News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by gwillen on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:36AM (#8135810)
While I understand that giving people experimental drugs is extraordinarily dangerous, it still saddens me that, in all likelihood, these guys only got the rules bent because they were doctors. Anybody else would likely not have had the option.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by jacquesm on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:38AM (#8135921)
Doctors risk their lives. If and when they get ill during their work we should spare absolutely no expense to get them well again.

Also, if I were a doctor in a situation like that it would be good to know that my back is covered in case I do get ill. It would substantially increase the likelihood of me continuing to risk my life. If I saw other doctors around me being abandoned if they got ill then I might have second thoughts about staying in that line of work.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by gwillen on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:04PM (#8138660)
To be clear: I think it's _great_ that we went out of our way to get those doctors back to the US for treatment. If it would be resource-prohibitive to help everyone, I think it's important to help the helpers first, and we owe that to them.

But the issue with experimental drugs is not one of resource constraint. We _could_ give them to anybody who asks. It's not that we gave them to the doctors because they are more deserving, but rather because they are insiders to the system and thus can get strings pulled and rules bent.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by seanflyon on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:57PM (#8138314)
The bending of the rules gwillen was referring to is not paying for expensive medication, it is allowing these doctors to take experimental drugs. The sad thing is not that these deserving doctors got the help they needed, but that if they were less deserving we would have forcibly prevented them from getting the help they needed, out of a misguided attempt to protect them.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by jimmcslim on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:55AM (#8136067)
There's a certain irony in that The Onion is currently running a story, 'Experts: Ebola vaccine at least 50 white people away'.

http://www.theonion.com/articles/experts-ebola-vaccine-at-le...

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by tjohns on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:56AM (#8135852)
To be fair, Nancy Writebol (one of the two who received that drug) isn't a doctor, though she did volunteer at ELWA Hospital. From what I read, her official job title is "Personnel Coordinator", and she is also a certified nursing assistant. She was also helping disinfect staff leaving the isolation ward.

Regardless, if we've only got a few doses of an experimental drug available, I think it's totally fair to give it to the folks who are putting their lives on the line to help treat hundreds of others.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by yread on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:02AM (#8135976)
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by jnbiche on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:32AM (#8136767)
So? I realize you're not saying anything negative, but let's remember that she was there in the middle of a terrifying epidemic, helping people.

I'm not particularly religious, nor am I a Christian, but I don't feel the outrage that so many others do online about missionaries. To the contrary, I have a deep appreciation for anyone helping people in the midst of medical emergencies, regardless of motivation.

Now, do I think that American Missionaries, or any ex-pats, should have priority medical care over others, particularly local medical staff? That's the real issue here. What were the criteria for finding patients?

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by briandh on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:53AM (#8137568)
> Now, do I think that American Missionaries, or any ex-pats, should have priority medical care over others, particularly local medical staff? That's the real issue here. What were the criteria for finding patients?

While I share the same general sentiment, and I don't know what laws the US has about quarantining people, I think the big factor to keep in mind here is that as American citizens, they have every right to return to the US -- they just happen to be returning for medical treatment. Whereas foreign nationals with infectious diseases (much less Ebola) could be turned away as a matter of routine.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by yread on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:50AM (#8136865)
Did you see that much outrage in my comment that you had to reply?

> Now, do I think that American Missionaries, or any ex-pats, should have priority medical care over others, particularly local medical staff? That's the real issue here. What were the criteria for finding patients?

I don't think any officials considered that. They have just airlifted her because she was helping the sick - i.e. she was more of a nurse than missionary.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by dublinben on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:45AM (#8137519)
I'm pretty sure she and the other doctor were airlifted because they were Americans. The other high-profile doctors who have caught the disease haven't been evacuated to the US for treatment, because they're Africans.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:38PM (#8138544)
Medical missionaries are a real thing. "Missionary" is a pretty broad term, and "evangelization through works" is the focus of a lot of missionary work. Not all missionaries are involved in preaching as such, and even fewer are exclusively involved in such work.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by mentalhealth on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:06AM (#8135870)
I do partially agree with you, but it's at least worth noting that people in the medical field are much more likely to have the capacity to genuinely consent to the receipt of experimental drugs (in the sense of actually understanding what they're agreeing to).
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by aestra on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:03AM (#8136667)
Imagine if there had been a negative outcome. Like they went into a vegetative state.

News at 6: "Poor Black People In Third World Country Maimed by Being Used As Guinea Pigs for American Pharmaceutical Company."

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by jleyank on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:00PM (#8139390)
We discussed this over lunch. Ebola's one of the (fortunately) few diseases that have a quick, negative outcome. So, faced with "death in hours or days", risk management is altered. So, taking something that might not work (die quick), kill you (die quick) or give you more than hours or days to live seems like a good gamble. Or at least not a bad one.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by colinbartlett on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:24PM (#8137723)
This is the plot to a movie I have seen, though I can't recall its name.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by xsmasher on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:01PM (#8137965)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_experimentation_in_Afri...

Influenced "The Constant Gardener," based on a John le Carré novel.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by DanBC on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:32PM (#8139223)
The Constant Gardener, after a John Le Carre book.

http://m.imdb.com/title/tt0387131/

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by XorNot on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:56PM (#8137919)
The Constant Gardner. Also a book.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by walshemj on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:51AM (#8136870)
Dr's would probably better able to understand the risks and give informed consent - there is also a long history of Doctors experimenting on themselves.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by gfodor on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:53AM (#8135846)
instead of being saddened by it you should be happy that these are two lives spared for people who can go on to now help others. and it also will potentially accelerate the development of these drugs.

what would be truly sad is if we had the ability to save these people and we didn't do so because it would be bending the rules.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by seanflyon on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:08PM (#8138384)
I think it is appropriate to be saddened because these people would not have been allowed to receive treatment if we did not bend the rules for them and at the same time be happy that these two lives were saved.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by Pxtl on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:50PM (#8137874)
If they're doctors that contracted Ebola because they were deliberately putting themselves in harm's way treating other Ebola sufferers and plan to continue doing so after they recover?

Yeah, they get the front of the line.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by Fuxy on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:27AM (#8136016)
"As doctors, trying an untested drug on patients is a very difficult choice since our first priority is to do no harm, and we would not be sure that the experimental treatment would do more harm than good."

Really? I don't think this is a difficult choice at all there's nothing worse than dying so at that point any experimental drug should be fair game with the patients consent.

We already know what will happen if they don't take anything so why not try something else instead of letting people die all the time.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by cpwright on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:02AM (#8136664)
They don't know that the patients will die. There is a survival rate of somewhere between 10-50%. The patient will likely die if you do nothing, but it isn't a certainty.

That said, I don't think there was anything wrong with giving it a go when they have pretty poor odds.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by HelloMcFly on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @10:51AM (#8137164)
From what I was reading about this Ebola outbreak, most of the "survivor" percentages were from those who hadn't yet had the illness long enough to die or be certain they will live. There is a lot of uncertainty about the death rate for Ebola in a given outbreak, this one included.

While trying to find a description of this, it looks like FiveThirtyEight put something together on the exact topic: http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/we-still-dont-know-how-de...

As for using experimental drugs, there are certainly times when the probability of death may seem dramatically increased for one patient relative to the overall survival numbers. "Certainty" for a population is one thing, "certainty" for some patients can be more (but not entirely) clear.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by rayiner on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:46AM (#8137523)
There was a quote in an article yesterday, where a doctor at Emory basically said: our treatment strategy with Ebola is just to keep the patient alive long enough for the body's immune system to fight the disease. People don't die of the bleeding per se, but the fluid loss and organs going into shock: http://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-ebola-vi.... A doctor in that article estimates that the mortality rate with proper medical care is more like 45-55%.

So the proper base rate to consider for an experimental treatment with respect to U.S. persons is not the 90% mortality rate in Africa, but the ~50% mortality rate that might be expected of someone in a hospital here in the U.S.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by shiven on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:44AM (#8136265)
there's nothing worse than dying

Donald Rumsfeld, the CIA and victims of "extraordinary rendition" would like to disagree. (hint: waterboarding)

so at that point any experimental drug should be fair game with the patients consent.

The ethics of it are way more complicated than that. How would you like to take the risk of not only dying a horrible death, but having the pain magnified 10x due to a drug side effect? Or a drug that causes permanent brain damage to the point of vegetative state but saves your life?

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by Fuxy on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:48AM (#8136850)
Humans will always find inventive ways to torture other humans however if i had a choice between waterboarding and Ebola i will have to go with the one with higher chances of survival.

As far as drug side effects are concerned it's up to the patient really.

Risk brain damage or amplification of pain for the potential for a higher chance?

There's only so far you can go experimenting on animals before you just have to give people a chance to choose for themselves.

Once the drug has been proven to give you better odds without known severe side effects or it the likelihood of the side effects is very low then it's up to each individual person to decide even if these test were only done on animals before.

What is worse being given a choice or being prevented from choosing by a lot of read tape.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by codexjourneys on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:42PM (#8137825)
I agree it does not seem fair, although if they now use this drug more broadly for everyone who's infected, it would be worth the unfairness. I also think Sheik Umar Khan, who was Sierra Leone's head doctor on this, deserved a chance -- surprised he did not try a blood transfusion from a survivor.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by robin_reala on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:51AM (#8135843)
Not ‘would likely not have’; the rest of the deaths in the current outbreak haven’t had this chance.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by rjsw on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:40AM (#8136261)
We will want them to be able to write up any data they have on the spread of the disease, bit difficult to do that if they are dead.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by floody-berry on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:45AM (#8135936)
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by Shivetya on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:41AM (#8136165)
and the fallout if an untested experimental drug, one that has not even reached clinical trials, killed a non white non American...

really there is no please your type. damned if we do, damned if we don't.

What saddens me, unlike the OP about Doctors getting it, is that far too many are looking to take offense or worse, take offense for someone else who may not actually be offended, for nearly any event which occurs.

Two people already volunteering to do work I bet over ninety nine percent of us here would never volunteer to do in a place we would certainly not volunteer to go to took a drug that just as likely could have not even worked, I am more than happy it worked out for them I am betting if allowed the will go back

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by mcherm on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:23AM (#8136729)
Actually, I could support a policy that said:

  When we have an experimental treatment for
  which there are not enough doses for all
  victims, medical personnel go to the front
  of the line.
I could also support a policy that said:

  When we have an experimental treatment which
  has not been proven safe in humans, it may
  only be given to those who have given
  informed consent.
But what if someone told you that our actual policy is this:

  When we have an experimental treatment it
  is made available only to Americans and
  Europeans, never Africans.
I could never support a policy like that. I would consider it deeply unethical. And if that is the policy being implemented, then there is something deeply wrong.

You are criticizing floody-berry's post, saying things like "there is no please [sic] your type". But in fact, floody-berry is providing actual evidence (albeit circumstantial) that the actual practice implements that third possibility. And if that is true, then I want to know about it -- because I want to change the behavior of my country.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by krschultz on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:03PM (#8137980)
From the perspective of society as a whole, the most important thing is whether or not this drug works. There are limited doses, it has potential to save many lives, but we need good data on it. That means we can't just take the handful of doses and use them willy-nilly, the patients need to be brought to a lab for observation (and to see what happens if given the best medical care available).

Given that the research for the drugs is happening in the US and the US's CDC is really responsible for all of it, that means the patients need to come to the US.

Given that there is not a snowballs chance in hell of a bringing a non-US citizen to the US when they are known to have Ebola (many didn't even want to let a US citizen back in), it has to be a US citizen.

The 3rd outcome is a result of multiple factors, not some insane racist conspiracy.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by nknighthb on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @05:47AM (#8136176)
> really there is no please your type

What "type" would that be, exactly? I agree the deciding factor is that they were white Americans. So obviously you must think I'm of some "type" who would be part of some "fallout" if it had killed a non-white non-American.

And you would be 100% wrong.

I'll accept your apology now.

Actually, scratch that, I won't. I don't want an apology from your type.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by victorhooi on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:29AM (#8136243)
Gosh, all the crazies crawl our of the woodwork now...

Look, unless you have some actual proof, speculating that because they were white, that's why they got it is just conspiracy theory wackiness.

The drug company was an American company, perhaps for legal or whatever reasons, they thought it better to test on their own citizens first? And Shivetya has a point - if they had picked some random chump from Africa to use as their guinea pig and things had gone south, I bet there would be a s*itstorm of moral outrage that we'd used those poor foreigners as our test subjects.

As others have pointed out, one of the victims was a doctor, the other some type of nursing staff, who flew over to Africa from the US, of their own volition, to help look after Ebola victims. Have you done something like that recently?

If I was risking my life every day, to try to help Ebola victims, I'd want to think that I'd at least be covered.

I have neither their raw courage or medical skillset, but I tip my hat off to them.

I don't think we just begrudge that an American company was ok to use them as guinea pigs for an experimental drug that had never been tested in humans.

And hey, look, if these people get cured, maybe they'll head back over to Africa again, to continue helping people.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by mcherm on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:32AM (#8136764)
> Gosh, all the crazies crawl our of the woodwork now...

Please stop with the name-calling. We at Hacker News should be better than that.

> Look, unless you have some actual proof, speculating that because they were white, that's why they got it is just conspiracy theory wackiness.

No, it is speculation, but it is not "conspiracy theory wackiness". An extremely plausible theory is that these two received the drug while others did not because they were American. Your own posting suggests that. floody-berry posted three links to other health care professionals who happen to be African, who had died in this outbreak.

> As others have pointed out, one of the victims was a doctor, the other some type of nursing staff, who flew over to Africa from the US, of their own volition, to help look after Ebola victims. Have you done something like that recently? > > If I was risking my life every day, to try to help Ebola victims, I'd want to think that I'd at least be covered.

Indeed. So what about Dr. Sheik Humarr Khan? He was lauded by news services and governments around the world for the enormous difference he had made in the treatment of Ebola in Sierra Leone. I would want someone like him to be covered too.

But he wasn't. Why not? Is it, as you suggest, because the company decided "perhaps for legal or whatever reasons" (your words) that they should only provide the experimental drug for Americans? Because if so, I think that is TERRIBLE -- and I think that the laws (or "whatever reasons") should be changed. Because it is unethical to say that only American lives are important enough to save with an experimental treatment.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by victorhooi on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:24PM (#8137721)
I suspect you perhaps didn't actually read my post that carefully.

As I pointed out, this was a drug from an American pharmaceutical company.

And the trial was overseen by the CDC, which last time I checked, was an American federal body.

So it's perfectly reasonable, whether for legal, jurisdictional, or whatever reasons, that they would pick American citizens as their first guinea pigs.

This has nothing to do with "only saving American lives". You could replace American with any other country, and it would probably be exactly the same.

For example - Bayer, a German drug company, has in tandem with the Bundesinstitut für risikobewertung decided to run a trial on two local volunteer. Would you be just as outraged then?

Yet, you seem to see this as some grand conspiracy to protect American lives...

Further, you seem to have completely overlooked the fact that we have American citizens flying over to Africa, and putting themselves at risk to look after Ebola victims.

I'm not even from America, and I don't really see the huge moral outrage here. The drugs hasn't even hit human clinical trials yet, so I don't see how you can even draw conclusions on who it might or might not be offered to.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by darkmagnus on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:38AM (#8136259)
The tin-foil hat, overly sensitive type....
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by webXL on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:10AM (#8136696)
And the type who has no clue what predominately white Americans spend on predominately black Africans to help them fight AIDS. It's 2014. You can drop the race baiting and nationalism.

http://www.avert.org/funding-hiv-and-aids.htm

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by hueving on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:52AM (#8135950)
Being American is a possible reason because the Americans tend to get more attention in America. White has nothing to do with it though. There is no evidence of that. Get over your hangups.
Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by victorhooi on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:32AM (#8136245)
It was an American pharmaceutical company.

And the CDC was the one coordinating this trial.

I think it's perfectly reasonable that they were able to get clearance to use two American citizens as their test subjects.

Imagine the outrage if we'd picked two foreigners, and the trial had gone south (it still could, touch wood).

Besides, these were two American citizens who flew to Africa to help Ebola victims, risking their lives. I certainly don't begrudge them.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by floody-berry on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:56AM (#8137585)
You might have a point if they were treated in America

http://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-soon-can-a-vaccine-or-treatm...

> Last week, several vials of an experimental drug serum called ZMAPP were transported to Liberia from the NIH in an effort to treat two American aid workers with Ebola.

Two of the doctors I linked died in Liberia.

Re:Experimental Drug Likely Saved Ebola Patients by krschultz on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:09PM (#8138020)
And then the patients were put in a US plane with US staff and flown to a US hospital next to the US CDC, all paid for by a US charity. There they will be monitored by the US trained doctors, meanwhile feeding information back to the US based company that invented the drug, which is manufactured on US soil.

This has nothing to do with them being doctors and everything to do with them being American. Sorry, it's not an insane conspiracy, it's just the way the system works. You keep pointing it out - but we all already get it. There is a different standard when it comes to American vs non-Americans in the situation.

The important question is whether or not the drug works. Because if it does, you can bet your ass people are going to try and get as much as of it to the affected countries as possible. If we made a stockpile of the wonder drug and withheld it from Africa, then you would have a point. Until then, cross your fingers like the rest of us that this will work.