There's no other way to put it.
(Besides the sexist application of a misguided law)
"Police also arrested the teen and took him to juvenile jail, where Foster said they took photos of the teen’s genitals against his will."
The want ANOTHER picture.
Note the quote from the Commonwealth Attorney: Prince William County Commonwealth’s Attorney Paul B. Ebert said that police told him “these allegations [by the lawyers] lack credibility.” They're saying that it's not credible that the threat actually occurred, which likely means that even if it did, they realize how stupid it would be to actually follow through with it at this point.
Don't get me wrong, I'm against the idea of them prosecuting the kid for sending dick pictures, but I'd like to see that fail on its own (lack of) merit.
While these allegations sound bizarre, the existence of the photo and affidavit's contents are questions of fact, and if they do exist those materials are in the possession of the court. I can't think of a court that would entertain motions concerning documents whose existence the court knew to be a fiction. Even making unfounded claims of this sort in public seems like it could result in sanctions.
It's at least as plausible that the government attorneys and/or the police are being dishonest. Prosecutors have already fouled the case up once resulting is a dismissal (for failure to certify the defendant as a juvenile). Since people on the government side have a great deal to lose if the allegations turn out to be true, they certainly have an interest in denying the allegations.
And then of course there was this woman, who had something similar happen.[2] And you know that they are not the only ones - they are just the ones who made a stink about it and got national news coverage.
More generally, prosecutors love leverage, the more the better (which is a big reason why they don't want to legalize pot). They leveraged Aaron Swartz, too.
I trust the Washington Post - and I further trust that if the WaPo made a mistake, the Manassas PD and DA would be making a big stink about it.
Who I don't trust are juries who, like you, still have an irrational belief in the government and the police - that they are infallible, impartial, and concerned only with serving justice and keeping us safe. The truth is that they are vicious, prejudiced bullies who have a tremendous amount of unchecked power and almost no accountability, operating within a complicated system that they have mastered against suspects who are often cowed in to pleading guilty just to avoid inordinate punishment for things they never did. It's a shit show.
[1] http://www.cnn.com/2013/11/06/justice/new-mexico-search-laws... [2] http://www.elpasotimes.com/latestnews/ci_26100843/aclu-woman...
Newspapers can and do report surprising legal claims that originate with an attorney because such claims are essentially backed by the attorney's professional reputation, and could result in sanctions or even disbarment if they were made without foundation.
Edit to add: Who I don't trust are juries [...]
I'm with you on that. If unjustly accused I would far rather have the decision made by someone trained to weigh evidence and who will have to state the basis of his/her findings of fact for the record, where they can be challenged at appeal if they are not well founded.
Given the evidence of past police misconduct in the narrow area of forced medical procedures as a form of extra-legal coercement, the benefit of the doubt here has to go to the defendant.
If they had verified the claims, why wouldn't they say so? It would certainly make the article more effective. I don't have any particular belief in the government and police, but I do pay close attention to what articles are implying versus what they are claiming, because for an honest news source, it tends to highlight the differences between what they have verified and what they haven't.
Edit: to be completely clear, the article does not say the prosecutor made these threats. The article says that the defense attorney says the prosecutor made these threats.
>> Man, I've heard of some verticals in my day, but I'm hoping that's an outrageously small market.
Well played.
The "root" of all this evil is the fact that politicians have little incentive and much disincentive to run on a platform (or mention an issue) where they would actually even come close to touching a subject like this with a ten foot pool.
I mean if there ever was a third rail it is this entire subject.
"The police are supposed to protect your children from predators. The Attorney General's office is supposed to prosecute those who would do your children harm. But as the events in Manassas City demonstrate, they are wolves in sheep's clothing. mikestew promises to protect your children, not prey on them. Elect mikestew and he'll make sure the people you're supposed to trust aren't taking nekkid pictures of your kids."
Okay, that last sentence might need a little rewording, possibly explaining why I've never been elected to office. But I can't imagine that a decent campaign manager couldn't pull this off in a tasteful manner while still getting the point across.
But, man, if I lived in that area I would be running for election come the next round, and I'd beat this story into the ground for the entire campaign. Not that I'd want the job. I've run for office, and thankfully lost thus far. But this is one of those times that it's better to have someone who doesn't know what they're doing (and believe me, there are few less qualified for the job of AG of VA than I) than to let these nutcases continue to run the asylum.
In this hypothetical case, were I to lose and the incumbents stayed in, this would be the sign for any VA resident to get the hell out as your neighbors obviously think this is okay.
As an aside, "special <penis matching> software". Man, I've heard of some verticals in my day, but I'm hoping that's an outrageously small market. (Of course, the guy they quoted is just bullshitting.)