That said, I don't think there was anything wrong with giving it a go when they have pretty poor odds.
While trying to find a description of this, it looks like FiveThirtyEight put something together on the exact topic: http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/we-still-dont-know-how-de...
As for using experimental drugs, there are certainly times when the probability of death may seem dramatically increased for one patient relative to the overall survival numbers. "Certainty" for a population is one thing, "certainty" for some patients can be more (but not entirely) clear.
So the proper base rate to consider for an experimental treatment with respect to U.S. persons is not the 90% mortality rate in Africa, but the ~50% mortality rate that might be expected of someone in a hospital here in the U.S.
Donald Rumsfeld, the CIA and victims of "extraordinary rendition" would like to disagree. (hint: waterboarding)
so at that point any experimental drug should be fair game with the patients consent.
The ethics of it are way more complicated than that. How would you like to take the risk of not only dying a horrible death, but having the pain magnified 10x due to a drug side effect? Or a drug that causes permanent brain damage to the point of vegetative state but saves your life?
As far as drug side effects are concerned it's up to the patient really.
Risk brain damage or amplification of pain for the potential for a higher chance?
There's only so far you can go experimenting on animals before you just have to give people a chance to choose for themselves.
Once the drug has been proven to give you better odds without known severe side effects or it the likelihood of the side effects is very low then it's up to each individual person to decide even if these test were only done on animals before.
What is worse being given a choice or being prevented from choosing by a lot of read tape.
Really? I don't think this is a difficult choice at all there's nothing worse than dying so at that point any experimental drug should be fair game with the patients consent.
We already know what will happen if they don't take anything so why not try something else instead of letting people die all the time.