News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by jedanbik on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:29PM (#8138126)
FBI exploits vulnerabilities in old versions of TorBrowser. Solution: only run latest version of TorBrowser.

Did I parse the article correctly?

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by Canada on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:20PM (#8138445)
It's safe to assume such well funded attackers will use zero day.

You could force all your traffic through Tor with a router. That way your compromised end point won't easily reveal your public IP. The attacker would be forced to generate some traffic they could fingerprint or use the microphone and camera to spy on you.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by Sami_Lehtinen on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @12:46PM (#8143361)
Yeah, so many fails. First they failed to use Whonix or similar separation which forces all traffic to go only through tor. Secondly you shouldn't ever mess with, normal (daily use), secure (secret / confidential), and anonymous (no identifying information what so ever) systems. All of those should be completely separate, as deep as hardware level, preferably with individual Internet connections. For secure systems it's good idea to use separation with extremely limited connectivity (rs-serial cable in my case), it's enough to pass ASCII armored pgp messages. AS well for anonymous systems you'll use prepaid data with burner phone and also replace hardware from time to time. You'll also boot the system from read only media, so when ever you'll reset it, it'll be clean again. But if you're lazy and don't care, it's easy to fail. If you use your normal system for all three settings, the results will probably be pretty bad. Also always check signatures, without signature(s) checking it's trivial to give you version which contains well, what ever.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by x0x0 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:01PM (#8138647)
True, so don't engage in behavior like child porn worth burning a zero-day for.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by CapitalistCartr on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:08PM (#8138693)
"Like - having the same characteristics or qualities as; similar to"

Who decides what is worth compromising basic security and a zero-day? In the recent past, the US federal gov't has shown itself far more hostile to those who challenged them, or ratted on their actions than actual dangerous people. Is the "similar to" being a whistle-blower? Maybe being person who criticizes the policies of the gov't while being employed by it? If I trusted my gov't to restrain itself to child pornographers and actual threats to the country (not government, country), I'd sleep easier.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by csandreasen on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:33PM (#8139600)
Who decides what is worth compromising basic security and a zero-day?

Ultimately, lawmakers and the people who elected them. Additionally, elected presidents and the people who elect them, as well as the court system.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by coldtea on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:58PM (#8139742)
I don't think that's how modern democracy works, if it works at all. Direct democracy in 4 b.C Athens, maybe.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by csandreasen on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:40PM (#8139940)
It's a slow system with a lot of flaws, but ultimately if Congress were to pass a law saying who the FBI could or could not use a 0-day against, they'd be legally bound to comply. Ditto for presidential directives. If you're arrested as a result evidence acquired through use of a 0-day, you can make an argument in court if you really think you have a compelling case.

There's a whole lot of little details that make these easier or harder under certain circumstances, but none of these are impossible, especially if you have popular support for your cause.

If you don't like the way something works, you can talk to your congressmen, vote, support organizations that promote your cause, etc. Just complaining on the internet won't change much.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by justizin on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:51PM (#8139340)
Unfortunately, not everything "worth burning a zero-day" to some misguided government agent is as clear cut of an activity to categorize as child porn.

Obviously, I mean, it's fine if the government just walks into your house once a week for inspection because, pff, what have you got to hide?

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by higherpurpose on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:20PM (#8138443)
Yes. It's also old news. The new news here is that FBI used regular warrants to infect everyone who visited a certain website with malware, which I think is inexcusable under the 4th amendment - and common sense.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by adestefan on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:39PM (#8138549)
That's debatable.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by mike_hearn on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:07PM (#8138680)
Highly debatable. As pointed out in the comments of the article, the FBI would not require a special warrant to watch people going in and out of a crack house.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by delucain on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:51PM (#8138946)
But this isn't watching them going in and out of a crack house. This is watching all their movements after going in and out of a crack house. Still debatable, but I think your analogy didn't show how broad the scope of this would be.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by justizin on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:52PM (#8139345)
and possibly after pulling into the driveway of a crackhouse for a three-point turnaround.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by x0x0 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:03PM (#8138654)
If visiting the site itself is prima facie evidence of wrongdoing -- like child porn -- I disagree. In the case Silk Road, I agree: users could merely be motivated by curiosity and therefore browsing isn't on its face a crime.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by centizen on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:55PM (#8138971)
What about misspelled domains? DNS Hijacking or Bit Errors? Hostile redirects from innocuous hacked domains? I'm not against using access as evidence, but there needs to be more context than a single attempt to access a domain.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by sp332 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:35PM (#8138528)
Unfortunately, the solution is: never find out that you used any version of TorBrowser when the FBI was exploiting it. After all, the vulnerability existed back when that version was the "latest version."
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by comex on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:35PM (#8138169)
FBI has, in one case where the exploit was spotted and made public (and they probably knew it would be, since it was deployed so widely), exploited an out-of-date version of TorBrowser. No guarantee that they don't use zero-days elsewhere or won't in the future.

This is why I think TorBrowser should switch to Chromium. Whatever you have to say about Google, Chromium is unambiguously more secure than Firefox.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by makomk on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:56PM (#8138302)
Unfortunately, quite a lot of browser changes are required to prevent information leaks when using Tor, and it's not clear that Chromium can feasibly be made suitable or where the developer time to do it would come from. (That's I think part of the reason TorBrowser is based on Firefox ESR - they can't keep up with the new features otherwise. I don't believe Chromium has equivalent extended-support releases; in order to get security fixes you have to upgrade to new versions with new features and new information leaks.)

If you screw up and miss something, the FBI might not even need to exploit a bug in order to find users' IP addresses, they could just use documented browser features to get users to connect to their honeypot using their real IP addresses.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by pcwalton on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:46PM (#8139299)
Right. I don't believe that process sandboxing would have prevented what the FBI wanted to do here: unmask the identities of Tor users. I would be surprised if compromising a renderer at the moment didn't give you access to enough information for law enforcement to figure out who was accessing the site. (See the list of current leaks on the Site Isolation description [1] just to name a few.)

As a practical example, the FBI could slurp usernames and passwords from other sites the user has been to, then subpoena them to determine if they'd ever logged in without Tor, and so forth.

[1]: http://www.chromium.org/developers/design-documents/site-iso...

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by mike_hearn on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:07PM (#8138684)
This is an artifact of how Tor works. VPN services don't suffer from this issue because all traffic gets routed via the VPN at the operating system level.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by makomk on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:16PM (#8138754)
Even then there's the issue of various browser and OS fingerprinting attacks which the current Tor Browser goes to significant effort to prevent. Tor actually supports a VPN-like mode, at least on Linux, but it can only protect against some classes of attack.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by wtallis on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:44PM (#8138220)
If you actually care about security and privacy, then there are plenty of Firefox extensions that go far beyond what can be done with Chromium. Even just adding NoScript to Firefox closes whatever gap still exists.

(Aside from the process-per-tab model, what's Chromium got out of the box that Firefox still lacks?)

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by coderzach on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:54PM (#8138290)
Sandboxed processes. There are limits to what code running in chrome can do. AFAIK firefox provides no such guarantees.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by Freaky on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:56PM (#8138974)
Firefox is moving in that direction at least: https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by comex on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:15PM (#8138738)
It's certainly true that using NoScript prevents most browser exploits (though not all), and that if you're strongly concerned about privacy, you should use it. And make sure not to disable it for any trusted darknet sites, since as this article reminds, they have a habit of being compromised... I'm not trying to be sarcastic - this is totally reasonable for many use cases.

But the default browser bundle leaves JavaScript enabled by default for good reasons[1], and if you want higher security with JavaScript enabled and/or against non-JS exploits, Chrome's process sandbox is a big deal, and will probably keep it significantly more secure than Firefox for a good amount of time.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by debux on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:51PM (#8138260)
NoScript equivalent for Chrome is "HTTP Switchboard"
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by wtallis on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:56PM (#8138307)
Only superficially, and even then, they're not really equivalent. HTTP Switchboard has some blocking features that NoScript users need to use things like AdBlock Plus and RequestPolicy to get. NoScript's features aside from script and plugin blocking are completely beyond the scope of HTTP Switchboard, and some of them are completely unique to NoScript.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by finnn on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:01PM (#8138342)
Hardly, but chrome does has an option to disable Javascript on a per site basis, similar to NoScript.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by dublinben on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:53PM (#8138281)
The TorBrowserBundle is based on Firefox ESR. This is a stable release with extended support for security patches. There is no equivalent for Chromium, which is essentially the unstable track of the Chrome browser.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by jordigh on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:39PM (#8138193)
Unambiguously? This seems like a strong statement. What makes you say that?
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by Niten on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:01PM (#8138341)
comex's statement is correct. Chrome/Chromium was designed from the ground up for fine-grained sandboxing of renderers and extensions; Firefox's single-process design currently prevents it from implementing any similar layered defense.

Mozilla acknowledges as much with the mission statement of their Electrolysis project:

https://wiki.mozilla.org/Electrolysis

Hopefully Firefox's situation will improve in the near future—at the very least, we'll all benefit if Chrome has a viable competitor. But in the meantime Firefox absolutely is behind Chrome in the security department.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by aaron42net on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:56PM (#8138308)
Until Firefox tightens their sandbox, I believe any exploit can still use system calls to directly create TCP sockets.

Chrome forces sandboxed processes to use its network stack; if that's been configured to use Tor, it shouldn't end up revealing your IP and therefore identity.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by RexRollman on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:22PM (#8139151)
I think they should consider opening a conversation with Mozilla and see what can be worked out.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by fiatmoney on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:10PM (#8138030)
"all computers that access the website" seems the polar opposite of "particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized".
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by rudimentary on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:19PM (#8138072)
Except, these agencies are quick to retroactively redefine terms. Maybe data isn't "seized" until you classify it as evidence.

And if all else fails, "think of the children" usually works.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by higherpurpose on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:40PM (#8138197)
That argument should never hold in a Court. I'm still hoping one of these surveillance cases goes to the Supreme Court.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:41PM (#8139948)
The trick is to shop around for the most loathsome defendants you can find until you get a precedent established, then you can expand the technique's use more broadly.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by tedunangst on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:28PM (#8138497)
Is there no precedent for a warrant like "this whorehouse, address blah blah, and all the whores found therein"?
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by dublinben on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:32PM (#8138837)
It would be more like "this motel, known to be frequented by prostitutes, and every guest, regardless of their purpose for being there."
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by tedunangst on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:22PM (#8139144)
Would it? Did the FBI plant the malware on general purpose sites that happened to have some child porn, or on specific sites dedicated to child porn?
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by AlyssaRowan on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:11PM (#8139454)
Everything hosted by FreedomHosting, including Tormail, which was most probably the true purpose of their op (it had been used by Snowden and others, but all the mail was GnuPG encrypted).
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by tedunangst on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:37PM (#8139622)
The initial Operation Torpedo seemed rather strictly targeted ("Pedoboard"), and those are the cases working their way through court.

The Freedom Hosting malware came later, and it's not clear whether there even was a warrant or not, since it all appears to be still secret. To argue whether the warrant was sufficiently particular is impossible to say. I can concede that was too large a scope, but that defense can't really be made until there's a defendant.

Was it even the same malware in both operations?

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by AlyssaRowan on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @01:08PM (#8143506)
Same C&Cs. :)
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by tedunangst on Thursday August 07, 2014 @10:29AM (#8147861)
That would have been a good detail to include in the article.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:36PM (#8139921)
Good question! Click here to find out. http://ttly.me/eB3Ca
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by anigbrowl on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:36PM (#8139248)
It's different where you have prima facie evidence of guilt. Think of it as the digital equivalent to (perfectly legal) dye packs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dye_pack
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by trhway on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:08PM (#8138381)
applying the same principle of "2nd amendment was written when AK-47 didn't exist", the 4th was written when Internet (with its immense capabilities for child pornographers in particular) didn't exist. You did let that happen to 2nd, now it happens to the 4th and the 1st will come next (Twitter isn't just like AK-47, it is more like small WMD)... Slippery slope isn't just an argument, it is a physical law of Nature (known as 2nd law in other branches of sciences).
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by AlyssaRowan on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:06PM (#8139426)
That's not all exactly true.

Let me name it: the name of that exploit is EGOTISTICALGIRAFFE.

Sound familiar?

They actually infected everything on that service provider, including Tormail. That was deliberate and part of an NSA op. They didn't hack the server, the hosting provider gave them root. Data seized is being secretly used in various Tormail operations (not covered by warrant), and in "parallel construction" in several drug-bust cases and one related to another leaker. I'm not saying this is a cover, but it is awfully convenient.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by GrinningFool on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:40PM (#8139270)
What's with editorialized title?

The targets are those who downloaded the porn, those who hosted the porn, but - as far as the article discussed - not the pornographers producing the content [1]

[1]Pornographer - one who produces pornography -- http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pornographer

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by _archon_ on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:53PM (#8139350)
Interesting... I would tend to think that the highest priority target is the one creating such material and harming minors in the process.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by gabriel34 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:35PM (#8138849)
Regardless of the legality issue, a privacy bundle subject to these vulnerabilities is not really a privacy bundle.

TOR should stand on its own. If its security is dependent on legal framework than it's insecure.

In my opinion, nothing can ever be considered completely safe. All you can do is make sure the attacker's effort is bigger than the value of what you are protecting is in his view.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by EliRivers on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:55PM (#8139728)
But hidden services are also a mainstay of the nefarious activities carried out on the so-called Dark Net: the home of drug markets, child porn, murder for hire, and a site that does nothing but stream pirated My Little Pony episodes.

My God. Those pony-pirating monsters.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by peterkelly on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:31PM (#8138144)
So let me get this straight: Breaking into other's computer systems to gain unauthorised access is only illegal/unethical for the little people - is that right?
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by devindotcom on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:35PM (#8138167)
Not exactly... it's kind of like asking whether peeping into someone else's home at night is only illegal for the little people. For you and me, it's stalking. For a police force that has presented probable cause, evidence, etc to a judge and been awarded a search warrant or wiretap, it's normal investigative technique.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by peterkelly on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:47PM (#8138240)
The problem I have with this technique specifically is that it takes advantage of software vulnerabilities that arguably should be reported to the vendor and fixed.

If we accept that it's just fine for government agencies (and remember, it might not be a government in your own country) to find exploits, not report them in order to protect people who use that software, and keep those to themselves for their own benefit, then I have a problem with that. It leaves people at risk of being infiltrated not just by (some government agency) but by criminals e.g. looking for their credit card information.

Put another way, let's suppose you find a vulnerability in Chrome. Do you:

1) Report it to Google, wait until a patch is available, and then discuss it publicly (aka responsible disclosure)

2) Keep it for yourself, or sell to a government agency (possibly that of a country not friendly to your own) to take advantage of

The thing I really have a major beef with is that so many people think that option 2 is just fine. Software should be secure - everyone in the industry has a responsibility to protect users, not leave them vulnerable.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by mike_hearn on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:11PM (#8138713)
I would agree, but then consider what happens after that - the FBI and similar in other countries have no other options left, and the path of least resistance for them is now to go to politicians and ask for Tor itself to be banned.

Though I hate to say it, a system that (accidentally) allows police forces to deanonymise select individuals whilst other actors cannot do so, and even the police cannot do so in bulk all the time, is not a terrible tradeoff. Snowden has made similar remarks, I believe. Of course the supply of zero-days is presumably not infinite. As pointed out, if Tor had more manpower they'd maybe switch to Chrome which is much harder to exploit. So this situation whilst it may not seem ideal is perhaps the frying pan, and as endpoint security improves we may find ourselves in the fire.

I recently proposed on tor-dev that individual relays be able to stop acting as introduction points for specific hidden services, with exactly this scenario in mind. They ignored me of course. They seem to feel invincible.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by hollerith on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:53PM (#8139349)
Great comment.

Can you give a brief explanation about why Chrome would be harder to exploit than Firefox is when used with Tor?

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by jnbiche on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:44PM (#8138216)
>Not exactly... it's kind of like asking whether peeping into someone else's home at night is only illegal for the little people.

Well, if that's the analogy you want to use, then this is like police peeping in on the homes of thousands of people who have nothing to do with any crime, all in an effort to find a handful of criminals.

There are many people who are OK with that state of affairs.

I'm not.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by sliverstorm on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:33PM (#8138156)
So let me get this straight: enforcement should be bound by exactly the same rules as citizens - am I correct?
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by coldtea on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:36PM (#8138176)
Yes, you are correct, and yes it should.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by Loughla on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:46PM (#8138234)
So to commit any crime at all, I just need to be sure to close my doors and not allow law-enforcement in when they ask to enter. Correct? That is unbelievable naive, whatever your view on the current state of law-enforcement is.

There are times when law-enforcement needs slightly more space to work than regular citizens; search warrants, for instance. The questions arise when we discuss where the line is for how much more space they need and when they need it.

99% of the time, I agree with you; law enforcement should have to operate under the same rules as everyone else. But, for that one percent, asking politely if any crimes are being committed on the premises is just not enough.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by peterkelly on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:34PM (#8138527)
So let's consider how we might encode this notion into an authorisation protocol.

A given computer system allows access to a set of individuals who, according to some criteria, have been granted authorisation (by some party) to have access that system. This lists consists, at minimum, of:

1) The owner of the system

2) Other users who have been granted access by the owner of the system

3) Law enforcement agencies from one or more jurisdictions

If one were to implement this, then this would involve the software explicitly granting access to the law enforcement agencies in question. And if we assume this is desirable, then the next question to arise would be which agencies should be granted access.

Now, this is where politics and international law come in. Australia, for example, would love to have access to government systems of Indonesia. Similarly, China for the US. And arguably all permutations of these, and every country in the world. And in many cases they likely already do.

If you were to take the transitive closure of the desires and claims of all law enforcement agencies worldwide, then this would result in a situation where all such agencies have access to all system worldwide. If this is the case, then why even bother with exploits? It should be explicitly encoded in the default ACLs of all operating systems, perhaps using a regularly updated list obtained from a reliable source.

Microsoft, Apple, and the Linux kernel developers could then embed this list, and the necessary update mechanisms, directly into the OS. This would ensure that all agencies have access to the systems they desire.

The problem that comes here of course is that which agencies should be granted access to which systems. Should it be only those within the same country? Should it be those of allied countries as well? How do you determine whether country A should have access to systems in country B?

I understand there are legitimate needs of law enforcement. But I also, by default, take the position that computer systems should be secure, and that everyone who's work touches on this should be focused on ensuring this. This is the difference between white hats (the "good guys") and black hats (the "bad guys").

Disclaimer: I'm a computer scientist, not a politician, intelligence analyst, or international law expert. My views have also been influenced by the overreach of the NSA and it's partner agencies.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by mike_hearn on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:14PM (#8138731)
I would say you've summed up one of the biggest and most important issues of our time.

The internet is international. Governments aren't. What now?!

My own gut feeling is that we should try and head in the same direction as the email system. The internet largely conquered spam without needing government intervention or international treaties through automatic reputation systems, blacklisting of email abusers and so on. It's basically a giant group consensus system in which spam is defined as "whatever our users think spam is" instead of an explicit law. It works! Similar techniques could be applied to other systems like Tor, if only the developers cared (they don't).

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by adestefan on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:43PM (#8138566)
You just described CALEA.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by coldtea on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:57PM (#8139733)
>So to commit any crime at all, I just need to be sure to close my doors and not allow law-enforcement in when they ask to enter. Correct?

Unless they have proper and signed warrant. Which is like any other citizen, eg. me or you, having a permit to go into some place X. If we have to follow those rules (e.g about unauthorised access) then they should too.

Breaking into computer systems (or houses) to find evidence is not playing by the same rules. Nor is getting that kind of power arbitrarily over everyone, as they do, without specifics about a target/case.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by anon4 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:08PM (#8138385)
You're right but you don't want the executive branch to grant itself powers. You want the judiciary branch to give the executive branch an exceptional above-law right to do things in a specific situation that you don't want done to just any random person.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by peterkelly on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:58PM (#8138325)
So which country's law should apply, in the case where a law enforcement agency from country A is breaking into systems owned and operated from within country B?
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by coldtea on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:40PM (#8139943)
They should not break into systems within country B. That's an act of war.
Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by peterkelly on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:55PM (#8138298)
Regarding computer security, yes.

When we build software we have a responsibility to ensure that their use of this software - particularly for communication tools is secure.

If there are instances where a piece of software is not secure, I believe (and I gather the general opinion in the industry is) that we should do what is necessary to fix those problems.

Re:FBI Exploits Tor Browser Bundle to Target Child Pornograp... by sliverstorm on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:05PM (#8138364)
As a member of the private sector working on software, yes. Make it as secure as you can and fix holes.

But that isn't the FBI's job.