News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by gwillen on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:09PM (#8000315)
Your claim that your product will not be discontinued is worthless.

If you're so sure of that, put your money where your mouth is, and offer an SLA with a contractual minimum duration you promise to keep the service up, and significant monetary penalties if you fail to meet it.

Doesn't sound like a good idea? Then shut up.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by grinich on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:22PM (#8000420)
(Michael from Inbox here.)

Ouch. We're just a few hackers trying to fix broken developer tools.

Any claim is just a claim, for sure. We know that it's a long road to earn trust of other developers. One of the (many) reasons we made the sync engine open source was so that developers could run it on their own metal without trusting us. Transparency is really important to us.

This is just the beta announcement of our API. I'd love to hear any comments you have on what guaranteed level of support+performance you would need for a hosted product. We're working on a hosted version now (so you don't have to run it yourself), and developer happiness is the #1 priority.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by GuiA on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:54PM (#8000598)
> Ouch. We're just a few hackers trying to fix broken developer tools.

And we (gwillen and anyone who agrees with his comment, myself included) are just a few hackers who are tired of having the rug pulled under their feet when $CORP inevitably comes with the big bucks and all claims made by the founders in the early days of the company mysteriously disappear from the homepage.

Talk is cheap.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by grinich on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:07PM (#8000680)
I like to think that shipping code is the best argument.

https://github.com/inboxapp/inbox

But yeah, I totally understand the lousy feeling of being burned when $STARTUP gets acquired or shut down.

Wish I could say more to quell your concerns. We're just going to keep working on this every day to earn respect from developers. We don't take it lightly.

/edit

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by amirmc on Monday July 07, 2014 @04:16PM (#8001119)
Easiest way to earn the kind of respect you're after is to only make claims you can visibly and tangibly support. You cannot realistically claim you will 'never' get bought out, so don't say it.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by Kadrith on Monday July 07, 2014 @07:31PM (#8002213)
If the code is released with an Open Source license, haven't they already met the claim? Sure the company could be bought out, but the code can't be.

Even if they were bought out the code would still be available and someone else could provide the service and continue development. Releasing the code seems like the best guarantee possible.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pdonis on Monday July 07, 2014 @04:20PM (#8001144)
> We're just a few hackers trying to fix broken developer tools.

This may be part of your problem. The way I see it, IMAP and POP suckage is not a developer problem; it's a user problem. As in, users don't care that IMAP and POP suck; they only care that their email works. Most people's email works.

In other words, you can make developers as happy as clams and it won't matter, because "making developers happy" is not a sustainable business model. (Particularly if the way you are going to make them happy is to open source your toolkit and give it away for free. Not that that isn't a great thing to do: it's just not a sustainable business model.) I think a lot of the skepticism in this thread is because on some level everyone realizes this, even thought it's kind of an unpleasant truth for developers.

A sustainable business model would be: you're going to (a) convince users that, even if their email works now, it will work so much better with your new platform that they'll be amazed; and then (b) get the users to pay for that awesome service. I have seen nothing that indicates you have such a business model. Without it, I have to agree with the skeptics that, from a VC's perspective, you are far more likely to exit as an acquisition than as an IPO. Which means the VCs aren't really investing in your business, they're investing in your talent; that's what they're betting that some large company will be willing to pay for down the road, once you've demonstrated the ability to build something. But once you're acquired, you might end up building something completely different from "a better email".

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by nawitus on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:46PM (#8000559)
But if you believe in the claim, why not sign a contract that brings some validity to the claim?
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by cookiecaper on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:44PM (#8000921)
Agreed. Those kind of binding agreements are the only way you can guarantee that something won't change immediately upon acquisition, and an interested party may still buy your company if you have such agreements. They may just have to wait a while to shut you down if that is indeed their plan. However, I don't really know if that's a better alternative than just shutting down upon acquisition, lest a false sense of security be provided to the users.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by bduerst on Monday July 07, 2014 @07:24PM (#8002186)
That makes sense - even if Inbox goes back on their word, there can be grandfathered-in users who have a contractual obligation from Inbox and whoever acquires/resells it.

Makes the existing user base much less valuable to possible buyers though :)

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by girvo on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @05:43AM (#8003685)
They've release the code. That's contract enough for me.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by gwillen on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:42AM (#8029740)
I don't know if you'll see this comment; as far as I'm aware there's no way to passively monitor HN for replies.

But if you do see it, please check my reply to dang's comment for a thought on why I'm so angry about this.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by Splendor on Monday July 07, 2014 @04:43PM (#8001280)
When an attack on another company's offering becomes your selling point you're bound to reap some negativity in return.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by hsod on Monday July 07, 2014 @06:58PM (#8002093)
Indeed. It's pretty silly to attack another company and then go all "aw, shucks guys" when someone questions your attack. You made this an issue by making an extraordinary claim, you should stand behind your marketing.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pc on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:25PM (#8000439)
> Doesn't sound like a good idea? Then shut up.

Your comment is needlessly mean-spirited. The top-voted comment on the recent Show HN thread would seem to apply here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7984826

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by cookiecaper on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:42PM (#8000910)
I don't think it has to be read as especially malicious. He's trying to make a point with pointed language, but it doesn't necessarily imply ill-will.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by dang on Monday July 07, 2014 @05:35PM (#8001593)
Such nuances are lost in an anonymous internet forum. It doesn't have to be read that way (what does?) but that doesn't matter—look at the effect it has had.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by throwaway7714 on Monday July 07, 2014 @07:00PM (#8002096)
Moderation systems fail when they don't accept that toxicity is a human norm, pretending instead that human toxicity is an enemy to be defeated.

Why is it so wrong to criticize a bad idea? To do so bluntly?

The "effect that it had" was an honest conversation. Ultimately I find HN's policies an embarrassment and a symptom of dishonesty. Way I see it, you were brought on to make moderation more transparent, and you're doing well, but you weren't actually given powers to attack HN's main problem, which I'd define as a discomfort with disagreement.

And maybe that's a human problem. But we live in a very negative time. Outright hatred is a part of life, and tools of hatred (downvoting, shadowbanning) are hypocritically applied to shut hatred down.

But it doesn't shut it down, and it shouldn't. To say "You shouldn't feel this way" is fair game when applied as an argument between people. What you say when you banish shit is "You shouldn't exist," and that's an unsustainable mindset.

You can see the logs. You can probably see that I'm a serial offender when it comes to pissing people off here. I've got yet another account on your bad list because you think you can control discomfort.

But you don't have a modicum of transparency or honesty in your line of work, dang: there's nothing you can point to that explains why my downvoted comments are both at -4 as some minimum, but the css makes them different shades of grey.

That's really trivial shit to care about, but that's my point: you're not taking care of trivial explanation of policy. You're an improvement, but that doesn't mean you're done.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pessimizer on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:52PM (#8000587)
>Instead of "you're doing it wrong", suggest alternatives.
[deleted]
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by jacalata on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:30PM (#8000825)
He obviously doesn't think it's normal. He thinks they are making abnormal claims ("we will remain available") and therefore should be prepared to make guarantees beyond normal in order for anyone to take them seriously. Sounds reasonable to me, if you think it is unreasonable, can you explain why?
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by cracell on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:39PM (#8000522)
I'd love to see companies whose charters legally make them impossible to acquire. No idea how this would work in practice or if you could actually make it enforceable under US law.

But I'm so sick of startups just being R&D for corporations and screwing over their userbase once they get acquired. Or even worse is companies that only get off of the ground because of user support via kickstarter or similar fund raising platforms and then get acquired.

Of course it would be much harder for those companies to raise funds but there's always bootstrapping. It'd be a big win for the consumers of the product and if marketed correctly (something like "Non-Acquirable LLC"), it could become a good way for a startup to show that they put their users first.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by bengali3 on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:24PM (#8000777)
I'm guessing a limit on possible exits would be a red flag for investors who are looking for a return.

Having clauses with each investor that let you purchase back your shares from them at predetermined times and rates (returns would need to be healthy for them) limits their upside, but lets you buy back control whenever. - assuming you can afford it

for public companies in the US, also see "Poison pill":

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shareholder_rights_plan

http://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2014/06/30/dealpolitik-poison...

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pjc50 on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:58PM (#8000621)
Mutuals.

I was involved in setting one up at university (http://www.srcf.ucam.org/) and it's still running long past the time I had anything to do with it. I believe it's a good model for "community" internet services, by definition run in the interests of the users.

It's not impossible for one to sell out, but it requires the members (customers) to vote for it. In the case of the UK building societies, by bribing them with the capital reserves that were turned out to be essential to keeping the mortgage system running.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by _puk on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:49PM (#8000955)
And the building societies that didn't sell out have since become the safe harbours in times of uncertainty i.e. Nationwide.

You'd hope there'd be a lesson in there somewhere - short term gain versus long term stability.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by dublinben on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:11PM (#8000715)
A worker-owned cooperative would be seemingly impossible to "acquire" since it is wholly owned, and operated, by those working in the organization. If the corporate charter does not allow outside shareholders, that would prevent the most common forms of acquisition.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by MichaelApproved on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:32PM (#8000489)
> with a contractual minimum duration you promise to keep the service up, and significant monetary penalties if you fail to meet it.

Take it down a few notches, you're solution will likely not work.

This is the company's only product. If the product gets discontinued, the company is likely broke. The "significant monetary penalties" is unenforceable because the company will not have any money to fulfill the SLA penalty.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by smacktoward on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:43PM (#8000539)
>If the product gets discontinued, the company is likely broke

Or has just been acquired, which I think is more what the parent was getting at.

>The "significant monetary penalties" is unenforceable because the company will not have any money to fulfill the SLA penalty.

The acquirer would, though!

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by andrewfong on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:42PM (#8000538)
It's a good hedge against an acquisition though. Presumably you could structure the SLA such that any acquirer would be on the hook.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by kenster07 on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:17PM (#8000379)
I find the angry tone of this message to be misplaced and unnecessary.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by thejosh on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:19PM (#8000397)
Not really. If someone claims that their service will not be discontinued, unless they can offer some sort of agreement then it's worthless.

Not like they can't shutdown their company irrespective of any promises.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pfraze on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:07PM (#8000677)
How about building it to be self-hosted and releasing under the AGPL license?
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by extesy on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:21PM (#8000406)
I also disagree with the tone but I understand the reason. They will gladly shut the service down once someone offers them enough money in aqui-hire.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by grinich on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:28PM (#8000453)

    They will gladly shut the service down once someone offers them enough money in aqui-hire.
It's a bummer this is the status quo with startups. To me, it's the most disappointing thing about the tech world. I actually interviewed at other companies first, and only cofounded Inbox when I couldn't find anywhere else to solve this problem.

Probably the only convincing thing I can say is that if you wanted to build a company to flip quickly, an email infrastructure startup is certainly the most painful, masochistic way you could go about it. We spent the better part of last year reading RFCs and fixing tons of obscure bugs to get this far.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by nawitus on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:47PM (#8000565)
But if you don't plan to be acquired, why not sign a contract in that effect?
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by wldcordeiro on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:20PM (#8000401)
Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory in action. http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/19
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by Dylan16807 on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:36PM (#8000510)
Disagree. It's harsh to make a point that there is no evidence they're telling the truth, not to be edgy or get attention. It would be better without the 'shut up' but a bit of an 'angry' tone is fitting.

Really, I'm more uncomfortable with a link to a webcomic joke as an argument point...

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by wldcordeiro on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:05PM (#8000670)
I'm just citing where I got the 'theory.' The OP of the comment could have made their point just fine without being confrontational or 'angry' as you put it. I don't see why people are defending someone's rudeness, you can get your point across without being a jerk about it.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by Dylan16807 on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:15PM (#8000734)
It's more subtle than that.

The 'shut up' detracts from the comment. Being a jerk is bad.

But being confrontational is in this case a benefit. The first line is "Your claim that your product will not be discontinued is worthless." This is confrontational in a good way, and this line is not being a jerk. It's pointing out a serious flaw without attacking anyone.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by wldcordeiro on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:37PM (#8000874)
It could be phrased differently still without insinuating that what they say is worthless.

Something like, "How will you back up your claim of the product not being discontinued?" or "What will prevent your product from being discontinued?" Gets the same point across without coming off rude (it may just be me but saying "your claim ... is worthless" seems rude.) The OP of the comment definitely has a good point but it's said in a way that isn't constructive.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by hueving on Monday July 07, 2014 @05:08PM (#8001429)
But that's precisely what he/she needed to insinuate. That claim is worthless to the users it's targeted towards.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by girvo on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @05:56AM (#8003712)
Well, they release their code as AGPL ready to be self hosted. If that's not a guarantee about it not going away, I don't know what ever could be.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pessimizer on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:55PM (#8000606)
It's not even an argument point, but just being used as a way to call someone a name without owning it.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by wldcordeiro on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:06PM (#8000676)
No it isn't. If I want to call the poster a fuckwad, I'll call him one. The only reason I linked the comic is because it may not be common knowledge to everyone where the 'theory' is from.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by pessimizer on Monday July 07, 2014 @05:48PM (#8001693)
Then you're just poisoning the well with a bit of ad hominem (in a pretty stupid way), saying that someone else's opinion is wrong because they're anonymous when you're anonymous yourself.

Whatever it is, it's worthless.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by Throwaway618 on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:39PM (#8000892)
You disingenuous bastard: "Greater Internet Fuckwad Theory in action"

You seriously don't think you called him a fuckwad?

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by wldcordeiro on Monday July 07, 2014 @03:50PM (#8000965)
That's the name of the 'theory' while it does imply that they're a 'fuckwad' (whatever that may be) it's not my chosen word to call them, I'm just citing it. But go ahead and defend the unnecessary rudeness and hide behind your throwaway account. I'll make it clear: The OP of the comment is being an asshole/fuckwad/douchebag/<insert word conveying sentiment here> by being needlessly rude due to the anonymity provided by having an online pseudonym.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by throwaway7714 on Monday July 07, 2014 @07:03PM (#8002114)
Well, you've managed some consistency, then.

You are just as rude as the activity you're calling out. That's all I'm trying to say.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by dang on Monday July 07, 2014 @05:55PM (#8001741)
> Doesn't sound like a good idea? Then shut up.

Please don't be aggressive like this on Hacker News. It violates the guidelines and degrades the discourse.

That sentence has no information in it—it's just rude—so the comment would be better without it.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by gwillen on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:41AM (#8029735)
I apologize for the unnecessarily confrontational tone of my comment.

(Because of HN's lack of comment notification system, I had no idea it was so controversial until I happened upon it again just now.)

Its significantly positive score does suggest to me, though, that there is a lot of sympathy for my position, and the angry way I stated it. In fact, it's one of my most upvoted comments. (And assuming it's received a significant number of downvotes for being unnecessarily rude, I suspect it's my most-upvoted comment of all time, in gross numbers.)

The claim that I'm complaining about is basically outright fraud, as far as I'm concerned -- they're advertising their startup as being different from other services, on the basis of having a quality they have absolutely no ability to promise (that of being guaranteed not to terminate service out from under the users without warning.) The only mitigating factor is that they are almost certainly misleading themselves as much as their users. Whether this is noble, I leave as an exercise for the reader.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by dang on Monday July 14, 2014 @04:14AM (#8029992)
Thanks. I understand your point and was not disputing it—only the tone, which violated the HN guidelines. Upvotes are not a reliable index to this. A lot of uncivil comments get heavily upvoted, unfortunately.

In some contexts, rough-and-tumble language is just fine and makes things more vigorous. Empirically, HN isn't one of those. Its system is too fragile. So if we want any high-quality discourse, we have to protect it. It's not an ethical injunction so much as a practical tradeoff.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by npizzolato on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @12:46AM (#8003037)
Sorry, but I have to disagree. The sentence only has no information in it I'd you choose to blindly look at the words in a vacuum. But if you think about what he said, what he meant, the tone has a ton of information, the most obvious is a drop frustration of the empty promises and frequent shut downs that is all too common in recent startups.

I think the comment created worthwhile conversation. And I'm not sure it would be better off without it. Obviously you can disagree, and given your position perhaps my opinion doesn't really matter, but to say it has no information is just being dishonest, and I say that in the nicest way possible.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by dang on Tuesday July 08, 2014 @02:22AM (#8003243)
> I think the comment created worthwhile conversation.

I see two conversations here. One is about users feeling betrayed by acquisitions and whether that could be mitigated contractually. That conversation didn't require abusiveness to be created. The other conversation is about who is being a fuckwad, and hardly counts as "worthwhile". Unfortunately, it is what such rudeness leads to, and it only gets worse.

Keep in mind that we're not talking about rudeness in general. We're talking about its effect on the already precarious balance of a particular optionally-anonymous internet forum. The argument here isn't ethical so much as empirical.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by mgkimsal on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:21PM (#8000405)
" and will not be ‘discontinued’ unexpectedly."

'unexpectedly' is the key. Giving people 3-6 months of runway to say "we're shutting down on day X" is still living up to that statement.

Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by aroman on Monday July 07, 2014 @02:25PM (#8000438)
That's not much of a feature, it's more like a common courtesy. Call me entitled, but I would expect that to be the case even without them explicitly saying so.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by izolate on Monday July 07, 2014 @05:52PM (#8001717)
If it's any consolation, if I were to post something to HN, I'd appreciate this kind of brutal honesty above everything else. But I suspect I'm in the minority.
Re:MIT And Dropbox Alums Launch Inbox, a Next-Generation Ema... by mkal_tsr on Monday July 07, 2014 @06:32PM (#8001983)
Yup. And let's not forget, that's usually for Show HN, whereas this is a full-on company release/announcement ... not the typical "check out what I made over the week/weekend" where there are bound to be more flaws by virtue of short development time.