News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by Spooky23 on Monday August 04, 2014 @05:35PM (#8134173)
End of the day, you shouldn't have laws that 80% of the population breaks during the ordinary course if business.

I've found myself in vehicles towing trailers where 65 mph was about as fast as I could go. I continuously had cars passing me. If everyone is a criminal, something is wrong with the law.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by rtpg on Monday August 04, 2014 @11:00PM (#8135317)
Well, there seems to be this myth that its OK to speed 5 miles above the posted speed limit, so the speed limit is still useful. It'll just be limiting the speed to 60 instead of 55.

As to whether things are enforced that way, that's a different story.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by Spooky23 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:13AM (#8135481)
There's a lot of truth to that. Many places use 7-10 mph over as a threshold. Smaller tickets always get plead down, and cops get measured by collars or tickets.

I don't think skirting the limits has much impact on behavior as the limits go up. In my personal observation, I've observed little if any difference between highway driving on the Deegan Expressway in NYC (50 mph), i95 in South Carolina (70/75) or the mass pike (65). Once you hit 70-80 mph, driving requires more attention.

On the other side, you have absurd local limits as well. The standard for streets in most towns in New York was 35 twenty years ago. Now it's 30, with zones as low as 15 or 20 mph near schools. It's a scheme to get bigger tickets and more drug arrests in "school zones". I wish they'd just get to the point and put up a toll barricade.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by saalweachter on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:03AM (#8136665)
Is the statistic NYC posts a lie? For a few years they've had signs up claiming that 80% of pedestrians hit at 30 mph survive, while 75% of pedestrians hit at 40 mph were killed.

That seemed like a pretty good reason to have lower speed limits in pedestrian areas to me.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:33AM (#8137436)
Seems like it would be a better reason to increase the physical separation between motorized and non-motorized traffic. I'd wager that more pedestrians would survive near 40 mph traffic if there were more energy-absorbing materials between them and the cars. The signs are probably just up to cut down on lawsuits directed toward the city.

The goal of improving roads is to increase the throughput of traffic. If it seems as though a problem could be solved by slowing down traffic, that's like solving a problem with a circuit by throwing a resistor into it. It may solve the immediate problem, but it will also reduce the overall efficiency of the circuit by converting energy into heat rather than usable work.

They could also put up signs that say 100% of the people who drive 40 mph reach their destinations 33% faster than those who drive 30 mph. It's just a distraction from the fact that solving the problem in a better way is more expensive than just blaming drivers and letting insurance handle the fallout.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by tomkarlo on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:04PM (#8139031)
It's entirely impractical to expect NY to build collision barriers at every spot where pedestrians get near cars within the city. Unless you want to have raised / underground pedestrian crossings everywhere (which have generally not been found to work very well, and are ugly as hell too), the reality is you're going to have traffic and pedestrians intermixed within the city.

"The goal of improving roads is to increase the throughput of traffic" - that is considered an outdated goal by most planners these days. For one thing, if you increase the capacity of roads, you simply encourage more driving, and things end up congested anyway. In many cases urban planners now actively seek to decrease the throughput of traffic on mixed-use streets in urban areas.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @06:10PM (#8139813)
It is far more impractical to employ live humans to enforce speed limits and jaywalking ordinances in the name of safety. We don't see the solutions that best improve safety because there are many other considerations in play.

As I mentioned before, the urban planners who are adding resistance to the system are not helping the overall efficiency. Intentionally decreasing the capacity of urban infrastructure is almost criminally stupid. It approaches the level of solving an overpopulation problem by conducting a decimation lottery every time the number of people approaches some upper limit.

Some planners are shutting down some roads to increase throughput, by encouraging greater use of more improved roads. Others are altering roads, or installing traffic circles, or adding stop signs and speed bumps, just to make vehicle traffic gratuitously more difficult. Those people are the assholes.

Congestion results from insufficient infrastructure to meet public demand. If your sidewalk is too narrow for the foot traffic, and people get jammed up and spill out onto the street, you cannot solve the problem by making it narrower and throwing caltrops onto it. And that doesn't work with cars on roads, either.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by maxerickson on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @11:37AM (#8137471)
You can quickly invent a distinction between a road and a street, where roads are indeed intended to maximize throughput but streets are intended to provide access.

So maybe those signs are on streets where throughput is not the primary goal, and where substantial barriers would interfere with people moving from their parked cars to the sidewalk and the like.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by logfromblammo on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:01PM (#8137604)
A line of parked cars between traffic and sidewalk is a substantial barrier on its own.

If you look at a high-traffic street where parking is prohibited, the Magnificent Mile in Chicago, you'll notice that there are gigantic concrete planters between the cars and the regular pedestrian traffic. Retail stores protect their entrances with concrete bollards. Construction zones protect workers from traffic with segmented Jersey barriers and water-filled crash barrels. Those are actual solutions.

But then you have suburban pearl-clutchers who lobby for a 15 mph speed limit and speed bumps in their cookie-cutter subdivisions, rather than actually making their streets safer for pedestrians. Or by replacing yield signs with stop signs. Those people don't realize that "change the law" is not always equivalent to "fix the problem".

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by Spooky23 on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @09:13PM (#8140452)
I'm sure that it is true based in physics, but is a statistic without meaningful context.
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by tomkarlo on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @04:00PM (#8138993)
While it might be socially acceptable, we'd all also agree that going 5 over the posted speed limit is "breaking the law", which is exactly the problem - it's encouraging a societal norm of "kind of" following the law, which is extremely problematic (especially when you consider that enforcement is often not applied evenly.)
Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by cpncrunch on Monday August 04, 2014 @07:31PM (#8134673)
They say 85% break the limit, but by how much? According to a 2003 UK study only 25% of people break the 30mph speed limit by more than 5mph, and only 20% break motorway speed limits by more than 10mph.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Road_speed_limit_enforcement_i...

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by PantaloonFlames on Monday August 04, 2014 @09:26PM (#8135070)
I think you have that backwards. The text in the article was:

> they want to set the speed limit so that 15% of drivers exceed it and 85% of drivers drive at or below the speed limit.

The citation you provided is roughly consistent with that.

The original article also said:

> Lt. Megge believes the compliance rate in Michigan to be well under 50%.

That's the only part that estimates rates of non-compliance. And it's not 85%.

Re:Is Every Speed Limit Too Low? by cpncrunch on Tuesday August 05, 2014 @12:25PM (#8137738)
Actually, the article says “I’ve found that about 10% of drivers truly identify the speed limit sign and drive at or near that limit,”. That is what we were discussing here, not the 85/15 percentile thing. (Sorry I should have said 90% rather than 85%).

Of course the article doesn't say what those other 90% are doing. I suspect they aren't all breaking the limit - probably some are going slower than the speed limit.