>Other studies looked at speed dispersion and found evidence that this is also an important factor in determining crash rate. Larger differences in speed between vehicles are related to a higher crash rate. Without exception, a vehicle that moved (much) faster than other traffic around it, had a higher crash rate.
Which is the whole point of this article. The article isn't saying that isn't dangerous, it is saying that speed differential is more dangerous than speed. It is saying that speed limits are generally ignored by most people (most people drive some combination of the speed of traffic and the speed they feel comfortable with), however the few people that DO listen to them cause accidents because it makes the differential speed much higher.
> A good starting mental model is that vehicle speeds increase both the frequency and severity of crashes.
This is a horrible starting model. The severity of crashes is physics, but the frequency can't be looked at in isolation. Even the article you cite hints at the fact that the relationship isn't that simple: In figure 1, rural roads with higher speed limits have a shallow linear relationship between crashes and speed, while urban roads with lower speed limits have a much steeper, exponential relationship between crashes and speed. Which counteracts a very simple "speed increases the frequency of accidents".
It's just an abstract that we're discussing here, I know, but the abstract absolutely, categorically does not say that. At all. You're guessing that's what it means.
> it is saying that speed differential is more dangerous than speed.
No it's not, the article is saying that a delta in speed is a factor in crash frequency. (And no, I didn't copy paste the whole abstract, because I was posting the part of the abstract germane to the quote I cited from the original article.)
> This is a horrible starting model. The severity of crashes is physics, but the frequency can't be looked at in isolation.
No, it's still a good starting model. If you read all the way to the end of that abstract, I think you'll see my point:
> Without exception, a vehicle that moved (much) faster than other traffic around it, had a higher crash rate. With regard to the rate of a (much) slower moving vehicle, the evidence is inconclusive.
So, much faster moving vehicles always had higher crash rates, while much slower vehicles... inconclusive.
There's a saying in statistics (George Box) that all models are wrong, but some models are useful. I think you'll find examples where speed isn't a problem, but those aren't the norm. If you're looking for a simple univariate model that goes a good long ways toward explaining vehicle safety, I'd challenge you to come up with a better one than what I've proposed here.
There was little evidence presented that justified the assumption that most people won't drive any faster with a raised speed limit, but if we take that as true, then its conclusion is consistent with the research you linked. It is NOT making the claim that driving faster is safer. In fact, it again clearly states that in an ideal world, everybody would just travel at slower and safer speeds, but that we can't effectively enforce such a low speed limit.
Emphasis mine. Your slower moving vehicle could relate to vehicles moving slower than other cars. Which is what gp claimed.
What about the Autobahn, me passing traffic with a difference in speed of 100km/h at times (it's entirely possible to reach higher values w/ faster cars, reckless driving, unusually slow traffic on the slow lane, like trucks).
I think it can work. Obviously it cannot work without education and experience, but pointing at speed differences as the one stat that leads to chaos and mayhem seems empirically wrong.
A Dutch engineer once told me (back before 2004 I guess ) that they once raised the speed limit on the roads in Netherlands and found that counterintuitively, - average speed decreased.
His explanation IIRC was that
1. once people break the rules it doesn't matter how much
and
2. when speed limits felt more correct more people respected them.
this, according to him, meant that even if some people were driving faster a lot of those who used to break the rules now followed them.
I'd still love to know if anyone has any more pointers to research on this and I am fairly sure someone around here knows a whole lot. ( I got some unexpected input in the other thread already.)
The data is open and there is a nice website showing the top speeds: http://www.bestwelsnel.nl/ (best wel snel = pretty fast)
Is there any documented effect of that data being public to people trying to "beat" the speeds?
The establishment of the national maximum highway speed limit of 55mph was about that. Speed limits more generally (which predate that by quite a long time), not so much.
EDIT: As it has been accurately pointed out that the above response is US-centric, more generally: the establishment of reduced speed limits in many jurisdictions in the early-mid 1970s (including the US national maximum highway speed limit of 55mph) were due to the concerns of saving fuel in an oil crisis, but that is not true of speed limits more generally (either before -- stretching back to more than a century before automobiles existed -- or after the 1970s.)
http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/december/15...
Sure, that doesn't change the fact that your statement upthread is still generally wrong. But I've updated my response to it to be more general and less US-centric.
Actually saving fuel would have involved sitting down a dozen auto manufacturers and persuasively asking them to participate in a cartel to improve vehicle fuel efficiency without disproportionately harming any individual participant's competitiveness.
Instead, they ordered 250 million people to slow down. According to the article, only 10% are generally willing to do that consistently, and that just increases the collision rate.
So in the end, the 55 mile per hour speed limit wasn't about anything but ignorant management doing something with a high visibility to appear wise, leaderly, and decisive. But it actually just hurt everyone else. We've seen that story so many times, the details are practically unnecessary.
The sad thing is that the people that really need to learn the lessons of history are too busy trying to crank out more illustrative examples.
Maybe European cars are different?
This might be another "tantalizingly counterintuitive" observation, but raising speed limits may not necessarily make everyone go faster. What it might do, though, is make people more courteous to each other.
As an example, if the speed limit is 50mph and you're going 50mph and someone is tailgating you, the fact that they're tailgating you probably frustrates you and makes you less likely to speed up or switch lanes. In fact, depending on your personality, it might make you mad enough to slow down or brake check them. However, if you're going 50mph because that's the speed you're comfortable with, but the speed limit is 65mph, you'll probably still be annoyed at somebody tailgating you but you might also be more sympathetic and hence less likely to do something passive aggressive.
This is, of course, all speculation.
I've found myself in vehicles towing trailers where 65 mph was about as fast as I could go. I continuously had cars passing me. If everyone is a criminal, something is wrong with the law.
As to whether things are enforced that way, that's a different story.
I don't think skirting the limits has much impact on behavior as the limits go up. In my personal observation, I've observed little if any difference between highway driving on the Deegan Expressway in NYC (50 mph), i95 in South Carolina (70/75) or the mass pike (65). Once you hit 70-80 mph, driving requires more attention.
On the other side, you have absurd local limits as well. The standard for streets in most towns in New York was 35 twenty years ago. Now it's 30, with zones as low as 15 or 20 mph near schools. It's a scheme to get bigger tickets and more drug arrests in "school zones". I wish they'd just get to the point and put up a toll barricade.
That seemed like a pretty good reason to have lower speed limits in pedestrian areas to me.
The goal of improving roads is to increase the throughput of traffic. If it seems as though a problem could be solved by slowing down traffic, that's like solving a problem with a circuit by throwing a resistor into it. It may solve the immediate problem, but it will also reduce the overall efficiency of the circuit by converting energy into heat rather than usable work.
They could also put up signs that say 100% of the people who drive 40 mph reach their destinations 33% faster than those who drive 30 mph. It's just a distraction from the fact that solving the problem in a better way is more expensive than just blaming drivers and letting insurance handle the fallout.
"The goal of improving roads is to increase the throughput of traffic" - that is considered an outdated goal by most planners these days. For one thing, if you increase the capacity of roads, you simply encourage more driving, and things end up congested anyway. In many cases urban planners now actively seek to decrease the throughput of traffic on mixed-use streets in urban areas.
As I mentioned before, the urban planners who are adding resistance to the system are not helping the overall efficiency. Intentionally decreasing the capacity of urban infrastructure is almost criminally stupid. It approaches the level of solving an overpopulation problem by conducting a decimation lottery every time the number of people approaches some upper limit.
Some planners are shutting down some roads to increase throughput, by encouraging greater use of more improved roads. Others are altering roads, or installing traffic circles, or adding stop signs and speed bumps, just to make vehicle traffic gratuitously more difficult. Those people are the assholes.
Congestion results from insufficient infrastructure to meet public demand. If your sidewalk is too narrow for the foot traffic, and people get jammed up and spill out onto the street, you cannot solve the problem by making it narrower and throwing caltrops onto it. And that doesn't work with cars on roads, either.
So maybe those signs are on streets where throughput is not the primary goal, and where substantial barriers would interfere with people moving from their parked cars to the sidewalk and the like.
If you look at a high-traffic street where parking is prohibited, the Magnificent Mile in Chicago, you'll notice that there are gigantic concrete planters between the cars and the regular pedestrian traffic. Retail stores protect their entrances with concrete bollards. Construction zones protect workers from traffic with segmented Jersey barriers and water-filled crash barrels. Those are actual solutions.
But then you have suburban pearl-clutchers who lobby for a 15 mph speed limit and speed bumps in their cookie-cutter subdivisions, rather than actually making their streets safer for pedestrians. Or by replacing yield signs with stop signs. Those people don't realize that "change the law" is not always equivalent to "fix the problem".
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_speed_limit_enforcement_i...
> they want to set the speed limit so that 15% of drivers exceed it and 85% of drivers drive at or below the speed limit.
The citation you provided is roughly consistent with that.
The original article also said:
> Lt. Megge believes the compliance rate in Michigan to be well under 50%.
That's the only part that estimates rates of non-compliance. And it's not 85%.
Of course the article doesn't say what those other 90% are doing. I suspect they aren't all breaking the limit - probably some are going slower than the speed limit.
Average US worker spends 25 minutes on a one-way trip to work. Lets assume an average speed of 60mph (hint: it's slower). If you went at 70 instead of 60, then you'll save a whole 3.5 minutes.
Here(http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:jWbI1mK...) is a link to a NHTSA presentation on speed limit changes and its effects on crashes. Notably, when states were given control of speed limits, we saw raises from 60-65 to 70-75 mph in some situations, and a 35% increase in fatalities.
if we do the whole "life is worth $3M dollars" argument, divide by two because I'm trying to make this favorable to you (even though car fatalities disproportionately affect young people), letting people go 70 instead of 60 could still end up causing almost 10k more deaths per year, so there's $15B in lost value per year. At least I'll get to sleep in for 3.5 more minutes.
3.5 minutes/trip saved * 2 trips/day * 200 working days per year (probably more) = 1400 minutes saved per year per person.
working-age population of US (2012) = 243 million. Employment-to-population_ratio = 67%, so 162 million.
Let's say that half drive, or 80 million. So, 80m * 1400 minutes = 112 billion minutes a year saved by speeding or 1.9 billion hours. At a wage of $10 per hour, that's $19 billion, which is a bit ahead of the $15b loss of value per your number, but I'm sure our confidence intervals overlap.
112 billion minutes = 213000 person-years of being stuck inside a car saved by speeding. With a US average lifespan of 79, that's 2700 total additional lifespans spent in a car by losing those 3.5 minutes.
Come on, that's not a fair argument. The effects are obviously much bigger than one guy saving 3.5 minutes.
To get closer to the meat: If your calculation always outputs numbers that make slower traffic look better, no matter what the starting speed is, then your methodology is wrong. Your method here would make 15mph look better than speeds 20mph or faster, despite a 15mph speed limit being a blatantly terrible idea.
(Also doesn't your assumption of an average speed of 60 bias your argument heavily against high speed limits? I would expect saving 4 minutes on a 30mph route to be much safer than saving 4 minutes off a 60mph route. Is my expectation wrong here?)
Obviously if we're going from 15 to 20 the numbers change. But at the same time if people were on average driving around at 15mph on average car accidents wouldn't be such a big issue, instead of the leading cause of death among teenagers.
actually with lower speed limits you would gain more time by going 10mph faster. For example, if people were driving at 10mph on average, going 20mph would half their transit time. The point is that the speeding people commit usually doesn't earn them much more time, but disproportionately endanger themselves and those around them at higher speeds.
Right, not sure why you have 'actually' there because that was my point. When you picked 60 vs. 70 you were picking the speeds most likely to favor not going faster.
>the speeding people commit usually doesn't earn them much more time, but disproportionately endanger themselves and those around them
It's the 'disproportionately' that's at argument. A tiny-per-person cost for a noble purpose seems like an obvious choice, but when you repeat the action a billion times over it gets more complicated.
"I think that we should set speed limits to somewhere around where they are now or lower, and then re-engineer our roads to make it harder for people to speed. This is practical and will save lives, and the evidence supports this."
If I'm reading you correctly, I have a number of problems with it:
1. I don't think it's in any way practical to re-engineer roads on the massive scale that would be necessary to do this. If, as asserted, the majority of people exceed the speed limits the majority of the time, you're talking about re-engineering the majority of roads. That's an enormous project compared to resetting the speed limits.
2. You're a bit light on details about what you would do to make people obey the speed limits, but you list as contributing to speeding "wide lanes, big setbacks, and homogenous environments." Leaving aside homogenous environments (are we now talking about re-engineering not only all of our roads, but also all of our cities in general?), I'm sure that making lanes narrower and setbacks smaller would in fact make people drive slower, but would it actually increase safety compared to the counterfactual of not re-engineering and increasing speed limits? I doubt it. Certainly, I don't see evidence for it.
3. Hidden in here is a question of legitimacy. Are current speed limits a result of a social consensus about the speed/safety tradeoff made by an open society? I don't think that there's any convincing evidence that they are. They appear to be a reaction to OPEC and a revenue model for local governments at least as much as they are about a democratic consensus -- and to the extent that they are about a democratic consensus, they seem to be based on one in which the democracy in general was not aware of the deleterious effects of low speed limits in terms of speed differentials.
So, look, the situation right now appears to be:
a. Roads designed for speed, but with artificially low speed limits leading to inflated danger.
And a couple of possible future policies could be:
b. Roads designed for speed, with higher speed limits leading to reduced danger compared to a.
c. Roads designed for lower speed, with the same or lower speed limits leading to reduced danger compared to either a. or b.
It seems like you've jumped to the conclusion that option c is the right one, but I don't know that it is, even granted that it is the safest option.
However, the quote from the Lieutenant was clearly stating that speeding was not the problem. The whole article appears to have been either crafted or embarrassingly not crafted to muddle these two questions.
More than that, it's pure econo-meta - regulation is bad, freedom is good, if you leave people alone they'll behave responsibly, and everyone wins.
It's a moral parable (for economic values of 'moral') not a peer-reviewed paper.
Here's a newspaper piece that summarises some of the relevant peer reviewed research and draws a different conclusion:
http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2013/may/13/speed-l...
also, while that (faster = crash more) may be true, its not the only thing going on. it may be the case (and one argued in the article) that driving speed differences results in more crashes.
I suspect that's a temporary effect. The speed people are comfortable at is mostly a learned phenomenon. The more they drive fast safely, the more comfortable they feel.
Remember when you first started riding your bicycle? 10 mph was super fast and was super scary. And it is; that's faster than the speeds that the human body was evolved to support.
Most people who ride motorcycles or mopeds do it faster than they would on a bicycle.
Just like on a bike, the first one was a heavy steel one with thick tires. Now, I'm riding a road bike that weighs a tiny amount and has dual compound tires.
[1] http://www.vancitybuzz.com/2013/09/speed-does-not-kill-vanco...
The facts should speak for themselves regardless of what each of us wants.
But when I'm looking for facts I should prefer well constructed research, and not a documentary.
Examples:
- http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/publications/research/safety/97084/9...
- http://www.th.gov.bc.ca/publications/eng_publications/speed_...
But, I also don't see either source providing justification for driving faster. Both reports seem to accept this (in fact, this is about as close to pure physics you'll find in transportation engineering):
From the FHWA's report:
These requests are founded on public knowledge that crash severity increases with increasing vehicle speed, because in a collision, the amount of kinetic energy dissipated is proportional to the square of the velocity. Simply stated, when a vehicle is involved in a crash, the higher the vehicle speed, the greater the chance of being seriously injured or killed.
and quoted by the BC report:
A driver’s choice of speed can impose risks on other road users. Crash severity increases with increasing speeds because in a collision, the amount of kinetic energy dissipated is proportional to the square of the velocity.
Now, beyond this, there are some subtleties. Both of these reports state that crashes are more likely to occur when there is a greater delta between fast and slow roadway users. That's fine. They also talk about how speed limits are more likely to be exceeded where the roadway design encourages higher speeds. Emphatically agree.
So, now we are left with a policy question. Surely we agree that habituating people to breaking the law is bad. If people respond to a combination of law and roadway design (perhaps leaning more heavily on the latter), and we want behavior in line with law, what should we do? Ease the law or change the roadway design?
Normatively, for most roadways (especially those containing bicycles and pedestrians), I say we need to move more toward changing the roadway design to discourage higher speeds. On some highways, it might be appropriate to lift speed limits, though even then I'd tend to cast a cautionary gaze toward the Montana experiment that was referenced elsewhere in this thread.
Or change the context in some third way (e.g., enforcement)? The thing with roadway design is that the roadway designs which enourage higher speed are generally the same ones that are safer at any given speed, so changing the design to reduce the incentive for high speed may not improve safety as much as the reduced "natural speed" would seem to suggest -- and may retain the high delta beteween fast drivers and slow drivers that you note is a major factor in accidents, just reducing the median.
But what if through technology we could get enforcement of existing limits to a place where the probability of penalty for violations was higher (even if the penalty range had a lower bottom end)? One problem with law as an factor in behavior right now is that the probability of any given violation (or even a pattern of consistent violations) being punished is so low that the law serves more as a very weak social signal and the source of an inverted lottery of punishment than as a rational utility factor in regular behavior calculations.
With more consistent enforcement, we may be able to reduce the delta between high and low speed drivers (as the high speed end is usually significantly above the legal limit) without changing the law (at least, the speed limits in the law) or the road design significantly.
Technology, as you point out, more broadly deployable, as well as cheaper and less likely to discriminate. For that reason, I actually kind of like speed / red light cameras. However, they are wildly unpopular to the point of being made illegal in many places. Plus, I think there are legitimate concerns about surveillance aspects of our newly smart cities.
With respect to "safer at any given speed" designs, I think you have to consider that, in order for safety to hold, you need to make some unrealistic assumptions about other factors remaining constant. Also, many of those so-called safer designs really do everything possible to eliminate other kinds of roadway users from the mix.
An automobile monoculture isn't very robust, and it also assumes the wrong units of analysis. Traffic engineers used to measure mobility in vehicle throughput. Amazingly, if you shift your units of analysis to people, monoculture looks less compelling. And that's even before you consider physical activity, environmental externalities, and a raft of other issues.
But this is going to be a hard sell for both drivers (who feel entitled to their high speed) and law enforcement (which treats ticketing as a revenue source; widespread deployment of such system would dry up the money stream almost immediately).
It wouldn't be a tough sell to lower speed limits on some portions, and raise it on others, even on a time-neutral but safety-positive basis, but yet, the powers that be stick to their arbitrary number.
I haven't seen any actual calculations used for setting speed limits, but I do remember being taught in school (on physics lessons) that if you want maximum road throughput then after factoring in safe distance (which is proportional to square of velocity) you end up with ~50km/h as a sweet spot. Even if some other factors (like fuel efficiency) alter this calculation, 100km/h feels quite plausible to me.
Also I believe that many consider speed limits as arbitrary because most people seem not to care about safe distances anyway.
Ultimately, how many deaths are acceptable for people to get to work 5 minutes earlier?
I don't know if people are less likely to speed on those roads; I think it is unlikely because growing up in a small town, people speed on backwoods roads all the time. Still, I'm not sure that this is the case.
What I do know is that roads like that are less safe, particularly if you DO speed.
So, unless you can show me that making a road less safe for speeding reduces the rate at which people drive, I'm going to keep thinking that that argument is like saying you can't give out condoms to kids because it makes them more likely to have sex.
In it, Dimauita et al credit every foot of lane width with a 2 mph increase in vehicle speeds, and Wang et al credit each additional lane with a 6.5 mph increase.
There is also the matter that many of the ways to make roads look less safe would in actual fact make the roads less safe. At a given speed, narrower lanes increase the probability of a collision. Parked cars on the side of a road increase the probability that one will be hit, or conceal from motorists the presence of pedestrians about to step into the street.
People focused on speed are asking the wrong question. The question is not "how do we get people to slow down" but rather "how do we make the roads safer"? Speed is only one variable.
if we really wanted to reduce motoring accidents, rather than regulating speed, we'd regulate away everything you can do in a car other than drive (radio, food, shaving, makeup, newspapers, etc.). i'd even suggest that driving fast might cause you to be less distracted because of the higher severity of a crash (would be an interesting research topic).
And because faster reaction times require you to stay more aware.
Unfortunately, trying to find where I heard about this just comes back with a bunch of stuff about risk tolerance w.r.t. financial investments.
The article weakly, and quietly made an argument that I do agree with. Namely, roadway design needs to accompany speed limits to ensure people actually drive the desired speeds. Wide lanes, big setbacks, homogenous environments encourage speeding regardless of what is posted. But let's be clear, we should have our design follow our policy, not our policy follow bad designs that were put in place by roadway engineers of yesteryear.
That message seemed to be lost in the race to tell us something tantalizingly counterintuitive. I love "everything we know is wrong" storytelling as much as the next guy, but only when that's actually backed up with solid evidence. Take for example this gem from the article:
> “We all speed, yet months and months usually pass between us seeing a crash,” Lt. Megge tells us when we call to discuss speed limits. “That tells me that most of us are adequate, safe, reasonable drivers. Speeding and traffic safety have a small correlation.”
That would seem to be at odds with this peer reviewed article (sorry, paywall, but you can read the abstract):
> Respectively, they found evidence for an exponential function and a power function between speed and crash rate. Both types of studies found evidence that crash rate increases faster with an increase in speed on minor roads than on major roads. At a more detailed level, lane width, junction density, and traffic flow were found to interact with the speed–crash rate relation.
Link to article: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0001457505...
Priceonomics's banner ad tells me it is selling a new book titled "Everything is Bullshit." Quite right.