News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by IBM on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:10PM (#7865725)
It's pretty clear that Apple is positioning themselves in stark contrast to Google, they want to be the privacy/security company. Internet companies with advertising business models are a dime a dozen so that is a real advantage that differentiates Apple.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:29PM (#7865799)
The FT brought up a similar contrast two weeks ago when discussing Apple and Google's smart home strategies. They speculated that Apple is likely "to emphasise the privacy protections built into its smart home system... Apple considers privacy a key advantage over Google...since Google relies on targeted advertising as its main source of income" [1].

This will be an interesting competition. Google, for openness and transparency; Apple, for control and privacy.

[1] http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/1bef71b8-e433-11e3-a73a-00144...

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by jwr on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:30PM (#7865984)
> Google, for openness and transparency

I'm not entirely sure what you mean — that Google openly and transparently tracks user behaviors so that they can make money on targeted advertising?

If you try to compare the two companies, I'd say the difference is that Apple charges you a premium for their devices (thus making money), while Google gathers data about you so that it can be sold to advertisers (thus making money). Theoretically, each company could do both, but recently Apple started differentiating itself by actually emphasizing privacy and limiting access to data about users, in many places.

I do agree that it will be interesting, though.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by bsimpson on Monday June 09, 2014 @10:02AM (#7868467)
I suspect OP is comparing the way the companies embrace technology. Google has been an big proponent of the open web and of supporting the same standards as everybody else. Apple has been pretty single-mindedly focused on being proprietary whenever possible. (They support open standards on the web, but the rest of their platform is only inner-operable with itself.)
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by goldfeld on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:44PM (#7865834)
It's not really transparency when what they have on you is far more extensive than what they show you. I'd say Google is for control as much as Apple, I'll concede openness vs. privacy which both sound like something spouted out by a suit.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by JumpCrisscross on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:55PM (#7865876)
> I'd say Google is for control as much as Apple, I'll concede openness vs. privacy which both sound like something spouted out by a suit.

Naturally they are both vying for leverage. To borrow a line from The Lords of Strategy, "the key way to think about competitive advantage is to think about how to design ecology in such a way to achieve goals you’re trying to pursue" [1].

Apple monetises device sales. It fiercely protects those sales by ensuring everything one does in its ecosystem is done through its devices. That fortification gives it more freedom with user data, which it can play against Google by encrypting and anonymizing its users' activity.

Google, on the other hand, monetises its access to user data. It fiercely protects that access by ensuring everything one does in its ecosystem runs through its servers. That fortification gives it more freedom with devices and standards, which it can play against Apple by encouraging modularity, adaptability, and customisation.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/The-Lords-Strategy-Intellectual-Corpor...

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by anko on Monday June 09, 2014 @06:27AM (#7867749)
Yep so what you're saying is google is neither open nor transparent.

Maybe flexible?

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by geon on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:46PM (#7865842)
> Google, for openness and transparency

I don't really see it. They have released some stuff as / contributed to open source, but so has Apple.

By transparency, do you mean their real name policy?

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by r00fus on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:34PM (#7866178)
Notably, more recently Google has become less open. Apps written for AOSP that don't use the "Google Play Services" library are second class citizens.

Google is for "openness" only when it doesn't impact their bottom line.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by hahainternet on Monday June 09, 2014 @10:04AM (#7868476)
> Apps written for AOSP that don't use the "Google Play Services" library are second class citizens

I love some of the hyperbole that gets written on HN about Google/Android.

Where do you even get some of this nonsense?

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by awhitty on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:24PM (#7865779)
Maybe I'm a little high on design rhetoric right now, but I see this less in terms of Apple being a privacy/security company and more along the lines of Apple being a user-centered design company. No user wants their data shuffled around and sold, so any company that relies on the commodification of its users' data is inherently at odds with its users' needs.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by wmf on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:35PM (#7865818)
Google probably also sees themselves as user-centered by providing advanced services for free.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by awhitty on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:50PM (#7865855)
I think that's the "easy way out," in a way. Sure, it's not easy to provide the services for free, but it also doesn't particularly excuse them.

Like Netflix vs. YouTube. Netflix fights for your ability to stream HD videos comfortably because you pay for the service. YouTube crams a perfectly-buffered, crisp HD ad down your throat before leaving you with a video that might stutter or fail to load even at 480p. Sure, people can't complain when it's free (though they do), but I think it really limits what an experience can be, and I don't consider that particularly user-centered.

Anyway, just my thoughts.

Edit: Fixed some parallel structure

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by mcintyre1994 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @08:07PM (#7866414)
I've noticed on Youtube they seem to buffer really popular videos really well, things like Gangnam Style when it was being played probably to tens of thousands of simultaneous users were surprisingly good - I think they have some sort of really good buffered caching or something. I suspect they might do the same with adverts that they know will stay the same and know they will serve to many users.

The disconnect is there for many videos where a perfectly buffered ad precedes a slow buffering video or something, but they seem to use that technology on some user videos too I think - or something similar.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by moe on Monday June 09, 2014 @08:51AM (#7868183)
You are correct.

Due to the nature of how CDNs work the ads don't normally need special treatment.

They simply benefit from being 'very popular videos'. Meaning they stay hot in all edge caches because everyone, everywhere is watching them all the time.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by thrownaway2424 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @11:02PM (#7866813)
The ads are all in the edge caches and the videos you want to watch might not be.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by eevilspock on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:56PM (#7869557)
It's an absolute fallacy that Google provides services for free. In fact, it is more much more expensive:

1. The advertisers who pay google get their money from us, added to the prices of the things we buy. There is no free lunch.

2. The overhead cost of advertising is huge and we pay for that too.

3. We pay the opportunity cost of a product that cannot put users first because they live or die by giving advertisers what they want (and what we want indirectly and secondarily). This includes both the cost of lost privacy as well as well as design that optimizes advertising revenue. As has been said, we are more Google's products than we are their customers.

4. We pay the social costs. Democracy and the free market assume people make voting and purchasing decisions based on facts and reason. Advertising as predominantly about manipulation and deceit. I believe this is the most expensive cost of services that rely on advertising revenue.

Added together, we are paying a lot more for "free" web searches and email than if we could just straight up pay Google for straight-up ad-free versions.

[This is a condensed version of a more detailed case with reference links that I made here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7485773]

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by c1sc0 on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:58PM (#7866054)
This. If you have access to the developer sessions from WWDC14 I urge you to look at the HealthKit, CloudKit & TouchID stuff. "We take privacy very seriously" was a recurring theme and seeing it baked into the new APIs made me smile. Very cool & reassuring move.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by josso on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:39AM (#7867504)
For anyone interested: The videos are open to the public at https://developer.apple.com/videos/wwdc/2014/.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by catfoods on Monday June 09, 2014 @01:02AM (#7867111)
I noticed this as well after watching several sessions. Definitely a good direction.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:17PM (#7866111)
> It's pretty clear that Apple is positioning themselves in stark contrast to Google, they want to be the privacy/security company.

I don't see how this move is anything out of line with something Google might do. Google can track you because you're using their services on their OS. They don't need a network of WiFi access points to triangulate your location, they can just read it out of your phone's GPS receiver. Randomizing your MAC when scanning for networks is in the same nature as enabling SSL by default for Google services -- it doesn't hide anything from Google (or, as the case may be, from Apple) but it hides things from other people you don't want observing you.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by zmmmmm on Sunday June 08, 2014 @08:47PM (#7866501)
On the other hand, they are also actively developing the ominously named 'iBeacon' functionality. A more cynical viewpoint would be that they are trying to sabotage any possible systems that would compete with their own proximity based marketing solution.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by hatsix on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:23PM (#7865774)
> It's pretty clear that Apple is positioning themselves in stark contrast to Google, they want to be the privacy/security company. Internet companies with advertising business models are a dime a dozen so that is a real advantage that differentiates Apple.

Yes, Apple certainly wouldn't develop/release a product whose sole purpose is to track user's physical presence, with the primary use point being able to sell the ability to push 'app usage': http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBeacon http://appleinsider.com/articles/14/06/03/apples-ios-8-uses-...

This is about the ability to track handsets, and how Apple wants to corner the market on tracking their own handsets.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by abalone on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:00PM (#7865888)
No, you misunderstand iBeacon. The sole purpose of iBeacon is to let handsets detect it, not the other way around.

In order to for it to be used to track users, the user would have to run an app that detects the beacon and then communicates back to the business. In other words, the user has to opt in to tracking.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by hahainternet on Monday June 09, 2014 @10:06AM (#7868487)
> No, you misunderstand iBeacon. The sole purpose of iBeacon is to let handsets detect it, not the other way around.

You are wrong, the point of iBeacon is to allow an app to track its position.

Apple is not about privacy, they're about controlling what they consider to be their customers. They will be the gateway the users go through for any service whatsoever. They get their 30% no matter what.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by arrrg on Monday June 09, 2014 @10:24AM (#7868580)
Huh?

The big difference is opting in and consent. That’s what’s important. Also, yeah, Apple get their 30% – but only if apps actually cost anything. Those store apps usually don’t cost anything (the stores want to sell the stuff in the stores, not apps) so they will cost Apple money, not make Apple money.

I don’t really get where you see the incentive for Apple to do this, besides privacy.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by abalone on Monday June 09, 2014 @03:54PM (#7870140)
You are confusing geolocation with tracking. Geolocation merely lets the handset determine where it is. "Tracking" implies there is another party involved in monitoring your location. That can't happen with beacons unless the user runs an app that communicates your location back to a third party -- which it could do with regular old GPS geolocation too. iBeacons are just another way to do geolocation.

Also, iBeacon broadcasts can be detected by Android, or any other platform that wants to. I'm surprised no one has said this on the thread. It's clearly not about Apple lock-in.

Here's an Android library for doing it: http://developer.radiusnetworks.com/ibeacon/android/

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by wikyd on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:44PM (#7865837)
The difference is that for iBeacon to track devices the user has to download an app related to the beacons and give permission. MAC address tracking happens without the user giving consent.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:49PM (#7865851)
Is it not possible to track devices based on their Bluetooth MAC?
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by jmgrosen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:01PM (#7865891)
If you have discoverable mode on, sure. But typically that's specifically user-activated and only lasts for a couple of minutes.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:48PM (#7866029)
I'm working at a place that uses a simple app running on a Raspberry Pi to update a dashboard whenever a known Bluetooth MAC comes into the building, with no need to turn on discoverability or pair with the Pi.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by ashah on Sunday June 08, 2014 @09:22PM (#7866581)
flawed metrics buddy, bluetooth mac address is randomized.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:31AM (#7867038)
Not on the iPhones and Android phones of the people whose names are consistently correctly displayed on the dashboard. The MAC address had to be entered into the dashboard software manually, but no interaction was required on the phone whatsoever.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by AllenKids on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:21PM (#7865953)
if I recall correctly, Apple's Bluetooth BLE UUID is also randomized while in broadcasting mode.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:17PM (#7865747)
It's pretty clear that Apple is positioning themselves in stark contrast to Google, they want to be the privacy/security company. Internet companies with advertising business models are a dime a dozen so that is a real advantage that differentiates Apple.

It's difficult to reconcile this claim with their participation in PRISM et. al., previous long-term storage of cell tower locations, ownership of a mobile ad network, and wanton abuse of the patent system to stifle competition.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by kevinchen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:32PM (#7865810)
- We still don't know whether or not the companies on the PRISM slides were participating voluntarily or even knowingly.

- I don't see how constructing a database of cell tower locations violates privacy. They are beacons used for finding the user's location when they have location services turned on.

- iAd is a joke of an ad network, and stores a negligible amount of user data compared to Google's. It's also relatively easy to reset tracking on iAd, for the few apps that do use it.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by mpyne on Sunday June 08, 2014 @07:00PM (#7866245)
> - We still don't know whether or not the companies on the PRISM slides were participating voluntarily or even knowingly.

Sure we do. PRISM has an NSA part and a company part. The company had to build out their end in order to participate in PRISM.

However it's important to realize that compliance in some form with NSLs and warrants was not optional for Apple. By not participating in PRISM they would simply have turned over the same data on each request by manual means.

That modality is probably an even bigger threat to user privacy than PRISM. In PRISM, Apple's legal team would have to vet each and every single NSL or warrant and then manually activate an automated process to ship the required data over. While Apple didn't release a ton of details about how they implement it, this automated process is precisely the thing that can be done without a raft of Apple employees having to map/reduce it all manually (and possibly leak part of it themselves, maliciously or accidentally).

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:46PM (#7865843)
- I don't see how constructing a database of cell tower locations violates privacy. They are beacons used for finding the user's location when they have location services turned on.

They were storing location history: http://www.cnn.com/2011/TECH/mobile/04/20/iphone.tracking/in...

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by uxp on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:55PM (#7865877)
This again? They were storing location history as to more easily pinpoint the user's location without having to maintain a constant connection with a GPS satellite. They weren't storing it and sending it off to the NSA, your local police, or their own data center to mine it.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:43PM (#7866011)
Were users warned about this before the tracking started?
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by feld on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:12PM (#7866094)
It's NOT tracking. It was only ever stored locally on that device. That's called logging.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:24PM (#7866147)
Were users warned about this before the logging started?

Edit: FWIW, "track" is the word used in the CNN article I linked.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by glhaynes on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:53PM (#7865867)
On the user's devices.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @05:44PM (#7866013)
Where anybody with physical access to their phone or their computer, or access to their cloud sync data, could get at it.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by feld on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:14PM (#7866098)
Do you have proof that it was synced to iCloud? I don't believe it ever was.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:22PM (#7866132)
It was definitely in computer sync data. I don't use iTunes, so couldn't say whether it went into the cloud from there.

Edit: there are more ways for data to get into the "cloud" than "iCloud".

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by viscanti on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:24PM (#7865778)
> and wanton abuse of the patent system to stifle competition.

Use (or abuse) of the patent system seems entirely orthogonal to privacy/security.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:44PM (#7865835)
But definitely contradicts a "good citizen/respects you" persona.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by goldfeld on Sunday June 08, 2014 @04:54PM (#7865871)
Big corps would be hard pressed to be "good citizens" or bear anything resembling respectfulness. They're a multitude of individuals with often conflicting interests who are all given the general direction of going for profit. Maybe an exception could be a big company where a founder who really puts his grand vision/values above anything else is still in control, which is not the case (or has ever been for Apple.)
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @06:23PM (#7866140)
User IBM's original comment was that Apple is going for the "privacy/security" persona, which is kind of impossible if they're not also acting as a "good citizen" worthy of trust with one's privacy and security.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Sunday June 08, 2014 @07:56PM (#7866375)
Thanks, everyone, for reminding me why I stopped reading and commenting on Apple-related threads on HN. 27+ downvotes later, I still haven't changed my mind, but if you wish to try, logic works better than weak justifications for exploitative, sociopathic corporate behavior and targeted downvoting.
Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by josai on Monday June 09, 2014 @04:51AM (#7867526)
I don't think your downvotes relate to criticising Apple per se; they're due to a poor argument style. I am no great fan of Apple, but hurling vague accusations and FUD, then shifting the goalposts when anyone tries to refute you, adds little to the conversation besides noise.

> I still haven't changed my mind

Well you should have. You've been thoroughly shot down. The fact you don't accept that says more about you than anyone else.

Re:iOS 8 randomises the MAC address while scanning for WiFi ... by nitrogen on Monday June 09, 2014 @12:58PM (#7869259)
Thanks for your comment. Consider my response below to apply to the thread, not just to your comment specifically.

  ------
I don't think your downvotes relate to criticising Apple per se; they're due to a poor argument style.

I'll admit I haven't invested my best efforts into my comments on this thread, but where other than an Apple thread would every single comment by one person be downvoted beyond -4? It's not worth the effort if one knows one's comments will be grayed out anyway.

Even mpyne's much more thorough comment was downvoted, so it's clear that the downvotes aren't strictly targeting poor argumentation. Furthermore, if that were the case, there's no reason to target every single comment by a person equally, as inevitably some of them must be better argued than others.

  ------
then shifting the goalposts when anyone tries to refute you

I never shifted any goalposts. All I said was that it's difficult to reconcile user IBM's claim that Apple wants to be the "privacy" company with their actual behavior, then provided clarifications when prompted.

  ------
You've been thoroughly shot down.

Where? I see lots of disagreement, but no disproof. Show me the counterargument of the form, "Apple can be trusted despite these events because...".

It's easy to shoot somebody down. Just yell louder. What I've yet to see is a solid refutation to any of the things I said. A downvote is argumentatively equivalent to yelling, "Shut up!" So let's see how many "Shut ups" there are, and how many refutations.

It takes 5 counted downvotes to bring a comment from +1 to -4, where all of my other comments currently lie (I don't know how the HN anti-voting-ring algo turns clicks into actual downvotes, so there may be even more). However, beyond -4 points the comments can still get lighter. I'll assume that #aeaeae is the original -4 comment, since it's the darkest of my comments on this thread. I also have comments at #bebebe, #cecece and #dddddd. So I'll count #ae as 5, #be as 6, #ce as 7, and #dd as 8 or more.

  Original comment - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865747 - #dddddd - 8+
  Location history - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865843 - #bebebe - 6
  [Tracking]       - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866011 - #dddddd - 8+
  [Logging]        - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866147 - #dddddd - 8+
  Physical access  - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866013 - #dddddd - 8+
  Cloud sync       - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866132 - #cecece - 7
  Good citizen     - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865835 - #dddddd - 8+
  Worthy of trust  - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865835 - #cecece - 7
  Thanks, everyone - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866375 - #aeaeae - 5
  ------
  Total: 65+ downvotes
That's 65 or more counts of "Shut up," not including mpyne's comment. How many actual comments?

  Still don't know   - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865810
  This again?        - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865877
  Tracking semantics - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866094
  User's devices     - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865867
  Do you have proof  - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7866098
  Orthogonal         - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865778
  Big corps not good - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7865871
  ------
  Total: 7 comments (4 one-liners)
Only seven comments, four of which were one-liners with less content than most of my own comments. The remaining comments are mostly distractions from the actual claim, that Apple's past behavior doesn't lend itself to trust with one's privacy.

So again, where's the refutation? MAC address randomization is awesome, but why can I trust Apple to take the position of the "privacy" company?