transportation costs.)

I do know that in other similar situations, wealthier, more populated areas end up subsidizing poorer, less populated areas.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by rquantz on Monday September 01, 2014 @12:06AM (#8251495)
New Yorkers are already paying for Idaho, and every other backwards, poor, uneducated, unpopulated state. And we talk about leaving the Union all the time, but that isn't why. It's because those same backwards, poor, uneducated, unpopulated states whose roads, schools, and healthcare we pay for keep blocking our attempts to turn the United States into a modern developed country.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by mehwoot on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:14AM (#8249330)
The United States is an enormous country comprised of 50 separate state governments, where the powers of the federal government are extremely limited (both by the constitution itself, and by the fact that it is practically impossible to do anything at that kind of scale).

Hold on, if the U.S. is 50 separate governments, each of which have great power (since "the powers of the federal government are extremely limited"), then shouldn't each state be able to pass effective healthcare by itself? Only 2 U.S. states have populations larger than Australia, and none would make it into the top 5 E.U. countries by population.

Talking about solutions that work well in smaller countries is all well and good, but the reality is you need different solutions if you want them to work at scale.

But you just said each state is separate and the federal government has limited power, so why do they need to work at scale larger than anywhere else?

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ThomPete on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:49AM (#8249076)
I agree that Denmark don't scale. But that doesn't mean that the current system we have in the US is good or that the insurance based version is by any metrics the best possible solution for the US. You could also think in states instead.

If you look at it from a purely financial point of view the problem of the US system is that when given the choice, younger people don't insure themselves because they are healthy and so don't participate in financing those who are sick by costing the system less.

As they grow older and get sicker they end up paying insane prices unless they are paid by employees and even there the quality of the insurance varies and you still have some really absurd pre-existing conditions rules etc. If you don't have an employer to back you up you are basically screwed.

Obama Care is an attempt at solving this issue. It's not single payer but it's closer and hopefully it will help improving the healthcare system for millions of those without either healthcare or proper healthcare.

Now in my mind there is a middle ground where you pay most of your healthcare yourself (the checkups, the sinus infection etc) but you don't end up in endless debt because you become sick, your kid gets born to early and have to stay at a neonathal facility, for a longer period of time and don't have the right insurance.

And having been through the system I must say that if people think it's less beucratic than say they Danish system (which is much more social in its approach) then they would be mistaken. The sheer number of interests involved in any single episode creates complexity way beyond what seems reasonable.

So agree it's not possible to take a small nation and apply what they do, but it is possible to look at the current system and realize that the healthcare system in the US is def not a feature but rather a system with plenty of room for improvement.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jval on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:55AM (#8249090)
Sorry - edited my post to make clearer the fact that I'm not saying the US's healthcare system is good. I just think that comparisons with other countries are futile. My comment was intended to be a general one about the way politics works in the US.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ThomPete on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:35AM (#8249378)
The countries in the EU which is 400mio serms to be handling this ok and thats even with national laws. You might say the realpolitics will nok make it possible but its not a scale problem but rather a political one.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Retric on Sunday August 31, 2014 @11:57AM (#8249589)
Insurance is a competing market and companies can discriminate by age so the young don't subsidize the older though the insurance system.

You could argue that the healthy subsidize the sick but that's the point of insurance. It's like saying the living subsidize the life insurance payouts of the dead.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ThomPete on Sunday August 31, 2014 @12:06PM (#8249618)
They discriminate in so many other ways. Thats all fine and good they are privately owned companies and can do what they want, but it's not a good setup for healthcare.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by VLM on Sunday August 31, 2014 @08:37AM (#8249163)
"50 separate state governments"

I'm not understanding the problem here. Run "git clone" on the Canadian model fifty times. All done.

Furthermore we seem to have "no problem" scaling up central federal control of seemingly everything other than health care, so a comparative explanation would seem necessary, as to why federal social security is possible or federal OSHA or federal EPA or federal militarized police or the federal military itself, but for no provided reason federal health care would be impossible to scale.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ceejayoz on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:17AM (#8249337)
The scale argument is fundamentally a copout for folks who ideologically oppose national healthcare, IMO.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Mvandenbergh on Sunday August 31, 2014 @08:00AM (#8249100)
Healthcare is administered regionally, by the NHS trusts, in the UK.

Also, Germany is a federal country of 80+ million people, that's surely a better comparison than Denmark.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by amirmc on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:20AM (#8249346)
> "It's the reason why if you look at a list of the world's oldest nations the United States is right at the top, and is one of the largest."

Really? Please can you elaborate on this as it makes no sense to me.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by gyardley on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:44AM (#8249396)
He's arguing that the United States has had a stable political system for a long period of time because the federal government has relatively few powers, allowing the people in its widespread, culturally-different regions to craft state and local governments to their liking. I suspect he believes an activist, centralized government, imposed on all Americans, would eventually result in the division of the United States.

There's plenty of stuff in there to debate (the US did have a rather bloody civil war, so it's not like it's been perfectly stable), but his argument is plausible enough - I'm not sure why it makes no sense to you. Personally, traveling around the United States has convinced me that there's ten countries worth of distinct cultures in it - one-size-fits-all government isn't going to work well.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ThomPete on Sunday August 31, 2014 @12:07PM (#8249622)
The size of the country have a much higher impact on the fact that there haven't been more conflicts IMHO.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:59PM (#8247253)
I think it's all about 1945-1950. That's when Truman (accidentally?) ensconced employer-based healthcare into law in the US and the NHS began in Britain. Of course France's solution is quite compelling, as is Germany's, Canada's, Japan's...

The "socialism" thing is just spall from decades of identity politics. Pick apart the propaganda aspects of John Wayne's movies, especially "The Alamo". I'm not snarkin' on Wayne, I love his stuff, partly because it's propaganda.

Our cognitive dissonance is best cognitive dissonance :)

I also have to wonder - if the US actually embraces a public health service would that take the pressure off the public health services of the world to keep cost down?

As economics, it's actually pretty difficult to analyze this issue. The assumptions are formidable.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by javert on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:45PM (#8247203)
The actual experience in the US has been that healthcare functioned best when it was closest to a free market, and the more we socialize it, the worse it gets. (We have been slowly socializing it for many decades through regulation.)

You can argue that we haven't been socializing it "properly," but the way we are doing it is just the way government works in the US, and that's not going to change.

In general, we don't have an efficient, honest, effective government, so it can't do anything right on a large scale. Though there are some exceptions, those are exceptions. Look at the Obamacare website scandal. That is the rule.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by johan_larson on Saturday August 30, 2014 @05:17PM (#8247623)
There is very little about the health care industry, at any level, that is "free market". The government funds much of the basic research that generates new medicines and medical devices and then regulates which ones can be sold. It works hand in hand with medical professional associations to determine who can practice medicine and in what capacity; it also funds residencies, the crucial gateway to becoming a physician. It pays for a hefty portion of medical care (for the young, the old, the very poor, and veterans) directly and regulates how the rest is paid for (out of pocket, through employer-provided insurance, or privately purchased insurance).

There are a few islands of private industry in healthcare, but between the regulation and the direct payments, it's a government sea.

Barring the most radical dissolution of the current system, the question isn't whether the government should be involved, but how.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by wtbob on Saturday August 30, 2014 @05:41PM (#8247668)
You're right that the current healthcare industry is far from a free market, but javert too is right that the golden age of American healthcare was when it was far closer to a free market.

Interestingly, the golden age for physicians' personal wealth was during the socialisation phase, as they were able to pocket fees increasingly paid by insurers, leading to a quintupling in income. They went from lower-middle class at $50,000/year in 2010 terms to $250,000 in 2010 terms. Doors anyone seriously suspect that we'll ever get back to $50,000/yr physicians? This illustrates why industries are often keen to socialise: they can guarantee outsize personal success.

What our system absolutely rewrites is radical dissolution.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by vacri on Saturday August 30, 2014 @07:27PM (#8247886)
When were doctors ever 'lower-middle class' in any western society?
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by MaysonL on Saturday August 30, 2014 @08:43PM (#8248043)
When I was a kid in the '50s, our family doctor lived and had his office in a house little larger than ours, in much the same neighborhood as ours: definitely middle class.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by vacri on Sunday August 31, 2014 @05:50PM (#8250488)
I didn't say not middle class, I said not lower-middle class. Doctors as a demographic have never been lower-middle class.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jasonisalive on Saturday August 30, 2014 @07:57PM (#8247948)
Any time right up until the 1950s I would say. I don't know what you'd call the status of mid-19th century doctors in Britain, for example, but they definitely weren't upper class.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by vacri on Sunday August 31, 2014 @05:35PM (#8250438)
'lower-middle class' is the lower part of the middle class. It's not "lower or middle class". Lower-middle, middle-middle, upper-middle. If it was 'lower or middle', that'd make even less sense - university-educated professionals being part of the working class demographic, at a time when university was an oddity rather than the norm?
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by wtbob on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:19PM (#8250795)
From the article physicians averaged $50,000/year in 2010 dollars back in the 30s or 40s. $50,000/year in 2010 was lower middle class. It's enough to live on, but certainly not enough to be comfortable, especially with a family, not is it enough to save much.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:12PM (#8247453)
So we can't but Canada can?

As straining-of-credulity as such a bumper-sticker is, isn't that the logical conclusion?

Very Serious People ( with whom I happen to agree) actually say such things in "Fragile By Design". Calomiris/Haber are good writers and good thinkers. They do not call out medical nor political leadership there, but it's not exactly a stretch.

It's a short drop from this to the view of America from "V for Vendetta".

[deleted]
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:29PM (#8247502)
Very good point - although you'd think it would be possible to have models and feedback for models that would scale.

I expect the "higher GDP" tells us a lot. I first discussed this with my Dad when we took one of us the the Emergency Room for stitches ( it just wasn't a summer as a kid without a bike wreck or something leading to stitches ) and I was shocked by the bill - in 1972.

I'd be pressed to find the reference, but people have shown that proportional percent of income ( in the aggregate, GDP ) spent on medical care has been consistent between countries.

I hold that employer-based health care has turned out more sour than it perhaps once was because employment has gotten weirder. That arguably was not true in, say 1950. But medicine was also smaller then.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by dalke on Saturday August 30, 2014 @06:06PM (#8247726)
> I'd be pressed to find the reference, but people have shown that proportional percent of income ( in the aggregate, GDP ) spent on medical care has been consistent between countries.

There's a couple of tables related to that at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_heal... . US is an outlier, with a total health expenditure of 17.7% of GDP. Otherwise, yes, most similar countries (Germany, France, etc.) spend between about 8 and 11% of GDP.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ArkyBeagle on Sunday August 31, 2014 @04:29PM (#8250279)
Thanks! That's exactly it.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by forkandwait on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:58PM (#8247245)
Downvoted, here is why:

I find your statements to be over general to an almost crazy degree -- "the actual experience"? Everywhere? "In general we don't have an honest effective government" -- really? Got data? Etc, etc.

Also, I would be interested in specific metrics of worse and better -- you make the claim it is worse because of regulation, which you imply is basically the same as socialized funding (which it isn't). So where is the data?

No offense, but this sounds like canned right wing bullshit rhetoric straight off Fox News. Granted, there is plenty of canned rhetoric on all "sides" to go around, but that doesn't make this any better.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by zo1 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @05:09AM (#8248827)
"Granted, there is plenty of canned rhetoric on all "sides" to go around, but that doesn't make this any better."

The problem is that certain sides get way less flak for "canned rhetoric". Particularly populist viewpoints.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by eli_gottlieb on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:49PM (#8247214)
>The actual experience in the US has been that healthcare functioned best when it was closest to a free market,

When was this?

>the way we are doing it is just the way government works in the US, and that's not going to change.

That's some nice fatalism you've got there.

>In general, we don't have an efficient, honest, effective government, so it can't do anything right on a large scale.

Except for all the things you forget to mention, or even to think of as government programs, because they tick quietly away, working perfectly, in the background.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by CamperBob2 on Saturday August 30, 2014 @09:38PM (#8248166)
It's not a free market if you're forced to participate in it. Which we all are, by virtue of being alive.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by dantheman on Sunday August 31, 2014 @02:30AM (#8248602)
You mean like food, housing, etc? Free markets don't mean they're optional, it means that participants interact freely and voluntarily.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by CamperBob2 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @03:29AM (#8248681)
Not really. Every human being can survive with the same minimal allotment of food and housing, but that's not true of health care. Some people will use very little while some will use a lot more through no fault of their own.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by zo1 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @05:05AM (#8248818)
You're still free to choose who you get healthcare from.

It's like saying the food/farming industry isn't a free market because "some people will use very little while some [fat people] will use a lot more through no fault of their own." It's a ridiculous argument, and sounds more along the lines of Peter Joseph's "structural violence" mantra. The whole "you're not truly free until you get all this free shit given to you so you can be free to do nothing/be lazy".

Granted, it isn't actually a truly free-market, anyways. Government subsidies, minimum prices, etc, all distort the market and affect peoples' actions.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by CamperBob2 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @02:43PM (#8250007)
I hear what you're saying and agree in part, certainly where things other than health care are concerned. Both sides of the argument are deeply flawed. The fact remains, though, that we in the US pay more for our health care and get less in return for it than residents of countries with real "socialized medicine." We are indisputably doing it wrong. We owe it to ourselves to consider the problem more deeply than we can by comparing it to traded commodities like food and housing.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by venomsnake on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:54PM (#8247232)
In US you have socialized the costs. Not the healthcare system. I think the only social type of medicine in US is the VA (they have the purse, their own hospitals and staff IIRC) and last time I read their costs of delivered product were much lower that the US average.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by anon13434 on Saturday August 30, 2014 @03:23PM (#8247331)
The VA is not a good example of a working system though, it has been heavily in the news for denying timely treatment, see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Veterans_Health_Administration_...
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by dlp211 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @11:35AM (#8249530)
Bad press about a few VA clinics does not mean that the entire system is garbage. In fact, as recently as last year, veterans rated their satisfaction with VA care higher than the general public rates private care[1]. Also according the the Inspector General, while no one denies that delays in care happen at the VA (it should be noted that delays happen in the private sector as well), that the deaths at those hospitals can not be directly linked to the delay in care[2].

Finally, my anecdotal evidence: I am highly satisfied with the care that I receive at the VA. I have 20% disability due to a significant loss of peripheral vision in my right eye. I am scheduled yearly for an annual physical including urine and blood work, a field scan with my eyes to test regressions, and two general appointments with an optometrist. I also have free access to nutritionists and weight support groups since weight management can be an issue for veterans. Is it perfect, no, but I have never felt that I didn't get the care that I needed in a reasonable amount of time.

[1] http://www.va.gov/opa/pressrel/pressrelease.cfm?id=2537

[2] http://online.wsj.com/articles/no-deaths-caused-by-delays-at...

edit: formatting

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ceejayoz on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:20AM (#8249347)
Pre-Iraq/Afghanistan the VA was considered quite effective and people were very satisfied with their treatment there. A massive influx of injured/disabled soldiers from those wars (where death has largely been replaced by wounds thanks to good body armor) without a parallel ability to scale treatment up probably hurt them more than poor administration.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Shivetya on Saturday August 30, 2014 @03:20PM (#8247319)
lets be honest, the VA is not a shining example of health care. Much lower costs are not worth it considering the stories coming out of the VA.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by forkandwait on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:59PM (#8247257)
Socialized some of the costs.

Some systems in the US, especially Kaiser, are basically a socialized system supported by premiums, and seem to work pretty well.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by dobbsbob on Saturday August 30, 2014 @07:27PM (#8247888)
Problem with social health care is of course each successive government tries to purposely run it into the ground in my country so they can point to it's failures and claim we must adopt a US style private insurance method.

Another problem is creeping fees. Most clinics, hospitals ect all nickle and dime you for fees here which add up even though they aren't supposed to. Some regional health authorities here charge a flat monthly tax, which if you can't pay or are in arrears you're screwed and have to pay cash to these clinics. Because there is a standardized rate you're going to pay $135 just to talk to a doctor for 5 minutes because there's no low income clinics, all rates are the same.

Source: my young, foolish self who had to pay this out numerous times to clinics for being behind on taxes.

It's good that this works where you live but you need to be hyper vigilant on who is elected to govern your health authority, which is a huge downside of any kind of socialization of medicine. Governments are fleeting, the next one could purposely sabotage it to satisfy insurance lobbyists or be so incompetent they accidentally let it all go to hell.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by e40 on Saturday August 30, 2014 @07:15PM (#8247870)
There are many great examples of socialised health systems in the world, I'm not sure why the US ignores them?

Because debate in this country has been taken over by assholes and idiots. They lie at every turn to justify their position and they don't care about facts or figures, unless they agree with their ideology.

In my dreams I fantasize about what happened in Portugal regarding decriminalization of drugs. In the current US climate, that could never happen. It bums me out, too.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Symmetry on Sunday August 31, 2014 @01:25PM (#8249802)
The issue is more complicated than just socialized vs. non-socialized. There are many countries with privately run healthcare system that are perfectly good, such as France or Switzerland. And there are countries that combine both public and private provision of healthcare and have it work perfectly well, such as Sweden or Singapore[1]. The US actually does run some hospitals directly, the VA, and I doubt this made the news outside of the US but there was a huge scandal a while ago concerning them.

The current US health situation is the end result of a long process of complicated schemes to provide more healthcare to Americans without any clearly visible costs in ways complicated enough that there are no obvious deficiencies. For instance Nixon's scheme[2] to lower costs by preventing competitions between hospitals[3] is still on the books all these years later. Given all the government interventions in the healthcare market combined with an unwillingness to bite the bullet pay for or subsidize most people's insurance directly has left the US with a healthcare system that is neither government run nor free market, but something far inferior to both.

[1] Singapore has a really weird combination of forced savings, mostly private payment, and mostly public provision which is really weird compared to everyone else but somehow gives them really good health outcomes really cheaply. I don't think the US could make that system work, though.

[2] Is there something Nixon didn't screw up? Well, besides repairing our relationship with China.

[3] Back in the day everybody knew that the USSR had a far more efficient economy than the US did (the Soviet statistics said so!), and one way people explained this was that the Soviets weren't wasting resources on competition but instead just figured out the best way to do something and put all their effort behind that.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by refurb on Sunday August 31, 2014 @01:57PM (#8249874)
This is the best explanation of the healthcare problems the US has that I've seen in a while. It's not a "public vs. private" thing in the US that is the problem. It's a byzantine system of patchwork laws that have tried to make the system better, but only made it worse. It's so complicated now that it'll take a hell of a lot of work to fix it.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by tarr11 on Saturday August 30, 2014 @02:42PM (#8247192)
In which country do you work as an anaesthesiologist?
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by toasted on Sunday August 31, 2014 @05:17AM (#8248837)
NZ
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jasonisalive on Sunday August 31, 2014 @06:25AM (#8248960)
Keep in mind that, well-paid and satisfied specialists aside, there is another side to this picture - important to remember with state-run healthcare systems such as NZ, so often a poster child for socialist policy.

For example this IT department head of a major district health board who embezzled ~$17 million dollars over a period of 6 years, with which to buy, among other things, luxury vehicles.

http://www.odt.co.nz/news/tags/michael-swann-0

http://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/32268/fake-invoices-made-p...

Can you imagine this sort of thing happening in a free market for healthcare? I can't.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Mvandenbergh on Sunday August 31, 2014 @08:12AM (#8249124)
You... can't imagine embezzlement happening in the private sector?

That's bold.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ceejayoz on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:22AM (#8249353)
> Can you imagine this sort of thing happening in a free market for healthcare? I can't.

That's one hell of a lack of imagination. You mean stuff like this, which happens all the time here? http://www.buffalonews.com/city-region/federal-court/william...

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Spooky23 on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:57AM (#8249429)
Yes. Bad actors are present everywhere, and fraud happens everywhere. There's always a kink in the system.

There was a dentist a few years ago who was treating 2,000 patients a day, and stole several million dollars from several insurance companies.

I worked at a midsize company in a highly competitive market... one of the call center manager embezzled something like $75k over a period of 3 years by fraudulently purchasing telephone headsets. He paid for $$$$ plantronics, and delivered $ no-name brand.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Symmetry on Sunday August 31, 2014 @01:38PM (#8249840)
I expect there'd actually be more fraud under a free market system because catching fraud (past a certain point) is expensive and companies are only going to put the resources into catching fraud if it continues to exhibit a positive ROI. Or maybe NZ bureaucrats are insulated and dedicated enough to do the right thing rather than listen to the outrage of the voters when fraud makes the news, but I wouldn't expect that to be true in the US.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by specialist on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:48AM (#8249408)
Single payer accounting is greatly simplified, so is easier to audit, so has less fraud. Comparatively. In the real world.

http://www.amazon.com/Healthcare-Fraud-Auditing-Detection-Gu...

Also, you misspelled "corporatist oligarchy" as "free market". Easy mistake.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Bootvis on Sunday August 31, 2014 @06:43AM (#8248988)
That's unfortunate but the bottom line for patients is that the NZ works excellently.

Sure, it sucks that someone committed fraud and got rich in a dishonest manner but preventing that is not the goal. In the end, this fraud doesn't really affect the healthcare given.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by jasonisalive on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:17AM (#8249034)
NZ works excellently.

That is a pretty big claim... Have you ever actually lived in NZ and experienced the realities of paying for this system via taxes and claiming its services? Have you monitored the incessant demands for more services at better quality, the incessant complaints about being over-worked and underfunded, the endless criticisms and debates about inefficiency, long wait times, burdensome bureaucracy, poor outcomes, and unhappy doctors?

Outright fraud and corruption is just the tip of the iceberg of problems that naturally develop when a society decides to sever the act of consumption from the actual purchase of a service.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by Bootvis on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:38AM (#8249257)
You're not afraid of making some pretty big claims yourself. Wikipedia[1] supports my claim that while the situation might not be perfect it works quite well and that's the most important thing. Compared to other countries, the US in particular, the NZ healthcare system delivers good results. Which in my view makes it excellent.

Then what about the negative aspects you mention. Well, in the Netherlands we have a similar system and to be honest I don't care about all the whining you mention. Sure, people complain and things probably can be better. There is always room for improvement. Unfortunately people will complain about healthcare if they stub their toe. Fuck 'em, you can't stop these people from complaining and policy should not accommodate their every whim.

Can you support your claim that bad things happen and go unpunished

> when a society decides to sever the act of consumption from the actual purchase of a service.

I'm not feeling them, my family is not feeling them and my MD friends are happy with their jobs. And don't forget: the private sector is still an option so there is a choice.

[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_care_in_New_Zealand

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by specialist on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:54AM (#8249423)
You're confusing ideology (dogma) with market design and (lack of) incentives.

Markets are good for determining price. Not finding efficient solutions. You've heard of "rent seeking"?

Single payer systems enable the capitation model of care services. Because wellness is incentivized, vs the treatment of disease.

[deleted]
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:03PM (#8247424)
Probably because of an old concept called "modesty". I know, right?
[deleted]
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:22PM (#8247480)
That's a big part of modesty :)
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by watwut on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:27PM (#8247498)
He was not modest. He wrote the comment to say how much better his county medical system is. Except that he did not specified the country, so there is no way to verify his claim.

Many non US healthcare systems have bureaucracy or long hours too or both too.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by kghose on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:05AM (#8249305)
Radiology, Ophthalmology, Anesthesiology, and Dermatology ROAD to success.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by alexqgb on Saturday August 30, 2014 @03:54PM (#8247393)
It's not true to say that the US, in general, ignores these systems when in fact, a significant portion of the US population pays very close attention to them and would like nothing more than to seem them implemented here.

There is, however, a significant minority of really horrible, angry, violent, and generally racist people who feel deeply and ideologically threatened by the social contract on which these systems rest. And because of some unfortunate quirks in the American electoral system, they wield a level of political power that vastly exceeds their numbers. In a properly representational system, they'd be just as aggressive, ignorant, and self-defeating as they are right now. However, the body politic would be largely insulated from their rage, allowing us to safely get on with the design and development of a decent, cost-effective system.

In other words, we're being plagued by a really nasty infestation of trolls, and it's making progress in general pretty damn difficult. The good news is that this, too, shall pass. In demographic terms, this problematic political outlook is the rooted in the reactionary portion of the generation that came of age during the Civil Rights era. Their bigotry translated into a life-long political identity that has done everything it can to resist, if not reverse the "loss" they suffered in the wake of Jim Crow ending.

The Drug War is probably the best example of their continued effort to put a boot on the necks of black people. It's worth noting that the militarization of US police forces, combined with an exploding private prison industry, took root in the former Confederate states before spreading outwards to damage the rest of the nation. And of course, opposition to any kind of drug legalization remains strongest in places with the deepest histories of institutionalized racism.

The same perspective that says the state should be used as a weapon to harm black people also says the state should not be used to protect or help them in any way. Thus, the vitriolic opposition to any kind of welfare program than benefits black people. Keeping them out of the health care system was part and parcel of this larger push for institutionalized white supremacy.

But again, all this is a generational reaction to the 1960s, a particularly divisive and transformative time in American politics. When the generation that dedicated itself to obstructing the movement for greater equality finally passes from the stage, there won't be another one with either the size or the depth of hatred to maintain the current levels of opposition. So even in an electoral system as warped as ours, the certifiably batshit-insane won't be able to maintain their dominance. That's bad news for everyone with a stake in Fox News, great news for everyone else on planet Earth.

At that stage, with the right wing of the baby boom dead and buried, America will be able get on with the long-delayed work of creating a more-perfect union. Given how much pent-up demand there is for policies that reflect intelligence, fairness, humanity, and decency, I suspect demand for change - and the consensus to support it - will appear quite swiftly. So it's nice to know that there are already well-developed models we can refer to when the time comes.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by mynameishere on Saturday August 30, 2014 @04:33PM (#8247520)
Dude, chill. Not to intrude on your fantasy world too much, but a few things:

1. The left wing of the baby boom is going to die with the right.

2. The baby boomers were famously a bunch of hippies and radicals. More seriously, they were easily the most liberal-minded generation in America at the time--and they may still be.

3. This country's ongoing demographic transformation into Brazil is not going to help the health care system, or move us toward a "more perfect union", or do anything at all positive in general. It baffles me that people think things like that.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by alexqgb on Saturday August 30, 2014 @05:29PM (#8247647)
Um, you may have missed the point.

1. The thing that distinguishes the values of the Civil Rights era reactionaries is that they're generally failing to transmit themselves from one generation to a next. So unlike the more egalitarian values of the left - which are actually growing stronger with each subsequent generation - the bigotry of the right is uniquely tied to the lifespans of specific people. When they die, their fundamental opposition to social justice dies with them.

The break isn't perfectly clean, to be sure, but enough to make the retrograde electorally insignificant and that's the real point here.

2. The "hippies and radicals" on the Baby Boom's left were actually a distinct minority in the 1960s. Highly visible, yes, but politically (as opposed to culturally) persuasive? Not so much.

However, unlike the reactionary right - which was entering its last generation of social dominance - the lefties were well ahead of their time. In the long run, their ideas and values are the ones that are becoming mainstream, while the overt racism of the right is what's becoming retrograde. That's why gay marriage and drug decriminalization are happening, while the racist cops freaking out in Ferguson are seen as the bad guys in a dystopian nightmare that causes a general sense of recoil.

3. Not sure what you mean by this. Are you saying America needs a white majority to remain functional and prosperous?

So you know, the demographics I'm focused on are those of the millennial generation, which is the largest in American history. In terms of electoral politics, their preferences are going to dominate everything in the decades to come. And unlike the lefties in the BB generation, this is a generation in which broadly egalitarian and progressive views are, for the first time, held by a clear and ascendent majority.

As far as the health care system goes by the time these people hit middle age, it's safe to assume that sanity will be prevailing. Indeed, I suspect that will be true of politics in general.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by joshuaheard on Saturday August 30, 2014 @08:35PM (#8248026)
I'm not sure how racism worked its way into an article on health care. But, your assertions that the TEA Party and Republicans are inherently racist are misplaced. Let's start with a little history. Lincoln who freed the slaves, Republican. Jim Crow laws, Southern Democrats. Most votes against the 1964 Civil Rights act, Democrat. Inner cities where blacks are oppressed, run by Democrats. In fact, you would be hard pressed to find any racism in the TEA Party or Republican party. And, while Democrats profess to want to help blacks, it is their actions and policies that are hurting them more.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by secabeen on Sunday August 31, 2014 @02:20AM (#8248585)
That may all be true, but like Strom Thurmond, nearly all of the democrats you're referring to either retired or became republicans in the years since 1964.

>In fact, you would be hard pressed to find any racism in the TEA Party or Republican party.

That's an amusing perspective, given that both parties have members who espouse racist beliefs, with the Republican party having slightly (only slightly) more than the Democrats: http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/are-white-republicans-mo...

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by alexqgb on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:38PM (#8255225)
"In fact, you would be hard pressed to find any racism in the TEA Party or Republican party."

Lol.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by alexqgb on Tuesday September 09, 2014 @06:17PM (#8293639)
Here's an elected representative (i.e. not an unrepresentative outlier) who wants to make it harder for black people to vote specifically and explicitly because they're black.

http://fortressamerica.gawker.com/georgia-lawmaker-vows-to-e...

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by alexqgb on Tuesday September 02, 2014 @03:35PM (#8259625)
"I'm not sure how racism worked its way into an article on health care."

That confusion may be a product of poor reading comprehension. Notice that my comment was not a direct reply to the article, but one directed to a secondary question raised by the article. (Specifically, "Why, if we know what works, are these known solutions not being implemented in America?")

The answer, again, is that these systems depend on a social contract which is flatly incompatible with the white supremacist ideology that, for a variety of structural reasons, still holds a remarkable and disproportionate amount of power within our political system.

"But, your assertions that the TEA Party and Republicans are inherently racist are misplaced."

Um, no dude. Those are your assertions, not mine. Since I never mentioned Republicans or Tea Partiers at all, I could not have said anything specific about either. Indeed, I can think of many Republicans - some I know personally - who are deeply embarrassed by this concentration of racist, jingoist, revanchism that has not only found its way into their party, but has taken to calling those who try tempering their most toxic characteristics as "RINOs" (that's "Republicans In Name Only", in case you were unfamiliar with the term).

But since you mention history, let's discuss that. This toxic group, as you seem to know, is not new to American life. They were a principle target of Abraham Lincoln and the Republican party of the 19th century. What is (relatively) new is their occupation and transformation of the Republican party, and the way they turned what had been bastion of opposition into their home.

The switch started in the wake of LBJ's "betrayal" in signing Civil Rights legislation. LBJ was, of course, a Democrat. And he was faced with choosing between the people he saw as the future of the party and the Dixiecrats (as they were known), who represented its racist, soiled, and discredited past. He made the right choice, and in doing so, rendered a large block of Southern white supremacists politically homeless.

They didn't stay that way for long. By the 1970s they were staging an aggressive takeover of the once-hated Republican party, employing a heady mixture of religious fundamentalism, supply side economics, and "tough on crime" rhetoric, bringing a messianic zeal to re-establishing the dominance they'd lost with the scrapping of Jim Crow laws.

The GOP managed to temper and accommodate their presence through the presidency of George Bush senior. But his defeat after one term in office signaled the end of the moderation. By the time Bill Clinton was in the White House, Newt Gingrich attained the Speakership, and the extremist elements began calling the shots within the GOP. This marked the completion of an fundamental transformation. Within period of two decades they’d converted the Republican party from the traditional opponent of the Confederacy to the vehicle of its contemporary resurgence.

Getting back to health care, if you didn't see these people coming out in full force to oppose the ACA it's because you simply weren't paying attention. Like, not at all. In reality, the continued political presence and power of these people has an enormous amount to do with the irrationality of our medical system. (The same could also be said of our criminal justice and immigration systems.)

And the existence of these people is hardly a matter of speculation. We've had a number of racially charged incidents that become flash points for the racists to express their views and indicate their numbers. Consider the recent mayhem in Ferguson, where a white K-9 officer allowed his dog to urinate on the memorial set up by the mother of a young man killed by the same police force. It's impossible to chalk up contempt this raw as a rare an isolated thing when a staggering volume of social media posts indicates broad and deep support for this treatment - and worse - among certain quarters. Lynchings, may I remind you, are still a matter of living memory. And as open comment sections reveal, there are still plenty of Americans who would bring them back if they could. Thanks to the distorting effects of Senatorial overrepresentation in predominately rural states and pro-GOP gerrymandering of the House, their electoral power vastly exceeds their numbers. They do not represent America, but they do represent a major problem for America, and have done so since before the Civil War.

But the good news, is that their attitudes are not replicating themselves across generations as reliably as they once did. Given time, this problem will solve itself. For those who can't wait, I recommend a focus on the structural reforms that will accelerate their demise. Specifically, that means an end to closed primaries and partisan redistricting (i.e. gerrymandering) and much greater access to the ballot box.

In any case, if you are going to attempt lecturing people on the history of political alignments, make sure the version you’re trying to push doesn’t conveniently stop in the mid 60s, just before one of the most momentous realignments in American history took place. Being that economical with the facts makes you look stupid, dishonest, or both and HN is not the place to pull that shit.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by joshuaheard on Friday September 05, 2014 @11:02AM (#8274202)
You would think then that the Republican party would be full of KKK members. But the only KKK member to be elected to the Senate, Robert Byrd, was Democrat, and he retired in 2010, not 1960. I don't know why you call them "Dixiecrats". Why don't you call them by their real name: racist southern Democrats. There is simply no evidence there was a mass conversion from Democrats to Republicans in the South. A small amount converted due to the civil rights act and Nixon's Southern strategy, but the largest shift occurred in the 1990s with the rise of evangelical Christians. I think the debate would be better served if you kept to policy arguments instead of attacking your opponents.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by alexqgb on Sunday September 07, 2014 @11:07PM (#8283263)
>> "You would think then that the Republican party would be full of KKK members."

No, because the Republicans are a national party and the KKK barely has enough members to populate a state fair. In other words, I would not think this because I can do basic math.

>> "But the only KKK member to be elected to the Senate, Robert Byrd, was Democrat, and he retired in 2010, not 1960."

Not exactly true. Byrd dropped his membership in 1952, as he was running for the House, where he served from 1953 until 1959, when he ran for the Senate. But this is hardly relevant, since it all took place a decade or two before the great political realignment triggered by LBJ.

>> "I don't know why you call them "Dixiecrats".

Because that's what pro-segregation southern Democrats are called. And because that's exactly who we're talking about. So you know, "Dixiecrat" was the informal name used by a short-lived, pro- segregationist breakaway faction from the Democratic party. The group flamed out in 1948, but the name hung around, finally sticking to the southern, white, and openly racist Democrats who were vehemently opposed to the Civil Rights Act and who subsequently formed the core of today's predominantly Southern GOP - which is precisely who we're talking about here.

>> “There is simply no evidence there was a mass conversion from Democrats to Republicans in the South."

Um, wow. Where do I even begin? I mean, saying something this demonstrably wrong is a bit like saying "There's no evidence that the Earth is round," or "There's no evidence that the Titanic really sunk," or "There's no evidence that Boston is north of New York City."

I could go on, but you get the point. And yes, there's is lots (and lots and lots and lots) of evidence there was a mass conversion from Democrats to Republicans in the South. Chiefly, the public record of election results for the United States of America.

Here's but one summary of the shift. Scroll down for the helpful charts that document the shift on a year by year basis. The section you want to pay especially close attention to is marked "1964 Election – Regional Realignment".

http://mattsmaps.wordpress.com/2011/07/14/southern-realignme...

Again, this shift started in the Civil Rights era. It grew under Reagan, and it went ballistic in the 1990s, as you correctly note. Like I said originally, this didn't happen overnight. It took about three decades to unfold, by which time the home of southern, white voters who are generally opposed to strong civil rights legislation has completed its swing from the Democratic party to the GOP.

Today, the South is solidly Republican. In general, Democrats don’t have a snowball’s chance in hell of representing these states. Indeed, this is where they face their very toughest odds. And that’s not because there’s been some sea change in the population, culture, attitudes, or beliefs commonly held by white people in the American southeast. It’s because the party that was once aligned with their interests abandoned them, and because the party that once opposed those interests was captured and radically changed by them.

I accept this change, by the way. These shifts are par for the course in American politics. What I don’t accept is present day Republicans who try to deflect well-grounded charges of racism by claiming that they’re members of “the party of Lincoln” while ignoring the near-perfect realignment in the major party’s respective bases that happened between now and then. It's like somebody who has had a sex change trying to insist that they were born in their current state. I don't object to the operation. I do object to the lying.

Seriously, if the point your making only sounds convincing to people with zero grasp of history, then what you're asserting is just straigh-up bullshit, which is like lying, except worse.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/On_Bullshit

So you know, honest, intelligent, decent people who respect the truth don't behave like that. You - apparently - are none of the above.

>> "I think the debate would be better served if you kept to policy arguments instead of attacking your opponents."

Except this isn't a debate. This you not knowing your ass from your elbow, behaving in an intellectually dishonest fashion, and getting schooled accordingly. So you know, debates revolve around opinions, ideas, and perspectives. What we're talking about here are matters of well-established (i.e. non-debatable) fact.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by huherto on Saturday August 30, 2014 @07:07PM (#8247854)
Do we have evidence that the millennial generation on the deep south also has liberal values?
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by moo on Saturday August 30, 2014 @06:32PM (#8247774)
Your comment reminds me of a book, "Welfare, Ethnicity and Altruism: New Data and Evolutionary Theory". The book looks for empirical evidence for the theory of ethnic nepotism and kin altruism. I don't think I agree with all conclusions but interesting in that the book argues ethnic groupings resist collective programs because they don't want to share with or support other ethnic groups.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by disputin on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:39AM (#8249259)
I'll be taking a look at that, thanks. In London I find the majority of diversity has little integration, instead each nationality gathers in a location and forms an insular "community" mostly detached from the others, which seems to miss the point. I've met people who've been here for 20 years yet can't speak English due to that insularity. Members of nationality X walking 25 minutes to get a nation X pizza, rather than the Italian pizza five minutes away, only buy nation X products, only from nation X shops, nation based employment, nation based music lessons, and so on. Some preference, practicality, or nostalgia is understandable, but it's beyond that. There's polarization, which worsens when there's some form of stress. There's no discussion of it because because there's fear of accusations of racism in what's become a sort of racism witch hunt. The UK news has recently been filled with news of a Pakistani child sex grooming gang, but the media seem to be referring to them as Asian, which not only is sufficiently vague that they may as well be saying that they're from the northern hemisphere, but it also strikes me as even more divisive to be categorising an entire continent. Ethics and ideologies aside, I'm interested in the mechanics and where it can and where it is unlikely to succeed.
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by chelch on Sunday August 31, 2014 @09:57AM (#8249291)
It's not as simple as the right-wing boomers dying. There are a few things we need to keep in mind: - People become more conservative as they age. - The political right receives more support from crony capitalists. - Crony capitalism is what's causing problems for these doctors in the first place.

It's happening all over the world. There's a general trend where the right-wing trolls are aligning themselves with the cronies. While the next generation wants to fight the nastiness in racial/sexist/homophobic discrimination, they're not too enthusiastic about doing anything besides paying lip service to structural problems in the way the world works economically.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ConceptJunkie on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:24PM (#8250817)
> really horrible, angry, violent, and generally racist people

Bigoted commenter is really a bigot.

Thanks, you saved me from reading your post. If you had something worth saying, you blew your chance by starting out insulting me.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by mariodiana on Sunday August 31, 2014 @08:29AM (#8249154)
"really horrible, angry, violent, and generally racist people"

Seek help.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by theoh on Sunday August 31, 2014 @10:18AM (#8249343)
The language is a bit exaggerated but I don't think it deserves such an offensive dismissal. There is plenty of evidence that conservatives have those traits, not to mention that it is a widely held belief, which is enough to make it an acceptable comment. See for example http://faculty.virginia.edu/haidtlab/jost.glaser.political-c...
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by leftboot on Sunday August 31, 2014 @03:21PM (#8250128)
I don't know any conservatives. (I work in tech and live in SF). They sound like truly horrible people. I'll keep a sharp eye out for them in the future. Your link is great! Two of the authors are from Berkeley, where I went to school!
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ianstallings on Monday September 01, 2014 @10:29AM (#8252988)
Sorry I accidentally downvoted your post. I meant to upvote. The damn thing is too small!
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ConceptJunkie on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:38PM (#8250872)
Bigoted commenter is bigoted. Bigoted commenter excuses his bigotry by claiming that "everyone else does it".
Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by mariodiana on Monday September 01, 2014 @08:29AM (#8252511)
The language isn't "a bit exaggerated." It's an offensive dismissal of anyone who criticizes socialized medicine, in particular, and all other social welfare programs in general. His "analysis" is a blanket ad hominem attack. Years ago, if you criticized social programs, you could be summarily dismissed as an apologist for the rich. That kind of slander is bad enough. But now a certain segment of people who no doubt consider themselves enlightened members of polite society have devolved to jumping right to the immediate slander of branding anyone and everyone who disagrees with them as "racist."

You know what? That's social pathology, and the individual I'm responding to is obviously in the grip of it. I stand by what I've said. He should seek help.

Re:Why doctors are sick of their profession by ianstallings on Sunday August 31, 2014 @07:50AM (#8249079)
Such a bunch of bullshit hand wavy name calling tripe. I'd respond with eloquence but it's completely undeserved in this case. And to think you call others trolls. That in itself is humorous.