There are a few islands of private industry in healthcare, but between the regulation and the direct payments, it's a government sea.
Barring the most radical dissolution of the current system, the question isn't whether the government should be involved, but how.
Interestingly, the golden age for physicians' personal wealth was during the socialisation phase, as they were able to pocket fees increasingly paid by insurers, leading to a quintupling in income. They went from lower-middle class at $50,000/year in 2010 terms to $250,000 in 2010 terms. Doors anyone seriously suspect that we'll ever get back to $50,000/yr physicians? This illustrates why industries are often keen to socialise: they can guarantee outsize personal success.
What our system absolutely rewrites is radical dissolution.
As straining-of-credulity as such a bumper-sticker is, isn't that the logical conclusion?
Very Serious People ( with whom I happen to agree) actually say such things in "Fragile By Design". Calomiris/Haber are good writers and good thinkers. They do not call out medical nor political leadership there, but it's not exactly a stretch.
It's a short drop from this to the view of America from "V for Vendetta".
I expect the "higher GDP" tells us a lot. I first discussed this with my Dad when we took one of us the the Emergency Room for stitches ( it just wasn't a summer as a kid without a bike wreck or something leading to stitches ) and I was shocked by the bill - in 1972.
I'd be pressed to find the reference, but people have shown that proportional percent of income ( in the aggregate, GDP ) spent on medical care has been consistent between countries.
I hold that employer-based health care has turned out more sour than it perhaps once was because employment has gotten weirder. That arguably was not true in, say 1950. But medicine was also smaller then.
There's a couple of tables related to that at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_heal... . US is an outlier, with a total health expenditure of 17.7% of GDP. Otherwise, yes, most similar countries (Germany, France, etc.) spend between about 8 and 11% of GDP.
I find your statements to be over general to an almost crazy degree -- "the actual experience"? Everywhere? "In general we don't have an honest effective government" -- really? Got data? Etc, etc.
Also, I would be interested in specific metrics of worse and better -- you make the claim it is worse because of regulation, which you imply is basically the same as socialized funding (which it isn't). So where is the data?
No offense, but this sounds like canned right wing bullshit rhetoric straight off Fox News. Granted, there is plenty of canned rhetoric on all "sides" to go around, but that doesn't make this any better.
The problem is that certain sides get way less flak for "canned rhetoric". Particularly populist viewpoints.
When was this?
>the way we are doing it is just the way government works in the US, and that's not going to change.
That's some nice fatalism you've got there.
>In general, we don't have an efficient, honest, effective government, so it can't do anything right on a large scale.
Except for all the things you forget to mention, or even to think of as government programs, because they tick quietly away, working perfectly, in the background.
It's like saying the food/farming industry isn't a free market because "some people will use very little while some [fat people] will use a lot more through no fault of their own." It's a ridiculous argument, and sounds more along the lines of Peter Joseph's "structural violence" mantra. The whole "you're not truly free until you get all this free shit given to you so you can be free to do nothing/be lazy".
Granted, it isn't actually a truly free-market, anyways. Government subsidies, minimum prices, etc, all distort the market and affect peoples' actions.
Finally, my anecdotal evidence: I am highly satisfied with the care that I receive at the VA. I have 20% disability due to a significant loss of peripheral vision in my right eye. I am scheduled yearly for an annual physical including urine and blood work, a field scan with my eyes to test regressions, and two general appointments with an optometrist. I also have free access to nutritionists and weight support groups since weight management can be an issue for veterans. Is it perfect, no, but I have never felt that I didn't get the care that I needed in a reasonable amount of time.
[1] http://www.va.gov/opa/pressrel/pressrelease.cfm?id=2537
[2] http://online.wsj.com/articles/no-deaths-caused-by-delays-at...
edit: formatting
Some systems in the US, especially Kaiser, are basically a socialized system supported by premiums, and seem to work pretty well.
You can argue that we haven't been socializing it "properly," but the way we are doing it is just the way government works in the US, and that's not going to change.
In general, we don't have an efficient, honest, effective government, so it can't do anything right on a large scale. Though there are some exceptions, those are exceptions. Look at the Obamacare website scandal. That is the rule.