News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by lisper on Saturday August 16, 2014 @08:20PM (#8188111)
This sent chills down my spine:

"He [Hitler] had crushed the German labor movement and for that the property-owning classes were willing to forgive him almost anything. Both left and right concurred ... that National Socialism was merely a version of Conservatism.

Plus ca change...

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:36PM (#8188272)
It's easy to forget just how many Socialisms there were. The "Ein Volk!" were the "socia" in National Socialism, reusing the Goethe-und-Wagner nationalism from the Bismarck era. It's collectivist to the core and regarded the individual as very nearly nothing. Just because it's massively illiberal does not mean it was not a Socialism.

And technically Conservatism is also quite Liberal, coming as it had from Burke. It's just been abused to identify illiberal things.

What surprised me is that Orwell did not directly identify the sadomaschistic core of Naziism. Perhaps that came later, but given "Burmese Days" and how well known the ...libertine nature of Wiemar was, why I'd a thought...

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by mikeyouse on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:27PM (#8188250)
From a bit further as well;

> How was it that he was able to put this monstrous vision across? It is easy to say that at one stage of his career he was financed by the heavy industrialists, who saw in him the man who would smash the Socialists and Communists.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:42PM (#8188282)
It's easy to forget how profound the power vacuum was in Weimar Germany. The roughly Christian Socialists ( congruent with the Fabians in England, although that's not the term of art ) were a relatively stable influence in Germany. Von Hindenburg was roughly of that skein. The Communists were deadly violent and Stalin was a significant external threat.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by toyg on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:43PM (#8188385)
Von Hindenburg was certainly no moderate socialist of any kind. He was nominated exactly because he was seen as a link to the previous (aristocratic and Bismarckian) past without being too virulently anti-Socialist -- a safe pair of hands, so to speak, but certainly not a "christian socialist" of any sort. In fact, his suspicion and eventual (mis)treatment of the SPD was one of the causes of Hitler's rise to power.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by ArkyBeagle on Saturday August 16, 2014 @11:24PM (#8188449)
Well, it made sense while I was typing it :) I think you're probably right because "socialist" had a different meaning in a post-Bismarck Germany. If we consider what Fabian Socialism meant in England maybe. Even then the makeup of the Fabians was much more literary and not at all military. That doesn't work, either.

I'd have been better off identifying him as a Christian Democrat although that lacks something. He was one of the last of the Junkers Prussian caste to rule, and that really doesn't compare to much outside Germany and then only before WWII.

Of what came after, I'd say the CDU is closest to what von Hindenburg stood for, although it's still a stretch.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by yk on Sunday August 17, 2014 @06:35AM (#8189094)
Hindenburg was certainly not a socialist. He was a conservative nationalist, for 1920th values of conservative. That is, he wanted to reestablish monarchy and had the interests of the Prussian Junkers at his heart. In addition he got his job because he was a WWI war hero.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by ArkyBeagle on Sunday August 17, 2014 @07:23PM (#8190821)
I'd never seen that he wanted to reestablish the monarchy - presumably the Kaiser Wilhelm line? Some of the leftovers from (Queen Victoria's) Prince Albert's line? Interesting. Yeah, that's by-$DEITY about as conservative as it gets.

I dunno then - what do you call post-Bismarck welfare-state Germany? It was certainly cradle-to-grave, something we now identify with socialism. And yes - Bismarck was generally considered a conservative as well.

But the entire idea of Germany was basically... uh... racial. So it's a racial-ist socialism. Don't look at me like that, it's was their doing :) 19th century, phrenology, all that.

The Wikipedia page refers to Bismarck as a "revolutionary conservative". Ooh, my head hurts now :)

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by confluence on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:08PM (#8188207)
... plus c'est la même chose.

The funny thing is that many conservatives think National Socialism was "socialism", when in fact it was just their very own hard right conservatism. Tea Party and Republican candidates are where the Hitlers of the future will probably arise from.

> Down with immigration! Up with capital! Be a real American!

Welcome to the past.

Edit: I see the fascists have discovered my comment. Down vote away. It doesn't change history.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by mcantelon on Saturday August 16, 2014 @11:44PM (#8188474)
How do you know the next Hitler will come from the right wing? Left wing leaders have also racked up big death tolls purging and reordering society under the guise of progressive ideals.

Mao's leadership led to the death of 45 million:

http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/books/news/m...

Stalin killed an estimated 20 million:

http://www.ibtimes.com/how-many-people-did-joseph-stalin-kil...

Pol Pot killed 1.4 million+:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Khmer_Rouge

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by confluence on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:12AM (#8188524)
In my original response I stated that National Socialism wasn't actually comprised of left wing socialists, but rather hard right fascists, and go on and on about how conservatives completely misrepresent this stuff all the time, and in the very next response to that comment, you do the exact same thing that I was lamenting?

Ah yes the great "leftist" Mao, so "left" wing, he purged everyone who disagreed with him (McCarthy?). Ah yes Stalin, "left" wing extraordinaire with his extermination and enslavement of Russian minorities (The Conservative American South?). Pol Pot, such a "left" wing hippy he was a jack booted military thug (Brownshirts?).

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:42AM (#8188580)
So you're saying that anyone who purges people who disagree, who exterminates and enslaves minorities, and who uses military thugs to achieve his ends, can't be left wing? Please enlighten us on your highly non-standard definition of "left wing".
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by confluence on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:53AM (#8188602)
> In left-right politics, left-wing politics are political positions or activities that accept or support social equality, often in opposition to social hierarchy and social inequality

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Left-wing_politics

vs.

> Right-wing politics are political positions or activities that view some forms of social hierarchy or social inequality as either inevitable, natural, normal, or desirable, typically justifying this position on the basis of natural law or tradition.

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right-wing_politics

Which one seems to be more favorable to enacting your statement:

> exterminates and enslaves minorities

The equality faction or the hierarchy faction?

Here is an analogy:

You can claim yourself to be a pacifist (left wing) all you want. But if your actions are aggressive and cause war (right wing), then you aren't a pacifist, even if you claim to be one.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by mcantelon on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:03AM (#8188617)
>In left-right politics, left-wing politics are political positions or activities that accept or support social equality, often in opposition to social hierarchy and social inequality

Yes, and these are the positions Mao, Stalin, and Pol Pot took. They killed people using the justification that the people they killed were standing in the way of these ideals.

The next demagogue to rack of a massive body could could come from either the left or the right.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:18AM (#8188634)
Ok, so by this definition, Stalin was certainly not left-wing, since he exterminated and enslaved minorities, which you appear to agree is not supportive of social equality. Yet Stalin is used in the same Wikipedia article as an example of left-wing activities.

Also, if pacifism is left-wing, then the Obama administration is certainly not left-wing or anything close to it, since he has repeatedly authorized military action. I suppose you could finesse this point by saying that neither major party in the US is left-wing by your criterion. But trying to apply this more generally, for example to claim that Stalin, Mao, Pol Pot, etc., were not "really" left-wing, looks a lot like a "no true Scotsman" argument.

In fact, by the pacifism criterion, I'm not aware of any government or political movement that has ever been left-wing; the closest thing to it would be some religious orders, like the Amish, who really do try to be pacifists. (Some people would put the Quakers in this category, but the Quakers have always flavored their surface pacifism with a strong pragmatic streak; they sold gunpowder to Washington's army during the American Revolution, for example.) But this makes "left-wing" a basically useless term, not to mention that you would have to explain to an awful lot of people that they have been using it wrong for a long time, since most people apply the term to Stalin, as I noted above, as well as Mao, Pol Pot, etc.

Finally, if left-wing means supportive of social equality for everyone, then once again, there are hardly any true left-wingers and never have been. Take trade unions, for example: yes, they're very supportive of social equality for their members, but are they equally supportive of social equality for management? Not to mention social equality for people who are not members but would like to learn one of the trades that are unionized? In my experience, unions do a very poor job with things like apprenticeship programs, because training new members means less job security for existing members.

Similarly, central planning in economics, which is supposed to promote more economic equality, ends up giving special privileges to the planners and those who are closely connected with them (like large financial institutions); witness the huge bailouts of investment banks after the crash of 2008, while ordinary people got foreclosed on. The closest thing to true left-wingers by this criterion are left-libertarians or anarchists (which, to be fair, the Wikipedia article does mention).

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by Intermernet on Sunday August 17, 2014 @06:19AM (#8189067)
Please note, I'm not arguing your overall point, I agree with it completely. This comment is really just nit-picking over terminology.

I'm pretty sure that Stalin has been post-categorized into the "Left-Wing" camp as he stood for "Socialism".

That one label is about the only thing about Stalin that could be classified as "Left-Wing". There has been an enormous amount of jostling amongst all "Left-Wing" political parties (globally) since then in order to differentiate themselves from Stalin.

"Socialism" is now very different from Stalin's view of it, just as "Liberalism" has now been watered down to mean anyone who isn't on the extreme right.

Arguing left vs right is not the way to view this problem. Seeing through the emotive labels and debates, and analyzing the actual behaviour will show you that personal power is the driving motivator, not any political ideology.

According to Plato "The measure of a man is what he does with power". Most of our world leaders at the moment aren't measuring up.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:19PM (#8189837)
> This comment is really just nit-picking over terminology.

I agree that terminology in this area is very, very messed up. That's largely because the terminology has been used as a tool to gain and hold power, rather than as a tool of clear communication--Stalin being an obvious example.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by BugBrother on Sunday August 17, 2014 @08:06AM (#8189231)
>> "Socialism" is now very different from Stalin's view of it

Didn't released documents after 1989 show that most of the West European communist parties took orders directly from Moscow/Stalin?

IIRC, it was a big shock that the reason the Italian communist party was so reasonable after WW II was because it was orders from Moscow. (Stalin wanted to split Europe in two.)

I remember that the Swedish communist party used to be staunch Stalinists until Moscow told them he was wrong. Is that where the different view of Socialism came from? :-)

(The Swedish communists (SKP/VPK/V) claim to have stopped taking orders in the 1960s and have been critics of Soviet since 1989.)

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by Intermernet on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:14AM (#8189535)
Considering that Stalin died in 1953, it's improbable that he had any influence on the communist parties of Europe during the 80's.

I'd also refrain from conflating the "communist" parties from Europe with "Socialism", despite the obvious, ideological connections. Times had changed, labels were still being re-used.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by sbmassey on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:43AM (#8188674)
The extermination of minorities is a very popular tactic amongst people supporting social equality. Just look at the French revolution, for an explicit example, if you don't think Pol Pot and the other communists are really left wing.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by jcape on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:33AM (#8189579)
By analogy, you could say that the Inquisition was inherently unchristian, in so far as Christianity has an ideological character beyond simply "Christ worship".

Similarly, if we do the obvious thing and conflate "left wing" and "socialist", and believe that socialism has an ideological character beyond simply hating the existing organization of society, then extermination, slavery, thuggery, coercion, and violence are inherently anti-socialist.

This view is also the conclusion Orwell was operating under---the utopian ideal of capital-S Socialism which he approved of was used as operating cover to assist in the seizing of power by technocratic middle classes.

This view was pretty much explicitly stated in the Goldstein treatises in 1984, which described "English Socialism" as actually a form of "oligarchical collectivism," and claimed that "The Party rejects and vilifies every principle for which the Socialist movement originally stood, and it does so in the name of Socialism."

Similarly, there's this bit from the supposedly ex-Trotskyist James Burnham (who Orwell rightly abuses for being a power-worshiping scumbag):

"Some apologists try to excuse Marxism by saying that it has ‘never had a chance’. This is far from the truth. Marxism and the Marxist parties have had dozens of chances. In Russia, a Marxist party took power. Within a short time it abandoned Socialism; if not in words, at any rate in the effect of its actions. In most European nations there were during the last months of the first world war and the years immediately thereafter, social crises which left a wide-open door for the Marxist parties: without exception they proved unable to take and hold power. In a large number of countries — Germany, Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Austria, England, Australia, New Zealand, Spain, France — the reformist Marxist parties have administered the governments, and have uniformly failed to introduce Socialism or make any genuine step towards Socialism... These parties have, in practice, at every historical test — and there have been many — either failed Socialism or abandoned it. This is the fact which neither the bitterest foe nor the most ardent friend of Socialism can erase. This fact does not, as some think, prove anything about the moral quality of the Socialist ideal. But it does constitute unblinkable evidence that, whatever its moral quality, Socialism is not going to come."

To be fair, it's easy to believe claims about Stalin not being a socialist are simply ego-bruised leftists invoking the No True Scotsman fallacy. I don't think this necessarily applies simply because socialism is inherently an ideology. If someone claims to be a pacifist while marauding through a public place with an assault rifle, massacring people as they go, we have no problem resolving this dissonance: the murderer's claims of pacifism are simply lies.

Of course, pacifism was never taken all that seriously to begin with, so it's safe for us to simply say "you're lying about being a pacifist." We feel a bit more constrained telling someone they're lying about their status as a Christian or a socialist.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:44AM (#8188675)
> You can claim yourself to be a pacifist (left wing) all you want. But if your actions result in war (right wing), then you aren't a pacifist.

So you mean "left wing" is anything that leads to peace and "right wing" is anything that results in war. You may want to look up "tautology" or "circular reasoning".

By that standard a successful nuclear strike is left wing, and a failed one is right wing.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by anigbrowl on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:37PM (#8188274)
I'm continually astonished at the ultraconservative meme that Hitler was left-wing (which seems to originate with a book called 'Liberal Fascism' by Jonah Goldberg, although it has doubtless been floating around for much longer). Point out that one of the very first things that Hitler did on attaining power was have all the trade unionists arrested, and you might as well be talking to the air.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by judk on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:47PM (#8188287)
It's almost as though "left" and "right" are meaningless terms that are just use to split the people into two camps for battle against each other.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by icelancer on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:34AM (#8188776)
As long as "authoritarian" is part of both sides, the state is generally pleased to have both debate meaningless things.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by anigbrowl on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:53PM (#8188291)
I think they are good signifiers for significantly different economic/political beliefs. However, fanatacism in politics ends up looking pretty similar regardless of starting point.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by TeMPOraL on Sunday August 17, 2014 @09:57AM (#8189374)
I think that they are actively hurtful, they shut down rational thinking. Ideas that actually make sense tend not to cluster well along left/right axis, but are scattered all over the spectrum.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by fred_durst on Saturday August 16, 2014 @09:59PM (#8188305)
It's amazing how one can take the parity achieved via competition and relay it unilaterally to the quality achieved via competition.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by maxxxxx on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:16AM (#8189544)
It' not "almost as though" but they are meaningless terms (and harmful to political discussion in my view). American politics likes to force every issue into the "liberal" or "conservative" category but reality is much more subtle.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:58PM (#8189794)
On the other hand, here is the Nazi's public face :

http://www.historyplace.com/worldwar2/riseofhitler/25points....

Read it, then tell me if you still don't understand why these people might get classified as left-wing. They implemented quite a few of these points too, by the way. You can say whatever you want about Nazi's but they are by far the most successful leftist party in history, and quite a few "left-wing" rights today were first implemented by Nazi Germany. Big example : pensions. Scholarships (of the for-the-needy kind, not for-the-really-smart kind). There's many examples.

That said, it is beyond obvious that they are not comparable to today's left wing.

As hard as it is to understand today, the left-wing was very much anti-immigrant in the 1930's. But it's just one of many historical facts that have changed. What I still find hard to believe, is that it's the democrats were the pro-slavery anti-black side of the aisle.

Some choice cuts :

(the first parts are anti-versailles, and some anti-immigration)

  7. We demand that the State shall above all undertake to ensure that every citizen shall have the possibility of living decently and earning a livelihood. If it should not be possible to feed the whole population, then aliens (non-citizens) must be expelled from the Reich.
(8-9 are anti-immigrant)

  10. The first duty of every citizen must be to work mentally or physically. No individual shall do any work that offends against the interest of the community to the benefit of all.

  11. That all unearned income, and all income that does not arise from work, be abolished.

  12. Since every war imposes on the people fearful sacrifices in blood and treasure, all personal profit arising from the war must be regarded as treason to the people. We therefore demand the total confiscation of all war profits.

  13. We demand the nationalization of all trusts.

  14. We demand profit-sharing in large industries.

  15. We demand a generous increase in old-age pensions.
...
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by mpyne on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:45PM (#8189914)
You'll note, however, that many of those platform points were polar opposites to policies enacted in practice once the Nazis came to power.

War profits continued (indeed, Nazis who tried to actually push for getting rid of the profit motive were quickly removed from their posts and marginalized).

"Unearned" income continued. The Nazis even maintained the gold standard for international trade long after the other major economies had devalued their own currency, and much of the mobilization of their wartime economy came via inventive capitalist measures from the Reichsbank, Reich Economic Ministry, military-economic departments of the Oberkommandowehrmacht, and more.

Likewise the trusts were not only not nationalized (at least, at any great scale), but businesses and industry were forced to join specified cartels based on their market sector. It was through these cartels that the Reich enforced economic policy.

Most of the "left wing" economic policies that were enacted were emulated using good old standard "right wing" methods. Markets remained; instead of centrally planning economic output directly, the Reich simply regulated the market such as to achieve mostly the desired effect. Instead of banning refrigerators outright, the Reich simply failed to import enough iron ore to make civilian goods once the priority list for Wehrmacht and export needs had been filled.

Chemical plants that were absolutely essential for the Reich's strategic needs were contracted to companies like IG Farben with profit guarantees and profit sharing agreements, methods that would be perfectly accept to almost any right-wing economist.

There were state industries too (Junkers, a strategic industry expansion program, a steel/coal production cartel, etc.) so it's not as if Nazi Germany didn't have traditionally left-wing attributes to it. But nor was it lacking in traditionally right-wing attributes or methods.

All of these methods were means to an end, as opposed to being taken from either a left-wing or right-wing palette of options because they were left- or right-wing.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by maxxxxx on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:57PM (#8189942)
You expressed my point much more eloquently than I could. Always watch people actually do. Not only what they say.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Monday August 18, 2014 @12:14AM (#8191406)
Your making the point that because they weren't outright communist, they must have been right-wing. I agree that they weren't communists, I disagree with the conclusion you draw from that.

Most trusts were nationalized, just nazi style : their management was replaced or forced to obey party rule, mostly by threats. Yes that doesn't technically qualify as nationalization, but for all practical intents it boils down to the same thing. It is most definitely not a laissez-faire policy.

> Most of the "left wing" economic policies that were enacted were emulated using good old standard "right wing" methods

We're talking about the introduction of pensions, scholarships, unemployments payment increases, job guarantees, ...

> Chemical plants that were absolutely essential for the Reich's strategic needs were contracted to companies like IG Farben with profit guarantees and profit sharing agreements, methods that would be perfectly accept to almost any right-wing economist.

You left out the part where the party threatened to imprison (or worse) management if they did any orders that weren't for the government. Frankly, if a party with a thorough reputation for excessive use of violence that is in control of the government threatens prison if you don't sign a contract ... would you consider that free enterprise or laissez-faire ?

I agree that the methods used were not full-blown communist. The state was in absolute control, that was the goal, the means and what happened on the ground. Calling this right-wing policy is lunacy.

The way I see left, right, far left, and far right is this :

left: communist-lite policies. Try to achieve the same aims as communists, trying to avoid the worst inefficiencies of that by having market-based policies, with judicious application of direct government intervention and regulation. Example: Obamacare.

right: laissez-faire policies. Try to achieve (mostly) the same aims as communists, doing as little as possible to achieve those aims. If something needs to be done at all, don't let the government do it itself.

far left: outright communist policy. Put the government in direct control of everything, and have a direct reporting chain into the government for everything that happens. Government intervention is the only thing allowed to exist.

far right: don't try to achieve anything at all using the state. Anarchism.

On this scale, Nazis fall under "far left". They never had the time to really get to full-blown communism but they made great progress in that direction.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by the_af on Monday August 18, 2014 @02:48AM (#8191635)
I think your definition of the left-right axis is almost designed to make the Nazis belong in the far left, which is still (thankfully!) a fringe opinion.

Populism alone is not left-wing.

Your definition of left/right doesn't include aspects of the far right such as anti-labor measures (while calling themselves a "worker's party", the Nazis actually destroyed worker rights, which made them appealing to the industrial elite), and extreme racism. The Nazis also used the power of the state in a distinctly right-wing way: as a way to safeguard business and the property rights of the wealthy.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Monday August 18, 2014 @10:43AM (#8192836)
I appreciate the difference between what people claim they'll do and what they actually do given the chance. However at least in the case of the Nazis I'd like to point out the war. During this time in history, Germany, the Soviets and America destroyed worker's rights. We all know why. Does this indicate how they were aligned ? A little, but there are many other things far more important.

It keeps baffling me how offensive people find the idea that the far left was leaning towards racism and the far right was the more tolerant side of aisle during this period. Things change. Is this really so hard to imagine ? Everyone knows that the Vatican, for example, is very much for equality between races and has actually stood by this stance when politically inconvenient, just like they stand behind their (somewhat lunatic) anti-birth-control stand today. Given that, and the similar attitude of other religions, is it really so hard to believe that when public opinion turns racist (as I'm hoping people are still capable of realizing that it did), populist parties will turn with it, including leftist parties. Conservatives, as the name implies will be more constant, and will resist this change on both sides. Right now they're anti-immigration, because they're more so than the "big" left party, but not by much. That can change in a heartbeat, and if history is any guide, it will.

You know those old movies where you see rich women react to black people as if they were smelly insects ? Those movies are quite realistic and, like today, rich women are rather unlikely to be conservatives. Those people were part of the left. There was a time, not that long ago, when that was the norm, the social and popular thing to do. I bet most black adults can enlighten you to these facts if you're confused.

Everytime some range of immigrants starts lowering pay for a large group of workers, racism becomes popular, for obvious reasons. 1930 in Europe was like 2009, on the Mexican border, for people without a degree, only worse to the point where they actually feared starving to death on a regular basis (especially in Germany, where there were a few regions where there actually was starvation). Is it really so hard to comprehend that under those circumstances, sentiment will turn racist ? Doubly so given that the majority of taxes was going to foreignors ?

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by the_af on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @10:40AM (#8197515)
People -- or rather, myself, since I can't speak for everyone -- do not find it offensive as much as nonsensical. The far right was never tolerant, by any definition of far right. Racism is also inherently not a trait of the far left. When we find a leftist government/organization enacting extreme racist policies such as mass imprisonment, deportation or execution, we know there's something deeply wrong with it, and we usually denounce it ("how can they call themselves leftists if they do this!"). But the same policies by a far right government would surprise no-one.

I'm willing to concede many points, for example:

- That some branches of the left can be "conservative" at times, if we define conservative to mean "staying with the satus quo". For example, if the status quo is a leftist society. Also, individual people may be conservative as a general attitude towards life, regardless of political ideologies.

- That some groups historically called leftists were so in name only, or had right-wing traits at the same time.

- That the more extremist left and right wing at times are cosmetically very similar, especially when their discourse is at its most strident.

But the Nazis were far-right, paying only lip service to worker's rights. Most Western entrepreneurs were also anti worker's rights, which is why they initially saw Nazis in a very good light. They were definitely not "more tolerant" than the left.

I do not consider the Vatican or the Church as right-wing organizations, by the way. More like conservatists, which I have already agreed is a more broad classification. There exist sub-groups within the Church which belong to the extreme right, of course.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Tuesday August 19, 2014 @10:22PM (#8200837)
> When we find a leftist government/organization enacting extreme racist policies such as mass imprisonment, deportation or execution, we know there's something deeply wrong with it, and we usually denounce it ("how can they call themselves leftists if they do this!").

Strange. I must have missed that when it came to

1) First and foremost, Che Guevara. Allow me to quote him

"The blacks, those magnificent examples of the African race who have maintained their racial purity thanks to their lack of an affinity with bathing, have seen their territory invaded by a new kind of slave: the Portuguese. And the two ancient races have now begun a hard life together, fraught with bickering and squabbles. Discrimination and poverty unite them in the daily fight for survival but their different ways of approaching life separate them completely: The black is indolent and a dreamer; spending his meager wage on frivolity or drink; the European has a tradition of work and saving, which has pursued him as far as this corner of America and drives him to advance himself, even independently of his own individual aspirations."

Clearly being a racist murderous bastard does not preclude any leftist credentials. I would argue that if you checked the newspapers in the 1930's and 1950's-60's-70's you will find that similar reverence existed in the left for Hitler (up till July 1941, guess what happened at that moment), and Stalin, even when it was known that Soviets did the extermination camp thing.

Other examples that come to mind

2) the Soviets (against Jews, homosexuals, tatars, ...)

3) The open racism of Egypts various socialist government parties (religious, sexist and ethnic). Most glaringly, the left's support for the arab spring even when it got taken over by the muslim brotherhood, who is not merely racist, but genocidally so.

More generally, you'll see a lot of examples of this in the middle east.

4) The open racism in China, before (and even during) the latest pro-pseudo-capitalism era. And yes, this was while China was doing the Nepal thing.

Again, not just China, but a lot of Asian countries enjoyed this leftist support.

So forgive me for stating the obvious here : the left has a specific agenda, and is certainly willing to accept open racism in people it reveres, racist policies and even racist genocides to some extent, as long as they advance the cause.

I am more of a European-style leftist (meaning I find the democrats nowhere near the centre of the political spectrum), but I have very few illusions on this. I have been a party member at one time (student days ...) and after a while I was forced to conclude that while, yes, it was far-fetched that these people would ever be given the chance for genocide, but

1) there was a (granted, small) group always talking about it. Mostly about Jews and/or Israel

2) after a while I started to believe them.

3) these people were not just tolerated, but actually had high status. Some were part of the "core" of the party.

4) obviously, most people in the party were very much opposed to actually implementing this. Unlike this loud group however, they were not willing to sacrifice anything for that.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by the_af on Thursday August 21, 2014 @02:13PM (#8208750)
Now this will get dragged down to what can and cannot be considered the true Left :(

I won't discuss China, the Soviet Union, Che Guevara (where is that quote from, btw?) or anything of the sort here. It simply is not possible or suitable to debate this in a forum like hackernews. Call it a cop out if you want :)

However, I'll say I disagree with your fundamental assertion, that the Left is willing to tolerate open racism when it suits their needs. Racism stands directly against what the Left stands for. Of course corrupted leftist movements, often leftist in name only, are free to forget leftist ideals, just as religious organizations sometimes forget their founding principles.

But let me place emphasis on this: if a leftist movement turns racist, this is a serious contradiction that must be pointed out. If a rightwing movement is racist, there is no contradiction and its intended audience will applaud it; racism and discrimination are cornerstones of rightwing thought. It is a mistake for a leftist movement to tolerate a racist ally when it would temporarily help heir cause, but this is never a mistake for a rightwing movement because racism is often part of its core ideology.

By this definition, which I think is mainstream, it's impossible to consider the Nazis a far left movement. I believe there is an ideological intent to conflate the two extremes, left and right, which says less about them than about the people doing the conflating...

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by mpyne on Monday August 18, 2014 @12:44AM (#8191463)
> Your making the point that because they weren't outright communist, they must have been right-wing.

That wasn't the point I was trying to make.

And after re-reading, I'm pretty sure that wasn't the point I actually made. In fact I tried to make it pretty clear with the last sentence.

But perhaps it would be simpler to note that the Nazis were not simply a left wing group without confusing substantiation.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by maxxxxx on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:18PM (#8189835)
Sure, they had some left-wing traits. And they had some right wing traits too: The belief that Germany is a special country is pretty similar to today's conservatives belief that the US is exceptional and blessed by God.

My point was that by figuring out whether the Nazis were left or right wing nothing is learned. There are left wing and right wing democracies and there are left and right wing dictatorships. Left wing governments have killed a lot of people and so have right wing governments.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by the_af on Monday August 18, 2014 @02:51AM (#8191648)
Don't forget center-wing (is that a word?) governments, which have also killed a lot of people.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by adamnemecek on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:55AM (#8188695)
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:41AM (#8188669)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade_unions_in_the_Soviet_Unio...

Both the extreme left and the extreme right are very much opposed to unions. Ergo making a difference between them on that basis seems impossible.

It worked on the other side of the fence as well : Nazi Germany restricted or outlawed trade and business organisation just as it did it unions. They went after the Church too. They restriced universities. They replaced or otherwise forced the management of large businesses to do their bidding too. Hell, they went after a number of soccer clubs.

And the Soviets did the same. Slightly different order, with the emphasis placed slightly differently, but the same result.

In general I'd say that extreme left and extreme right are both totalitarian ideologies and will not allow any form of authority or power to reside in any organisation other than their own. Left or right merely determines the order and the emphasis.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by jahaja on Sunday August 17, 2014 @07:56AM (#8189219)
What is the extreme left for you? Stalinism isn't extreme left, it's just an totalitarianism promoted as socialism to gain credit. Just as north korea ain't a democracy even though they call themselves that. What I usually associate with "extreme" or far left is the "autonomous left" or similar where trade unions are certainly a fundamental part of the organisational idea.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by waps on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:40PM (#8189735)
This is the "but it was never implemented correctly" argument. To the rest of the world, I assure you that Soviet-style communism definitely qualifies as socialism.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by mpyne on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:59PM (#8189948)
I think the "but it was never implemented correctly" socialists always seem to forget the strength of a state required to simply "implement" socialism, and then enforce it.

Failing said state, it would require a very sizeable majority of the whole mass of people to simply switch over all at once, and again, somehow defend that new order from warlords and parasites.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by jahaja on Monday August 18, 2014 @01:21PM (#8193551)
That isn't even a reply is it? I could definitely build a solid case with a lot of historical references to support such an argument. However I'm very doubtful that you could build a solid case that Stalinism is in fact built on the foundations/ideas of Socialism. Just as it's pretty easy to build case that North Korea is not very aligned with democratic principles. This article is from 1940 and is skeptical of Stalinism. There's alot of more, and earlier, examples of such criticism as well.

But the propaganda that Stalinism is actually what socialism stands for was in the interest of both sides of the cold war, and we live with this "repeat-until-its-true" legacy today.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by philwelch on Saturday August 16, 2014 @11:40PM (#8188468)
There's one very important way in which Fascism was very anti-conservative, and that's in the sense that they literally believed in violent revolution to overthrow the existing order and install an ideologically-driven regime. That part is almost literally cribbed from communism, although the motivating ideologies behind the two are different.

Modern American conservatism, especially lately, is almost exclusively the boring and literal type of conservatism--the type that talks about traditional values and the merits of the status quo and says "no" to all these new liberal initiatives, ranging from gay marriage to Obamacare. It doesn't have the desire to overthrow the existing order of things, nor the ideological fervor to know what to do if it did.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by wdr1 on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:47PM (#8188391)
You're conflating several concepts with conservatism.

Sure, there are branches of Conservative thoughts that intersect with National Socialism, but the very same thing can be said about social liberalism.

In reality, however, neither side -- left or right -- in America is that close to the ideas of National Socialism.

To suggest otherwise is either genuine ignorance or a weak attempt to score political points.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by confluence on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:57AM (#8188608)
> neither side -- left or right -- in America is that close to the ideas of National Socialism

...

> False equivalence is a logical fallacy which describes a situation where there is a logical and apparent equivalence, but when in fact there is none. It would be the antonym of the mathematical concept of material equivalence.

...

> A common way for this fallacy to be perpetuated is one shared trait between two subjects is assumed to show equivalence, especially in order of magnitude

Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_equivalence

The party that attracts militias is probably not the same as the one that attracts pacifists.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by eudox on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:40PM (#8188377)
>Edit: I see the fascists have discovered my comment. Down vote away. It doesn't change history.

I was about to upvote you when I read this. Please don't be so anally frustrated in the future.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by orionblastar on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:26PM (#8188356)
Correct me if I am wrong, but conservatism doesn't have the social programs that Hitler had. Conservatism doesn't send people to concentration camps and then mass murder them.

I think this thread has reached a Godwin level. Both may be right-wing but:

Hitler supported abortion, gun control, big government, and other things the conservatives claim to be against.

To simply say conservatives = Hitler because both are right-wing is just as wrong as saying liberals = communists or anarchists because all are left-wing.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by AimHere on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:19AM (#8188752)
Firstly, Hitler liberalised German's gun laws slightly. He actually removed some of the restrictions and allowed Germans even to own some types of gun without a permit. Of course, Jews were banned from owning guns entirely, but in Nazi Germany, Jews were obviously a special case. The story that Hitler was a big supporter of gun control is just some bullshit propaganda by modern NRA types.

Secondly, you're conflating modern American ideas of what a Conservative is with what it would have meant in the 1930s or earlier. In the 19th century, conservatives would have been the guys in favour of protectionism and big government intervention in business, compared to the liberals of the day who'd have been more in favour of laissez-faire economics. By the 1940s, laissez-faire had been discredited by the Great Depression and nobody was too enthusiastic about the free market.

As for concentration camps, they were invented by the Conservative British government during the Boer war. (The six or seven death camps in Poland were an unprecedented phenomenon, so far unique to Nazi Germany, of course).

Political ideas change over time. You're trying to impose modern political ideas inappropriately onto what happened in the past.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by lisper on Saturday August 16, 2014 @11:23PM (#8188447)
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:45AM (#8188587)
Last I checked, none of those things were due to conservatives alone, nor have they been any better, on balance, when liberals control the government than when conservatives do. (Israel's methods of dealing with Gaza probably come closest to being "run by conservatives", but even there the same things tend to happen when more moderate Israeli governments are in power.)
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by rurban on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:54AM (#8188606)
There are liberals in the government? The last one was killed immediately, when he tried to stop the upcoming Vietnam theatre
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by lisper on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:02AM (#8188714)
Democrat != Liberal. Liberals have not controlled the government in the U.S. (or Israel) for a very long time.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:15PM (#8189827)
Well, everybody calls them liberals; they even call themselves liberals (when they're not calling themselves progressives, which is an even stronger code word for "left-wing"). If your argument is that they aren't "true" liberals, then who are the "true" liberals?
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by lisper on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:32PM (#8190025)
George McGovern. Walter Mondale. Lyndon Johnson. Franklin Roosevelt. William O. Douglas. Thurgood Marshall.

There are liberals in the government today, but they are a minority and wield very little power.

Here's an interesting historical perspective of the Supreme Court:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ideological_leanings_of_U.S._Su...

And a contemporary analysis of Congress:

http://thatsmycongress.com/house/ http://thatsmycongress.com/senate/

The extreme skewing towards conservatism is most evident at the extreme ends of the spectrum in the House: there are only 22 strong liberals vs 74 strong conservatives. There are two Congressmen with perfect 100 conservative scores and not a single one with a perfect liberal score.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @09:57PM (#8191151)
I'm skeptical of anyone's "analysis" of the positions of political figures because the analyst's biases always color the analysis. That's obvious from both of the links you give: the "That's My Congress" link is obviously biased liberal just from their naming of the categories, and both of your links only analyze positions on a one-dimensional scale, which assumes that no other dimensions are relevant. That just increases the skepticism of someone (like me) who thinks both major parties in the US are seriously off the rails on some issues (for example, the war on drugs).

As for your list of "true" liberals, McGovern is the only one who strikes me as consistently furthering "liberal" positions (by which I mean "liberal" by the definition you appear to be using--see below). Mondale didn't strike me as consistently furthering much of anything. Johnson got us deep into Vietnam. FDR got us into World War II (by which I don't just mean he was President when it started, I mean he consistently took actions, often covert ones, that were calculated to get us into the war). Douglas voted with the majority in Korematsu v. United States (his positions did change over time, so, for example, he wrote the majority opinion in Griswold v. Connecticut; but that just points up the fact that he wasn't always consistent). Marshall did win Brown v. Board of Education, but while education in the US is more integrated today than it was then, I question whether it is any more equal, unless it's in the sense that it's more equally bad. (To be fair, Marshall was pretty consistently liberal in his opinions as a Supreme Court Justice.)

Of course, from your point of view, this just makes the case stronger that "true" liberals have very little power in the US. But from my point of view, it makes the case stronger that your definition of the word "liberal" is not a useful or historically accurate one.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by girvo on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:46AM (#8188805)
I'm certainly not an American, but from where I've been standing I haven't seen a liberal in your administration since I've been alive?
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by pdonis on Sunday August 17, 2014 @01:16PM (#8189828)
See my response to lisper.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by reitanqild on Sunday August 17, 2014 @05:49AM (#8189036)
Last I checked Gaza were nothing like a concentration camp, and calling it that is an offense to anyone who experienced any real one.

When did foreign journalists have access to ccs? When did ccs have markets in broad daylight? Where is forced labour? (I didn't mention starvation etc because those ones are contested but still.)

I literally don't like to bring this up as it isually brings downvotes but letting people frame something this important, -no.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by lisper on Sunday August 17, 2014 @11:22AM (#8189554)
You're right, Gaza is more like the Warsaw ghetto than a concentration camp. History never repeats itself exactly.

But I should say that I didn't really want to emphasize the "conservative" aspect of what Orwell wrote about Hitler so much as that he was able to get away with a lot of what he did in the early days because the "property-owning classes" allowed him to. That is the part I found chilling.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by vacri on Sunday August 17, 2014 @05:43PM (#8190568)
Gaza is a bit like a concentration camp - an area where a group of people are contained and kept from moving freely. Generally concentration camps aren't big enough to support markets, but other concentration camps have allowed journalists, and forced labour is not a prerequisite for one either.

It is better associated with the Warsaw ghetto, but your requirements for a concentration camp are not actually definitive of one.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by BugBrother on Sunday August 17, 2014 @07:55AM (#8189218)
Let me add a couple of points re calling Gaza a concentration camp:

1. Gaza has among the highest population growths on the planet. Anyone implying organized murder is ... well, to not be impolite I also have to say: "is an offense to anyone who experienced any real [concentration camp]".

2. The borders were quite open to Israel, until the murders of Israeli civilians really started. It was common that people commuted to work in Israel and Israelis drove the car over to Gaza to have it fixed. Some problems are self generated.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by Intermernet on Sunday August 17, 2014 @12:24AM (#8188546)
I agree with you that this argument has little to do with conservatism vs. liberalism, but to state "Conservatism doesn't send people to concentration camps" is ignoring some glaring realities, unless you want to be really selective about the definition of a concentration camp.

Is Gitmo a concentration camp? How about Manus Island? Azouli Prison? These "detention centers" are full of people put there by both conservatives and self-labelled "liberals".

Left / Right, Conservative / Liberal, etc. don't really matter if the people in charge are just aligning themselves with these ideologies for political gain. I think you'll find that the politically opposed leaders of the world have more in common with each-other than they do with the average members of the populations they represent.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by deciplex on Sunday August 17, 2014 @10:46PM (#8191251)
Gitmo isn't a concentration camp because there is no 'concentration'. That is, the Gitmo prison is clearly not part of an effort to take some population of people and stick them all in one place. Nominally everyone there is a prisoner of war - they are not there because they a member of some Afghan minority, or homosexual or disabled or whatever the hell else. Neither is it a death camp, although it seems most everyone still there, will die there. Probably the most accurate label is that it's an internment camp.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by vixen99 on Sunday August 17, 2014 @02:23AM (#8188761)
You should detail the logical relationships between theses and people acting on them because -isms don't send anyone anywhere, people do. To say they do without offering a road map is loose thinking.
Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by Intermernet on Sunday August 17, 2014 @06:00AM (#8189042)
Yes, just like guns don't kill people, people do. Especially people who believe in -isms.

People justify their actions with -isms and theses and society often accepts those justifications. You can always say the -ism isn't to blame, because the person would have probably found another suitable -ism to justify their actions anyway.

The mistake a lot of people make is assuming that political leaders actually believe in ideologies (-isms), rather than assuming they just manipulate them for their own gain. Most politicians will flip-flop on any stance if their constituents demand it.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by josephlord on Sunday August 17, 2014 @05:45AM (#8189033)
Stalinism???

More seriously the claim was xxxism doesn't send people to concentration camps, this was responded to by counter examples. This is a perfectly reasonable response and disproof of the claim that xxxism doesn't send people to concentration camps. It was not a standalone claim that xxxism leads to concentration camps which may need to be supported as you wish.

I know the ideology wasn't xxx but exactly what it is isn't important to the point I was making.

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by DCKing on Sunday August 17, 2014 @08:50AM (#8189284)
It is nonsense to say that. If you think "Nazism sent people to concentration camps" is not a valid thing to say, then replace "Nazism" with "Jainism [0]" or "postmodernism".

Nazism entails the belief that a group of humans is inferior to other humans and that they can be destroyed. The arrow "someone is Nazi" -> "someone sends people to concentration camps" follows from their ideology. It would be absurd to say that Jainists or postmodernists send people to concentration camps, because nothing about their beliefs suggests a destruction of other people!

Saying that people's -isms "don't do anything" is dangerously morally relativist. Don't pretend that meaningful things cannot be said about the consequences Nazist beliefs might have. -isms are an important categorization of what kind of software people are running on their brains. It is useful in distinguishing what kind of destructive behaviour that software can result in.

[0]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jainism

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by toyg on Saturday August 16, 2014 @10:49PM (#8188395)
> I think this thread has reached a Godwin level

Well, it's hard not to mention Nazism in a thread about Mein Kampf... (sorry, I couldn't resist -- I do get what you are saying though).

Re:George Orwell's review of Mein Kampf (1940) by lisper on Monday August 18, 2014 @12:58AM (#8191482)
Heh, this is timely. Just showed up on Reddit:

http://www.vice.com/read/undercover-in-americas-privitised-p...

The money quote:

"I didn’t believe that a “concentration camp” could exist in America until, in Phoenix, Arizona, I saw one with my own eyes."