News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by Nursie on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:19AM (#7903570)
The political silence on this issue is indeed deafening. As was the press silence (other than the Guardian). The press in this country are far more interested in reality tv, political infighting, fanning flames about 'immigrants' and what the royals are up to.

And I suspect it's because most of the public don't care either. There are people who would like privacy, who think that GCHQ should be accountable and then there are other people who are perfectly happy that someone is watching everything, everywhere, because that makes them feel safe, and of course they aren't doing anything wrong, so why should they care?

And of course a large proportion of the population either aren't intelligent enough or aren't interested enough to understand what's going on.

It makes me angry, but that's the world we live in.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by netcan on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:01AM (#7904115)
There are issues that people care about in theory, in books & political science courses and such and there are issues that people care about in practice.

In their political sphere, people care about their wealth (economy), their identity (nationalism, religion) & drama (political scandals). These are pretty constant. They are the bread and butter of politics and have ben since ancient time. When wealth decreases, identity is challenged or political drama whips the mob into a frenzy political instability ensues. So long as those are kept in check, political stability is hard to challenge.

If you look at most big stability events (eg the recent riots and protests in Greece), they relate to these. Wealth & political drama. The US banking crisis related to wealth (recession), drama (evolving doors) and identity (corporate welfarism).

Abstract ideas like freedom (of X), democracy, equality, privacy, justice, do not have political weight in their own right. To make them count politically they need to become one of the things that matter, bundled into the national mythology, people's identity.

The US for all their faults, have a genuinely principled foundational mythology/ideology. They can graft principles like privacy onto those making "privacy" into an identity issue. Government spying is offensive to Americans in the same way (though sadly not to the same degree) as a perceived islamization of the UK to the British. Most major political "principle" issues are really identity issues. That's why nationalism and religion are impossible to exorcise from politics.

Americans seem better positioned to put up a fight against this spying stuff than the rest of us because they already have government-skepticism built into their national identity. Europeans can build onto our 'enlightened" edentate though this is less wieldy. But ultimately I have a hard time believing that any of us will avoid being completely surveilled by several governments. There is too much momentum in that direction.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by Silhouette on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:31AM (#7904276)
I hate this post, but mostly because I'm afraid of how accurate it is.

It is disturbing how quickly we forget the lessons of history -- even history still within living memory that shaped the entire future of Europe -- and instead allow an "it would never happen to me" mentality to take over.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by ivanca on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:55AM (#7904400)
Everyone should care about this; but as you said most people don't see the issue in practical terms. I think is our jobs as tech-savy people to put it in more practical terms for them, someway the average Joe can relate to, for example:

- NSA and GCHQ are probably watching your kids naked, a lot, because exploits from webcams are very common, and they cannot know before hand if someone is using Skype to plan tewowist attacks or a video for their teenage boyfriend.

- They are watching everything related to any company, so if an NSA employee happens to have stock in a rival company, well, that's insider trading sponsored by the state.

- Blackmailing is a piece of cake, because completely normal and legal activities such as watching porn are enough to defame you.

- They want security exploits to exist (and they pay for those), because that's how the intercept your communications, the problem is, those are the same exploits tewowist and black hat hackers use against you.

You get the idea.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by netcan on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:25AM (#7904582)
To the extent that I'm right, I don't think this is enough. You can respond to criticisms about blackmail exploits or watching your kids with layers of laws, bureaucracy and compromises. You can deny it or call it isolated incidences.

To fight something like this, we need something that makes people draw a line. An uncrossable one. The main item a politician can identify with.

Otherwise, this is a negotiation. One we'll lose.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grkvlt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @02:49PM (#7906215)
> Blackmailing is a piece of cake, because completely normal and legal activities such as watching porn are enough to defame you.

How can you blackmail someone with their normal and legal activities? Either watching porn is abnormal, and a source of blackmail opportunities, or it's normal and it's not, surely?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by DanBC on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @02:57PM (#7906260)
The UK is probably more relaxed about this than the US but I can imagine situations where people watching legal[1] porn could come under sever pressure at work because of it. Scout masters watching gay porn; headmasters watching legal but "teen" porn; teachers watching BDSM; etc - these are all people doing something legal that has no impact on their job but who would face severe pressure at work, and may well lose their job inder a variety of "disrepute" clauses.

[1] the legal situation in the UK for porn is not straightforward.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by harshreality on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:51AM (#7904377)
Is there one (or a few) book(s)/article(s) that shaped your view on this (most of all the wealth, identity, drama triad)? I'd be interested in reading them.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by digitalengineer on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:10AM (#7904482)
"The Century of the Self" (BBC documentary by Adam Curtis) is a good start. It discusses the Self(image), nationalism, (mass)psychology and much, much more. http://vimeo.com/87419450
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by samstave on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:20AM (#7904914)
Then make sure you watch "Human Resources" to see how manipulated and unknowingly controlled most of Human society is.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by digitalengineer on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @01:15PM (#7905613)
Found it. "The driving force in society is not love, but fear". It's on Youtube, but it's from this site: http://metanoia-films.org/films/
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by GHFigs on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @04:24PM (#7906780)
You may find this book interesting: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_True_Believer
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by jacobolus on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @01:59PM (#7905886)
See Machiavelli: both The Discourses on Livy and The Prince are quite insightful on these topics. I recommend reading both near the same time.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by madaxe_again on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:00AM (#7903676)
Don't forget about "the muslim problem" and the "international islamic conspiracy".

I'm sorry to Godwin the thread, but it's pertinent. The push on "british values" (nationalism) and "preventing non-violent extremism" (such doublespeak) and "combatting islam" is fucking terrifying to anyone even vaguely familiar with the events that preceded the holocaust and the second world war.

The surveillance state we find ourselves under just makes it that much easier for atrocities to be committed and utterly hidden from view.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pling on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:18AM (#7903725)
This.

I'm a UK resident and I note that the propaganda machine is running on overdrive. The batshit sheep majority (sorry but it's true at least where I live) of the country is almost calling out for anyone with a beard and a turban to be hung and the armed forces are constantly in focus in the media and in public word. If you look around facebook it's terrifying some of the rants you hear yet at the same time these people are slating the Nazis for their prejudice. It's literally:

"Kill all the muslims", "support our boys", "Nazi's bad m'kay".

I will say that none of these people were alive when the Nazis had their gig. Those who were are suspicious and aware of the consequences of thinking and acting like this.

I too am suspicious of anyone who holds a noose.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by fit2rule on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:52AM (#7904069)
The biggest problem in the UK is: groupthink. The national identity is oriented around just how conformant and pliable an individual is, in relation to their peers, and thinking what everyone else thinks is, fundamentally, at the core of what it means to be an Englishman. Don't rock the boat, don't go outside the boundaries of 'acceptable society', and so on.

Well, I'm sorry to say, but you English deserve your oppression. It will be a long road travelled hard before the UK is anywhere near the free, spirited nation it claims itself to be. I can only imagine there are new breeds of dissidents in the British isles, and I can only hope they rise some day to shock British culture out of its utterly self-righteous stupor.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pling on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:37AM (#7905004)
British person here. Very astute observation.

However I'm the opposite. I kick off regularly at people for being that pliable and conformant. What do I get in return? I am shunned for possibly being contrarian, despite the logic being flawless and have put up with a lot of shit over the years despite being right 100% of the time. This country is slowly descending into hell.

Britain needs to look at war-torn Europe up to the late 1990's. It was a fucking mess. I mean a real mess. People sleep with an eye open still and everyone understands what nationalism and prejudice brings: death and suffering.

Britain sleeps with its eyes shut, its fingers in its ears and it's identity in everyone else's business.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by madaxe_again on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:42AM (#7904330)
That's the human condition, and what you've just defined isn't "British culture", but all cultures. You can hardly have a homogenous whole without individual conformity.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by fit2rule on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:03AM (#7904814)
What you've basically said is "you can't have a compliant society unless everyone complies" .. but that's exactly the point I'm trying to make: compliant societies are weak and prone to immense amount of corruption. The right to express dissent shall not be infringed, if you want to live in a land not rendered useless by tyranny. As is the case in the UK.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by spingsprong on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:12AM (#7903708)
I suspect something much more mundane.

Politicians love to shout about their successes. Only, this government hasn't really got any to shout about, so they're falling back to the old standby that all governments do in situations like this. Wave the flag and be proud to be British.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by herghost on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:51AM (#7903838)
Sort of. The problem that the mainstream political parties have right now is that right-wing sentiment just scored high in the elections. They need a little bit of sabre-rattling and flag-waving to convince those on the left-most fringe of the newly-empowered right to come back towards the centre, and the only way they can do that is through winning the stupid, populist vote on simple issues again.

That of course, coupled with the lack of real achievement from the current government, the ongoing and incredibly unpopular austerity cuts, and a long and drawn-out recovery that doesn't seem to be materialising for most people means that any way to make political hay right now needs to be grasped.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by arel on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:57AM (#7904413)
Charlie Brooker, brilliant as ever:

David Cameron has responded to this crisis by declaring we need to celebrate "Britishness" with more enthusiasm. More enthusiasm? More? We've been celebrating Britishness with the strained determination of a man desperately trying to shit a cricket ball for the past five years.

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/jun/16/david-c...

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by seren on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:06AM (#7903882)
The worrying part is : what happens in 10 years if the sabre-rattling was not enough? What is the next step? (And this is not specific to UK but most European countries)
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by disputin on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:31AM (#7904977)
I don't see that - Cameron recently pointed out that he's a christian, and said that Britain is a christian country. He's bringing religion forward.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pjc50 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:17AM (#7903912)
There is certainly a slippery slope, but I think we need to recognise that there exist at least some organisations acting under the "Islamic" banner that are extraordinarily dangerous. 'ISIS' and 'Boko Haram' are the two most recent that come to mind. They already have a track record of mass execution of their enemies.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by makomk on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:07AM (#7904830)
Let me put it this way - one of the recent scare stories here in the UK involved a supposed "Islamic takeover" of schools in Birmingham that didn't get noticed by inspectors because the schools were delivering an impressively good secular education to deprived inner-city kids. Apparently a few teachers seated girls and boys seperately, though, which is un-British according to our prime minster and education minister who were both educated at exclusive boys-only schools and are proud of it (as were most of our other cabinet minsters).

Funnily enough, the politicians and journalists making a big deal out of this scandal are strong supporters of replacing state-run schools with state-funded academies run by Christian fundamentalists, especially failing ones in deprived inner city areas. Some of those have been caught teaching kids in science classes that the scientific evidence says the world is 6000 years old like the Bible says, but that didn't cause a big controversy for some weird reason. In fact, our leader David Cameron has been using this to push for more Christian indoctrination in schools.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by sfjailbird on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:05AM (#7904137)
Those groups are horrible and dangerous but they exist only in their regional contexts and so are hardly relevant in the U.K. There are Muslims in the West that sympathize with them, but they are (a) in the minority, and (b) fools who couldn't organize themselves out of a wet paper bag. Get three of them together and the third forms a splinter group. Which is why the over-focus on them is sensationalist nonsense; you could find 'shocking' views similar to theirs by trawling local pubs.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by eevilspock on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:30AM (#7903973)
There is also an organization operating under the "Democracy" banner that is extremely dangerous. Extremely dangerous to democracy, which is the thing we have to protect us from, amongst many other things, mass executions by the State.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by fit2rule on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:57AM (#7904099)
True that. I rate the UK Military-Industrial complex as a far more dangerous threat to free, open society. The English already have their extremist-enforced laws - its called the Official Secrets Act. If only folks would realize: all the things they're afraid "Islam" will do to them, have already been done in the name of "British safety".
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by rayiner on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:14AM (#7903906)
Not every cultural clash should be compared to the Holocaust. There are plenty of historical examples of societies that got eaten from within when they couldn't maintain their culture in the face of aggressive foreign ones.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by spodek on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:42AM (#7904020)
Germany in the 30s wasn't the Holocaust. The Holocaust emerged from it. Had people known where things would go, maybe they could have stopped it.

Today we have history to tell us where things could go. If we don't allow comparisons to the early stages, might we unwittingly make later stages more likely?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by king_jester on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:26AM (#7904587)
> There are plenty of historical examples of societies that got eaten from within when they couldn't maintain their culture in the face of aggressive foreign ones.

There's an implicit valuation of culture in this statement. Most cultures throughout history melded and adapted to other cultures, both in little and big ways. Xenophobia about cultural invasion is also throughout history, but the reality is that dominant cultures are never "pure" and diversity of culture was actively censored and/or ignored by some historians for a long time.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by madaxe_again on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @01:54PM (#7905850)
You acquire culture through co-mingling and confusion of the elements and ideas of different peoples. Isolate cultures have common roots with others, and evolved in the same way. Drift happens with extended isolation, but if anything this is more of a degenerative process than anything else.

Our precious "British" culture is a Franco-Germanic-Nordic-Celtic-Romano-Pictish-Jutish-Afro-Indian-Sinesian and god only knows what else fusion. They should teach Bayeux, not Carta.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by rayiner on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:58AM (#7904779)
> There's an implicit valuation of culture in this statement.

Damn right.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by quasque on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:47AM (#7904056)
Could you please elaborate on some examples of this?
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by melvinmt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:59AM (#7904424)
If you truly believe that "culture" is a fixed phenomenon, unable to transform itself, adapt and merge to new mixtures of people in society then I fear for our future.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by disputin on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:34AM (#7904628)
Agreed that not every cultural clash should be compared to 1930's Germany. Alarmist. There's a long way to go before getting to that state of affairs. Northern Ireland, Israel/Palestine, South Africa, ...
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by wolf550e on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:59AM (#7903862)
Why would you think the UK would round up and execute its Muslim citizens? And if nothing like this has any chance of occurring, just finding out who is in contact with real terrorists and who isn't seems useful, whether they're Muslim terrorists or Breivik. It is of course vitally important that information gathered for this purpose cannot be used for commercial or political ends, which is the hard part (maybe impossible).
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by CWuestefeld on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:08AM (#7904839)
This comment is misguided, but it doesn't deserve a downvote. It vocalizes the argument coming from the authority, and so it needs to be examined - and we can't do that if we downvote it to invisibility.

Taking away a person's privacy is a punishment. You can't do it because it might bear interesting information. That you don't know ahead of time whether that information will be important is no excuse: you can't punish someone unless you know they're guilty.

Further, given the shroud of secrecy around the collection of the information, how can we be assured that it's not going to be used for commercial or political ends? Even if you trust the present keepers of these secrets, will the next batch be as clean?

Why do you believe that it's so important to gather this information? Is there any real evidence that it's been used in ways that is truly important to our safety (not just for catching drug dealers), and that cannot be accomplished through conventional means?

And how can you even know? If the government won't even own up to what they're doing, how can the electorate weigh the factors? Given that the nature of the problem renders democratic action impossible, how can it be tolerated in a democratic state?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pjc50 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:21AM (#7903933)
'Terrorist' is fundamentally a political label, so it's not possible to separate the political and security questions.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by simonw on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:34AM (#7903982)
How do you define a "real terrorist"?
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by jiggy2011 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:58AM (#7904102)
Are you equating promotion of "british values" such as democracy,freedom,rule of law with nazism? Or am I misreading your argument?
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by skj on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:17AM (#7904202)
I believe the GP was equating "British values" as a dogwhistle for racists, in the same way claiming you're a "real American" is in the US.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by jiggy2011 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:24AM (#7904244)
I assumed they were referring to this. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-27853591

Which is a much more moderate message.

I'm not really convinced that the UK is becoming any more racist overall, it's just that the internet has given those who are already that way inclined a platform.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by prof_hobart on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:01AM (#7903681)
>And I suspect it's because most of the public don't care either.

I think that may be the effect rather than the cause. Public opinion is shaped to a pretty large degree by what the media tells people to be interested in.

And with the media mostly telling us that it's happening but that's it's not important, it's for our own good and that anyone publishing details about it (like the Guardian) is threatening national security, that's what a lot of people accept as fact.

It makes me angry because this is the exact reason why freedom of the press needs to exist - not to allow papers to publish details of some celeb's romantic life. But it's only the latter that 95% of the press in the UK seem to be prepared to battle to defend.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by digitalengineer on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:19AM (#7903727)
I just now realized the double-speak of their name, the Guardian. I thought they guarded the public. Silly me.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by tomp on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:44AM (#7903809)
What do you mean? Guardian is at the forefront of exposing the leaks and informing the public about the wrongdoings of the government!
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by eevilspock on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:34AM (#7903989)
He is being sarcastic. See his comment history.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by r0h1n on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:17AM (#7904200)
You nailed it. Why would politicians stick their necks out when their constituents - the British public - don't seem to care?

a. Why Surveillance Doesn’t Faze Britain [0]

b. Why the British like their spies [1]

[0] http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/09/opinion/why-do-brits-accep...

[1] http://blogs.ft.com/the-world/2013/11/why-the-british-like-t...

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by _k on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:10AM (#7903702)
Indifference always gets us in trouble.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by austincheney on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:11AM (#7904861)
Why bother blaming politics you don't control when instead you can blame the technology that makes this possible in the first place? Support an alternative like http://mailmarkup.org/value.xhtml
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by eevilspock on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:09AM (#7903889)
Further cause for anger: In a democracy the people own the government, not the other way around. Yet our government can spy on us and lie about it without consequence, while it is treasonous for the people to be given intel on our own government's actions (e.g. Edward Snowden)!

-

* Yet. As long as people such as peterlawest (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7903705) continue to be the majority.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by easytiger on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:17AM (#7903916)
> political silence on this issue is indeed deafening.

The UK Government does not comment on issues of national security. End of discussion.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by easytiger on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:00PM (#7907295)
who downvoted? do explain?
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by peterlawest on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:11AM (#7903705)
I consider myself an educated, well-informed person, and I have no problem whatsoever with government surveillance. Like anything, it can be abused, but I don't think that outweighs the benefits.

I think it's sad that it makes you 'angry' that some people simply disagree with you. We have a democracy, and obviously only a minority consider this to be an issue of concern.

If you have a problem with it, stand for election.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by coldtea on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:39AM (#7903787)
>I consider myself an educated, well-informed person, and I have no problem whatsoever with government surveillance

Well, I don't consider that stance well-informed.

Surely its not informed of the tons of abuses of surveillance from "democratic" governments. And its also not informed of thousands of people rotting in jail, targeted by the police, tortured etc. Perhaps people who think that way, believe that all governments are like their local bubble -- or that it has to be some third-world dictatorship for those abuses to happen.

But I'm pretty sure they're also misinformed about the abuses in their local bubble too.

If you're an American for example, you might not know FBI has an attrocious record (under McCarthyism, under the the direction of Hoover, in the sixties against students and black protesters, up to Occupy Wall Street). If you're British, you might not know of an equally disgusting history. And don't get me started on places like Italy, Greece, Spain etc. Or Latin America for that matter.

Or they know those things but just don't care, because either "this time is different" ("and now we're fully and trully a transparent democracy" -- which is the most laughable ignorance one can muster), or they agree with the abuses.

But there's an even easier explanation: they only care for themselves, and since they don't ever do anything to challenge things you think they are safe.

And it might even be true.

But those that do challenge things (from civil rights activists to new political parties, and from artists to people experimenting with new ways of living), are the ones who make society better. Not the cover-my-asses. And it's those people who challenge things that very much are targeted by the abuses.

And what exactly are the benefits? Living in a nanny state?

[edit: fixed typo, child commenter: you a funny man]

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pjc50 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:09AM (#7903891)
nunny state

No, that's Ireland (where the investigation of a mass grave of children in a nunnery is failing to get off the ground)

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pja on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:33AM (#7903775)
The communists claimed to have a democracy too. A state can maintain all the forms of democracy whilst in reality being run on a completely different basis by a parallel internal oligarchy.

"If you have a problem with it, stand for election" is facile: First past the post electoral district representative governments are almost designed to eliminate single issue candidates from ever having any electoral power. The only way to make a difference is to convince the main parties that this matters & that takes years of ground work against a well funded group which will oppose your every move using its access to the machinery of government. It isn't called the military-industrial-congressional complex for nothing you know.

As an aside, very few people have a problem with targeted government surveillance. What I have a problem with is the dragnet sweeping up of every communication, keeping as much as possible for future use against anyone and anybody whilst keeping this policy secret from the population in question. Historically this kind of action has been seen as a signifier of a totalitarian states who are afraid of their own population revolting against them and I fear that the UK/US (and by extension the five-eyes countries) have put in place the full machinery for a panopticon, in which any dissent against the ruling cadres is quietly quashed. This isn't a road I personally wish to see my country taking, yet the politicians and public at large seem blind to the risk, handing over sweeping powers to the security services with almost no oversight or control.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pizza234 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:33AM (#7903773)
There are a few problems in here.

Most notably though, I find terrible the statement that "we have a democracy" when essentially what we're talking about are tools whose abuse (which is going to be very welcomed by the government[s]) is exactly to suppress the democracy itself. Not only this, but also that fact the this is put in a context where government[s] are increasingly given powers to silence dissidence and legally rape people (or minorities, at worst), in an immoral (probable cause hello!) or worst, unlawful way (Snowden docs here).

All of this, with the fact that the "benefits" are not proven, and are actually very arguable. It's naive to think that indiscriminately listening to a billion conversations is an easy way to investigate "terrorism".

I don't think honestly that it's a well informed opinion to assume that we have a democracy just because we can vote somebody; more specifically, black/hispanic low-class people would not have the same opinion, at least, in some countries.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grkvlt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @03:09PM (#7906342)
> government[s] are increasingly given powers to silence dissidence and legally rape people

1. Governments have always had these powers. The state has 'a monopoly on violence' and that can be abused in many different ways, without the need for pervasive surveillance. But it isn't, at least in the USA and the UK, we don't have 'death squads' roaming the streets or summary extra-judicial executions by firing squad for supporting the wrong political party, or having the wrong religion.

2. Wait, legally rape people... What?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by yodsanklai on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:30AM (#7903765)
> Like anything, it can be abused, but I don't think that outweighs the benefits.

In a recent past, my great-grand-father was arrested and beaten up by the Gestapo for his political views (sorry for the emotional argument but i think it's appropriate). My point is that even if you perceive your country as a democracy where the leaders behave for the best, it may not be so forever. And as history shows, it can change very fast. It's important that we have strong laws that protect the people from their leaders.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by duairc on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:16AM (#7903717)
> We have a democracy, and obviously only a minority consider this to be an issue of concern. > > If you have a problem with it, stand for election.

There must be a name for this kind of fallacy.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by collyw on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:24AM (#7903943)
I call it "faith in democracy", as there is no evidence of it happening in any modern "democracy". Just got to believe....
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pdkl95 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:09AM (#7904164)
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by edanm on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:32AM (#7903769)
Is it really a fallacy?

Part of democracy is accepting that you don't necessarily agree with everyone about everything, and you have to compromise.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by ionised on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:37AM (#7903785)
When you have secret laws that protect secret proceedings or as we actually have now, agencies that operate in a legal black hole and are completely unaccountable then yes, the idea that this is somehow a democracy is comical.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grkvlt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:51AM (#7904382)
No.

Just because one part of an organisation does not have a particular property, it does not negate that property for all other parts. The USA and UK are, quite obviously, democracies. There are free and fair secret elections for government in which anyone can vote, and anyone can stand for election as a candidate. That makes them democracies, the behaviour of their secret intelligence services is irrelevant.

I worry about the thought processes that must occur for people to think this; or similar things, like conflating an instance of some law enforcement department abusing its power with a totalitarian police state... I understand hyperbole as a rhetorical device, but it isn't helpful when assumed as fact.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by ionised on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:39AM (#7905020)
> There are free and fair secret elections.

Sorry, but I'm going to have to call bullshit on this one.

Lobbying and uncapped campaign donations are tantamount to legalised bribery. The system is utterly corrupt.

Free they may be, but calling them fair is a gross misrepresentation in my opinion.

> I worry about the thought processes that must occur for people to think this; or similar things, like conflating an instance of some law enforcement department abusing its power with a totalitarian police state.

We're not saying it's a police state. We're saying it is becoming one because of the very tools that these agencies possess and abuse without accountability.

As an example, you've basically had a man (a criminal) James Clapper lie directly to congress knowingly and unabashedly. He's somehow still walking around, free and lol'ing at the general public he so joyously likes to mislead and scaremonger.

> I worry about the thought processes that must occur for people to think this; or similar things.

I honestly think the same of people who think that there is no problem here, nothing to worry about or even that it's a good thing. I honestly can't wrap my head around the immense wilfull ignorance some people seem to be displaying.

It makes me sad, angry and disgusted all at once.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grkvlt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @01:36PM (#7905752)
> We're not saying it's a police state. We're saying it is becoming one because of the very tools that these agencies possess and abuse without accountability

Right, this is my problem. I have no problem with posession of these tools. States possess much worse things, nuclear weapons spring to mind. And abuse of these tools in an unaccountable fashion is wrong, 100% with you on that. However it is not clear to me that such abuses have occurred, or are occurring in a systematic way. Are there any documented (to the extent possible) cases of this? I didn't think even the Snowden documents showed that. In fact, it looked like they were full of caveats about US and UK citizen surveillance being a problematic area, and stated requirements for legal reviews and checks in these cases?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by edanm on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:24AM (#7904936)
As grkvlt has said, this isn't a black or white issue. We're not either a) a democracy or b) not a democracy, we're obviously more democratic in some areas and less so in others.

I agree that having secret proceedings, etc., is a big problem. But there are cases where they're necessary, or at least many people think so. Like it or not, changing the way things work now means gaining some things (e.g. more freedom, more transparency) but potentially giving some things up (some measure of security).

Some people might be willing to give up different measures of freedom for different measures of security - others will have different numbers. That's why, in a democracy, we either convince people or compromise with them.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by eevilspock on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:46AM (#7903820)
Say you were born in 1850, but had the understanding about race and slavery that you do now. Slavery makes you angry (I'm assuming here) and you make an impassioned post about the evils of slavery. In reply you get, "We have a democracy, and obviously only a minority consider this to be an issue of concern."

Is it "sad that it makes you 'angry' that some people simply disagree with you"? Is it ok to dismiss your anger because you don't "stand for election"?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by edanm on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:21AM (#7904917)
I think if I were born in 1850, the right thing to do would be to try and convince other people of why I'm right about race and slavery.

Yes, part of democracy is accepting that some people will disagree with you. The right way to go is to either compromise or to convince them you're right. Incidentally, that's what actually happens most of the time.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by noir_lord on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:19AM (#7903728)
Created 9 minutes ago (as of this post) and has one post.

Doffs tin foil hat.

I see this a lot on a variety of forums whenever topics like this come up.

It would be interesting to do an analysis of the age of the average commenter’s account by topic across popular comment type sites.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pja on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:41AM (#7903797)
We know that the security state is spending large amounts of money employing people to run 'personas' on social media sites, make blog comments etc etc. Sometimes these are spectacularly obvious, but there are plenty who are good enough at their work to look plausible.

The goal is to create the feeling amongst those who are seeking to change the status quo that the population is not with them & that changing things will be difficult, whilst at the same time creating the impression for anyone reading the comments that certain viewpoints are unpopular or contested.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grkvlt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:56AM (#7904406)
Yes, I'm sure this has happened many times, and will continue to happen, although probably not as much on HN as on jihadi extremist forums and so on...

But the knee-jerk responses of 'shill' or 'astroturfer' to dismiss anyone whose opinion differs from the local majority is sad, and seems to be getting more common on many sites I frequent.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by pjc50 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:12AM (#7903897)
Standing for election will potentially get you put on a list of "extremists": http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2014/jun/15/green-party-...

The question is not so much can it be abused, but to what extent it is being abused. Remember, the security services are not above having people murdered if they're sufficiently troublesome: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-21283169

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by Nursie on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:55AM (#7904080)
>> I consider myself an educated, well-informed person, and I have no problem whatsoever with government surveillance. Like anything, it can be abused, but I don't think that outweighs the benefits.

You have cared enough to actually think about it and are prepared to engage in debate. Congrats, you are more interested/intelligent than 90% of the population.

>> I think it's sad that it makes you 'angry' that some people simply disagree with you.

No, I'm angry that most people don't care enough or aren't smart enough to think about it, and that's the majority, and so nothing can be done. Your assertion that I'm angry that people disagree with me is incorrect and patronising.

>> We have a democracy, and obviously only a minority consider this to be an issue of concern.

Our democracy is incredibly weak, it's arguable we even live under a democracy when we have secret trials and secret laws.

>> If you have a problem with it, stand for election.

That's a guaranteed way to waste time and money while achieving nothing.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by Shish2k on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:50AM (#7903833)
> We have a democracy, and obviously only a minority consider this to be an issue of concern.

I think those are separate things -- being in a democracy means the majority decide what happens; it doesn't mean that the majority are well-informed rational deciders of objective truth.

If the government were kicking puppies for entertainment, and nobody knew about it, then the majority wouldn't use their democratic powers to vote against that either :P

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by ionised on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:27AM (#7903753)
There hasn't been any evidence to support these 'benefits'.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by peterlawest on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:30AM (#7903763)
I don't know what else to say apart from that I've seen the same coverage as you, and I'm not bothered by it.

I'm sorry that this seems to infuriate you people so much, but that's my opinion. If I'm happy with it, I'm happy with it. So are many people.

Your indignation isn't going to going to change my mind, or many other people's minds.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by coldtea on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:43AM (#7903803)
>I don't know what else to say apart from that I've seen the same coverage as you, and I'm not bothered by it.

Sure, but then again the majority of Southerners weren't bothered by the slavery or the lynchings either. It took a civil war to make them change their ways.

I mean, if we are to put "not bothered" as some kind of argument.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by eevilspock on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:58AM (#7903858)
Sadly, even 100 years after the Civil War and the Emancipation Proclamation, and 200 years after the Declaration that "all men are created equal", we had huge resistance to the much belated civil rights acts of the 60's.

Yes, peterlawest is entirely right. Our indignation isn't going to going to change his mind, or that of many others like him.

"People don't change their minds. They die, and are replaced by people with different opinions" -- Arturo Albergati, via Paul Graham (http://www.paulgraham.com/quo.html)

"Science progresses one funeral at a time." -- Max Planck

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by gjm11 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:35AM (#7903781)
Downvoting for "you people", a phrase which pretty much universally seems to indicate dismissive contempt and disinterest in engaging the other party's point of view.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by SeanDav on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:53AM (#7904390)
This attitude is incredibly naive (the fact that you made an account 2 hours ago to express this opinion, means you probably agree and are just trolling). Governments change, but data is forever, what you say now or do in public may be politically neutral or acceptable at the moment, but might be worth a jail sentence in 20 years time. Your data will never disappear and you can be held accountable for something you said 15 years ago, even if your opinion has changed or if it was out of context.

For example, have you ever expressed a view about abortion, either for or against (or homosexuality, or religion, or politics? Right now any of the views you expressed may be socially and legally acceptable. It is conceivable that the legal views on this could change 10 years down the line and if you expressed a view that is out of favor with a government of the future you could potentially be in serious trouble.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by quasque on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:51AM (#7904380)
I find this view rather short-sighted.

To some extent I agree with you that there are benefits to mass surveillance, and that on the whole it is (probably) not currently being widely abused.

However, this is not predictive of the future.

By setting up such a pervasive surveillance machine, this massively enables abuses by future governments that may not be quite as benign towards its citizens.

Just consider how 'useful' this mass data mining of private communications would have been for the East German Stasi, or during McCarthyism in the USA, or many other examples of overly authoritarian governance.

The danger is that a system set up to protect state security, ostensibly with the best of intentions, can be subverted later on as a tool of governmental abuse.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by aluhut on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:20AM (#7903733)
What are these benefits?
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by peterlawest on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:26AM (#7903747)
I believe it helps ensure security. I don't believe they'd bother doing it if it didn't. I think you're a bit arrogant for assuming they give a fuck what you write to your girlfriend on iMessages.

I know you probably disagree with that, but this is my point - not everyone agrees that surveillance is bad. And I'm not alone - I think most people don't really care about surveillance. And this isn't a conspiracy - it's just a simple case of people not agreeing with you - this happens - get over it.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grey-area on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:46AM (#7903816)
I think you're a bit arrogant for assuming they give a fuck what you write to your girlfriend on iMessages.

This is absolutely not why people object to pervasive surveillance. The democracy that you harp on about above as the justification for your position is fundamentally incompatible with pervasive surveillance and secret trials.

The problem is not whether they can see pictures of my cats on twitter or imessages to my girlfriend, it's that with pervasive and universal surveillance of our communications which GCHQ is engaged in (collect it all, mastering the internet), those in power would become almost omniscient and able to manipulate our markets, our economy, our politicians, our judges and every other branch of our society. This activity is currently not significantly limited by law, but only by technical ability, which is fast changing. For example all SMS messages in the UK are stored, and all internet traffic crossing the kingdom (which is almost all of it) for as long as possible (Tempora), probably some phone calls too. We also don't even know who they share it with - probably the NSA given their subsidiary relationship. In the wrong hands, this would be a terrible weapon, and even in the right hands, it's likely to pervert those given the power.

If you had access to the private emails of judges, lawyers, accountants, politicians, in retrospect and forever it would be incredibly easy to make and break careers and manipulate everyone else in the country to bend them to your will. Now imagine this power in the hands of a select few, and the rise to power of someone ruthless enough to use it for their own ends. Perhaps initially they'd simply nudge a referendum on independence, or a presidential election by releasing inconvenient emails at the right moment, maybe they'd ensure their continued funding with blackmail (has this already happened, would we ever know?), maybe they'll decide they could run this place better after all - again, we wouldn't even know our democracy had been entirely subverted until it was too late.

IMO the time to oppose this sort of surveillance is now - surveillance should be one-off and controlled by independent judges on a case by case basis, not pervasive and eternal.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by seren on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:58AM (#7903859)
You don't even need to have access to the content of the mail, the meta data are more than enough to find out if you've called a known drug dealer, went to an abortion clinic, used an escort service... It is more than enough to end a career or silence a critic.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by gambiting on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:55AM (#7904762)
I come from a country where 30 years ago every single phone call was listened to by a government worker, and everyone knew,and no one cared. People literally did not care, using the same arguments as you are using - why would they worry about what they are saying to their girlfriends, wives, husbands, so on. And you know what? For most part, the government didn't care. But it was gathering notes on everyone - where are you going, when, with whom, are you drinking, are you buying something - everything that could be of importance was recorded,but never acted upon. Unless you managed to piss off someone. Unless you said something bad about the police or a local politician. Then these notes would be found, even from several years before,and they would be used to put you in prison for 20+ years, as a "danger to society".

This is exactly what is happening right now, and you have to be a complete IDIOT to not see that this is the case. Governments are gathering loads of data about every single one of us. Just because they decide not to act on that data right now,does not mean we should not be worried, and you couldn't be more wrong when you say that the government does not care what you write to your gf on iMessage.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by alandarev on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:38AM (#7903786)
Noone has mentioned there that they are afraid of their loveletters to be publicly available, as a consequence of surveilance. (It is possible, but whatever)

Instead, our problem, is that surveilance is being used as a an invaluable tool for autocracy.

And the question is not whether they will use surveilance for oppressing government opposition, but when if not already.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by grkvlt on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @01:42PM (#7905779)
I think that is a good question. And if there were ever a case of surveillance being used to suppress government opposition, that would be terrible. But this has not occurred, and opposition to the government is a protected and valued right of every citizen of both the UK and the US. There are even entire organisations devoted to the opposition of the current government, some in the UK even go as far as having a 'shadow' group that mirrors the current ruling cabinet, to contest their decisions publicly.
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by Nursie on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @03:08AM (#7908871)
You've not heard about the police embedding undercover officers into protest groups then? And acting as agent provocateurs when embedded within them? To the extent some of them had sham relationships and are now being pursued for effectively rape?

Maybe that's not surveillance being used to suppress in your book. Whatever. Your post reads like propaganda though.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by mike_hearn on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:28AM (#7903961)
> I think you're a bit arrogant for assuming they give a fuck what you write to your girlfriend on iMessages.

This statement is nonsensical, because we know now that recording and reading what we write to our girlfriends on iMessage is exactly what they are doing. Indeed GCHQ have watched so many webcam chats amongst random people they can tell us how many are pornographic to three significant digits of accuracy. This is very much the definition of "giving a fuck".

Given that the premise of your post is incorrect, I wonder why you hold the opinions you do.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by ionised on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:35AM (#7903782)
> I believe it helps ensure security.

Your beliefs are wrong, as we have been shown that this mass surveillance has failed to prevent even one terrorist attack since its inception.

Couple that with the immense amount of (wasted) tax payer money it costs to run and you've got a disgusting abuse of power and resources in exchange for the mere illusion of security to those who fail to actually do the research required to see through the bullshit.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by quasque on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:23AM (#7904570)
> Your beliefs are wrong, as we have been shown that this mass surveillance has failed to prevent even one terrorist attack since its inception.

We don't actually know this. Mass surveillance may have led to 'extrajudicial' methods of thwarting terrorist attacks, i.e. death squads or drone killings. Or when cases of terrorist plots have been taken to trial, its use could have been masked by parallel construction of evidence.

This level of underhandedness seems to be increasing in recent times. For example, there is a terrorist conspiracy trial currently ongoing in the UK that is being held almost entirely in secret - the public and media are not permitted to know the evidence or the sources of evidence against the suspects. In fact up until recently even the existence of the trial and the identities of the suspects were under a gag order, for reasons unknown[1].

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/law/2014/jun/12/secret-terror-tri...

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by ionised on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:48AM (#7905088)
You could be right.

I'm just not sure how much 'we can't reveal that due to national security concerns' is going to fly as an excuse anymore.

Far too many shady things can be covered up under that umbrella.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by quasque on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @10:47AM (#7910386)
Oh, I agree. Just pointing out that mass surveillance may well be both helpful to national security and very damaging to human rights.

For what it's worth, I suspect it's unduly balanced towards authoritarianism as well.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by throwawayaway on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:33AM (#7903776)
having a policeman standing in your kitchen to prevent domestic dispute, ensuring security.

a webcam in all bedrooms would ensure more security and possibly prevent other types of crime.

most people wouldn't go for those - some security measures are too invasive and ripe for abuse to support.

unless you've missed it, your location and contact endpoints are now permanently stored, and some of your conversations both written and audible are.

if one of your associates is within a certain number of hops from someone deemed undesirable - so are you.

the reason the london met phone hacking scandal resulted in outcry was that the general public could understand what happened.

this is slightly beyond their ken but it's the same problem - questionable powers that are ripe for abuse.

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by collyw on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:34AM (#7903987)
>I believe it helps ensure security.

How many terrorist attacks have been prevented as a result of this illegal privacy invasion?

Is there any evidence of it ensuring security? I see none.

What leads you to believe that it ensures security?

Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by aluhut on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @11:42AM (#7905048)
So you don't know what those benefits exactly are or how should I interpret this?
Re:UK intelligence forced to reveal secret policy for mass s... by kghose on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:42AM (#7903801)
Isn't it ironic that you are being downvoted?