News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:35PM (#8034437)
We don't know what the security guard told the FBI.

I'd be willing to bet that if a security guard bothers to report a 72 year old with a high-quality camera for taking pictures of obvious artwork to the FBI that the guard exaggerated the encounter.

I've heard of several of these FBI followups in the past ~10 years but the person being interviewed always said nothing but positive things about how professional and calm the FBI agents were. They didn't send a 30 person SWAT team like the DEA would or multiple agents to your door with exposed guns threatening you. Yes, I've personally seen multiple instances of the DEA raiding homes while I was in college, good peoples lives were ruined because "someone smelled marijuana at a party".

It's the FBI's job to follow up on these types of instances. They were heavily criticized after 9/11 that they received tips but didn't properly follow up, now they follow up and everyone complains that they shouldn't bother anyone.

Does anyone think the FBI would simply leave a card asking for a phone call if they really believed that person was any real threat?

I'm just offering another possible perspective to the story that doesn't fit the mainstream "all law enforcement are bad" group-think going around. Think before jumping on the bandwagon guys.

The security guard who over-reacted is the issue here, not the FBI. Yes, the Patriot Act needs to be revisited or even thrown out and the NSA needs to go back to having very strict limitations on sharing with other agencies and allied nations, but that's a different conversation.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by uptown on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:48PM (#8034476)
"It's the FBI's job to follow up on these types of instances."

What kind of instances? Taking a photo? The author's exact point is that society should recalibrate itself such that anybody photographing a public piece of artwork shouldn't raise suspicions or trigger an FBI follow-up. It's the physical equivalent to the NSA's "collect-it-all" mentality. Targeted intelligence gathering is the appropriate approach in my opinion. And sometimes that means accepting that a 72 year old photographing a made-to-be-photographed statue isn't leading a sleeper cell.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:54PM (#8034500)
No, reports from a security guard is the kind of instance I am referring to. If the security guard had said "an older man wanted to take pictures of this art-work which happens to be a common natural-gas storage tank, he didn't appear to be a threat", then I can't imagine that the FBI would have wasted resources following up with more than a phone call.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by nemothekid on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:57PM (#8034507)
Thats a tough issue, what if he was a threat. What harm is in the FBI just following up? When a 6 year old calls 911 to chat with an officer, police still follow up to make sure that it was just a 6 year old and not a distress signal.

If the officers were polite what harm is there in them following up and making sure?

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by kelnos on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:06PM (#8034538)
Instances of this have chilling effects. I don't want FBI agents showing up at my door, ever. I might think twice about photographing something in public for fear that someone might report me. That's messed up.

You can play the "what if" game until the cows go home, and opinions will of course differ as to where the line of caution should be drawn, but IMO we're far far into the land of paranoia at this point.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by pyre on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:11PM (#8034551)
It's a start down the 'report your neighbors for subversive ideas, comrade' path. What disincentive is there for security guards to not just "report everything, just in case?" How many people will decide not to photograph said art-piece because they might get a visit from the FBI?

Is the answer to all this just some hand-wavy 'everything changed after 9/11?'

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by csandreasen on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:37PM (#8034640)
> What disincentive is there for security guards to not just "report everything, just in case?"

Perhaps too many false positives and you get canned for not being able to do your job competently, then subsequently replaced by someone who can adequately assess threats?

Reporting suspicious activity and subsequently investigating it isn't a waste of time - analogously, if it were a waste of time we wouldn't keep security logs on any of our computers. The issue is adequately assessing what is a credible threat and what isn't, which the FBI is likely in a better position to do than the average security guard. That's likely the reason he just dropped off his business card instead of bringing along the SWAT team - based on whatever was tipped to the agent, this guy was probably not an actual threat.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by pyre on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @01:32AM (#8034949)
Several problems here:

- If there is such a "too many false-positives, you get canned" policy, I feel like the threshold is probably set too high... just in case.

- "Better safe than sorry, just report it because the FBI is in a better position to determine X" isn't the bar that you want to use for reporting things.

- The bar for 'suspicious' could just be 'argued with me (security guard) about my ability to prevent him (photographer) from photographing private property from public property.' Or maybe 'he knew his rights' / 'argued about his rights' / 'mentioned the ACLU.' Or just plain old 'he was Muslim and photographing things, I better report him!' I think that these 'filters' are not doing an adequate job of assessing threats, but probably fall well below any thresholds that would get said security guard in trouble for too many false-positives.

- From the FBI side of things, you could equally have 'better safe than sorry' group-think that says no one should be punished for making reports, because we don't want someone to see something that could prevent the 'next 9/11' and then not report it for fear of getting in trouble for if being a false-positive.

> Reporting suspicious activity and subsequently investigating it isn't a waste of time

The problem here is that everyone has different ideas on what is suspicious, and they bring their own prejudices to the table. Law-and-order / authority figures tend to view people that question them (and don't just fall in line) as acting subversively, and therefore suspicious. Just arguing with a guard about their inability to prevent you from photographing private property that is in plain-view from public property (without trespassing) could be enough to make you 'suspicious' just because most people are non-confrontational, and unwilling to push back against what the security guard says. As the Japanese saying goes, "The nail that sticks up its head, gets hammered."

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by ScottBurson on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:57AM (#8034863)
> Perhaps too many false positives and you get canned for not being able to do your job competently, then subsequently replaced by someone who can adequately assess threats?

That would be a great policy. Too bad the reality is nothing like that -- probably the opposite.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by judk on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:28PM (#8034613)
The FBI is older than 2001. Greybeards remember using telnet to send mail 'From: [email protected]' , triggering a reply with some colorful language, prompting a visit from Secret Service.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by stef25 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @05:55AM (#8035551)
Taking a photo yes, of a liquid gas storage tank. The feds wouldn't have showed up if he was taking pictures of a traffic light.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by pbhjpbhj on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:25PM (#8034604)
>What kind of instances? Taking a photo? [...] that anybody photographing a public piece of artwork shouldn't raise suspicions or trigger an FBI follow-up. //

If he took a single photo he's nothing like any photog that I've ever met. Sure, they probably have tourists, art appreciators or whatever, taking photos sometimes. But, I'm guessing, they don't all get added to an FBI SAR list - so this person was clearly not "[just] [t]aking a photo". Indeed he was probably taking dozens of photos, from lots of angles.

There's too little detail of course in the story to know - that would move against the angle they're trying to sell.

This was targeted intelligence gathering, surely.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by baddox on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:11PM (#8034552)
> It's the FBI's job to follow up on these types of instances.

It's part of their job to sanely estimate the credibility of reports. If I can phone the FBI and say something that causes them to send an agent to track someone down (or worse, to sent a SWAT team), there's a serious problem with the way they are performing their job.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:20PM (#8034590)
When the FBI investigates someone from a tip that isn't very obviously a serious threat they do not treat the person being investigated like a criminal, that's half of what I wrote above.

Many times if they want an extended chat they will even take the person out for coffee, just to get a feel of the situation and ask questions.

http://www.banterant.com/2013/08/homes-for-hackers-gets-visi...

Yes, if an investigation is more serious then the FBI can be very intimidating, such as: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/04/whitehat-hacker-g...

I'm just saying that if the FBI did investigate me there is a reasonable chance they would act civil and objectively rather than abusing their power and using unnecessary force, and that's the way it should be.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @02:52AM (#8035136)
So, what do you expect would their reaction be if you refused their coffee? And would you even try to refuse?

You see, having to explain what you do and why you do it is already a limitation of your freedom, and has chilling effects on society as a whole. If there is no indication I have done anything illegal, it's none of their business, I don't have to explain how I live my life and why, to anybody.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by astrange on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @06:20PM (#8039465)
> http://www.banterant.com/2013/08/homes-for-hackers-gets-visi...

Disappointing lack of common sense from these commenters.

The prior probability that someone has bugged your house isn't affected by their claiming to be an FBI agent and taking you out for coffee. That's because, if you secretly bug someone's house, it's a secret. They would be doing it either way. (Or not doing it, because what are you supposed to find exactly?)

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by pyre on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:05PM (#8034533)
> It's the FBI's job to follow up on these types of instances.

What types of instances are these? "I saw someone photographing a monument" instances? Don't you think that our resources would be spread pretty thin if we were investigating all such instances?

> They were heavily criticized after 9/11 that they received tips but didn't properly follow up

They were criticized for not following up on "photography of landmarks is suspicious" tips?

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by jonah on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:32PM (#8034625)
They had his name and address. I suspect they also found that he was a published photographer of the subject matter in question. Did no one think "oh, I see, he was just doing his work." and left it at that? No need to contact him.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:51PM (#8034683)
I would argue that we are not qualified to make that assumption but the FBI agents in question are.

There could have easily been a small fact or incident in the past with the author of the article that raised a red-flag for the agents. There could be a policy that says ALL tips must be followed up on and contacted.

I'm all for exposing and preventing abuses of power by law enforcement, but I see no evidence of that happening in this situation.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by jonah on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:46AM (#8034825)
I would agree that we don't know the details in this particular case. OTOH, I think we hear about similar cases often enough to safely assume that at least a fair number of them wouldn't need to be taken as far if a little bit of common sense was utilized. (But maybe it's just that we don't hear about the ones where it was.)
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @01:17AM (#8034921)
There are crazy and evil people in the world who are determined to harm society and other innocent people, and part of the FBI's job is to help prevent this. The acceptable cost is debatable.

If the FBI investigates 500,000 people and prevents a single instance similar to the photo below, is it worth it?

http://11even.net/wp-content/uploads/World-Trade-Center-2002...

There have been plenty of attacks stopped http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorism_in_the_United_States

There is always the possibility of something even worse happening. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_terrorism

A notable incident from 2013: http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/fbi-foils-plot-build-strange-...

I'm sorry if this sounds like fear-mongering, these things do happen though.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by jonah on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @02:19AM (#8035060)
Yeah. Crazy/evil people. Gotta keep an eye on 'em.

What I'm talking about is an 80 year old guy who is well documented for professionally photographing public art.

When they saw someone taking pictures of that piece there could be a couple reasons: A) he's scoping it out to come back later and lob an RPG at it, B) he's working on the second edition of his book you can buy on Amazon.

They don't need to talk to the guy to find out which one it is. That's what I'm saying.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by 59nadir on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @02:41AM (#8040854)
I think everyone wants to imagine some reason for this man being contacted, but I would put forward a different view:

The FBI just aren't bright enough to do a cursory Google search, because they 'have all the info anyways'.

It's simpler than "Oh, but maybe they saw he was part of some obscure group in the 60s...". They probably just aren't very good at what they do, but with almost unlimited power it's hard for other people to see how shit you are at your job, as an organization and as a person.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by GhotiFish on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @11:58AM (#8037190)
No, we can't speculate on that without information from the security guard. What did they report?
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by megablast on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:50PM (#8034487)
So, after how many times of being fooled by "minimum wage security guard"s do the FBI start taking this into consideration in their investigations?
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by tnorthcutt on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:46PM (#8034471)
From the guidelines[0]: Please don't bait other users by inviting them to downmod you.

0: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:51PM (#8034491)
Reworded that sentence, thanks, I didn't know that was a possible issue, was a little ticked off after typing a long thoughtful response only to see it instantly down-voted before anyone could have possibly had a chance to read it.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by c_c_c on Monday July 14, 2014 @10:58PM (#8034512)
What's the flip side to running down every lead though? Information overload that may (will?) miss more significant threats. Do they not have some sort of triage for this ?
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by dm2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:02PM (#8034522)
I'm sure the FBI understands the concept of prioritizing leads when/if they get overloaded. There are generally field offices in most major cities so I doubt they had to travel across the country or anything.
Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by jonnybgood on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:04PM (#8034530)
> Information overload that may (will?) miss more significant threats.

Well, that's kinda the point of these follow-ups. How would the FBI know if something is or isn't a significant threat?

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by kelnos on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:12PM (#8034554)
Common sense? An 80+ year old man standing on public property taking a photograph of a famous piece of artwork isn't remotely a terrorist threat. Presumably the FBI could have even figured out that he's been a professional photographer for most of his life, and done a little research on their that would make it entirely obvious that there was nothing fishy going on there.

And double shame on the security guards for even reporting him in the first place.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by jonnybgood on Monday July 14, 2014 @11:25PM (#8034602)
> Common sense? An 80+ year old man standing on public property taking a photograph of a famous piece of artwork isn't remotely a terrorist threat. Presumably the FBI could have even figured out that he's been a professional photographer for most of his life, and done a little research on their that would make it entirely obvious that there was nothing fishy going on there.

Everything you just said here is the point of a follow-up.

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by rurounijones on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:39AM (#8034801)
All of the above can be determined with 5 minutes of google.

No need for the chilling-effect visit to neighbourhood + knocking on neighbours doors

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by jonnybgood on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:50AM (#8034842)
> All of the above can be determined with 5 minutes of google.

Yes, because everything on Google is factually accurate.

Edit: Why am I getting downvoted for pointing out the obvious flaw in using Google?

Re:An FBI Counterterrorism Agent Tracked Me Down Because I T... by ScottBurson on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @01:06AM (#8034887)
Did you read the article? He's published books of photography. His work has been on display at the Smithsonian. Google and Wikipedia (yes, he has a page) might not give final confirmation of these facts, but it would bring them up, and the agents could verify them through other channels.