Re:In ‘sexting’ case, police want to photograph teen in sexu...
by anigbrowl on Wednesday July 09, 2014 @03:03PM
(#8011583)
That's true, but bear in mind that the defense lawyer is asserting that a) police have already taken a photo of the defendant's genitalia; and b) the affidavit for the search warrant they have filed with the court describes the idea of taking the teen to the hospital to induce and photograph an erection. (EDIT: I'm inferring the latter slightly, but justifiably I believe. If they expect to find other sexually-themed pictures the search warrant could be for his computer, digital camera etc., and chances are it includes those search targets. But if, per the story, the warrant can't be served without the defendant being around, I think it's a reasonable inference that the defendant's person is itself an object of their search.)
While these allegations sound bizarre, the existence of the photo and affidavit's contents are questions of fact, and if they do exist those materials are in the possession of the court. I can't think of a court that would entertain motions concerning documents whose existence the court knew to be a fiction. Even making unfounded claims of this sort in public seems like it could result in sanctions.
It's at least as plausible that the government attorneys and/or the police are being dishonest. Prosecutors have already fouled the case up once resulting is a dismissal (for failure to certify the defendant as a juvenile). Since people on the government side have a great deal to lose if the allegations turn out to be true, they certainly have an interest in denying the allegations.
While these allegations sound bizarre, the existence of the photo and affidavit's contents are questions of fact, and if they do exist those materials are in the possession of the court. I can't think of a court that would entertain motions concerning documents whose existence the court knew to be a fiction. Even making unfounded claims of this sort in public seems like it could result in sanctions.
It's at least as plausible that the government attorneys and/or the police are being dishonest. Prosecutors have already fouled the case up once resulting is a dismissal (for failure to certify the defendant as a juvenile). Since people on the government side have a great deal to lose if the allegations turn out to be true, they certainly have an interest in denying the allegations.