News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Friday May 30, 2014 @04:41PM (#7823958)
Mankind has made the most incredible art inspired by religion. Along the same lines, Bach's Chorales and in fact quite a bit of his other work.

Try this, if you feel like some really nice classical music:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MC3Upv8DuRQ

Re:Sistine Chapel by dredmorbius on Friday May 30, 2014 @09:40PM (#7824940)
Don't make that attribution error of associating the patron with the artist.

Yes, religion was the primary patron of visual, sculptural, and musical arts for much of the period from the Renaissance to the Enlightenment. But it wasn't the only.

And you'll find beautiful works among the secularist of the Classical and Romantic periods, say, the Pre-Raphaelites. Of whom neither the artists, models, nor subject are generally highly religious in nature.

Re:Sistine Chapel by cgore on Saturday May 31, 2014 @12:26AM (#7825269)
Bach was deeply religious, and not just because of some lap-dog sense of "that's who's paying the bills." He signed most of his works as "SDG", short for "Soli Deo Gloria", which roughly translates as "to God alone belongs all glory. His meaning being that any ability Bach thought he had was solely just God showing off: Bach made beautiful music, but God made Bach, and he knew it.
Re:Sistine Chapel by EzGraphs on Saturday May 31, 2014 @11:37AM (#7826273)
That is a great quote. I used it in the dedication section of a book I wrote recently. Bach is fascinating on many levels - lots of C.S. types quickly appreciate the structure/counterpoint in all of his instrumental music. But because so much of his music was written for a worship context, a whole additional dimension can be seen where he uses musical devices to comment on or support words being sung.
Re:Sistine Chapel by Myrmornis on Sunday June 01, 2014 @06:33AM (#7828727)
lots of C.S. types quickly appreciate the structure/counterpoint in all of his instrumental music

What on Earth does that mean?

Re:Sistine Chapel by prutschman on Monday June 02, 2014 @01:34AM (#7832050)
You can read that as "interesting patterns" for an approximate idea of what it means.
Re:Sistine Chapel by Myrmornis on Monday June 02, 2014 @12:22PM (#7834280)
No, I wasn't asking to be patronized. If I want to know what counterpoint is I'll look it up. I'm asking what on earth it has to do with computer science. Sure there's the Hofstadter book but with no explanation this comes off as merely pretentious. Do resist the temptation to patronize and mansplain though; I know it is one if the things we as a profession excel at.
Re:Sistine Chapel by prutschman on Thursday June 05, 2014 @07:03PM (#7855179)
I wasn't trying to be patronizing.

Clearly we both know you can look up "counterpoint" if you want to, so I read into your post you were a tiny bit interested but not so interested as to bother looking it up.

I'd hoped the shorthand would give you enough additional idea that you could decide whether doing so was worth it for you, the link between interesting patterns and computer science being hopefully obvious.

Re:Sistine Chapel by luxpir on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:08AM (#7825393)
It's also an era-fitting and socially acceptable way to humble-brag, if I'm wearing my cynic hat.
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:56AM (#7825457)
Bach was humble enough and gifted enough that he didn't have to brag. I'm fairly sure he meant what he wrote when he did that. This is not DHH bitching about how he came in second in a car race with the better car.

During his own time Bach was not even hailed as a great composer, his genius and contributions only gained appreciation long after he died.

Re:Sistine Chapel by efnysien on Saturday May 31, 2014 @01:18AM (#7825344)
> he \emph{believed} in it

ftfy

Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:53AM (#7825454)
Pretty much all of Bach's works were dedicated to God.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soli_Deo_gloria

For Michelangelo I'm not so sure, but for Bach there is absolutely no doubt.

Re:Sistine Chapel by theoh on Saturday May 31, 2014 @08:28AM (#7825868)
Well, in many Jesuit schools all schoolwork was marked with the initials AMDG, in a similar spirit. In many cases (personal experience) the students doing this were no more motivated by the greater glory of god than the average teenager, it was just a convention. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_maiorem_Dei_gloriam
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @08:48AM (#7825889)
Yes, but Bach was not exactly a student in some school and did this on many manuscripts that were never meant for public consumption (which is one of the reasons a whole lot of them were lost). It's not like some Church official checked his homework. Maybe he did it out of convention, but from what is known about Bach's life I find that unlikely.
Re:Sistine Chapel by dredmorbius on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:07PM (#7826692)
Much of Michelangelo's work was produced for the House of Medici, in large part to create a sense of culture around the newly-powerful clan. And while, yes, the family produced four Popes, though more as an outgrowth of their political and financial power consolidation than strict religious interest.

Again: the Church was very different during the period than it is today, representing political power, a center and repository of education and knowledge, tremendous financial power, and a very active role in political goings-on. Again: it's really not particularly surprising that the Church was so involved in sponsorship for the arts.

Today those roles are largely filled by commercial interests, an insight which first came to me in the late 1980s as an early computer animation festival was touring through my college town, and I realized that many of the best shorts, almost all advertisements, were for tobacco and alcohol companies. Today that niche is filled more by the FIRE sector.

Re:Sistine Chapel by wyager on Friday May 30, 2014 @10:02PM (#7824994)
I'm disappointed that you are in the negative points. Your comment was insightful and interesting, and I know more after reading it than I did before.
Re:Sistine Chapel by dredmorbius on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:08PM (#7826698)
Doesn't much bother me either way, but my comment seems to have been rescued from negative territory by a significant margin.
Re:Sistine Chapel by pavanred on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:09AM (#7825397)
I don't think you can attribute most incredible art to be inspired by religion, considering that during those times, art (sometimes just ideas) that lacked religious conformity were dealt with severity. Perhaps the reason there is so much art that is inspired by religion because not much else survived.

This brings a famous bit by George Carlin (I think) to my mind - ...It start's when we are kids, we are told to be creative and to colour within the lines... (paraphrased)

Re:Sistine Chapel by darasen on Saturday May 31, 2014 @12:25PM (#7826399)
Let us not forget that this concept doesn't just apply to Christianity, or religion in general, though.

Monet struggled with the Académie des Beaux-Arts fot painting the way they thought people should paint.

There is a long history of Ballet dancers in the USSR who struggled because they good communists.

Today character assassination is the norm for for so many people (especially in the arts) who don't strictly adhere to progressive politics.

I attended an art school for time where I was frequently shunned for dressing well, (apparently you can't be an "artist" if you wear slacks and dress shirts,) and adhering to Christian principles.

Look at the movie Moms' night out. Highly panned by critics because because the characters are not "feminist" enough. Yet highly rated by the audience.

Re:Sistine Chapel by sofal on Saturday May 31, 2014 @01:49PM (#7826630)
Your theory that the Mom's Night Out movie was panned only because critics thought it wasn't "feminist" enough can just as easily be turned around to say that the Christian audiences praised it only because the movie panders to them. All the praising user reviews I've read come from a very politically motivated and reactionary viewpoint.
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @04:06AM (#7825528)
It's definitely possible to be a 'fan' of Carlin, Bach and Michelangelo at the same time without any hint of cognitive dissonance.
Re:Sistine Chapel by lostlogin on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:21PM (#7824156)
You're quite right, but there is something strangely amusing to me about the idea of art inspired by religion in a thread about the Sistine chapel. It's almost more like science trumping religion. There are quite a few theories on just what some images are of - sections of brain, cross section of a penis, brain stem, eye, shoulder etc.
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Friday May 30, 2014 @05:24PM (#7824183)
In this case I should have probably used 'funded', but in those days not having a religion was not really an option.

Michelangelo was at continuous odds with his employers during his lifetime, he dissected corpses illegally at first, later with tacit approval of some of the church bigwigs in order to improve his skills as an artist. It was a continuous give-and-take to see who got the most out of the arrangement.

In the end I think we, the future dwellers able to see his work no matter what caused them to come into being are the real winners.

Not bad for a man who declared himself unfit to execute the work because he was a sculptor, not a painter...

There is a very good book about him that I forgot the title of (I read it ages ago).

Re:Sistine Chapel by hrjet on Saturday May 31, 2014 @12:16AM (#7825243)
> "declared himself unfit as a painter" ?

Wasn't it more like "declared painting as unfit for him"? Michelangelo had a strong disdain for paintings and painters especially Leonardo Da Vinci and his friends.

My only source is [this biography](1). Not sure how accurate that is.

[1]: http://www.amazon.com/The-Agony-Ecstasy-Biographical-Michela...

Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @06:32AM (#7825733)
I did not write that he declared himself unfit as a painter, I wrote that he did not consider himself to be a painter. Michelangelo's first love was marble, not paint.
Re:Sistine Chapel by hamstu on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:32PM (#7824463)
You may be referring to Michelangelo and the Pope's Ceiling by Ross King. Fantastic read for the interested. http://www.amazon.com/Michelangelo-Popes-Ceiling-Ross-King/d...
Re:Sistine Chapel by tinker_27 on Saturday May 31, 2014 @12:16AM (#7825245)
The Agony and the Ecstasy, by Irving Stone, perhaps? Its the first thing that came to mind when I saw this. Irving Stone's Lust for Life, about Vincent Van Gogh, is pretty good as well.
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @03:45AM (#7825504)
Given the timing that is most likely the one but I wouldn't know for sure without reading a few pages. Thanks for the hint. I've long ago lost pretty much all my books so it's hard for me to be sure about what I read where and when. Much appreciated.
Re:Sistine Chapel by pcrh on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:06PM (#7824357)
Most likely those interpretations of Michelangelo's frescoes as brain stem, etc are a case of pareidolia. In the case of the "brain cross-section" (where God touches Adam) There is no reason why Michelangelo should choose what is now a standard representation of the brain in a sagittal cross-section over any other cross-section; in fact the image doesn't look very much like a real brain in cross-section, but is closer to the stylized one that appears in modern text-books (which Michelangelo would obviously not have been aware of).
Re:Sistine Chapel by lostlogin on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:59PM (#7824552)
A midline section is the obvious one. And there are images by him in the chapel that have similarity to coronals too. Of all the images that look like anatomy the most famous one of the brain is the least obvious one in my opinion. Although that said, it isn't too much of a stretch to see it. I wouldn't really call it that stylised so much as obscured, presumably to prevent the bill payer moaning. Out of curiosity, when do you call text book image stylised? MR and CT images are basically the same as textbooks but without the colour. Many texts actually use the MR image as their image as they are so very good (sinus area possibly excluded).
Re:Sistine Chapel by pcrh on Friday May 30, 2014 @09:34PM (#7824927)
MR images, etc, are very modern. The choice of image to be displayed in a text book is not based only on what one would see if one had a brain to dissect at hand; dissection procedures, and the sections that result, are determined by precedence.

The "standard" sagittal section as in this image (i.imgur.com/ZTvy55n.jpg), or this image (i.imgur.com/73YdDXa.jpg) is chosen precisely because it shows in one image several important features of the brain, and is also recapitulated nicely by MRI images, as you mention.

However, there is no reason why Michelangelo would know anything about the different regions of the brain and therefore choose a representation that showed them.

A "fresh" human brain (which is what Michelangelo would have seen) looks like this (i.imgur.com/KXBLtrx.jpg), or this (i.imgur.com/Bm5l8n6.jpg), and without further dissection do not look much like his paintings.

Such brains can be further sectioned in any number of ways, none of which are necessarily obvious. The question then is would Michelangelo have dissected brains in the same way as is now done?

Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @02:02AM (#7825384)
That's a good question. I think that his interest in dissection was not driven by any desire to know anatomy per-se, but mostly by a desire to be a better sculptor. From his perspective (or at least, from what I know of his perspective, which is very much limited by what we know about him) what was in the head was not all that interesting. But muscles, the skeleton, the locations of internal organs that gave shape to the abdomen and such were of great interest. He could use that knowledge to depict people in a more realistic way.

The inside of the skull is not shaping the skull in a way that it will come out 'wrong' if you don't know about what's in the skull.

Re:Sistine Chapel by walden42 on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:12PM (#7824389)
Beautiful piece, thanks for sharing.
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:41PM (#7824495)
You're welcome. Lipatti was an amazing pianist, definitely someone worth spending some time on. You won't be disappointed. Good starting point: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pcdHbSZE9J4
Re:Sistine Chapel by ronaldx on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:01PM (#7824329)
It's hard to say that the Sistine Chapel was inspired by religion - it was paid for by religion, yes.
Re:Sistine Chapel by Natsu on Friday May 30, 2014 @10:53PM (#7825083)
What do you mean by 'inspired' here?

When looking at the chapel I see a large number of religious figures and imagery, so it seems odd to say that art depicting religious subjects, in a religious setting, sponsored by a religious patron was not inspired by Christianity.

Re:Sistine Chapel by laureny on Saturday May 31, 2014 @04:03AM (#7825520)
It was ordered and paid for by the catholic church, of course it's going to represent concepts of the catholic creed. If NASA ordered their rockets to be painted with science based themes, you could hardly call such paintings "inspired by science".

"Inspired" implies that the artist woke up with an idea and painted it.

Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Saturday May 31, 2014 @04:14AM (#7825536)
Michelangelo was mostly told to 'paint the ceiling', what he painted was of his own devising. For sure he would probably not have been paid if he painted a forest scene but there is some evidence in his own hand that his inspiration was mostly scripture (the OT).

I'm pretty sure the reigning pope approved of the design, both from an execution perspective as from the content itself.

But if he had done the job according to the normal way of decorating ceilings in that day we likely would not be having this discussion. It really is a masterpiece.

Re:Sistine Chapel by Natsu on Saturday May 31, 2014 @01:33PM (#7826588)
Why not? They would be the genesis of the idea, after all. It just seems bizarre to me to say that religion did not urge him to do this, which is the usual meaning of 'inspire.'
Re:Sistine Chapel by jacquesm on Friday May 30, 2014 @06:03PM (#7824341)
See sister comment.
Re:Sistine Chapel by disputin on Saturday May 31, 2014 @08:13AM (#7825855)
Do you think Bach would have been a rubbish musician if he was an atheist? I suspect religion was just one of many possible muses.