News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by mrgriscom on Monday August 04, 2014 @05:44PM (#8134228)
I'm annoyed that the taboo thing to say in this discussion is whether increased traffic fatalities is always an inherently bad thing. When you're talking about societal-scale policy, it's impossible to make anything 100% safe; rather, it's about acceptable trade-off in risk. We could make a universal speed limit of 10mph and traffic deaths would probably vanish, but we don't because the impact on transport is too great. People like to brush off this argument with "should someone die just so you can get to work 5 minutes earlier", but if you start multiplying those 5 minutes by millions of people, there is an actual trade-off to consider.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by rtpg on Monday August 04, 2014 @10:58PM (#8135311)
The tradeoff for speeding is stupidly small.

Average US worker spends 25 minutes on a one-way trip to work. Lets assume an average speed of 60mph (hint: it's slower). If you went at 70 instead of 60, then you'll save a whole 3.5 minutes.

Here(http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:jWbI1mK...) is a link to a NHTSA presentation on speed limit changes and its effects on crashes. Notably, when states were given control of speed limits, we saw raises from 60-65 to 70-75 mph in some situations, and a 35% increase in fatalities.

if we do the whole "life is worth $3M dollars" argument, divide by two because I'm trying to make this favorable to you (even though car fatalities disproportionately affect young people), letting people go 70 instead of 60 could still end up causing almost 10k more deaths per year, so there's $15B in lost value per year. At least I'll get to sleep in for 3.5 more minutes.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by Scoundreller on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:37PM (#8135385)
You still haven't shown that the increased risk of danger outweighs the aggregate time savings. It's a big consideration when looking at things like, the value of screening for unlikely outcomes.

3.5 minutes/trip saved * 2 trips/day * 200 working days per year (probably more) = 1400 minutes saved per year per person.

working-age population of US (2012) = 243 million. Employment-to-population_ratio = 67%, so 162 million.

Let's say that half drive, or 80 million. So, 80m * 1400 minutes = 112 billion minutes a year saved by speeding or 1.9 billion hours. At a wage of $10 per hour, that's $19 billion, which is a bit ahead of the $15b loss of value per your number, but I'm sure our confidence intervals overlap.

112 billion minutes = 213000 person-years of being stuck inside a car saved by speeding. With a US average lifespan of 79, that's 2700 total additional lifespans spent in a car by losing those 3.5 minutes.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by jacalata on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:48AM (#8135943)
so, 2,700 additional lifespans of time saved in trade for 10,000 people killed, let's pretend each of them was halfway through their lifespan (40) so we lost 5,000 lifespans of time, or net loss of 2,300 lifespans. Sounds like it's not worth the time savings.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:11AM (#8135637)
>At least I'll get to sleep in for 3.5 more minutes.

Come on, that's not a fair argument. The effects are obviously much bigger than one guy saving 3.5 minutes.

To get closer to the meat: If your calculation always outputs numbers that make slower traffic look better, no matter what the starting speed is, then your methodology is wrong. Your method here would make 15mph look better than speeds 20mph or faster, despite a 15mph speed limit being a blatantly terrible idea.

(Also doesn't your assumption of an average speed of 60 bias your argument heavily against high speed limits? I would expect saving 4 minutes on a 30mph route to be much safer than saving 4 minutes off a 60mph route. Is my expectation wrong here?)

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by rtpg on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @02:13AM (#8135774)
actually my argument is based more around 60 mph average speed because that's more or less the average speed on highways and people spend a decent amount of time driving on highways and the like. Also, the increased fatality rates were concerning a rise from 60 to 70mph.

Obviously if we're going from 15 to 20 the numbers change. But at the same time if people were on average driving around at 15mph on average car accidents wouldn't be such a big issue, instead of the leading cause of death among teenagers.

actually with lower speed limits you would gain more time by going 10mph faster. For example, if people were driving at 10mph on average, going 20mph would half their transit time. The point is that the speeding people commit usually doesn't earn them much more time, but disproportionately endanger themselves and those around them at higher speeds.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by Dylan16807 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @03:42AM (#8135931)
>actually with lower speed limits you would gain more time

Right, not sure why you have 'actually' there because that was my point. When you picked 60 vs. 70 you were picking the speeds most likely to favor not going faster.

>the speeding people commit usually doesn't earn them much more time, but disproportionately endanger themselves and those around them

It's the 'disproportionately' that's at argument. A tiny-per-person cost for a noble purpose seems like an obvious choice, but when you repeat the action a billion times over it gets more complicated.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by rokhayakebe on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:35PM (#8135382)
This is the reason I do not speed. I figured I barely ever drive more than 10-15 miles one way, hence going from 60 to 80 miles per hour is only going to save me a very few minutes and increase my chance at 1) getting a ticket, and 2) wasting 30 minutes when a cop pulls me over.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by easytiger on Wednesday August 06, 2014 @09:13AM (#8142263)
My goodness, that is quite a load of nonsense.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by thrownaway2424 on Monday August 04, 2014 @10:53PM (#8135302)
I hate slippery-slope arguments, but I feel that if you are going to advocate the scenario you seem to have advocated, then you can take it a lot further. For example I feel that anyone whose car stalls while crossing the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge should be banned from driving for life. Because every time someone stalls on the bridge at rush hour there's a traffic jam clear back to Reno.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by throwaway5752 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @01:38AM (#8135702)
How much time would we all lose because of the small increased risk of increased traffic accidents and the road closures to clear them? It almost feels like an area of knowledge that I'm clueless about, but someone has spent a lot of time and effort studying.